One or Two Vehicle Household?

  • Thread starter Thread starter MooCowSteph
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Depends on how much you use your vehicles. How far are you from shopping, how much running around to soccer games, dance lessons, choir practice, etc do you do? Do you or you husband attend meetings that would leave the other person without transportation? What if an emergency came up while the other person had the car? What would you do if the car were in the shop for a few days? In our case there is no way we could get by with one car.
 
40.png
cargopilot:
I don’t know why us guys get so attached to a hunk of metal, but for some reason we like to have 'em around. Just look at them as a retirement account that you have to house, buy insurance, tags, parts and batteries for. Oh, lets not forget the spare parts we have to accumulate and store to go with them. Yep, antique cars and airplanes sure are a good investment.:rolleyes:
I know you are being sarcastic here but they can be. I bought my '69 Barracuda in 1982 for $1600.00. since then I have probably put another $4,000 into it including tags, insurance, gas etc. The book on it right now is right around $29,000. That is a yield of over 600%. Just try to beat that in the market.
 
Rob's Wife:
**Steph - **
**Hmmm, I’ve got nothing against your dh’s cars, assuming the family can afford them. From a finance perspective, it doesn’t make since for you both to make this sacrifice when those cars (or at least 1 or 2 or them) are there to sacrifice instead. You’re a better wife than many if you didn’t get a bit resentfull about that I think. **

Some men have a natural desire to retain some … oh private ownership?.. issues with regards to having their own car. Something about being able throw their trash about and have the auto-dial on their own stations that makes them feel a bit more manly I think.😉 Whereas, it seems us ladies just view it as an extension of the house.

Maybe your dh would be okay with only driving his special cars on the days when you need the “family” car to make things a bit easier for everyone.
I think it is a private ownership issue with hubby, as well as a convenience issue. He’s a big car guy, and I think he probably wants to have that convenience of being able to go whenever, without regard to my schedule. I don’t mean that he’s inconsiderate, just that he doesn’t want to plan his trips to the post office with my trips to the doctor or grocery store.

I don’t resent the cars, at least not most of the time. :rolleyes: He loves his cars, he’s had them much longer than we’ve even known each other, and they really impact our budget very little. Insurance and tags aren’t too expensive on them, especially the historic one. Everyone needs a hobby. We spend less on them than many men spend golfing.
40.png
Lance:
Depends on how much you use your vehicles. How far are you from shopping, how much running around to soccer games, dance lessons, choir practice, etc do you do? Do you or you husband attend meetings that would leave the other person without transportation? What if an emergency came up while the other person had the car? What would you do if the car were in the shop for a few days? In our case there is no way we could get by with one car.
We’re very close to everything. We really don’t do much running around. We’re having our first baby in about 9 weeks, and since my husband works from home, he goes to the main office about once per week and to the post office almost daily. Other than that he’s pretty much always home. If there were an emergency, chances are one of us would still be within 20-25 minutes from home, and in a major emergency we’d just call an ambulance. The car breaking down or being in an accident would be the biggest inconveinence. We’d probably use one of his three cars. Guess I’d have to learn to drive stick. 🙂

There is no way we could get by with one car if one of us worked outside the home. Well, we could, but it’s not a sacrafice either of us would want to make.

It’s really great getting the different perspectives! 🙂
 
We have only one car which my husband with a crazy work schedule has all the time. When he gets home either at 4 or 6 or 10PM, I do my errands around his schedule (24 hour food stores I love it and Target is open till 10) I bank online, have automatic deposit, (I don’t remember the last time I went to a bank except an ATM. I plan Doctor visits around his day off. For emergency’s I can use the “Bomb” (my son’s car) in the driveway, just need to move the McDonald bags, kick away 4 different odd sneakers, dirty socks, bathing suit and towels from last summer and then hold my nose and turn the key:D
 
Rob's Wife:
**Nope. No public transport either. My schedule is pretty well made, which makes it easier for dh to plan around it as best he can - if he can. I don’t bother with trying to get the car more than 2 or 3 times a week. If that means a late night trip to get dh, then I load up the kids and that’s what we do. If it means getting up at the crack of dawn, then I do that too. We’ve done this for many years and once you’re used to it, it’s really not that big a deal. **
I am glad that that this works for you:) . My schedule is also pretty much well made as is my dh. But I can say that this is not for everyone…late night rides are different than rides at** 2 or 3 AM**.
I guess my husband agrees that is why we have two cars…and that I thank him for that since I really do enjoy my sleep 😃
 
Karin, I have nothing against you having 2 cars:) For those that either don’t have a choice or are willing to make the sacrifice - this can be a big help in finances. Of course, it is not for everyone.

I only responded to your post b/c you specificly asked if there were those in this situation. I guess I should have written late night or early morning. I’ve had to do the p/u or drop off at 11 at night and at 3 or 4 am and any other time of day/night too. It’s not a big deal anymore and we really can’t afford to not do it anyhow - so it’s just what we do.

40.png
Karin:
I am glad that that this works for you:) . My schedule is also pretty much well made as is my dh. But I can say that this is not for everyone…late night rides are different than rides at** 2 or 3 AM**.
I guess my husband agrees that is why we have two cars…and that I thank him for that since I really do enjoy my sleep 😃
 
Rob’s Wife said:
Karin, I have nothing against you having 2 cars:) For those that either don’t have a choice or are willing to make the sacrifice - this can be a big help in finances. Of course, it is not for everyone.

I only responded to your post b/c you specificly asked if there were those in this situation. I guess I should have written late night or early morning. I’ve had to do the p/u or drop off at 11 at night and at 3 or 4 am and any other time of day/night too. It’s not a big deal anymore and we really can’t afford to not do it anyhow - so it’s just what we do.

Rob’s Wife…
No offense taken…and yes I did ask the question thank you for the reply. It just seemed that you where implying that since you do it I should also…I see now that is not what you meant.


 
i wish we could be a one car family but DH works about 25 miles away so it isn’t doable. if we ever lived close enough for me to pick him up i would go for it.

we did pay both our cars off when they were 2-3 yrs old so that is nice not having payments.

is it necessary to get a “family car” with the first child. i’m going to hold on to my sedan until i can’t fit any more kids in it which would be 3
 
I would say that in your situation with your husband working from home and you being a SAHM, one car could work great for you all. (I think that situation is correct…) We had one car for a long time. We made it work because we needed to. But we lived on an air force base and dh worked 5 minutes from the house and could run home with the car if we needed it most of the time. That being said… when baby #3 came along… we bought a mini-van and I have LOVED it!! BUT with one baby, both parents at home, definitely go for it and save the money!!
 
40.png
spacecadet:
i

is it necessary to get a “family car” with the first child. i’m going to hold on to my sedan until i can’t fit any more kids in it which would be 3
Hey a “sedan” for some of us is a family car…not all of us require buses:) …I mean minivans or the such
 
We have 2 cars as well. We live in Los Angeles which is urban sprawl at its most extreme. Public transit would literally take us several hours each way (it’s really terrible but it’s also hard to cover just a huge area effectively). As a matter of fact, we just had to get my husband a new used car yesterday.
 
40.png
Karin:
Hey a “sedan” for some of us is a family car…not all of us require buses:) …I mean minivans or the such
good point. i just know at least 10 people that got rid of their sedan and got an SUV or minivan with the first kid
 
40.png
spacecadet:
i wish we could be a one car family but DH works about 25 miles away so it isn’t doable. if we ever lived close enough for me to pick him up i would go for it.

we did pay both our cars off when they were 2-3 yrs old so that is nice not having payments.

is it necessary to get a “family car” with the first child. i’m going to hold on to my sedan until i can’t fit any more kids in it which would be 3
That depends on what you mean by a family car…

We had a small vehicle when we had 2 kids in car seats and one old enough to be out. (That was back when 40 lbs/4 years old was considered OK to have them out of the Toddler seat. We also didn’t have a front passenger air bag.) We’d put one car seat in the front and one in the back. One adult and the oldest child would sit in back with the baby. We couldn’t do that today but it would have worked with two children in carseats.

The one thing I would say is that it is nice to have a 4 door rather than a 2 door sedan if you spend a lot of time hauling kids around.
 
40.png
spacecadet:
good point. i just know at least 10 people that got rid of their sedan and got an SUV or minivan with the first kid
**Why? 1 kid 2 adults unless you have an econo-box of a sedan you should all fit with the baby stuff and still have room to move:D **
**But then heck I know people with no kids that drive minivans…go figure:) **
 
Karin said:
**Why? 1 kid 2 adults unless you have an econo-box of a sedan you should all fit with the baby stuff and still have room to move:D **
**But then heck I know people with no kids that drive minivans…go figure:) **

it is beyond me too.
We had a small vehicle when we had 2 kids in car seats and one old enough to be out. (That was back when 40 lbs/4 years old was considered OK to have them out of the Toddler seat. We also didn’t have a front passenger air bag.) We’d put one car seat in the front and one in the back. One adult and the oldest child would sit in back with the baby. We couldn’t do that today but it would have worked with two children in carseats.
The one thing I would say is that it is nice to have a 4 door rather than a 2 door sedan if you spend a lot of time hauling kids around.
i meant when we have the 3rd then we’ll graduate to the minivan. 2 carseats in a 4 door car is fine for us. and yes 4 doors are wonderful
 
1 or 2? We have 3. Our oldest commutes to college in one direction and our second goes to community college in the opposite direction. Dh works about 25 min away.

I share a vehicle w/ my 17 yr old son- the one at community college.
—KCT
 
If you live in an area without much public transportation to get to the store, take care of errands, doctors appointments, whatever, you need to have a second car. Part of the expense of living in the suburbs.

Now, if you moved from Baltimore County to the city of Baltimore, one car would probably be sufficient.
 
Get another car if it’s not going to be a financial burden. My wife and I had one car for a long time. Hated it. And I work nights. I hated the fact that when I left with the car, she had no way to get around. We do have three kids, but even with one, it would be so much easier to have a second car. Also, as far as buying a mini-van with only one kid, go for it. You can end up with 2 kids in as little as a year or two. You’ll still have the mini and will be glad for it. Yes, you can stuff 2 adults and 2 kids into a compact car, but it’s not fun.

So, if you can afford it, get two cars. And if you want a mini van, get it.
 
40.png
pira114:
Get another car if it’s not going to be a financial burden. My wife and I had one car for a long time. Hated it. And I work nights. I hated the fact that when I left with the car, she had no way to get around. We do have three kids, but even with one, it would be so much easier to have a second car. Also, as far as buying a mini-van with only one kid, go for it. You can end up with 2 kids in as little as a year or two. You’ll still have the mini and will be glad for it. Yes, you can stuff 2 adults and 2 kids into a compact car, but it’s not fun.

So, if you can afford it, get two cars. And if you want a mini van, get it.
Well, it depends on whether you have some way to get going in an emergency, short of an ambulance… a neighbor, family, that kind of thing, even a local taxi service. Cars or pick-ups that are needed, but infrequently and at predictable times, can be rented, too.

Financially speaking, it is a mistake to buy the car you might need, instead of the one you actually need. Used car dealers are not leaving the planet. The bank and the insurance company can live without your contributions for awhile.

When assessing what your needs are, there is always the option of just trying to go without. Faithfully leave the one car home and see how you do. You might try it for Lent, even. Either way, you may be in for a surprise! You may decide that your local grocery parking lot is not someplace you want to be at 10 pm on a regular basis. You may find that with some planning you save not just money but time by refraining from jumping into the car at the drop of a hat.

PS Cool old cars? Well, they’re cool old cars! As King Lear said, “Reason not the need!” But if you’re paying to insure them, they could be the hubby errand car a few times a month… strictly a car-seat-free zone. Gotta run the engine once in awhile or they get full of condensation, right? 😉

I’m pretty sure that it is a venial sin to own something that is never going to be a museum piece, and refuse to use it. DH is going to be on his deathbed someday, or maybe even lose his driver’s license due to declining eyesight or reflexes.:eek:

If you love it, drive it! 👍
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top