Pastor asks for forgiveness for being White

  • Thread starter Thread starter Asimis
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
There are a ton of things I can feel guilty for that are my own fault, the color of my skin is not one of them.

Saying things just to be politically correct is hypocrisy, which is in the vanity family, which could possibly make the very statement somewhat sinful?

I am all for being sensitive to other peoples needs and beliefs, but we are going way too far apologizing for things we have no control over!
 
She compliments him on being “confident” enough to say what a lot of white people feel?
I don’t feel that way. Maybe that reduces the probability that I’m white. :eek:

Oy vey.
 
It’s funny how people against group politics always engage in group politics. This guy is terrible. Hopefully he also apologized for his mockery of imitating a man because he certainly isn’t.
 
She compliments him on being “confident” enough to say what a lot of white people feel?
I don’t feel that way. Maybe that reduces the probability that I’m white. :eek:

Oy vey.
Yeah, I guess I’m not white either, seeing as how I happy to be white, not guilty. I like my skin color, seeing as how it helped my ancestors survive in cooler northern climates. Black people should be like their skin color for it’s ability to help their ancestors survive in the warmer central regions.

That’s about as much importance as we should place on it though…
 
Pretty much
It reminds me of the show trials in Soviet Russia where people would step forward and confess things that they did not do, knowing they would be shot for it.

There has to be a psychological reason behind it. There are many examples of strange mass hysteria movements through the centuries. I suppose this is just a continuation of those.
 
So…is he saying God made a mistake in creating him? In creating all whites?

How far off from MLKs message have these folks gotten. He longed for the day when we wouldn’t judge someone by the color of their skin, only see every human being as a person.
 
She compliments him on being “confident” enough to say what a lot of white people feel?
I don’t feel that way. Maybe that reduces the probability that I’m white. :eek:
.
No, it’s because you are a patriarchal oppressor. Check your privilege.
 
There are a ton of things I can feel guilty for that are my own fault, the color of my skin is not one of them.

Saying things just to be politically correct is hypocrisy, which is in the vanity family, which could possibly make the very statement somewhat sinful?

I am all for being sensitive to other peoples needs and beliefs, but we are going way too far apologizing for things we have no control over!
He should be apologizing for leading his congregation away from truth and personal responsibility.
 
Is it me or am I detecting twinge of guilt in the statements detracting what the pastor said? Perhaps what was said was wrong, but why else, if not guilt, is there the need for lamentation over it?
 
Is it me or am I detecting twinge of guilt in the statements detracting what the pastor said? Perhaps what was said was wrong, but why else, if not guilt, is there the need for lamentation over it?
Since you asked, I think there’s a twinge of you looking for something where there is nothing.🤷
 
I didn’t have as negative a reaction against this video as it appears some of you did. I didn’t exactly have a positive reaction either though, lol. I mean, I agree that he seems to be tacking on guilt to all white people, but not simply for being white as some of these comments seem to make it seem - the guilt is for the history of racism against blacks we have seen in our country, not just for being white. And in a sense I think that’s kind of crazy too, since I think it’s debatable that there’s really that much racism in today’s culture, especially if you compare it to say, the 1950s? or something. Just that I’m wondering if what he’s saying is literally “asking forgiveness for being white” as the title of this thread claims.

As I said, I still think some of his claims are definitely debatable, but I don’t think he was apologizing simply for “being white”, so basically I’m just commenting because I feel like he is being criticized for a claim he didn’t make based on the title of the thread and some of these comments.
 
Is it me or am I detecting twinge of guilt in the statements detracting what the pastor said? Perhaps what was said was wrong, but why else, if not guilt, is there the need for lamentation over it?
I think what you’re detecting is disgust at blatant racism. Taken to the point you are expected to feel guilt for something beyond your control, to feel guilty about the way God created you is just wrong. Am I supposed to apologize that God did not create me with the ability to play pro-football, or to be a concert pianist, or the linguistic ability to speak many languages fluently, or to paint masterpieces, or for giving me black hair, or that I’m not going bald, for being able to see?

“Collectivism is a doctrine that holds that the individual has no rights, and the ultimate standard of value is the group to which ‘he belongs.’ Racism is the lowest, most crudely primitive form of collectivism. It is the notion of ascribing moral, social or political significance to a man’s genetic lineage—the notion that a man’s intellectual and characterological traits are produced and transmitted by his internal body chemistry. Which means, in practice, that a man is to be judged, not by his own character and actions, but by the characters and actions of a collective of ancestors. Racism claims that the content of a man’s mind (not his cognitive apparatus, but its content) is inherited; that a man’s convictions, values and character are determined before he is born, by physical factors beyond his control. This is the caveman’s version of the doctrine of innate ideas – or of inherited knowledge – which has been thoroughly refuted by philosophy and science. Racism is a doctrine of, by and for brutes. It is a barnyard or stock-farm version of collectivism, appropriate to a mentality that differentiates between various breeds of animals, but not between animals and men. Like every form of determinism, racism invalidates the specific attribute which distinguishes man from all other living species: his rational faculty. Racism negates two aspects of man’s life: reason and choice, or mind and morality, replacing them with chemical predestination.”
Ayn Rand

… and it is our rational faculty which is linked to our moral conduct. Not the color of our skin.
 
Maybe he meant “white” as a legal criteria in the US. Italians, Irish, Germans were all originally non-white and had to be labelled “white” to have certain rights.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top