E
Elizabeth502
Guest
news.yahoo.com/outrage-explodes-over-rhyming-diet-picture-book-140440927.html
, the realities of obesity are under-emphasized in our society. It is a culture of “accepting” and “tolerating” everything, no matter how unhealthy, unwise, and how permanently problematic. Further, the bar for acceptable weight has been pushed higher and higher, which in itself is a problem relative to childhood, because this is when the fat cells multiply, and then becomes (as the author noted when interviewed) a lifelong struggle, once established. (The author concedes this about himself.)
Editors and publishers can control a lot of the final product of an author, so I’m not convinced that the entire final product was the originally intended one (including the illustrations), but so far, from what I have read, the shortcomings could be:
~that only a girl was featured.
~that the mirror (self-image & “beauty”) is the cover’s visual focus
~that weight is lost rapidly
~that the juvenile format speaks to an unintended target audience
The facts are, especially in my region:
~Boys are far, far more likely to be grossly overweight than girls – something that is certainly counterintuitive, given how supposedly boys like to play sports and be generally active during childhood, and given the sports-focus of contemporary culture, which extends far into childhood.
~It is in fact young children who are increasingly on the path for this level of obesity. Funny how the book apparently features 50 pounds. That is precisely how I calculate the extent of overweight of a neighbor child of mine, only 8 years old, looks like a short, obese 12-year-old (and wears a 12-year-old’s sizes), already has a triple chin, and is easily 50 pounds overweight. He is very typical of children I have taught in the last 6 years. He is not an exception. He already stresses for air when he has to exert himself in the least.
He lives in a dual-parent household, and the parents are rarely home.
~Adult lifestyles are contributing in a major way to the problem. The boys I have taught recently are from households in which the children are (illegally) left alone, usually indoors, for anywhere from 5 hours to 18 hours at a time, while one/both parents work, and snacks are junk food (candy, chips).
~Our country’s recent history of random kidnapping has exacerbated the problem. Prior to ~ 15 years ago, parents were less afraid to release their children to bike, skate, run, out of view of parents. This definitely presents an entirely new set of problems, and it clearly has for me as a mother as well. But it never happened to my children because I have taken them to parks & playgrounds, and we have joined with other families on walking trips, etc. It has meant that I have had to make the time to do that, however.
~time for physical exercise has been drastically reduced in public education especially. In the charter schools (for example) that I’ve taught in, the bare-bones budget and focus allows for no period of physical exercise during the school day. In site schools, PE teachers have been cut, or PE reduced to twice/week. Definitely not enough to counteract sedentary lifestyles at home.
The fact that childhood obesity is a time-bomb waiting to explode is not the cry of fanatics. Heart problems
in such middle school children have already been documented medically. Further, the earlier this problem starts, the more likely it is to become chronic, for the merely practical effect of getting around becoming difficult when burdened with excess weight. Thus, this typical neighbor-boy would not be able to engage in vigorous sports right now, at the age of merely 8, unless he were to lose 50 pounds. Without a structured program, he’s not going to, and therefore his intake will greatly exceed his energy expenditure, likely throughout his childhood. 
Therefore ^^, I wish the book cover featured both a male and a female (or even just a male), were not even about a “mirror,” but illustrated a normal-sized boy standing next to the main character, with the theme centered on the inability to participate in the exhilarating physical feats of boyhood, a disappointment which also excludes boys from that important team bonding [which he is also later more likely (then) to seek in unhealthy “teams”].
Kramer, who struggled with obesity as a child and a young adult and still works to keep the pounds off, wishes Maggie’s fantasy self in the mirror wasn’t quite so thin on the book’s cover. He also wishes her transformation through weight loss wasn’t quite so much — 51 pounds in a little more than eight months.
“Now that I see the controversy I would say that I would have had her lose about 30 pounds and still have a little way to go,” said Kramer, who’s neither physician nor nutrition expert.
He said he’s just a guy who wants to inspire overweight kids to be healthy.
Must say, haven’t read said book yet, but in my highly-observant eyes“I regret that people associated the word ‘diet’ as me trying to push dieting on 4-year-olds and 6-year-olds. I’m not,” Kramer said. “To me, diet means a change of habits, eating nutritiously, losing unhealthy weight.”
Editors and publishers can control a lot of the final product of an author, so I’m not convinced that the entire final product was the originally intended one (including the illustrations), but so far, from what I have read, the shortcomings could be:
~that only a girl was featured.
~that the mirror (self-image & “beauty”) is the cover’s visual focus
~that weight is lost rapidly
~that the juvenile format speaks to an unintended target audience
The facts are, especially in my region:
~Boys are far, far more likely to be grossly overweight than girls – something that is certainly counterintuitive, given how supposedly boys like to play sports and be generally active during childhood, and given the sports-focus of contemporary culture, which extends far into childhood.
~It is in fact young children who are increasingly on the path for this level of obesity. Funny how the book apparently features 50 pounds. That is precisely how I calculate the extent of overweight of a neighbor child of mine, only 8 years old, looks like a short, obese 12-year-old (and wears a 12-year-old’s sizes), already has a triple chin, and is easily 50 pounds overweight. He is very typical of children I have taught in the last 6 years. He is not an exception. He already stresses for air when he has to exert himself in the least.
~Adult lifestyles are contributing in a major way to the problem. The boys I have taught recently are from households in which the children are (illegally) left alone, usually indoors, for anywhere from 5 hours to 18 hours at a time, while one/both parents work, and snacks are junk food (candy, chips).
~Our country’s recent history of random kidnapping has exacerbated the problem. Prior to ~ 15 years ago, parents were less afraid to release their children to bike, skate, run, out of view of parents. This definitely presents an entirely new set of problems, and it clearly has for me as a mother as well. But it never happened to my children because I have taken them to parks & playgrounds, and we have joined with other families on walking trips, etc. It has meant that I have had to make the time to do that, however.
~time for physical exercise has been drastically reduced in public education especially. In the charter schools (for example) that I’ve taught in, the bare-bones budget and focus allows for no period of physical exercise during the school day. In site schools, PE teachers have been cut, or PE reduced to twice/week. Definitely not enough to counteract sedentary lifestyles at home.
The fact that childhood obesity is a time-bomb waiting to explode is not the cry of fanatics. Heart problems
Therefore ^^, I wish the book cover featured both a male and a female (or even just a male), were not even about a “mirror,” but illustrated a normal-sized boy standing next to the main character, with the theme centered on the inability to participate in the exhilarating physical feats of boyhood, a disappointment which also excludes boys from that important team bonding [which he is also later more likely (then) to seek in unhealthy “teams”].