Parish Questions

  • Thread starter Thread starter Revert_43
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
R

Revert_43

Guest
I believe people should go to their local parish if at all possible and I do attend my local parish, the previous priest drove most people out (long story for another thread) and his replacement is much much better. Not as orthodox as I’d like but he’s pretty good. I do have two questions and am wondering if I’m being a little over the top.

First, each week there is a kids mass. The kids come up and sit on the altar and the sermon is geared toward them, this is pretty common in my archdiocese. For Halloween this year the kids can wear there Halloween costumes. That seems inappropriate to me.

Second, a local protestant church is having it’s final service in the next few weeks. My church has been invited to join in the final service of the church that is closing (not during mass times). Again, not sure if this is right. The local area churches try to be get along and one weekend a year the pastors all preach at each others church but it just doesn’t seem right.

Any thoughts?
 
I hope you mean the kids are in the sanctuary (bad enough) and not that they are literally sitting on the altar. :eek: I hope I don’t need to point out that treating a consecrated altar in that manner is not even remotely appropriate.

It is allowed to have a special children’s Mass–there are even approved Eucharistic prayers for these–with the homily geared towards children. I have heard conflicting reports about whether children are allowed in the sanctuary itself near the altar at any time during a Mass that uses the children’s liturgy. It is certainly not allowed at Masses other than children’s Masses, excepting that extraordinary ministers may approach the altar after the clergy have communicated, and of course that altar servers must approach the altar in order to carry out their duties. IOW, under normal circumstance, the altar is only approached by those whom the priest or deacon requires for help, at the time when their presence is required. As for dress at Mass, it is normally left up to parents. As there is a long history of actors dressing as angels and demons for performances of Mexican Christmas pastorelas, I think it is safe to say that dressing up in odd costumes is not automatically forbidden, per se, especially not for children.

Translators are allowed, but other than that nobody can preach a homily at Mass other than a bishop, priest or deacon who is in good standing with the local bishop. It is possible for others to preach in a Catholic church, under certain circumstances. A non-Catholic could be a guest speaker, if the bishop was OK with it, but never a guest homilist.

As for the priest participating in prayer at another church, I guess the principle is that from Unitatis Redintegratio (Decree on Ecumenism, 1964):
"*In certain special circumstances, such as the prescribed prayers “for unity,” and during ecumenical gatherings, it is allowable, indeed desirable that Catholics should join in prayer with their separated brethren. Such prayers in common are certainly an effective means of obtaining the grace of unity, and they are a true expression of the ties which still bind Catholics to their separated brethren. “For where two or three are gathered together in my name, there am I in the midst of them”.[33]

Yet worship in common (communicatio in sacris) is not to be considered as a means to be used indiscriminately for the restoration of Christian unity. There are two main principles governing the practice of such common worship: first, the bearing witness to the unity of the Church, and second, the sharing in the means of grace. Witness to the unity of the Church very generally forbids common worship to Christians, but the grace to be had from it sometimes commends this practice. The course to be adopted, with due regard to all the circumstances of time, place, and persons, is to be decided by local episcopal authority, unless otherwise provided for by the Bishops’ Conference according to its statutes, or by the Holy See*."

In other words, it may be permissible, but cases not specifically allowed by Rome or the USCCB would require the specific consent of the local bishop. In the case you described of the church closing, I’m guessing that a great many bishops would allow the visit. If the trade-a-preacher program remotely implied a non-Catholic preaching within the context of the Mass, there is no way. I have heard of such a thing happening, don’t get me wrong, but it is never in keeping with the rubrics.

Your diocese probably has an Office for Worship that can answer your specific questions more directly, though.
 
When the priest consecrates the Eucharist does he use the correct words? If so, I’m good.

Did you miss type about children sitting on the alter? I agree that they can sit around the ambo, but not on the alter.
 
Yes, I guess I mistyped, the children sit in front of the altar and the ambo. There are steps that lead up to the altar and ambo, the children sit there, the priest turns and addresses the children sitting there. Sorry for the confusion.
 
The Holy See has specifically directed that the laity (other than altar servers) are not to be in the sanctuary during the Eucharistric Prayer. Though not specifically spelt out, the tenor of the Church’s directives is that the laity (except EHMCs, Lectors etc.) should not be in the sanctuary during any other part of the Mass either.

Yes there are special children’s Mass forms, but these are directed to be used only when the congregation is “overwhelmingly” (say >90%) composed of children of primary school age and are primarily intended for weekday use. Adults who do their duty and come to Sunday Mass deserve to be allowed to particpate in an adult Mass, including hearing an adult sermon.

As for participating in the closing ceremonies for the protestant church, go for it! It could be a great opportunity to tell its congregation, “hey we’ve still got a great thriving Catholic parish down the road - try coming with us!”
 
I hope you mean the kids are in the sanctuary (bad enough) and not that they are literally sitting on the altar. :eek: I hope I don’t need to point out that treating a consecrated altar in that manner is not even remotely appropriate.
This is off-topic for the OP but I had to comment on this. I’ve noticed that many people use that expression when they mean ‘in the sanctuary’. One mother discovered how confusing the comment was when her university-aged daughter came home for holidays and as a former reader was invited to still be one during the summer.

The day she came for a refresher practice I told her she was the first reader and as such would be bringing up the Book of Gospels and she was to lay it on the altar. She looked at me, puzzled, and repeated “On the altar?” “Yes, you place it flat on the altar. Father will get it from there when it’s time to read the Gospel.” “OK.”

On Sunday, just before the readings, I noticed that the altar was bare of Book. When the priest walked over to the altar to retrieve the Book I saw him bend over and come up with the Book. Colour me confused.

After Mass I approached the girl and said “I guess we had a error in communication. You were supposed to put the Book on the altar.” “I did.” Her mother jumps in and says, “She did put it on the altar.” OK, I wasn’t about to argue in church so I just said, “Oh, I must have missed that.”

The mother called me apologetic, after overhearing her daughter say to a friend, “I always thought we put the Book of Gospels on the table so I was a surprised to be told to put it on the altar.” Upon questioning her, she realized that to her daughter, who had always been admonished to be very well behaved when she was “on the altar” for any reason (serving, reading, homily for children, etc) that meant “in the sanctuary” and the altar to her was really “the Table”.

Our language does need to be specific.
 
This is off-topic for the OP but I had to comment on this. I’ve noticed that many people use that expression when they mean ‘in the sanctuary’. One mother discovered how confusing the comment was when her university-aged daughter came home for holidays and as a former reader was invited to still be one during the summer.

The day she came for a refresher practice I told her she was the first reader and as such would be bringing up the Book of Gospels and she was to lay it on the altar. She looked at me, puzzled, and repeated “On the altar?” “Yes, you place it flat on the altar. Father will get it from there when it’s time to read the Gospel.” “OK.”

On Sunday, just before the readings, I noticed that the altar was bare of Book. When the priest walked over to the altar to retrieve the Book I saw him bend over and come up with the Book. Colour me confused.

After Mass I approached the girl and said “I guess we had a error in communication. You were supposed to put the Book on the altar.” “I did.” Her mother jumps in and says, “She did put it on the altar.” OK, I wasn’t about to argue in church so I just said, “Oh, I must have missed that.”

The mother called me apologetic, after overhearing her daughter say to a friend, “I always thought we put the Book of Gospels on the table so I was a surprised to be told to put it on the altar.” Upon questioning her, she realized that to her daughter, who had always been admonished to be very well behaved when she was “on the altar” for any reason (serving, reading, homily for children, etc) that meant “in the sanctuary” and the altar to her was really “the Table”.

Our language does need to be specific.
Good point, this complete thread has me a little humbled. I’m in my mid forties, born and raised Catholic, attended Catholic school through high school and I didn’t know the difference between the altar, ambo. I guess I need a remedial church course…
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top