Overbearing Parent

  • Thread starter Thread starter NM505StKate
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
N

NM505StKate

Guest
Hello. New to the forum. Nice to meet you all. I am 34, single, male. I live with my parents, due to it being expensive where I live. Life gets hard as my father is pretty over protective. Been told I could not make it on my own. Also been told how having kids is the worse mistake I could ever make. Anyway thanks and have a super day.
 
Thank you. I am wondering on how normal it is for a parent to be this protective? Mother and father were raised Catholic. I go to mass with my mom every Saturday. Went to Catholic school until I graduated.
 
You leave out a lot of details here. How are your parents overprotective? Do you want to move out? If so, what steps are you taking toward that goal?

And why does he think having children is such a horrible thing? :confused:
 
Maybe your parents are overbearing and overprotective because they assume you can’t make it on your own, which is an assumption many people might rightly or wrongly make about a 34 year old male still living with his parents.

Do you have aspirations beyond your current circumstances? eg do you want to marry and have a family? Frankly, a mid-30s adult make still living with his parents is likely to be a big red flag to many women looking for a potential spouse.

If you want greater independance from your parents, and be a more appealing dating prospect to most women, then you could consider moving out. If you stay in the family home, I find it unlikely that your parents will ever substantially change their attitude towards you.
 
If your parents were are somewhat like my deceased in-laws, they had a difficult time cutting the apron strings, especially with son #2. They had difficulty seeing and accepting their children as adults. Could this be the case? Many parents have a hard time giving up that role.

God bless.
 
And why does he think having children is such a horrible thing? :confused:
Although I cannot read the parent’s mind, I understand the sentiment. A number of persons deeply consider the possibility of remaining celibate for the rest of their lives, for both spiritual and personal reasons.

There are teenagers, myself included, who feel determined to prevent ourselves from acquiring a girlfriend and spouse, despite being aware of the benefits of marriage.
 
Maybe your parents are overbearing and overprotective because they assume you can’t make it on your own, which is an assumption many people might rightly or wrongly make about a 34 year old male still living with his parents.

Do you have aspirations beyond your current circumstances? eg do you want to marry and have a family? Frankly, a mid-30s adult make still living with his parents is likely to be a big red flag to many women looking for a potential spouse.

If you want greater independance from your parents, and be a more appealing dating prospect to most women, then you could consider moving out. If you stay in the family home, I find it unlikely that your parents will ever substantially change their attitude towards you.
This. And I agree with Lorelai that you have left a lot of details out…
 
Thank you. I am wondering on how normal it is for a parent to be this protective? Mother and father were raised Catholic. I go to mass with my mom every Saturday. Went to Catholic school until I graduated.
Well, it is not usual for parents to be this protective of someone your age–is there a reason for it? If you have a disability of some sort, that could cause them to be more protective than usual.

Have you gone to college? Do you have a job? What do you want for yourself?

ETA: A high level of overprotectiveness is not related to being Catholic.
 
When people are under stress, they say things they don’t mean, they say things that are better left unsaid, they forget to say things they should, and they forget to say things in the way they should. This is why people going through stresses that don’t seem to be related to their marriages or families often see their personal relationships suffer.

It is hard to say why he is stressed out–the reasons one might feel stressed to have an adult child living with them really are varied–but you are getting some insight into how your father handles stress. Try not to take the things your father says personally. Maybe he believes them. Maybe he doesn’t. Do make a mental note about this for the future. Stress brings some people closer, but probably not you and your dad. If you do what you can to preserve the relationship until the two of you can get separate residences, the chances are very high that you will thank yourself later. It is easy to burn bridges, and hard to re-build them. Take notes on the things your dad is doing that you don’t want to imitate, but try not to be too hard on him for not hitting a home run on how he’s handling this. He’s got you under his roof, so try to cut him some slack.

You say your parents are protective and want to know if it is normal. I don’t even know what you mean by “protective,” but the chances are that the answer is “yes.” There is a great range in the amount of control people think they ought to have over anyone living under their roof, whether they pay rent or not. It doesn’t matter, really. You have the family you have.

As one saying says, “the definition of a dysfunctional family is this: a dysfunctional family is any family with more than one person in it.” The chances are high that yours does not need professional help. The chances are even higher that yours needs lots of lots of patience. Love is patient. Love is kind…" and you know the rest.

Hang in there. This is rough, but others have gotten through it. Try to love your parents as well as you can and move out at your first decent opportunity. When you’ve done that, you’ll probably enjoy each other a lot more! (I come from a very big family; I know whereof I speak…)
 
Thank you. I am wondering on how normal it is for a parent to be this protective? Mother and father were raised Catholic. I go to mass with my mom every Saturday. Went to Catholic school until I graduated.
You have to make the move if that is what you are pondering. Are you paying your share to your parents? It is important because it is the adult thing to do. If you want to move out, you might start by looking for a housemate. If that is too difficult right now, try an activity like biking where you can race, meet people and maybe even take a trip with people in the club.
 
Hey all. Thanks for the responses. Let me see if I can provide some more details. first I am the adopted only child of two parents. They are both in their 60’s. I have a full time job that I have held for the past 11 years. I pay what bills my dad lets me pay, my cell and help out with car insurance. Dad wishes me to have no debt when he and mom pass away so he pays all the bills and buys all the groceries.

I agree that living with my folks makes dating rough but I am able to save up a decent savings account. I own my car, paid for it myself.

I don’t know what else to add here.
 
Thank you. You gave more details about what your parents are like, and what life is like living with them. However the most useful detail is what does God want you to do with your life, and are you willing to follow His path?

God gave you wonderful gifts, God has a wonderful plan for your life! Do you feel called to the priesthood, marriage or the single life? What is your faith life like?

It is important to honor your parents, that is the commandment. It is not a commandment to surrender your entire life to them, you must surrender your life to God. Is it God’s plan for you to live with your parent’s forever or does he have another path that you are hiding from because you are used to your current life? Please be assured of my prayers.
Honestly I am not following what you are saying. I love my parents but at the same time can’t stand to be around them at times. Dad has gone back no his word and can be very nosy about what goes on. My mother and myself have to go out of our way to not set dad off as he can have a very short temper. At the same time I feel I owe my parents my life and a huge debt. I have told my dad I would give up everything for him. To him I am the center of his entire universe. He places me before even my mom. They have been together almost 50 years.

I sometimes wish to be married but single life is rather nice too. Same with kids. I sometimes want some and other times enjoy having free time and money.
 
Honestly I am not following what you are saying. I love my parents but at the same time can’t stand to be around them at times. Dad has gone back no his word and can be very nosy about what goes on. My mother and myself have to go out of our way to not set dad off as he can have a very short temper. At the same time I feel I owe my parents my life and a huge debt. I have told my dad I would give up everything for him. To him I am the center of his entire universe. He places me before even my mom. They have been together almost 50 years.

I sometimes wish to be married but single life is rather nice too. Same with kids. I sometimes want some and other times enjoy having free time and money.
I have enough brothers that I cannot count them on one hand. I have brothers that lived with my parents into their 30s and brothers that essentially moved out as soon as finances allowed for it. You’re one of the ones who ought to move out. This is not good for you.

Move out as soon as you can find a suitable place to live. Just say, “Dad, I love you, and I know you love me, we’d lay down our lives for each other, but we do not love living under the same roof. It is wonderful that you’re helping me save money, but I’d rather economize on how much we drive each other nuts than economize on money.” (Your parents reply, then you say, “OK, then: I’d rather economize on how nuts I am going by living at home at the age of 34 than economize on money.”) Then find yourself a place of your own to live. If you have to, get a roommate. Make it a point to visit your parents often, but have your own place, even if it is a little nothing of a place.

If you marry a woman your own age, you window for having children is fast approaching the day it will close. I do not just mean in terms of fertility. I mean that you have to still have the energy and the time to parent. The next decade will fly by faster than you think. You need to get a place of your own in order to decide if living alone is what you want when you no longer have your parents to care for.

There are reasons to live alone besides wanting to marry and have children, however. You may want to live alone just so you can conduct your career and your social life without the supervision of your parents. You may want to be the one who makes your “house rules.” I think this unquestionably describes you. This describes the vast majority of typical 25 year olds, let alone the vast majority of 34 year olds. Again: Some like living with their parents at that age, but most of us want more autonomy than we could possibly have if we lived with our parents or even with our siblings. (Did anyone tell you that the TV show “Dallas” was a total lie? It was. No one that rich lives in the same house with their parents. No wonder that family was so dysfunctional.)

As for finding a woman, if you are living at home with your parents at age 34, you are drastically narrowing the field of women who would even consider marrying you. Many (perhaps most) will conclude that you are not likely enough to separate from your parents to the degree necessary to have a separate life with her that they don’t control in some way. A woman might love your parents very much and yet still not want to be married to them, if you get my drift.

My mother and myself have to go out of our way to not set dad off as he can have a very short temper… I have told my dad I would give up everything for him. To him I am the center of his entire universe. He places me before even my mom.

You are adopted, and an only child. Your situation isn’t far from typical–you only have to read the extensive world library of “Jewish mother” jokes to realize that–but it really isn’t healthy, either.

The wonders of Jewish mothers (and lots of other parents who will remain nameless)

• My mother taught me TO APPRECIATE A JOB WELL DONE
“If you two are going to kill each other, do it outside - I just finished cleaning!”

• My mother taught me about TIME TRAVEL
“If you don’t behave, I’m going to knock you into the middle of next week!”

• My mother taught me LOGIC
“Because I said so, that’s why.”

• My mother taught me FORESIGHT
“Make sure you wear clean underwear, in case you’re in an accident.”

• My mother taught me IRONY
“Keep crying and I’ll give you something to cry about.”

• My mother taught me about OSMOSIS
“Shut your mouth and eat your supper!”

• My mother taught me about CONTORTIONISM
“Will you look at the dirt on the back of your neck!”

• My mother taught me about WEATHER
“It looks as if a tornado swept through your room.”

• My mother taught me about HYPOCRISY
“If I’ve told you once, I’ve told you a million times - Don’t Exaggerate!!!”

• My mother taught me THE CIRCLE OF LIFE
“I brought you into this world, and I can take you out.”

• My mother taught me about BEHAVIOUR MODIFICATION
“Stop acting like your father!”

• My mother taught me about ENVY
“There are millions of less fortunate children in this world who don’t have wonderful parents like you do!”

• My mother taught me TO THINK AHEAD
“If you don’t pass your spelling test, you’ll never get a good job!”

• My mother taught me ESP
“Put your sweater on - don’t you think I know when you’re cold?”

• My mother taught me TO MEET A CHALLENGE
“What were you thinking? Answer me when I talk to you! Don’t talk back to me!”

• My mother taught me GENETICS.
“You’re just like your father.”

• My mother taught me about my ROOTS.
“Shut that door behind you. Do you think you were born in a barn?”

• My mother taught me WISDOM.
“When you get to be my age, you’ll understand.”

• My mother taught me about JUSTICE.
“One day you’ll have kids, and I hope they turn out just like you!”
 
Does any of this sound familiar? Again–you are not alone, but you need to be living under a roof that you can call your own. The parental habits below are God’s way of getting adults to move out of an otherwise cushy situation: living with their parents.

• Mothers only offer advice twice, when you want it and when you don’t.
• A mother’s love is a better cure than chicken soup, but chicken soup is cheaper.
• Your mother is the only person who knows more about you than you know about yourself.
• The motherly advice you ignore will always turn out to be the best advice she ever gave you.
• If you forget, your mother will remind you of all your mistakes so you don’t repeat them.
• Anything you do can be criticized by your mother - even doing nothing.
• You can’t “out mother” your mother. Don’t even try.
• Never lie to your mother. And if you do, never think you got away with it.
• The harder you try to hide something from your mother, the more she resembles a webcam.
• The older you are, the more you feel like a child around your mother.
• Mother’s way is best. If you don’t believe it, ask her.
 
Actually none of it sounds familiar. I stay at home a lot, don’t like clubbing, I love to read, my second home is the internet (lol), work hard, get along great with others, have plenty of friends, have some hobbies, don’t smoke, don’t drink, don’t do drugs.

All of that aside my dad has told me I can’t make it on my own. That my savings would vanish quickly. His plan is I live my life at the house until they die. House is pad off, three out of four of our cars are paid off, heck I think they are paying off their funeral expenses so I don’t have to worry about a thing. Mom even told me a week or so ago that once I die the plan is I am buried with them/cremated and place with them.

Life isn’t exactly comfy nor is it easy. Despite assumptions being an only child can suck a lot.
 
Actually none of it sounds familiar. I stay at home a lot, don’t like clubbing, I love to read, my second home is the internet (lol), work hard, get along great with others, have plenty of friends, have some hobbies, don’t smoke, don’t drink, don’t do drugs.

All of that aside my dad has told me I can’t make it on my own. That my savings would vanish quickly. His plan is I live my life at the house until they die. House is pad off, three out of four of our cars are paid off, heck I think they are paying off their funeral expenses so I don’t have to worry about a thing. Mom even told me a week or so ago that once I die the plan is I am buried with them/cremated and place with them.

Life isn’t exactly comfy nor is it easy. Despite assumptions being an only child can suck a lot.
It’s good that this doesn’t sound familiar, but you don’t sound like my brothers who actually enjoyed living at home after the age of 30. How much time have you spent living on your own–that is, not at home and not in a dorm or a fraternity?

It is great for your parents to offer all of these things to you. It isn’t great for them to assume that you, unlike nearly every other single 34-year old in the world with a steady job, have no way to live within your means. It is a little insulting that they don’t think that your burial place is something that is you deserve to be consulted about. You could live on your own, and it is your right to declare pronouncements that you can’t as taboo. Make that a condition of sticking around. Really. That’s terribly insulting.

This is all up to you. If you think you might want to marry, move out. That is a no-brainer. Do not tell anyone you date that you have decided you are going to live in your childhood home when your parents die, whether your wife would like it or not. *That *is a no-brainer. If you want to attract someone with whom you can “leave father and mother…and become one body,” then start by showing you are capable of leaving your father and your mother.

Having said that, the harshest reality of being a singleton is when the health of your parents starts to fail. When that happens, it will be you taking care of them, and not the other way around. It can be very stressful to have to shoulder that load with no siblings to help, even if you have the support of a husband or wife while you’re doing it. It is even more stressful if you haven’t carved out and adult-to-adult relationship with your parents. On that account, I’d say that if you move out and do not marry, it is not at all unlikely that you will move back in when one of your parents becomes too much for the other one to care for alone. That might be tomorrow or that may be in thirty years. No one can know that. If you’d like to live on your own some time in the next thirty years, though, I would advise you do it now.

If you do stay at home, congratulations, it is your job to draw your own boundaries with your parents and enforce your own expectation that you be treated as the adult you are. Have fun with that while you’re still living at home. It can be done, though. It is a lot noisier and more stressful, but it is hardly impossible. You DO need to do that, though. You are too old to be “protected” by your parents. You are a man, now, and you have been one for a long time. It is time that you insist that you be treated like one. If you don’t, you can thank yourself if you are treated like a child. People will usually do what they can get away with doing, and parents are not an exception.
 
I honestly think it’s time – past time for you to get out on your own and stand on your own two feet. While your parents are truly nice and loving, they’re hindering your growth – and you’re allowing it to happen.

It might be very expensive where you live; but that doesn’t mean you can’t make it. Either rent something very cheap or get roommates. If you’ve truly saved a bunch of money, you’d probably have a pretty good down payment for a house or condo – though I would highly suggest you rent for a while and get used to paying your own bills before jumping into home ownership.

I think you underestimate how much damage is being done to your personal growth. Living with your parents when you’re in transition is a great and loving gift they can give to you. You’re beyond that.
 
You sound a lot like me! Only I’m female, I pay my bills, and my parents are not completely controlling, but they don’t give me much encouragement to live by myself, I’m having to talk myself into it and am now taking steps to find my own place. But I get you! 🙂
 
Honestly thanks! I have been told I need to move out. Heck I want to but my self esteem is poor due to being told I can’t do it. Dad makes breakfast for me, they drive me to work. While all nice it does get to be inhibitive. I got stuff to think on.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top