On the subject of heavy metal and hard rock

  • Thread starter Thread starter ILoveTheLordGod
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I

ILoveTheLordGod

Guest
My favorite genres are heavy metal and hard rock, but as we all know it, a lot of songs of these kinds are quite satanic.

I mean, I enjoy the song “Highway to Hell” by AC/DC, but then again, the message springs a problem into mind. Would it be sinful to enjoy the song? I mean, if the song won’t inspire me to do anything, would it still be sinful? If so, what if I won’t pay attention to the lyrics?
 
Maybe this isn’t the perfect solution, but there are a lot of heavy metal and hard rock Christian bands out there. For a couple of examples Demon Hunter is a Christian HEAVY Metal band, Emery is kind of pop-punk/scream, The Almost, Abandon Kansas, and House of Heroes are all rock-hard rock thought they’re all kinda small time. Skillet is hard-rock nowadays, they used to be electronica rock. Flyleaf has a female singer and they’re hard rock. The Wedding is hard rock. Christian rock is out there, the lyrics may not reflect the fullness of Truth, but hey that’s better than Satanic stuff.

I really like music haha.
 
There are many rock/metal threads in the Popular Media forum if you care to take a look. There are even some AC/DC threads, too. 🙂

I think you’ll find a variety of opinions here on CAF ranging from “It’s of the deviiilll!!!” to “Anything goes”.

I think that, in this area, there is no substitute for personal discernment. We always want to be mindful of how what we take in effects our relationship with others, with ourself, and with God. I think the most oft overlooked aspect (at least, speaking for myself) is that of a possible cumulative corrosive effect. I’ve been listening to hard rock/heavy metal for the past 25 years. I’m not a violent person. I don’t cuss or smoke or do drugs or many of the things associated with that scene. But I do periodically revisit the question: how does this impact my relationship with God?

I haven’t really looked at the lyrics, but I’m pretty sure that AC/DC song is not about reveling in the fact that one is hell-bound. Metal lyrics tend to use provocative images to make a point. Perhaps others more familiar with that song will comment.

I would really take it to prayer, though. I know some people who felt called to purge most of their music collection upon their conversion. They had too many negative associations bound up with the music. I have never felt called to do that thus far (though I’m far from a perfect listener when it comes to following God’s will for my life). I don’t have any negative associations with the music as I never really fell in with the “wrong crowd”.

That said, there are still certain bands and certain songs that I just won’t listen to. I can tolerate a certain amount of criticism of Christianity and/or organized religion. Often times, such lyrics are born out of perceived hypocrisy (which is not completely unfounded) or commentary on actual scandals. I can understand that. But blatant blasphemy really has no place in my music collection.
 
It is impossible not to be influenced by the music one listens to. The brain analyzes music on multiple levels.

That being said, I do not think it a sin to listen to music so long as the lyrics themselves are not conducive to sinful imaginings (i.e, an explicit [you know what kind I mean] song would, I think, fall under the sin of pornography).

Music affects our behaviors and attitudes.

I used to listen to heavy metal myself, but I stopped listening to it, not because of the above, but because my tastes changed. The style simply does not appeal anymore on stylistic, not moral, grounds.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top