N
new_atheist
Guest
This is worth a read.
au.news.yahoo.com/vic/a/22441399/pedophile-priests-attrocities-laid-bare/?cmp=ydn
au.news.yahoo.com/vic/a/22441399/pedophile-priests-attrocities-laid-bare/?cmp=ydn
I don’t think that’s such a great idea as the intentions of the last one are yet to be accurately implemented. Give it another 50 years perhaps.My view is that an Ecumenical Council is the only body which can deal with the crisis…
Although I really don’t know for sure, It seemed to me that the professional confidentiality of the Catholic confessional may have gotten into the way …What was the logic behind moving these priests around in the first place? Why not report them to the police? Was it honestly believed that such people could be reformed?
The vast majority of the billion+ Roman Catholics in the world understand the truth about the scandals, know it was a small minority of priests, know that the teachings of the vast majority of the other purely innocent Catholic priests is good and still love the RCC.As one newspaper reported a couple of years ago , the sex-abuse scandal in the Church is its greatest problem since the Reformation .
I was taken aback by such a remark , but on reflection I accepted its validity .
We can say “Good-bye” to evangelization for a long time since the Magisterium has lost its credibilty .
The Church is almost mortally wounded , and the problem is not going to go away for a long time .
My view is that an Ecumenical Council is the only body which can deal with the crisis and let the rest of the world see that the Church means business.
The Church has, and always will have, sinners in its ranks. It started that way by Peter denying Christ three times, Thomas doubting Christ, and Judas (hand picked by Christ) betrayed Him. The teaching authority of the Church still has credibility if one simply takes the time to read what Christ and His Apostles said.As one newspaper reported a couple of years ago , the sex-abuse scandal in the Church is its greatest problem since the Reformation .
I was taken aback by such a remark , but on reflection I accepted its validity .
We can say “Good-bye” to evangelization for a long time since the Magisterium has lost its credibilty .
The Church is almost mortally wounded , and the problem is not going to go away for a long time .
My view is that an Ecumenical Council is the only body which can deal with the crisis and let the rest of the world see that the Church means business.
Well the gates of hell may not have prevailed against the church, but they’ve sure given it a very good rattling =/The Church has, and always will have, sinners in its ranks. It started that way by Peter denying Christ three times, Thomas doubting Christ, and Judas (hand picked by Christ) betrayed Him. The teaching authority of the Church still has credibility if one simply takes the time to read what Christ and His Apostles said.
Christ promised His Church would last forever:
“And so I say to you, you are Peter, and upon this rock I will build my church, and the gates of the netherworld shall not prevail against it.” (Mt 16:18)
The Church has addressed and is continuing to address the problem. The level of credible accusations against the Church has dropped to a level virtually no other organization in the country can claim. ** Last year according to the Catholic League, there were only 7 credible accusations** against a total of 40,000 priests (Meaning 99.99% of Priests are innocent). While that is still 7 too many, compared to virtually any other organization, that number is low, and shows the Church has made great strides in addressing the issue.
Catholic League did not investigate the Catholic Church, only counted the number of priests and counted the number of credible allegations brought against the Catholic clergy. Credible being define as those cases where they were not dismissed by law enforcement. Over the last 5 years average number of credible accusations is 7 for over 40,000 priests.Well the gates of hell may not have prevailed against the church, but they’ve sure given it a very good rattling =/
I guess the issue with those statistics is they result from a Catholic organisation investigating the Catholic Church, which some may a problem with
I think a good thing to do would be to make child abuse excommunicable, if it’s not already.
Motive? Laziness, incompetence, dereliction of duty all covered over by a veneer of “professionalism” that was a massive fad in the ranks of the bishops starting after WWII. Every level of the church seemed to suddenly get enamored of credentials for this, certifications for that, consultants for each and every issue. Sadly, this coincided with the time frame that the Kinsey disciples were taking over the soft sciences and the advice received from “experts” was horrible (focusing on counseling and treatment for the abusers rather than protecting the children). This was by no means limited to the Church. This was the pattern throughout society in that era. Roman Polanski’s prosecution was the exception, not the norm back then.What was the logic behind moving these priests around in the first place? Why not report them to the police? Was it honestly believed that such people could be reformed?
WowMotive? Laziness, incompetence, dereliction of duty all covered over by a veneer of “professionalism” that was a massive fad in the ranks of the bishops starting after WWII. Every level of the church seemed to suddenly get enamored of credentials for this, certifications for that, consultants for each and every issue. Sadly, this coincided with the time frame that the Kinsey disciples were taking over the soft sciences and the advice received from “experts” was horrible (focusing on counseling and treatment for the abusers rather than protecting the children). This was by no means limited to the Church. This was the pattern throughout society in that era. Roman Polanski’s prosecution was the exception, not the norm back then.
But the church leadership should have known better. They had the eternal wisdom of revelation and Tradition to guide them and instead they trusted quacky faddish counselors and psychiatrists. Shame.
Federal Rules of Evidence 506 - Communications to Clergy[edit]
(Federal recommended guidelines for State laws)
(a) Definitions. As used in this rule:
(1) A “clergyman” is a minister, priest, rabbi, or other similar functionary of a religious organization, or an individual reasonably believed so to be by the person consulting him. (2) A communication is “confidential” if made privately and not intended for further disclosure except to other persons present in furtherance of the purpose of the communication. (b) General rule of privilege. A person has a privilege to refuse to disclose and to prevent another from disclosing a confidential communication made by the person to a clergyman in his professional character as a spiritual adviser. (c) Who may claim the privilege. The privilege may be claimed by the person, by his guardian or conservator, or by his personal representative if he is deceased. The clergyman may claim the privilege on behalf of the person. His authority so to do is presumed in the absence of evidence to the contrary.
rexCatholic League did not investigate the Catholic Church, only counted the number of priests and counted the number of credible allegations brought against the Catholic clergy. Credible being define as those cases where they were not dismissed by law enforcement. Over the last 5 years average number of credible accusations is 7 for over 40,000 priests.
You should also read the studies done by the John Jay College of Criminal Justice (CUNY)…they are not a Catholic Organization. Relates to the causes of the issue.
If you want shockingly high numbers…research child abuse by public school teachers…the nation’s big secret. (I say that not to deflect blame, but rather to put in context the media attention on the Catholic Church, that does not exist for Jewish clergy, Protestant clergy, school teachers, etc.).
The Catholic Church has done a very good job cleaning up a mess.