Outrage explodes over rhytming "diet" picture book

  • Thread starter Thread starter Elizabeth502
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
E

Elizabeth502

Guest
news.yahoo.com/outrage-explodes-over-rhyming-diet-picture-book-140440927.html
Kramer, who struggled with obesity as a child and a young adult and still works to keep the pounds off, wishes Maggie’s fantasy self in the mirror wasn’t quite so thin on the book’s cover. He also wishes her transformation through weight loss wasn’t quite so much — 51 pounds in a little more than eight months.
“Now that I see the controversy I would say that I would have had her lose about 30 pounds and still have a little way to go,” said Kramer, who’s neither physician nor nutrition expert.
He said he’s just a guy who wants to inspire overweight kids to be healthy.
“I regret that people associated the word ‘diet’ as me trying to push dieting on 4-year-olds and 6-year-olds. I’m not,” Kramer said. “To me, diet means a change of habits, eating nutritiously, losing unhealthy weight.”
Must say, haven’t read said book yet, but in my highly-observant eyes ;), the realities of obesity are under-emphasized in our society. It is a culture of “accepting” and “tolerating” everything, no matter how unhealthy, unwise, and how permanently problematic. Further, the bar for acceptable weight has been pushed higher and higher, which in itself is a problem relative to childhood, because this is when the fat cells multiply, and then becomes (as the author noted when interviewed) a lifelong struggle, once established. (The author concedes this about himself.)

Editors and publishers can control a lot of the final product of an author, so I’m not convinced that the entire final product was the originally intended one (including the illustrations), but so far, from what I have read, the shortcomings could be:

~that only a girl was featured.
~that the mirror (self-image & “beauty”) is the cover’s visual focus
~that weight is lost rapidly
~that the juvenile format speaks to an unintended target audience

The facts are, especially in my region:

~Boys are far, far more likely to be grossly overweight than girls – something that is certainly counterintuitive, given how supposedly boys like to play sports and be generally active during childhood, and given the sports-focus of contemporary culture, which extends far into childhood.

~It is in fact young children who are increasingly on the path for this level of obesity. Funny how the book apparently features 50 pounds. That is precisely how I calculate the extent of overweight of a neighbor child of mine, only 8 years old, looks like a short, obese 12-year-old (and wears a 12-year-old’s sizes), already has a triple chin, and is easily 50 pounds overweight. He is very typical of children I have taught in the last 6 years. He is not an exception. He already stresses for air when he has to exert himself in the least. :eek: He lives in a dual-parent household, and the parents are rarely home.

~Adult lifestyles are contributing in a major way to the problem. The boys I have taught recently are from households in which the children are (illegally) left alone, usually indoors, for anywhere from 5 hours to 18 hours at a time, while one/both parents work, and snacks are junk food (candy, chips).

~Our country’s recent history of random kidnapping has exacerbated the problem. Prior to ~ 15 years ago, parents were less afraid to release their children to bike, skate, run, out of view of parents. This definitely presents an entirely new set of problems, and it clearly has for me as a mother as well. But it never happened to my children because I have taken them to parks & playgrounds, and we have joined with other families on walking trips, etc. It has meant that I have had to make the time to do that, however.

~time for physical exercise has been drastically reduced in public education especially. In the charter schools (for example) that I’ve taught in, the bare-bones budget and focus allows for no period of physical exercise during the school day. In site schools, PE teachers have been cut, or PE reduced to twice/week. Definitely not enough to counteract sedentary lifestyles at home.

The fact that childhood obesity is a time-bomb waiting to explode is not the cry of fanatics. Heart problems :eek: in such middle school children have already been documented medically. Further, the earlier this problem starts, the more likely it is to become chronic, for the merely practical effect of getting around becoming difficult when burdened with excess weight. Thus, this typical neighbor-boy would not be able to engage in vigorous sports right now, at the age of merely 8, unless he were to lose 50 pounds. Without a structured program, he’s not going to, and therefore his intake will greatly exceed his energy expenditure, likely throughout his childhood. 😦

Therefore ^^, I wish the book cover featured both a male and a female (or even just a male), were not even about a “mirror,” but illustrated a normal-sized boy standing next to the main character, with the theme centered on the inability to participate in the exhilarating physical feats of boyhood, a disappointment which also excludes boys from that important team bonding [which he is also later more likely (then) to seek in unhealthy “teams”].
 
Sorry about the accidental typo in the thread title. Sloppy proof-reading. :eek:
 
news.yahoo.com/outrage-explodes-over-rhyming-diet-picture-book-140440927.html

Must say, haven’t read said book yet, but in my highly-observant eyes ;), the realities of obesity are under-emphasized in our society. It is a culture of “accepting” and “tolerating” everything, no matter how unhealthy, unwise, and how permanently problematic. Further, the bar for acceptable weight has been pushed higher and higher, which in itself is a problem relative to childhood, because this is when the fat cells multiply, and then becomes (as the author noted when interviewed) a lifelong struggle, once established. (The author concedes this about himself.)
…

Therefore ^^, I wish the book cover featured both a male and a female (or even just a male), were not even about a “mirror,” but illustrated a normal-sized boy standing next to the main character, with the theme centered on the inability to participate in the exhilarating physical feats of boyhood, a disappointment which also excludes boys from that important team bonding [which he is also later more likely (then) to seek in unhealthy “teams”].
I agree with your view of childhood obesity, but I think that a fiction book is the wrong format to address such issues. This should be addressed by doctors to parents and the kids. Fiction stories are targeted at a general audience, but a message of “you are fat” and “you should be thin, and look perfect in a dress,” is the wrong message to send out to all the pre-teen girls who will read it. (Since the heroine is a girl it will be generally marketed towards girls).
 
~Boys are far, far more likely to be grossly overweight than girls – something that is certainly counterintuitive, given how supposedly boys like to play sports and be generally active during childhood, and given the sports-focus of contemporary culture, which extends far into childhood.

~It is in fact young children who are increasingly on the path for this level of obesity. Funny how the book apparently features 50 pounds. That is precisely how I calculate the extent of overweight of a neighbor child of mine, only 8 years old, looks like a short, obese 12-year-old (and wears a 12-year-old’s sizes), already has a triple chin, and is easily 50 pounds overweight. He is very typical of children I have taught in the last 6 years. He is not an exception. He already stresses for air when he has to exert himself in the least. :eek: He lives in a dual-parent household, and the parents are rarely home…
Boys aren’t nearly as active as they once were. As you state “outside” activity is restricted due to the parent’s idea that they must supervise activities to prevent injury or abduction. Video games eat up massive amounts of time that was once spent being active. Years ago most houses had one TV, and it was set to what the adults wanted to watch. If the kids didn’t like it they found something else to do. Now it’s common for children of all economic levels to have their own TV(s) to watch their own shows.
 
^ This is so true, Sam. However, in the case of the neighbor boy, there is not enough money for videogames or even TV. The guy gets almost no exercise in the space of any given week. Dad aspires to a more middle-class lifestyle, so is working & rarely at home; Mom and big brother can’t be bothered to take kid to park a half-mile away. Boy is driven everywhere; never made to walk long distances, let alone to run.

…The point being that the phenomenon of the under-exercised child is affecting to some degree all economic levels, and to absent parents the most. I do not understand why parents would not make the time to take children to exercise. This is a matter of basic health, especially long-term, as the author of this article notes. It is essential, not an “extra.” I have been a Mom now in the same era of abduction as these other parents, yet I have had to “inconvenience” myself (if one perceives it as that) by taking my children to parks. This is really a no-brainer. Parents can get together with other families and trade these supervisory duties among themselves. (I’ve done it; so have many others.)
 
Thought that Dr. Andreas Eenfeldt had a nice article on the book.

“A diet book for kids (!) and what it can teach us”
The net is in an uproar about the book, to be published in October. Is it a prescription for eating disorders? Or is it a necessary message to combat the growing obesity epidemic?
Personally I think it’s something worse.
Insanity
This is a perfect illustration of the massive mistake behind the obesity epidemic. We are eating bad food (sugar, refined starch) that makes us want to eat too much. But many (if not most) people think the solution is to just ignore the hunger, eat garbage low fat products and work out more, instead of getting rid of the problem.
Of course it’s not working. Adults are getting more and more obese. And now we are giving the same failed advice to kids!
The problem: It is not a four year old kids fault if he or she has a weight problem. She does not buy the food. She does not cook the food. If the parents would have given her good real food, without any refined sugar, she probably would never get a weight problem to begin with.
It is not the overweight kids fault. So we absolutely should not put the responsibility of getting thin on her shoulders.
In a less insane world the parents would instead make sure that the kid mainly has access to good food. Low sugar. Low starch.
The rest can be seen at:

dietdoctor.com/a-diet-book-for-kids-and-what-it-can-teach-us
 
So true, Roselle, and thanks for the additional info and link. Definitely a parental responsibility – the food purchased & offered, the exercise offered & not offered.
🙂
 
Hello Elizabeth502 from a non-American, but one who happens to live in a very affluent western social setting nevertheless. Only yesterday I was in an urban shopping centre with a fellow I used to play a lot of sport with. The one single thing that jumped out at us as we sat and enjoyed a cup of coffee or three was the number of fat people walking around. I mean really, really fat. So fat they wobble when they walk! Fat people of all ages. And it seemed to be correlative that fat people seemed to be the ones sitting down munching on french fries and polishing off soft drinks. It has just become so very obvious in this day and age. One doesn’t need a science degree, or to carry out any type of fancy sociological study to see this phenomenon. It is glaringly obvious!

Of course, one is no longer allowed to call any one “fat”, as their feelings may be hurt. Even those ‘weight challenged’ youngsters who can’t run to save themselves must be mollycoddled and encouraged to give up their sedentary game playing to venture outside to soak up a bit of Vitamin D. But not too much, mind, in case their sensitive little skins develop cancer in twenty or thirty years time. And, of course, they aren’t allowed to climb trees in case they fall and break an arm. No swimming in the local creeks or rivers, either, in case the fish are upset and of course, shock, horror, there would always be some little brat that might pee in the water. Can’t have that, can we?!

I remember as a kid doing all these dangerous and socially unnacceptable things (yeah, I already confessed to peeing in the creek once 😊 ) and honestly, I don’t know how I survived without society caring about me so much as it does about people today. What’s worse, I even played full contact body sports, like football. At school we played games like British Bulldog, which you Americans might not know much about, perhaps you can Google it, but, beleive me, it resulted in many bloody noses. We climbed trees and wrestled and did all sorts of really dangerous things. We were pretty deprived kids, of course, not having a Macdonalds on every corner like they have today and even our school lunches were pretty bland, usually consisting of a sandwich and a biscuit made by our Mums. Today, the kids get all sorts of goodies wrapped in fancy foils which let the kids know just how nutritious it all is. No wonder we were often told by some kindly old Aunt that we needed fattening up!

I sometimes now wonder if that older generation of parents really cared about us. I mean, they would let us wander all over the countryside all day. Todays parents wont allow their children out of sight and of course, if they dissapear around a corner they must, absolutely must, phone home on their cell phone. No-one taught me how to do that at five years of age. And that parental protectiveness even extends into sport and tree climbing. If anyone ever snotted me during a game off football, I was told to “get over it and get on with it”, but today’s parents will haul the offending brute before a court and demand compensation. And, should kids today be naughty and fall out of a tree they shouldn’t have been climbing, well, they haul the local government authorities before a Judge and make them pay up too. Even God doesn’t get off lightly. No more of those “Acts of God” stuff. People really go to great lengths to make sure they find out who is to really blame. Gee, if your life gets messed up and you can’t hold down a job, well, they simply drag your fourth grade teacher into court and demand she pay for the damage she caused. Yeah, I know, that was a sexist statement. The thing is though, I don’t think they have men teaching kids in fourth grade any more. Too dangerous.

Anyway, I must stop feeling sorry for myself, and just marvel at how the caring nature of humanity has made evryone feel so much safer. The young uns of today wont grow old with creaking bones and ligaments that wont hold the joints together properly. No sir, -] fit /-] -] healthy /-] -] interesting /-] -]adventure filled /-] longer lives await them.

It’s just that when I see all those fat people in the shopping centre, well, being a bloke, one of the thoughts that crossed my mind was if I had to dance with some of the modern women, a fellow wouldn’t know what he was grabbing! Anyway, I reckon the girls would be pretty safe dancing with a lot of the blokes of today. The fat stomachs of the men would mean they couldn’t get closer than a couple of feet of their dance partner anyway.

Gee, we lived dangerously…
 
John,
:rotfl:

I notice the same thing in shopping malls especially, btw. I avoid shopping malls because they depress me for different reasons (the consumerism --the recreational shopping-- depresses me), but I do notice that the more active types avoid them (in my area), possibly one reason being that when all those overweight people are walking so slowly, it’s hard to pick up one’s pace and reach even a normal calorie-burning walk. (I find it frustrating to be required to walk that slowly, myself.)

I also had a physically adventurous childhood. Keep in mind, though (in all fairness),

~abduction was virtually nonexistent, also I had 3 siblings (who often accompanied me), as well as other friends (often neighbors!) who alternately accompanied me or us.
~family outings in the true out-of-doors were the usual way to take vacations, for the middle class, camping with all the physical exercise entailed being one of the typical vacations.
~physical education was more rigorous in all public schools. It was mandated daily, and included timed tests at various landmark ages. By middle school, we were all required to engage in (learn) every single sport: swimming, soccer, baseball, volleyball, gymastics, trampoline, and archery.
~neighborhoods were more self-contained for children, meaning that your school was within walking distance of home, as were safe playgrounds and parks that Mum & Dad felt secure allowing you to play in, as long as there was daylight.
~swim centers were open daily in summertime, with cheap admission. I used to swim virtually daily in summertime.
~skating was done not in rinks to which you had to be driven in a car, 30 miles away, but outside your house, in your neighborhood, on sidewalks. Ditto for biking.
~We were used to taking very long walks – sometimes with friends or siblings, but often alone. Walking alone even for a child age 5 and up was considered safe unless the neighborhood was quite rough, which was unusual for most families.
~summers were much less “organized;” in fact, usually the organized activities were few & far between, which forced chidlren to find physical recreation. In our “neck of the woods,” there were still dairy farms which had not been industrialized, and corrals of horses which were accessible to curious visitors. To reach them, one had to take a long walk in the warm sun (sans suncreen :D), and the farmers were friendly to children who wanted to join in the milking, greet the horses, etc.
~Like you, we played in creeks and dry creekbeds, which were also accessible and not privatized. Now it seems that everything is “owned” either by a private party or by a gov’t agency, and fenced. Empty lots were also accessible. Now those are rare, and where they exist, they are also fenced.

All of the above has drastically changed. That includes things like swim centers now being open for only limited time periods during the day & during summers, and far fewer swim centers open. (Mine was a part of the junior high, with the pool being open all summer, regardless of class not being in session. Now public school grounds are seen as habitats for criminals and aspiring criminals, and are “locked down” when not in school session or summer session.)

Neighborhoods are no longer homogeneous, with neighbors knowing each other very well. (It happens, but it tends to be the exception, due to mobility, lifestyles, & much else.) Rarely is someone’s own school within walking distance of one’s home; it is often not even in the neighborhood, but miles away. This makes walking to & from school impractical & even impossible.

And the typical American child has one sibling, and increasingly no siblings, unless there’s a twin due to IVF.

But my point is, since the auto is the primary means of getting from point A to point B for most children now, families must make opportunities for exercise. One has to arrange opportunities for vigorous play on a regular basis, and it helps also if their outside activities have a large element of physicality in them (organized sports, dance, etc.) It’s just more of a challenge, but every bit as essential, and every bit as much of parental responsibility as it was when it was easier to get children moving. I don’t care if you work full-time; it’s part of parenting to provide that exercise time.

Btw, John, obesity in the US is of epidemic proportions now. Something like half of all adults are at least 10 + lbs overweight (or is it 20?), and a sizeable portion of those are obese, with the morbidly obese on the rise.

Recreational electronics have certainly exacerbated the problem: the array of cable channels, the whole “dish” network thing, the plethora of video games & internet access, all of which encourage non-gross-motor movement. The problem is the availability: people feel they “must” advantage themselves of all those TV channels (now there’s satellite radio, too, as if the TV possibilities were not enough, not to mention internet TV & radio). If you pay for such services, you apparently feel you need to use them or you overpaying for the value. In my day, you were advanced if you had access to FM radio. Daytime TV was dullsville – what existed of it, and there were like 5 channels. And the deadliest combo of all may be TV screens inside large autos, as if there’s not enough encoruagement to remain seated!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top