A
I am with the people on pretty much all of this, except evolution! Science has become kind of a religion. And it is not always practiced as objectively as its proponents would like us (or they themselves) to believe. Science disconnected from religion falls subject to human moral weakness and can really terrorize the human race - think arms race, nuclear bombs, just to name a few examples. Technology in itself does not equal good. Technology governed and limited by human reason and morality equals good.
So well stated! Thank you!Interesting. I think the media can be a powerful tool for presenting science to the public in an accurate way but needs to include real names and real institutions into the picture as well. Unlike the internet with legions of anonymous posters, blogs and contentious forums which can be highly biased and uncivil, a transparent, actual, ‘science that has meaning to you’ kind of program would be great.
However, the trend on TV is what? Celebrities, killings, disasters and sports and weather. Great presentation is the key. I am so tired about hearing about some person I’ll never meet doing something bad. And reality shows? Shoot me now. I can’t believe people watch them - any of them.
And, based on my own readings of various sites (not just Catholic/Christian), science is the only god you need. That said, I have great respect for scientists who are making a positive impact on the world, and new inventions that are helping people. Instead of being presented as bland, I think a positive “here’s what science is doing now to help people and the earth” would be cool and encouraging.
As a professional media watcher, there’s just too much negativity and ‘darkness’ out there. I mean scientists in various fields are finding out cool things almost daily, and some are making discoveries, and applied science is making things to make life better for those with various health issues.
Ed
Seconded.So well stated! Thank you!
I would add that the media is far more interested in catchy headlines than hard science or researching the details behind the claims. You know-- ‘researchers claim cauliflower may make you grow a second head!!’ get airtime regardless of the science behind it. Things like MMGW get promoted and publicized both from a political agenda they tend to support and the catchy “Your children may never see snow” “New Jersey may be under 2 feet of water in 10 years” – too many media outlets just print the claims for clickbait/ratings/sales.Interesting. I think the media can be a powerful tool for presenting science to the public in an accurate way but needs to include real names and real institutions into the picture as well. Unlike the internet with legions of anonymous posters, blogs and contentious forums which can be highly biased and uncivil, a transparent, actual, ‘science that has meaning to you’ kind of program would be great.
However, the trend on TV is what? Celebrities, killings, disasters and sports and weather. Great presentation is the key. I am so tired about hearing about some person I’ll never meet doing something bad. And reality shows? Shoot me now. I can’t believe people watch them - any of them.
And, based on my own readings of various sites (not just Catholic/Christian), science is the only god you need. That said, I have great respect for scientists who are making a positive impact on the world, and new inventions that are helping people. Instead of being presented as bland, I think a positive “here’s what science is doing now to help people and the earth” would be cool and encouraging.
As a professional media watcher, there’s just too much negativity and ‘darkness’ out there. I mean scientists in various fields are finding out cool things almost daily, and some are making discoveries, and applied science is making things to make life better for those with various health issues.
Ed
Thank you for that. There are a few companies that are extracting CO2 from factories, for example, and using it to make products which make profits. I think it’s safe to say that profits are the key driver. Can we make a lot of money from creating a “carbon tax” or a “carbon exchange” or expensive “carbon sequestering” schemes? If the answer is yes and the public, along with policy makers, can be convinced, we’re in business, literally.I would add that the media is far more interested in catchy headlines than hard science or researching the details behind the claims. You know-- ‘researchers claim cauliflower may make you grow a second head!!’ get airtime regardless of the science behind it. Things like MMGW get promoted and publicized both from a political agenda they tend to support and the catchy “Your children may never see snow” “New Jersey may be under 2 feet of water in 10 years” – too many media outlets just print the claims for clickbait/ratings/sales.
Here’s an interesting article which may be why the public and scientists have a gap. The public is getting more skeptical:
breitbart.com/london/2015/01/30/forget-climategate-this-global-warming-scandal-is-much-bigger/
This seems too facile.I am with the people on pretty much all of this, except evolution! Science has become kind of a religion. And it is not always practiced as objectively as its proponents would like us (or they themselves) to believe. Science disconnected from religion falls subject to human moral weakness and can really terrorize the human race - think arms race, nuclear bombs, just to name a few examples. Technology in itself does not equal good. Technology governed and limited by human reason and morality equals good.
I think Western culture needs to get off the science prayer mat, and am just fine with these differences in viewpoints between the scientific community and the people. Mind you, I don’t reject science - I recognize the incredible positive impact it has had on almost every aspect of our lives. I just think the concept of the “theory” needs to be front and center, the fact that science is changing and evolving, that there are limitations to human knowledge, and also the very real fact that all scientists have prejudices just like the rest of us. They are not impartial Gods.
There is a lot here, to the point where it’s hard to figure out which comment to respond to. I do better with manageable, time-friendly tidbits. Some random comments:This seems too facile.
So what does religion specifically have to say about the development of atomic weapons? If you were Roosevelt or a high-ranking military official, will you sponsor the Manhattan Project? You have evidence that the Germans are pursuing their own nuclear weapon (but they do not realize that pure graphite was a good moderator for a reactor and had to use inordinately expensive deuterated water which stymied their development program).
How would you deal with a nuclear arms race? I don’t think abjuring destructive weapons would be helpful in a world ruled by political realism, especially when the possession of those weapons can grant a state enormous geopolitical leverage.
My remarks do not necessarily deal with science and religion, but geopolitical exigencies. With your nuclear weapons example, the philosophical question is how to reconcile religious righteousness with political realism? Not to mention that you “begged the question” by conflating religion with morality.
The reverence granted to scientific knowledge and inquiry is due to the immense practical applications of that knowledge as it enable one to have some control over nature and ameliorate some of the suffering in the human condition. Furthermore, scientific knowledge provides fairly robust theoretical frameworks for describing, explaining and investigating natural phenomenon. Thus, any statement or conclusion that is supported using scientific evidence and reasoning would have a high degree of credibility. No other system of philosophy can attest to that legacy of success. This legacy of success is what makes “metascience” or, more precisely, the philosophy of science, an worthy subject of inquiry. For example, the philosophy of science deals with issues concerning the ontology of unobservable “theoretical entities” (whether they have to necessarily be “real”) and scientific “laws”, the semantics of scientific theories and hypotheses, and how to distinguish between non-scientific or “pseudoscientific” ideas versus “bona fide” “scientific” ones.
Still, good philosophy of science first requires an appreciation of good science; one first needs to appreciate scientific knowledge and methods (in a general manner as specialized knowledge is the province of actual scientists) before one have sufficient curiosity to delve into the philosophical issues of science.
Clearly this is a more nuanced issue that merely proclaiming that scientific statements are incontrovertible and* ex cathedra *. It is almost as vulgar as a hidebound attitude that disregards some scientific knowledge and theories because it is too abstruse and abstract or that it is not congruous with someone’s prior ideological commitments.
Carbon sequestration produces nothing, and IMO is of no value to anyone. So, any company’s “profits” will come from squeezing people’s wallets even more via new onerous government regulations. As Obama promised, the cost of electricity will skyrocket (in conjunction with the prices of every product you can imagine). This is quite a scam that the millionaires and billionaires support…Thank you for that. There are a few companies that are extracting CO2 from factories, for example, and using it to make products which make profits. I think it’s safe to say that profits are the key driver. Can we make a lot of money from creating a “carbon tax” or a “carbon exchange” or expensive “carbon sequestering” schemes? If the answer is yes and the public, along with policy makers, can be convinced, we’re in business, literally.
Then there is the financial threat to the fossil fuel industry from various developments.
rt.com/business/212383-australia-record-solar-energy/
newscientist.com/article/mg22229654.100-giant-solar-farm-uses-molten-salt-to-keep-power-coming.html
I miss the days of more in-depth reporting of various world developments, minus celebrity news. The media, unfortunately, is driven by advertising and the more eyeballs/clicks/whatever, the more you can charge for ads.
Ed
I am not going to provide specific questions. I am primarily interested in playing with or critiquing ideas (and this behavior shows up even on non-verbal media such as competitive Pokemon and Yu-Gi-Oh! online where I like to play, not to win, but test different strategies under the constraints of the game’s mechanics and probability, and do my best with the resources I have in a particular matchup. I like to assess things like opportunity cost of using a moveslot or a card in my deck, and how to execute strategies in various situations in games.) To maintain a dialogue with me, find some point of (perceived) disagreement and respond.There is a lot here, to the point where it’s hard to figure out which comment to respond to. I do better with manageable, time-friendly tidbits. Some random comments:
Some quotes from one of my heroes, Robert Oppenheimer:
- Do you believe in morality outside of a religious context or as I would say “God”? What is its source? Do you believe in good and evil?
- I am not repudiating the value of science in favor of religion. I was quite clear that I valued the very real, tangible impact of science on our lives. What I fear is when people practice science according to their own will and desires, beyond the moral framework instituted by God.
“In some sort of crude sense, which no vulgarity, no humor, no overstatement can quite extinguish, the physicists have known sin; and this is a knowledge which they cannot lose.”
“The atomic bomb made the prospect of future war unendurable. It has led us up those last few steps to the mountain pass; and beyond there is a different country.”
“I am become death, the destroyer of worlds.”
J. Robert Oppenheimer
(My point with Oppenheimer is that science without morality is insanity.) Morality that discounts science and reason is insanity.
Ask me more specific questions.
A few Marxist-Leninist commentators remarked that Iraq was invaded because Saddam didn’t have weapons of mass destruction, the weapons which were the pretext for the invasion. In other words, Iraq did not wield the deterring power of nuclear weapons. Also, according to those commentators, North Korea actually pursues its (pathetic) nuclear weapons program for self-defensive in a unipolar geopolitical milieu. From what I do remember, it didn’t need to pursue a nuclear weapons program when it was under the aegis of the Soviet Union.“The atomic bomb made the prospect of future war unendurable. It has led us up those last few steps to the mountain pass; and beyond there is a different country.”
So why do we have an arms race? Why do we have nuclear weapons? We aren’t we applying our capacity to cooperate and respect one another to avoid potential annihiliation of the planet? Surely this is in our best interests?As for morality in general, I believe that humans are capable of cooperating and respecting each other in an interpersonal setting without the need of adhering to some external (and often imposed) system of morality.
Basic prisoner’s dilemma, I guess. There is an incentive to hold nuclear weapons or to “defect”, especially when others show the capacity and willingness to defect.So why do we have an arms race? Why do we have nuclear weapons? We aren’t we applying our capacity to cooperate and respect one another to avoid potential annihiliation of the planet? Surely this is in our best interests?
Because a person with undiagnosed paranoid schizophrenia has been put in charge of designing US nuclear strategy.So why do we have an arms race? Why do we have nuclear weapons? We aren’t we applying our capacity to cooperate and respect one another to avoid potential annihiliation of the planet? Surely this is in our best interests?
That is the problem. By becoming an instrument of science and agendas, scientists have done much to discredit themselves.Because science has become political. This is the juxtaposition that has been presented before us.