Plus sized models inside Sports Illustrated

  • Thread starter Thread starter josie_L
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I agree. Is the fact that a magazine is showing slightly heavier women wearing almost nothing so that men can objectify them really something we should be celebrating?
But that wasn’t the point of the thread, i.e., I am not lauding Sports Illustrated.
I think focusing on the ways that the secular, often anti-Christian media can use social engineering to change people’s minds is the wrong way to go.
Again, that is not the point of the thread, however, I believe you to be wrong, i.e., the media is a powerful tool that we Christians can use to reach out and change people’s minds with (the Church has put an emphasis on social media as a means to communicate with the global community).
We should be encouraging people NOT to look to the media
Maybe we should tell EWTN to shut it’s doors as apparently all media is an inappropriate means to spread God’s love or moral message.
but to God, for affirmation and healthy self-image and encouraging those around us to treat each other with love instead of contempt.
Again, this thread was not meant to sing the praises of the fashion/modeling industry, I am simply acknowledging the fact that there may be a shift in these industries that might prove to be positive, which will help us in turn in our quest to promulgate a healthy self-image.
When I gained a bit of weight in high school, I didn’t worry about the fashion models or celebrities. I worried about the people around me and the comments they were making.
Well, yes, but people don’t get their ideas/beliefs from thin air they are influenced by the society they live in, and that society in turn is influenced by the fashion and movie industry for their perceptions of beauty (I’m not saying this is right only acknowledging the obvious).
And I agree with previous posters that health should be encouraged over some specific size. Size doesn’t really tell you much. I’m 5’6’’ and pretty skinny right now, but I wear a size 4 for skirts and pants and a size 10 for shirts and dresses because of my “top-heavy” body shape.
Yes, absolutely, but if the industry is changing it’s opinions of beauty (one that is currently an unhealthy ideal), then why shouldn’t we see this as something positive that we can use to shift the paradigm.
 
Could you post it? I’d like to read it.
Yes. Here it is:

au.lifestyle.yahoo.com/fashion/trends/a/17500448/Sofia-Vergara-says-designer-sample-sizes-are-insane/

As I mentioned, when my mom was a seamstress, the sample size was a size 10.

A size 0 is not a realistic “healthy” body type. My sister is 5.9 and 120 pounds. She hasn’t ever been a 0, because she is Italian, so she has curves.

When I was 15, I could wear a size 2. Because I was .5.3 and 90 pounds.

My current size is about a 12, basically because I’m full figured, again being Italian, I will never ever be a size 0. I’m not unhealthy, my blood pressure, and cholesterol levels are good. I don’t have diabetes.

Also, going to a museum and seeing the artistic nudes, they more resemble Ashley Graham then they do a size 0.
 
Yes. Here it is:

au.lifestyle.yahoo.com/fashion/trends/a/17500448/Sofia-Vergara-says-designer-sample-sizes-are-insane/

As I mentioned, when my mom was a seamstress, the sample size was a size 10.

A size 0 is not a realistic “healthy” body type. My sister is 5.9 and 120 pounds. She hasn’t ever been a 0, because she is Italian, so she has curves.

When I was 15, I could wear a size 2. Because I was .5.3 and 90 pounds.

My current size is about a 12, basically because I’m full figured, again being Italian, I will never ever be a size 0. I’m not unhealthy, my blood pressure, and cholesterol levels are good. I don’t have diabetes.

Also, going to a museum and seeing the artistic nudes, they more resemble Ashley Graham then they do a size 0.
I too am Italian, so I also have curves. The smallest I’ve ever been (naturally) is a size 5/6, now as I’ve already stated I’m a 10 sometimes 8. I don’t think I’m unhealthy, however, I do believe I can do more to be active, so I have joined a gym, in the quest to shed several pounds, but also to get in shape.

Thanks for the article.
 
My dad, who lived one of the healthiest lifestyles you’ve ever seen, died two years ago of kidney cancer. He was 83, and we all thought he would live to be 110 due to his healthy lifestyle. But cancer is cruel.

One of the last things he said before he died (and he was still in his right mind) was “I wish I’d eaten more.”

He was always so careful about what he ate, but in the last few weeks of his life, he couldn’t keep anything down. So sad.

Eating is pleasurable. Eating uncontrollably is NOT pleasurable and many of us struggle to control appetite out of control. That’s what we should be aiming for–a normal appetite and normal consumption. For some, this might mean eating a double cheeseburger and fries, while for others, it might mean a bunless burger with a salad. The main thing is, we should be in control when we eat.

I work in a hospital, and there are many many MANY people who die in their 80s and 90s who are fat by any standards. Somehow, they made it into their Golden Years.

And there are many many MANY people who die in their 60s who are thin and fit. Many of them die of heart disease.

I don’t think all the evidence is in concerning weight and health. There are some very unhealthy “thin” people, and there are some very healthy “fat” people.

As for stigma–with over 1/3 of children and teens obese, kids really can’t be making fun of the “fat” kid because there are so many of them. Even many “thin” kids are bigger than the kids of a generation or two ago. I think most kids accept each other the way they are. Only bullies make fun of others, and at this time in history, bullies are definitely socially unacceptable.
 
I don’t think all the evidence is in concerning weight and health. **There are some very unhealthy “thin” people, and there are some very healthy “fat” people. **
And that’s what I’ve been trying to point out with my posts, so thank you!
 
How to put this without sounding like I’m trying to glorify a fatty lifestyle, there is a part of me that agrees with what you’ve said and another part of me that is actually kind of happy that this particular model doesn’t give a hoot what others may think of her.

I mean we know she isn’t a role model in the sense that we should aspire to look like her, but it would nice if we could emulate in a sense her insouciance to public opinion and/or beauty ideals.

Moreover, I don’t mind that she’s a plus sized model modeling a bathing suit, as we all know that fat people also go to the beach.

I don’t think she’s trying to say or encourage others to be fat, rather I think she’s just happy to be in the skin she’s in (whether you agree with her or not).
 
Plus size SI swimsuit models?!!:eek:

One more sign of the decline of western civilization…:yup:
 
Gee. I have no idea what size I am.
Between you and me (shhhh) I don’t think the women posters on here realize that men have no idea what these womens’ sizes mean. “Size 5, size 10”. They might as well be speaking in Chinese.

Maybe they don’t care. Probably don’t. 🤷
 
Between you and me (shhhh) I don’t think the women posters on here realize that men have no idea what these womens’ sizes mean. “Size 5, size 10”. They might as well be speaking in Chinese.

Maybe they don’t care. Probably don’t. 🤷
Not true, in fact, I think men have differing ideals about beauty than women do, which is why it’s good to know the male perspective.
 
You know if your wife finds out you posted her size to a public group you will probably need to run and hide for a very long time? Why font you go for the tri-fecta and tell us her age and weight!
 
My dad, who lived one of the healthiest lifestyles you’ve ever seen, died two years ago of kidney cancer. He was 83, and we all thought he would live to be 110 due to his healthy lifestyle. But cancer is cruel.

One of the last things he said before he died (and he was still in his right mind) was “I wish I’d eaten more.”

He was always so careful about what he ate, but in the last few weeks of his life, he couldn’t keep anything down. So sad.

Eating is pleasurable. Eating uncontrollably is NOT pleasurable and many of us struggle to control appetite out of control. That’s what we should be aiming for–a normal appetite and normal consumption. For some, this might mean eating a double cheeseburger and fries, while for others, it might mean a bunless burger with a salad. The main thing is, we should be in control when we eat.

I work in a hospital, and there are many many MANY people who die in their 80s and 90s who are fat by any standards. Somehow, they made it into their Golden Years.

And there are many many MANY people who die in their 60s who are thin and fit. Many of them die of heart disease.

I don’t think all the evidence is in concerning weight and health. There are some very unhealthy “thin” people, and there are some very healthy “fat” people.

As for stigma–with over 1/3 of children and teens obese, kids really can’t be making fun of the “fat” kid because there are so many of them. Even many “thin” kids are bigger than the kids of a generation or two ago. I think most kids accept each other the way they are. Only bullies make fun of others, and at this time in history, bullies are definitely socially unacceptable./QUOT

I can really relate to this post. My mom was 5foot 2 and had low cholesterol. She always was conscious of cooking healthily and watched her weight. She always complained that my dad liked desserts too and worried about his cholesterol and nagged him about his eating habits. The result? She died of a heart attack at 78! And my dad? He died at 82 not from a heart attack but from complications from a hip surgery.

After my mom diied my dad ate stuff my mother always complained about, but not excessively. He had a love for chocolate that I inherited. So, I say, don’t over indulge but don’t keep away from the things that God created, especially desserts. Also, a good Catholic man. He prayed the rosary and attended Mass daily. I still miss him.
 
The Apocalypse is upon us. 😛
hold on! This model is in an ADVERTISEMENT in the SI issue, not as one of the featured models…So the apocalypse is NOT upon us…

I feel like Harold Camping…😊

But anyway, no don’t like the stick figure models, but don’t think we ought to be glamourizing being overweight either.
 
How is a problem? It isn’t glorifying fat. It’s catering to the market that company caters too.

Fat women want to know how clothes/swim suits look on them. Not on someone 5 sizes smaller. Especially when it is supposedly clothes/swim suits designed specifically for the larger sizes.

I’m large. Fat. Showing me a picture of a “healthy” women in a swim suit isn’t going to encourage my business. Showing me a picture of a woman I can identify with? That will.

This is just smart business sense.
 
How is a problem? It isn’t glorifying fat. It’s catering to the market that company caters too.

Fat women want to know how clothes/swim suits look on them. Not on someone 5 sizes smaller. Especially when it is supposedly clothes/swim suits designed specifically for the larger sizes.

I’m large. Fat. Showing me a picture of a “healthy” women in a swim suit isn’t going to encourage my business. Showing me a picture of a woman I can identify with? That will.

This is just smart business sense.
That model shown was an actual “plus sized model”. I think the tattoos would probably not allow her to work for many companies who would prefer a more neutral look. (I normally don’t see tattoos on models in catalogs)

She doesn’t look much different than the Lane Bryant models.
 
hold on! This model is in an ADVERTISEMENT in the SI issue, not as one of the featured models…So the apocalypse is NOT upon us…

I feel like Harold Camping…😊

But anyway, no don’t like the stick figure models, but don’t think we ought to be glamourizing being overweight either.
No, I don’t want to glamourize being overweight either, but I don’t see anything wrong with having plus sized women in fashion magazines, because, well, plus sized women make up a certain percentage of women in our society, and magazines should reflect that to an extent.

p.s. I don’t know who Harold Camping is (I guess I’ll have to google him), although I assume he’s one of those people who have prophesied about the comings or goings of the apocalypse.
 
Without getting to detailed, I would like to mention three things:
  1. A few years back, I recall that there was a hostess at a popular national chain restaurant in Detroit whose boss put her on probation for her weight. The hostess was 5’-8" and 132 pounds (by the way, this story made national news). I don’t know what this boss was thinking - 5’-8" and 132 pounds is a healthy weight.
  2. I like SI as much as the next guy, but last year I noticed that the shortest woman in there was 5-7.5", and most of them were under 30. Most of the models like Lily Aldridge are 5’-9" or taller. Quite frankly, it would be nice to profile more “normal” looking women. Several modeling agencies will not even look at a girl who is under 5’-7" (there have been a few exceptions, like Roslyn Sanchez from Without a Trace, Evangeline Lily from Lost, and the Guess girl Josie Maran.)
  3. I have liked that in the past some of the Olympic swimmers (like Dara Torres and Natalie Coughlin) have been featured, since they are athletes, and swimmers really cannot turn pro like football and basketball players. Pro surfers don’t make much money either. That’s one reason some of the female pro surfers (like Alana Blanchard) model, it’s in order to make some extra money.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top