Palestinian Christians practice neo-marcionism?

  • Thread starter Thread starter trdchubi
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Amen!

Support by Western Christians for the modern state of Israel is actually worsening the situation of Palestinian Christians. It must therefore cease.
online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052970203960804577239923033348982.html

frontpagemag.com/2012/04/06/the-christian-era-in-the-middle-east-is-over/?utm_source=FrontPage+Magazine&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=7974a2e930-Mailchimp_FrontPageMag

It’s good to know that while Islam is persecuting and destroying Christians and Christianity in the Middle East, they can still be united in their mutual enmity toward the the Jews.
 
online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052970203960804577239923033348982.html

frontpagemag.com/2012/04/06/the-christian-era-in-the-middle-east-is-over/?utm_source=FrontPage+Magazine&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=7974a2e930-Mailchimp_FrontPageMag

It’s good to know that while Islam is persecuting and destroying Christians and Christianity in the Middle East, they can still be united in their mutual enmity toward the the Jews.
I am all for clarity. I see you stating a run on sentence that for me needs clarification. You say that something here is good to know. If something is good to know then I want to know what it is. God alone is good and if something is good to know then it must pertain to something that would be true, close to true or leading me to an understanding of God.

Next you say that Islam is persecuting and destroying Christians and Christianity in the Middle East.

So far I think I follow you. Where I lose you is here. “They”. They are united. Who is this they that you speak of? Is this knowledge personal knowledge, opinion, belief, inferrence as it is not clear. What is the basis of your knowledge, opinion, belief that summarizes who “they” are?

I ask you to define the they for me so that I may understand what it is you are generalizing about. Please take your time.🙂
 
online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052970203960804577239923033348982.html

frontpagemag.com/2012/04/06/the-christian-era-in-the-middle-east-is-over/?utm_source=FrontPage+Magazine&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=7974a2e930-Mailchimp_FrontPageMag

It’s good to know that while Islam is persecuting and destroying Christians and Christianity in the Middle East, they can still be united in their mutual enmity toward the the Jews.
It is interesting that you equate criticism of the state of Israel with enmity toward Jews or Judaism.

I don’t see it.
 
online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052970203960804577239923033348982.html

frontpagemag.com/2012/04/06/the-christian-era-in-the-middle-east-is-over/?utm_source=FrontPage+Magazine&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=7974a2e930-Mailchimp_FrontPageMag

It’s good to know that while Islam is persecuting and destroying Christians and Christianity in the Middle East, they can still be united in their mutual enmity toward the the Jews.
You know maybe you are on to something. Why not give back the land to the American Indan. The reservations are no substitute for a land of my own. The Incas, Aztecs, Toltecs, Mayans all have survivors that would relish the notion of restoration of land that was lost. Let us not forget Northern Ireland. What about the Kurds? Why stop with the Middle East and all lands properly lost. Babylon, Assyria and Samria can be restored…good thought.
 
You know maybe you are on to something. Why not give back the land to the American Indan. The reservations are no substitute for a land of my own. The Incas, Aztecs, Toltecs, Mayans all have survivors that would relish the notion of restoration of land that was lost. Let us not forget Northern Ireland. What about the Kurds? Why stop with the Middle East and all lands properly lost. Babylon, Assyria and Samria can be restored…good thought.
I demand that the Palestinians return their land to the Greeks, that the Greeks return that land to the Israelis, and that the Israelis return that land to the Canaanites. Also that the Turks leave modern Turkey and return it to the Greeks.
 
You know maybe you are on to something. Why not give back the land to the American Indan. The reservations are no substitute for a land of my own. The Incas, Aztecs, Toltecs, Mayans all have survivors that would relish the notion of restoration of land that was lost. Let us not forget Northern Ireland. What about the Kurds? Why stop with the Middle East and all lands properly lost. Babylon, Assyria and Samria can be restored…good thought.
I am of the opinion that occupied Assyria should be returned to the natives. Kurdish dominance of North Iraq, for instance, is a result of genocide and complicity with the planners of genocide, the Muslim Arabs and Turks. So the Kurds of Asia minor, for instance, may go to Central Asia together with their masters who originated there, the Turks. They are not good stewards of the land, and their cries for freedom for themselves ring incredibly hollow in light of Simele and the Assyrian Genocide, both of which they readily participated in, and which no good people of conscience should ever forget.
 
That article is a bunch of baloney. The patristic understanding of God’s promises to Abraham and Israel was always that the Christians are the new Israel, and that God has no further plan for those who reject His Christ but are of the Law, because in Christ, the Law, prophets, and the Old Covenant have been fulfilled. The Palestinian Christians the author is so savagely attacking are Orthodox Christians who have had this understanding of the Scriptures long before the state of Israel every came to be.
I like to share this wonderful insight coming from an Orthodox Priest, Archimandrite Rev. Fr. Eusebius A. Stephanou, Th. D.

He said:

“It appears we have not learned anything from the lesson of Old Israel. Instead, we have followed in their footsteps. We have copied their ominous example. They were incapable of recognizing the Messiah when He came. The Greeks and most Orthodox today are incapable of recognizing the Holy Spirit, as He manifests Himself in the current end-time worldwide outpouring in preparation for the appearance of the Lord Jesus Christ in glory. The Jews resisted God’s Son. The Greeks and other Orthodox resist God’s Spirit”.

He added:

“Yet, the Greeks followed the pattern of the Jews in their national rebellion and apostasy. The Jews began with grace (in Abraham) because of God’s sovereign election of Israel, but ended up in the bondage of the Law. The Greeks, also, began with grace, with the promises of the Gospel, with a covenant relationship in the blood of the Lamb of God. But, like the Jews, they, too, ultimately fell into the bondage of religious legalism, dead forms and self-righteousness”.
 
“Weapon against Israel”? Why can’t people who don’t know what they’re talking about just leave the Palestinian Christians alone. They’re already viewed with suspicion in their own homeland by the Muslim majority, and now they’re castigated for not supporting the forces on the other side of the conflict that have driven so many off the land and out of the region because of modern Christian Zionist (WRONG) readings of scripture? Sick. The writer of that article should be ashamed.
Yes I understand, but have you also consider why those Christian Zionist are acting with doubt against the arab Christians in the Holy Land?

Have you consider why they are being castigated by the government of Israel?

I think Maozisrael understand what the Palestinians Christians wants to do. They are viewing Christians under a leadership that is very anti Israel.

The Greek Orthodox Church is the oldest, richest and most powerful church in Jerusalem. Its present patriarch, Irineos I, and his former spokesman, Father Atallah Hanna, have used even more virulent rhetoric in their own collaborationist campaign. That rhetoric includes supporting suicide bombing, charging the Jews with deicide and advocating their expulsion from the Holy Land.

Ireneos I, even wrote this letter to Arafat:
“You are finally aware of the sentiments of disgust and disrespect that all the Holy Sepulcher Fathers are feeling for the descendants of the crucifiers of our Lord Jesus Christ, actual crucifiers of your people, Sionists (sic) Jewish conquerors of the Holy Land of Palestine”.
I understand that the Patriarch has responsibility towards the flock of Christ in the Holy Land, spiritually and politically. But is this the kind of leadership that the Palestinian Christians need? Is he setting the example of Christ for the Palestinian Christians to imitate and follow?
 
You’re turning things around completely. It’s the pro-Israel Christians who are arguing that God’s love for one particular nation supersedes universal values of peace and justice and also corrects the historic, orthodox Christian understanding of the Church. What pro-Israel folks call “Replacement theology” is, in one way or another, the historic stance of the Church. It’s dispensationalism that is a radical, unorthodox distortion of Biblical teaching.
I really like what Rev. Innokenty Pavlov, professor of theology at Moscow’s Biblical Theological Institute regarding Israel and antisemetism.

Sadly, there are some Orthodox Christians who propagate disgusting anti-Semitism under the banner of Orthodoxy, which is incompatible with Christianity," “We have to raise our voices and call on Orthodox laity and the Church leadership to formulate an official position of the Orthodox Church toward our relations with Judaism, as it was formulated a few decades ago by the Catholic Church”.
Now there are certainly problems with replacement theology. God has never abandoned his care for Israel–that is clear. But the orthodox, historic Christian view is that God’s people now includes both Jews and Gentiles, and that God’s promises to Abraham are fulfilled through Jesus. The modern nation-state of Israel is not the same as the historic people of Israel and is certainly not the chosen people of God. Christians are not called upon to “bless Israel” if that means support the nationalist policies of this particular state.
I don’t get it, how can the Jews who practiced Jewish customs and traditions for centuries NOT be the historic people of Israel and to say the least revive a dead language that is Hebrew? What about the Continuous Jewish Presence in the Holy Land? Did we forgot the scattering and gathering part of the bible?

Blessing Israel is one thing but I am more inclined on blessing and praising God for being truthful to His words in modern times.

I believe Jews and Greeks (all orthodox) should walk together, for the reason that God favored them both. Yes the word is favored. Both peoples were endowed with distinct qualities serving to fulfill God’s redemptive plan for all the nations of the earth. What I am having difficulty with is the idea that the Greeks became extremely legalistic and inflexible that they can’t discern the lessons of the Fig tree today.
 
There’s nothing Marcionite here and nothing that distorts or rejects any part of traditional Christian doctrine. Your citation is highly misleading, because the first two sentences in your quote are not from Ateek but from the pro-Israel website you cite. Of course Ateek never said that he was trying to find a radical new theology–the old, historic, orthodox Christian theology would be quite enough (and indeed a bit too much, insofar as that theology was often anti-Jewish!). The last two sentences then stand without any context, except the biased, misleading context given them by the pro-Israel website. I am pretty sure that Ateek was making a rhetorical point–that this was how Palestinians felt when they heard their fellow-Christians misusing the OT to dehumanize them. But without the full context for his words, we don’t know.

Edwin
Naim Ateek became the unofficial founder of the movement called Christian Palestianism when he established Sabeel. And yes he wrote it in his book **Justice, and Only Justice: A Palestinian Theology of Liberation **as a suggestion. But his followers took it a little further. Philip Saad, a Palestinian Christian who lives in Haifa, Israel said that:
In recent years a phenomenon of palestinization has also occurred among the Christian Arabs who live in Israel. Saad describes these recent developments in the following way: liberation theology, amillennialism, Replacement theology and the Covenant of Grace theology. It also includes a strong rejection of dispensationalism and of a literal interpretation of the Bible. He notes that some Christian Palestinians do not use the Old Testament as a source for their theology and that some writers still use the Old Testament but selectively, while he characterizes them as all using a spiritual hermeneutic
.
 
Are the Arab Christians in Judea and Samaria opening themselves to the heresy of Marcion? Marcionism believes that many of the teachings of Christ are incompatible with the actions of the God of the Old Testament.

According to Rev. Dr. Naim Ateek, former Canon of St. George’s Cathedral in East Jerusalem

Read The Latest Weapon Against Israel: Palestinian Christianity

These statements from an Anglican reverent indicate a sense of national or ethnic belonging that supersedes Christian fellowship. Although they might sound at home in a nationalist Church, they do not fit comfortably in a faith that is deeply rooted into Judeo-Christian beliefs.

I’m really wondering, is Palestinian sovereignty really more important to these Christians to which they are willing to change God’s word in order for it to go well with their political agenda?
You seem to have an Israeli agenda of your own 🤷
 
I demand that the Palestinians return their land to the Greeks, that the Greeks return that land to the Israelis, and that the Israelis return that land to the Canaanites. Also that the Turks leave modern Turkey and return it to the Greeks.
And the USA return Hawaii to the native Hawaiians! 👍
 
Yes I understand, but have you also consider why those Christian Zionist are acting with doubt against the arab Christians in the Holy Land?

Should I have to? They’re helping to ruin the lives of the Palestinian Christians. I have no sympathy for the agendas they employ in doing so. Let them go home to England and America; they can just as easily wait for the Messiah there and leave the Palestinians alone.
Have you consider why they are being castigated by the government of Israel?
 
I like to share this wonderful insight coming from an Orthodox Priest, Archimandrite Rev. Fr. Eusebius A. Stephanou, Th. D.

He said:

“It appears we have not learned anything from the lesson of Old Israel. Instead, we have followed in their footsteps. We have copied their ominous example. They were incapable of recognizing the Messiah when He came. The Greeks and most Orthodox today are incapable of recognizing the Holy Spirit, as He manifests Himself in the current end-time worldwide outpouring in preparation for the appearance of the Lord Jesus Christ in glory. The Jews resisted God’s Son. The Greeks and other Orthodox resist God’s Spirit”.

He added:

“Yet, the Greeks followed the pattern of the Jews in their national rebellion and apostasy. The Jews began with grace (in Abraham) because of God’s sovereign election of Israel, but ended up in the bondage of the Law. The Greeks, also, began with grace, with the promises of the Gospel, with a covenant relationship in the blood of the Lamb of God. But, like the Jews, they, too, ultimately fell into the bondage of religious legalism, dead forms and self-righteousness”.
Firstly, Orthodox and Greek are not the same. I am not Greek, but I am, by the grace of God, Orthodox. Secondly, his criticism of modern Greeks in no way undermines the self-understanding that Orthodoxy is the One, Holy, Catholic and Apostolic Church. Now what does that have to do with the content of my response to your original post? You still have not offered any response to the fact that the much-maligned “replacement theory” is patristic, while modern protestant interpretations of who “Israel” refers to are not. What allows you, as a Catholic, to reject the patristic tradition in favor of modern Protestant theories?
 
Here is what Orthodox Jews are saying about Zionism!

nkusa.org/

JUDAISM AND ZIONISM ARE NOT THE SAME THING
We would like to take a few minutes of your time to prevent you from making a terrible mistake that may have disastrous results for many.

You have always without a doubt heard and read much about the political crises in the Middle East in which the State of Israel plays a central role. This is, in fact, an ongoing series of crises with potential to bring the greatest misfortune on the entire world. Tragically many believe that Zionism and Judaism are identical. Thus they conclude that the entire Jewish people is responsible for the actions of the Zionist government and the world crises which emanates from it. This is a Grave Error!

The truth is that the Jewish faith and Zionism are two very different philosophies. They are as opposite as day and night. The Jewish people have existed for thousands of years. In their two thousand years of Divinely decreed exile no Jew ever sought to end this exile and establish independent political sovereignty anywhere. The people’s sole purpose was the study and fulfillment of the Divine commandments of the Torah.

The Zionist movement created the Israeli state
. The latter is a persuasion less than one hundred years old. Its essential goal was and is to change the nature of the Jewish people from that of a religious entity to a political movement. From Zionism’s inception the spiritual leaders of the Jewish people stood in staunch opposition to it.

To this day Torah Jewry remains forever loyal to its faith. Zionists want the world to believe that they are the representatives of the entire Jewish people. This is false! The Jewish people never chose them as their leaders.

The Zionists have deceived many well meaning Jewish people via terror, trickery and false propaganda. They have at their disposal the use of a nearly universally subservient media. Whoever attempts to criticize them puts his livelihood and, at times, his very life in danger.


However, despite the media blackout and easy resort to terror the simple truth remains unrefuted and irrefutable:** ACCORDING TO THE JEWISH FAITH AND TORAH LAW THE JEWISH PEOPLE ARE FORBIDDEN TO HAVE THEIR OWN STATE WHILE AWAITING THE MESSIANIC ERA!**

The Creator gave us the Holy Land thousands of years ago. Yet, when we sinned, He took it away and sent us into exile. Since that time our task is to wait for Him to send the Messiah. At that time, the Creator alone, without any human being lifting a hand or saying a word, will bring us together and take us out of exile. He will likewise establish universal peace among all mankind and all will serve Him in good will.

Some religious Jews, confused by Zionist propaganda quote Biblical verses that state that G-d gave the children of Israel the Holy Land. They overlook, unfortunately, those verses which say that He took it away due to our sins. They further ignore those prophecies which explicitly describe the last exile’s conclusion as a Divine, not a human process.

The Creator has commanded every Jew to follow the ways of peace and to be loyal to the country where he lives.


**Torah true Jewry waits patiently for the Messianic redemption. They have nothing to do with any kind of pseudo “Jewish State” and its aggressions against other peoples. They have a deep sympathy for the plight of the Palestinians who have suffered the most from Zionism’s false teachings and barbaric actions. The Zionist state is not a Jewish state. The Zionists alone are the only ones responsible for their actions. Authentic Jewry has and will continue to oppose the very existence of this blasphemous state.
**
May all mankind witness the true redemption.
 
Here is what Orthodox Jews are saying about Zionism!

nkusa.org/

JUDAISM AND ZIONISM ARE NOT THE SAME THING
We would like to take a few minutes of your time to prevent you from making a terrible mistake that may have disastrous results for many.

You have always without a doubt heard and read much about the political crises in the Middle East in which the State of Israel plays a central role. This is, in fact, an ongoing series of crises with potential to bring the greatest misfortune on the entire world. Tragically many believe that Zionism and Judaism are identical. Thus they conclude that the entire Jewish people is responsible for the actions of the Zionist government and the world crises which emanates from it. This is a Grave Error!

The truth is that the Jewish faith and Zionism are two very different philosophies. They are as opposite as day and night. The Jewish people have existed for thousands of years. In their two thousand years of Divinely decreed exile no Jew ever sought to end this exile and establish independent political sovereignty anywhere. The people’s sole purpose was the study and fulfillment of the Divine commandments of the Torah.

The Zionist movement created the Israeli state
. The latter is a persuasion less than one hundred years old. Its essential goal was and is to change the nature of the Jewish people from that of a religious entity to a political movement. From Zionism’s inception the spiritual leaders of the Jewish people stood in staunch opposition to it.

To this day Torah Jewry remains forever loyal to its faith. Zionists want the world to believe that they are the representatives of the entire Jewish people. This is false! The Jewish people never chose them as their leaders.

The Zionists have deceived many well meaning Jewish people via terror, trickery and false propaganda. They have at their disposal the use of a nearly universally subservient media. Whoever attempts to criticize them puts his livelihood and, at times, his very life in danger.


However, despite the media blackout and easy resort to terror the simple truth remains unrefuted and irrefutable:** ACCORDING TO THE JEWISH FAITH AND TORAH LAW THE JEWISH PEOPLE ARE FORBIDDEN TO HAVE THEIR OWN STATE WHILE AWAITING THE MESSIANIC ERA!**

The Creator gave us the Holy Land thousands of years ago. Yet, when we sinned, He took it away and sent us into exile. Since that time our task is to wait for Him to send the Messiah. At that time, the Creator alone, without any human being lifting a hand or saying a word, will bring us together and take us out of exile. He will likewise establish universal peace among all mankind and all will serve Him in good will.

Some religious Jews, confused by Zionist propaganda quote Biblical verses that state that G-d gave the children of Israel the Holy Land. They overlook, unfortunately, those verses which say that He took it away due to our sins. They further ignore those prophecies which explicitly describe the last exile’s conclusion as a Divine, not a human process.

The Creator has commanded every Jew to follow the ways of peace and to be loyal to the country where he lives.


**Torah true Jewry waits patiently for the Messianic redemption. They have nothing to do with any kind of pseudo “Jewish State” and its aggressions against other peoples. They have a deep sympathy for the plight of the Palestinians who have suffered the most from Zionism’s false teachings and barbaric actions. The Zionist state is not a Jewish state. The Zionists alone are the only ones responsible for their actions. Authentic Jewry has and will continue to oppose the very existence of this blasphemous state.
**
May all mankind witness the true redemption.
The most important point is that you have here what are called “Torah” Jews. There are “Talmud” Jews. Judaism of Ezrah/Nehemiah no longer exists as there is no temple, no Levitical priesthood and no animal sacrifices. We have descendants of what was. They are people. God is God of all, God is God of Jew, Gentile, Barbarian, Greek, Gentile, Pagan, Barbarian…and Israel is people not land…

Wow. Are there still Cananites that would want their land?
 
online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052970203960804577239923033348982.html

frontpagemag.com/2012/04/06/the-christian-era-in-the-middle-east-is-over/?utm_source=FrontPage+Magazine&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=7974a2e930-Mailchimp_FrontPageMag

It’s good to know that while Islam is persecuting and destroying Christians and Christianity in the Middle East, they can still be united in their mutual enmity toward the the Jews.
Thank you for conveniently sidestepping the issue. It is preposterous to imply that objecting to the policies pursued by the state of Israel is comparable, in any way, shape, or form, to wishing for the destruction of all Jews on earth. This clever trick to distract from the question at hand–one which does not reflect well on the country which too many people support unquestioningly–is absolutely outrageous. I harbour no feelings of anti-Semitism whatsoever, and even insinuating the contrary is a completely unwarranted assault on my character.

Although Israel isn’t violently persecuting Christians as have been Wahhabi/Salafi Islamists in Iraq, the results are the same: an unending exodus of the followers of Christ from, and a continual decrease in their numbers in, the region where the faith was born.
 
I’m pretty sure the Church is in solidarity with all persecuted Christians and that includes the Palestinians.

Vatican and Israeli relations are quite complicated and at times have been quite hostile. Trchubi reeks of an agenda clearly by portraying Palestinian Christians as unworthy adherents of the faith.

And quite frankly it saddens and disgusts me that a fellow Christian would be so blinded by there own political agenda (Yes the Israeli stance is purely political).

The Palestinians aren’t perfect and there’s groups of them that do horrible things to Israel. But for one poster (a Christian no matter) to go out of their way to say all Palestinians are bad Christians is terribly wrong and misguided.

🤷
 
The most important point is that you have here what are called “Torah” Jews. There are “Talmud” Jews. Judaism of Ezrah/Nehemiah no longer exists as there is no temple, no Levitical priesthood and no animal sacrifices. We have descendants of what was. They are people. God is God of all, God is God of Jew, Gentile, Barbarian, Greek, Gentile, Pagan, Barbarian…and Israel is people not land…

Wow. Are there still Cananites that would want their land?
Indeed, this post of mine was taken from Neturei Karta, an international organization of Orthodox Jews dedicated to the propagation and clarification of Torah Judaism.

I think Zionism is ludicrous, dangerous, and not just anti-palastinian, but anti-jew and anti-human.

I used to attend a Calvary Chapel, and they would often talk about the third temple, and how “we must stand up for Israel, because they are God’s chosen people and that is their God given land”

One guy I talked to used to pray for World War 3 :eek: Nuclear war :eek: so “God’s Will, would be done, and Jesus Return, to start the literal 1000 year reign.” After that we could all enter some sort of Neo-Platonic, non physical, spiritual heaven.

I cited the Neturei Karta article to point out, it’s the Atheistic Jews, that promote, the nation state of Israel, while the Jews that actually believe in God, reject Zionism!

Zionism is yet another dangerous Idea, to come out of Dispensationalism!

Talk to a dispensationalist and tell them you are against Zionism and for peace in the Middle East, and they may call you an anti-semite, or tell you that you just don’t believe God’s Word, because you are saying NO to Jesus return. Ridiculous!!!

As a Catholic, I think we are to reject Zionism, because we are to love the Jew, Gentile, Barbarian, Greek, Gentile, Pagan, Barbarian. Zionism and Love of humanity are incompatible IMHO!

Peace and Love in Christ to the all, the Jew, Gentile, Barbarian, Greek, Gentile, Pagan, Barbarian.👍
 
Psalms 69;5

ה רַבּוּ, מִשַּׂעֲרוֹת רֹאשִׁי-- שֹׂנְאַי חִנָּם:
עָצְמוּ מַצְמִיתַי, אֹיְבַי שֶׁקֶר–
  1. Those who hate me for nothing are more numerous than the hairs of my head; mighty are those who would cut me off, who are my enemies because of lies;
1 Maccabees 15:33

And Simon answered him, and said to him: We have neither taken other men’s land, neither do we hold that which is other men’s: but the inheritance of our fathers, which was for some time unjustly possessed by our enemies.
  • Douay Rheims Bible
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top