There is nothing scandalous in the article.
Let’s look at this closely. Do secular Catholic men wear scent of some kind or another?
Yes. Many do wear after shave, cologne or some kind of bath oil, whatever. I don’t buy the stuff. I just see it at Walgreen’s.
Next, is this pope a secular Catholic man?
Yes, he is. He is not a consecrated religious. He was a diocesan priest. Prior to working at the Sacred Congregation for the Faith, he spent most of his time in a suit, shirt and tie, because that’s how theology professors in Europe dress, be they clergy, religious or lay. It’s kind of a standard “Nerd” look.
Let the man wear what he wants to wear. Why do other secular Catholic men get to choose and the secular clergy get restricted as if they were religious? They are not religious. They should not be expected to act the part. It’s being unreasonable to them. Next, we’ll be telling the pope what kind of car he can drive or what kind of suit he can wear.
The man is not a Franciscan, with a strict vow of poverty. He has never made a vow of poverty.
He is not a Cistercian monk who lives his life separated from the world. He has never lived that way. Prior to becoming pope he spent evenings in restaurants around Rome, at the theater, the opera, concerts, lecture, art galleries or sharing a beer with friends. He was part of the world around him.
He is not a Carmelite with a vocation to the contemplative life. His life of prayer has always been his to govern and manage according to his personality, not structured like that of a Carmelite.
He was never a Jesuit with a missionary vocation. He spent most of his life in a classroom or in administration.
There is nothing “religious” about this man. It is not reasonable to try to pigeon hole him into the religious mode.
Finally, the article does not say that he requested this or is paying for it. Even if he is, heck he gets no salary. He’s the only bishop in the world who works for free. Every other bishop has room, board, insurance, retirement benefits, social security, an expense account and a salary, albeit a modest one compared to other CEOs. It’s only a five figure salary. The pope has none of the above. If he abdicates tomorrow, the only thing he has is whatever money he may have saved over the years and the home that he and his brother own in Bavaria. He has a lot less than the average Catholic. He doesn’t even own the furniture in his apartment.
Let him smell nice.
Fraternally,
Br.JR, OSF
