Pope can't be infallible

  • Thread starter Thread starter jfoges
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
You are right that dogmata can go from being implicit to explicit. From being taught by the ordinary magisterium to the extraordinary magisterium. However, for something to be taught by the ordinary magisterium in teh first place it has to be universally agreed upon by the bishops. This is the only test as to whether it is in revelation, according to textbook theology. So, if something was at one time highly disputed among the bishops, then according to textbook theology, it can’t ever have been in revelation in the first place.
Excellent. 👍 My opinion as well.
 
Support for Papal Infallibility according to Sacred Scripture and Sacred Tradition, is as follows:

St. Peter Chrysologus (d. 450), against Eutyches affirmed: “For the Holy Peter who lives on in his episcopal chair and is its director, offers the true belief to them that seek it” (with Leo I, Ep. 25,2).

This assurance in matters of dispute regarding the deposit of faith implies that the Roman Pontiff is always to be trusted to speak the “true belief,” now and into the future as the successor of Peter. This implies the existence of some supernatural help such that he may never depart from “true belief” in his role as Roman Pontiff.

Pope St. Hormisdas (519) appealing to Mat 16:18 affirmed: “These [words] which are spoken [Matt 16:18] are proved by the effects of the deeds, because in the Apostolic See the Catholic religion was always preserved without stain” (*Libellus professionis fidei, *added to the epistle Inter ea quae to the bishops of Spain, April 2, 517).

The above rule of faith was subscribed to by all the bishops of the East, by the emperor Justinian, and by the Constantinopolitan patriarchs Epiphanius, John, Menna, and finally in the eighth ecumenical council, Constantinople IV, act. I, by the Greek and Latin Fathers.

So you see, it is not a “new” dogma, but is based upon that which has always been implicit in Scripture and Tradition. This is obvious to Catholics, who hold to the ancient rule of faith and affirm together with Augustine, saint and Doctor of the Holy Catholic Church, that on this matter formerly under dispute, the replies from Rome have come, and as a consequence, “causa finita est,” the erroneous claims of schismatics and heretics notwithstanding.
Dave,

Thanks for your replies. You made a few posts so I will try to respond to some of your more salient points, not just from the post I quoted.

First of all, you say that dogmata can develop formally and what was once implicit can become explicit. My question is, how does the Magisterium determine what is implicit? In order to do this it is insufficient to look simply in Scripture, or what is in the writings of Church fathers. One would have to look at the universally held beliefs of the Church.

Ratzinger acknowledges this in the quote from the CDF, but then he says that it is possible for something to be an implicit teaching even if it isn’t held by the majority of bishops. This seems to just place the final say on the Ordinary Magisterium in Rome itself. Ratzinger is paying lip service to the idea of the Ordinary Magisterium residing in the episcopacy as a whole, but then implying that it is in Rome’s power to overule the views of all the bishops as to the content of our faith.

In this case you can see that Roman theology places the Pope as an infallible teacher on all matters, whether ex cathedra teachings or ordinary teachings.

It is true that traditionally, the bishop of Rome was considered to exercize a Petrine office of pastoral leadership over the bishops and the Church as a whole. The many quotes you gave from fathers and doctors of the Church attest to this. However, I do not think the Pope was always considered infallible by the Church as a whole. There are examples in history of bishops exercizing a degree of autonomy from Rome that would be inconsistent with a belief in infallibility.

This whole issue begs another question. Namely, is the Ordinary Magisterium, residing in the episcopacy, infallible in the first place. I would say that it should not be considered infallible. It is not clear from scripture that God promised an infallible teaching authority to develop dogmata. God made many promises in scripture to be with the Church in many ways, but this does not necessarily mean infallible teaching authority.

The Catholic Church should admit that the Magisterium is not infallible, while continuing to exercize magisterial authority in order to teach the faith, without claiming that its teachings are binding on the faithful who disagree in good conscience.
 
To folllow up my last post, I want to add something about the actual beliefs of the faithful with regards to infallibility. I would argue that the majority of the faithful have a great difficulty with infalliblity and fnd it a huge stumbling block. The vast majority of the faithful in many parts of the world do not obey all of the teachings of the Pope. Contraception is an important one. The official teachings on contraception are, to say the least, a stumbling block for married people and a really unfair and impossible teaching. Most people ignore the rule. They then pay lip service to infallibility and rationalize their decision to ignore it, citing “subjetive” conditions of the sin. This creates a climate of intellectual dishonesty and hypocrisy. Rather then be hypocrites, lets just be intellectually honest and admit the Pope is not infallible.
 
To folllow up my last post, I want to add something about the actual beliefs of the faithful with regards to infallibility. I would argue that the majority of the faithful have a great difficulty with infalliblity and fnd it a huge stumbling block. The vast majority of the faithful in many parts of the world do not obey all of the teachings of the Pope. Contraception is an important one. The official teachings on contraception are, to say the least, a stumbling block for married people and a really unfair and impossible teaching. Most people ignore the rule. They then pay lip service to infallibility and rationalize their decision to ignore it, citing “subjetive” conditions of the sin. This creates a climate of intellectual dishonesty and hypocrisy. Rather then be hypocrites, lets just be intellectually honest and admit the Pope is not infallible.
That seems like a very weak argument. You’re stateing that in your opinion most Catholics don’t believe the Pope is infallible therefore, to be intellectually honest, we must admit he is not infallible. So truth is determined by majority vote?

I know we’re running different circles because I don’t run into many Catholics who don’t believe in the infallibility of the Pope. I do run into Catholics, including some priests, who believe Humanae Vitae was not an infallible teaching. Note there is a huge difference between believing a teaching is not infallible and believing that the Pope cannot make an infallible teaching.
 
That seems like a very weak argument. You’re stateing that in your opinion most Catholics don’t believe the Pope is infallible therefore, to be intellectually honest, we must admit he is not infallible. So truth is determined by majority vote?

I know we’re running different circles because I don’t run into many Catholics who don’t believe in the infallibility of the Pope. I do run into Catholics, including some priests, who believe Humanae Vitae was not an infallible teaching. Note there is a huge difference between believing a teaching is not infallible and believing that the Pope cannot make an infallible teaching.
That really is not my argument. The post you quoted was just a follow up to my argument about infallibility. I know there are priests who say Humanae Vitae is not an infallible teaching. This, however, is not true. According to catholic theology of infallibility it is definetly infallible. This is the kind of intellectual dishonest that is a result of the doctrine of infallibility.
 
That really is not my argument. The post you quoted was just a follow up to my argument about infallibility. I know there are priests who say Humanae Vitae is not an infallible teaching. This, however, is not true. According to catholic theology of infallibility it is definetly infallible. This is the kind of intellectual dishonest that is a result of the doctrine of infallibility.
I don’t see where there’s any intellectual dishonesty in the fact that there are e some priests and theologians who disagree that Humanae Vitae was infallible. With all due respect I think you throw that term around too much.
 
Glad to know you agree with me. Are you Catholic yourself?
Born and raised in the faith.

Buried two parents through the church, raised three children through the church. Latin Catholic for fifty years, Orthodox since 2005. In part because of these (and similar) arguments.

Hans Kung is still a priest, standing before the altar of God confecting the Eucharist daily. So apparently there is still a place for these truths within the church.
 
I don’t see where there’s any intellectual dishonesty in the fact that there are e some priests and theologians who disagree that Humanae Vitae was infallible. With all due respect I think you throw that term around too much.
I think there is a lot of intellectual dishonesty that is used to rationalize ignoring teachings of the Magisterium. Take Humanae Vitae for instance. This ban on contraception is taught by the pope, and bishops. It was taught by the pope and bishops in the recent past. Therefore, it is an infallibe teaching of the ordinary Magisterium. Catholics who don’t want to follow it can either disagree with the Magisterium, admitting it is not infallible, or they can rationalize their actions by making the argument that Humanae Vitae is not infallible, or that subjective factors excuse their actions.
 
Born and raised in the faith.

Buried two parents through the church, raised three children through the church. Latin Catholic for fifty years, Orthodox since 2005. In part because of these (and similar) arguments.

Hans Kung is still a priest, standing before the altar of God confecting the Eucharist daily. So apparently there is still a place for these truths within the church.
Of course there is a place for these views within the Church. Many Catholics, perhaps even most, do not really accept all the teachings of the Magisterium. However, instead of attacking the idea of infallility itself, they simply rationalize there actions.

What does your Orthodox Church say about infallibility?
 
First of all, you say that dogmata can develop formally and what was once implicit can become explicit. My question is, how does the Magisterium determine what is implicit?
I believe the excerpt above from Dr. Ott’s *Fundamentals of Catholic Dogma *outlines this process accurately. You can also read the detailed (online) exposition on this process cited above from Ven. John Henry Cardinal Newman.

Non-Catholic patristic scholars have also affirmed:
“Irenaeus and Tertullian point to the church tradition as the authoritative locus of the unadulterated teaching of the apostles, they cannot longer appeal to the immediate memory, as could the earliest writers. Instead they lay stress on the affirmation that this teaching has been transmitted faithfully from generation to generation. One could say that in their thinking, apostolic succession occupies same place that is held by the living memory in the Apostolic Fathers.” (Ellen Flessman-Van Leer, Scripture and Tradition in the Early Church, p.188).
Another non-Catholic patristic scholar notes:
"It should be unnecessary to accumulate further evidence. Throughout the whole [early Church] period Scripture and tradition ranked as complementary authorities, media different in form but coincident in content. To inquire which counted as superior or more ultimate is to pose the question in misleading terms. If Scripture was abundantly sufficient in principle, tradition was recognized as the surest clue to its interpretation, for in tradition the Church retained, as a legacy from the apostles which was embedded in all the organs of her institutional life, an unerring grasp of the real purport and meaning of the revelation to which Scripture and tradition alike bore witness…
“Thus in the end the Christian must, like Timothy [cf. 1 Tim 6:20] ‘guard the deposit’, i.e. the revelation enshrined in its completeness in Holy Scripture and correctly interpreted in the Church’s unerring tradition.” (JND Kelly, Early Christian Doctrines, page 47-48, 51)
Thus, according to the same deposit of faith handed on to the early Church, the Catholic Church continues to belief in agreement with the early Fathers, that as a matter of faith, the content or deposit of faith continues to be interpreted unerringly by the magisterium, through recourse to the her “living memory.” That living memory is protected from error by the Holy Spirit, when in the ordinary universal exercise or extraordinary exercise of her teaching authority, the magistierum intends to expound upon or defend that which is *de fide, *or closely related truths.

The process is also described in the Catholic Encyclopedia, here: CATHOLIC ENCYCLOPEDIA: Tradition and Living Magisterium

The article describes the living magisterium as, “a Divinely authorized living magistracy for the solution of controversies arising among themselves”. (see Matt 18:17, “tell it to the Church”).

Here’s some excerpts:
Documents of all kinds (writings, monuments, etc.) are in the hands of masters, as of the faithful, a means of finding or recognizing the revealed truth confided to the Church under the direction of her pastors. There is between written documents and the living magisterium of the Church a relation similar, proportionately speaking, to that already outlined between Scripture and the living magisterium. In them is found the traditional thought expressed according to varieties of environments and circumstances, no longer in an inspired language, as is the case with Scripture, but in a purely human language, consequently subject to the imperfections and shortcomings of human thought. … the living magisterium searches in the past, now for authorities in favour of its present thought in order to defend it against attacks or dangers of mutilation, now for light to walk the right road without straying. The thought of the Church is essentially a traditional thought and the living magisterium by taking cognizance of ancient formulas of this thought thereby recruits its strength and prepares to give to immutable truth a new expression which shall be in harmony with the circumstances of the day and within reach of contemporary minds… The living magisterium, therefore, makes extensive use of documents of the past, but it does so while judging and interpreting, gladly finding in them its present thought, but likewise, when needful, distinguishing its present thought from what is traditional only in appearance. It is revealed truth always living in the mind of the Church, or, if it is preferred, the present thought of the Church in continuity with her traditional thought, which is for it the final criterion, according to which the living magisterium adopts as true or rejects as false the often obscure and confused formulas which occur in the monuments of the past. Thus are explained both her respect for the writings of the Fathers of the Church and her supreme independence towards those writings–she judges them more than she is judged by them.
I recommend you read the entire article for a fuller understanding of this process.
 
Thanks Dave,

I will look at this material and get back to you when I have something to say about it.I also reccoment the book Infallibility, An Inquiry by Hans Kung (1971) for a contrary argument.
 
To folllow up my last post, I want to add something about the actual beliefs of the faithful with regards to infallibility. I would argue that the majority of the faithful have a great difficulty with infalliblity and fnd it a huge stumbling block. The vast majority of the faithful in many parts of the world do not obey all of the teachings of the Pope. Contraception is an important one. The official teachings on contraception are, to say the least, a stumbling block for married people and a really unfair and impossible teaching. Most people ignore the rule. They then pay lip service to infallibility and rationalize their decision to ignore it, citing “subjetive” conditions of the sin. This creates a climate of intellectual dishonesty and hypocrisy. Rather then be hypocrites, lets just be intellectually honest and admit the Pope is not infallible.
As a married person myself, I must wholly object to the underlined. I personally wouldn’t have it any other way. But that’s getting off-topic.

Furthermore, the fact that some people (but by no means all) are hypocritical about contraception vis à vis papal authority has absolutely nothing to do with the validity of said authority. It would be just as intellectually honest of them to admit that the pope is right and that they need to stop contracepting.

Sam, the Neon Orange Knight
 
Of course there is a place for these views within the Church. Many Catholics, perhaps even most, do not really accept all the teachings of the Magisterium. However, instead of attacking the idea of infallility itself, they simply rationalize there actions.

What does your Orthodox Church say about infallibility?
No single bishop anywhere may pronounce dogma for the whole church. Throughout Christian history only heretics have ever pronounced dogma on their own authority.

No single bishop anywhere has ever had a personal gift of infallibility. The idea itself is a novelty.

What infallibility the church has is of the entire church. It can be seen through consensus of the bishops in action. This isn’t like someone declaring “I have taken a poll of the bishops and they all seem to agree with me, so I declare…”

Orthodox operate under the assumption that everything necessary for salvation has been passed from Jesus Christ through the Apostles. The function of the Orthodox church is to protect and teach this deposit of Faith, passing it intact to each new generation. The Faithful as a whole (bishops, priests and laity) are quite capable of doing this, even when we see occasional individuals faltering. Christ is in charge and we simply put our faith in that fact.

The people learn the faith first in their mothers’ lap. They drink it in, so to say, with the breastmilk. The children get a soft whisper of a lecture from Poppa every time he lifts them up to kiss an icon. The whole parish is involved in some ways, everything we believe is prayed in the liturgy, it functions like our catechism, and following the liturgical cycle faithfully one cannot fail to grasp the essence of the faith. This is where our bishops and priests come from.

Perhaps one may wish to call the Sensus Fidelium (and of course it is just that although we don’t use the term), except that in the Orthodox understanding there are no new definitions, this is not used as a justification to pronounce new dogmas that were not pronounced before. That really has a lot of potential for abuse. In the sensus fidelium dogma remain dogma and theolougemena remain theolougemena. Pious opinions can wax and wane in popularity without threatening the deposit of Faith. Popular ideas are not doctrine because most people think they are true, they can only be doctrine if they have been already received as doctrine.

Every prayerful person can be a theologian, and every theologian must be a person of prayer. Even illiterate grandmothers in their babushkas are capable of discerning when someone is slipping a change into the teaching or prayers of the church. They may come out in legion to face off with their bishop, brooms and pans in hand, demanding the explanation. Monks likewise.

Apophatic thinking predominates, and the church is notoriously conservative by nature. The Vincentian Canon is worth remembering here.
 
jfoges,

Even if Vatican I had never defined the individual infallibility of the pope, it would not make a difference in the matters you seem concerned with.

Such teachings as the evil of contraception and the inability of the Church to ordain women are among those that have been part of the Tradition from the beginning. Papal writings like Humanae Vitae and Ordinatio Sacerdotalis are exactly the sort of “defense of the existing Tradition” you agree the Magisterium should be performing.

Usagi
 
jfoges,

Even if Vatican I had never defined the individual infallibility of the pope, it would not make a difference in the matters you seem concerned with.

Such teachings as the evil of contraception and the inability of the Church to ordain women are among those that have been part of the Tradition from the beginning. Papal writings like Humanae Vitae and Ordinatio Sacerdotalis are exactly the sort of “defense of the existing Tradition” you agree the Magisterium should be performing.

Usagi
Maybe it is, but if you think that the magisterium is teaching correctly, why do you need it to be infallible? You are using your own faculties of reason to determine the teaching is correct.
 
Maybe it is, but if you think that the magisterium is teaching correctly, why do you need it to be infallible? You are using your own faculties of reason to determine the teaching is correct.
It is infallible because otherwise allthose catholics for free choice, or catholic women priests or what what could easily just say, well we are not sure the magisterium is always right, so we just do what we want. The same thing happened to protestants and now there is probably as many different opinions of teaching among them as there is individuals in protestant churches. that is a big problem. In Catholicism anybody can know what is true and what is not… It is also infallible so heretics can be distiunguished from true believers…

One of the biggest virtue is humility, i think that is what we must practice here and matters related to this… I do not think God wants us to fight about who is right or what what but accept the teaching of His church with humility and respect…
 
I think there is a lot of intellectual dishonesty that is used to rationalize ignoring teachings of the Magisterium. Take Humanae Vitae for instance. This ban on contraception is taught by the pope, and bishops. It was taught by the pope and bishops in the recent past. Therefore, it is an infallibe teaching of the ordinary Magisterium. …
There are indeed Catholics who doubt or deny de fide teachings, such as that presented within Casti Connubii (1930) and Humanae Vitae (1968), and if they do so pertinaciously, they are excommunicated *latae sententia, *that is, incurred automatically upon the commission of an offense. No different the obstinate denial of Papal Infallibility. Many who claim to be Catholic are in fact, excommunicated.

In the context of Catholic Moral Theology, “contraception” is not understood as simply “avoiding pregnancy.” Instead, "contraception" is the Catholic sense is understood as "any positive means of preventing conception." Contemporary Moral Theology, Vol. II - Marriage Questions, John Ford, S.J. and Gerard Kelly, S.J., Newman Press, 1964].

Paul VI, in Humanae Vitae cites Casti Connubii and the teachings of Pius XII. It is clear he is teaching exactly what prior popes have also taught, which has been the constant teaching of the Catholic Church since the early Church period. Any unbiased student of Catholic moral theology in the 1960s should have drawn the same conclusion, that this teaching was irrevocable, and therefore infallible.

For instance, according to the 1959 moral theology textbook by John C. Ford, S.J., and Gerard Kelly, S.J., Contemporary Moral Theology Vol. 1: “It is hardly conceivable that the papal teaching on such things as divorce, contraception, the direct killing of the innocent…is anything short of infallible” (p.22).

According to John T. Noonan’s 1965 publication, *Contraception - A History of its Treatment by the Catholic Theolgians and Canonists: *"***Never had it been admitted by a Catholic theologian that complete sexual intercourse might be had in which by deliberation, procreation was excluded." ***(*p.*438).

According to Felix Cappelo, S.J.'s 1933 and 1961 edition of *De Matrimonio, *n. 816, speaking of the teaching of Casti Connubii on the immorality of contraception, he says, “***These very solemn words, uttered ‘in signum legationis divinae,’ obviously are an expression of infallible teaching authority, that is, a definition *ex cathedra.”

According to Arthur Vermeersch, S.J., in his 1931 commentary on Casti Connubii, he says that “***the pope wished to put the stamp of his own infallible teaching authority on the traditional teaching of the Church ***” [cited by Ford, Contemporary Moral Theology, Vol II (1964), *p.263-264]

According to A. Piscetta, S.S., and A Gennaro, S.S., in their seventh volume of Elementa theologia moralis published in 1944, they *agree with Vermeersch above on the infallible teaching of Casti Connubii * on the matter.

According to Francis Ter Haar, C.SS.R., in his 1939 text Casus conscientiae, II. De praecipuis hujus aetatis vitiis eorumque remediis, n. 136, speaking of the passage against contraception in Casti Connubii, "this passage of the encyclical, contains a definition by the Roman Pontiff speaking ‘ex cathedra’.

According to Andre’ Snoeck, S.J., in his article"Fecondation inhibee et morale catholique," *Nouvelle revue theologique *75 (1953), 690-702, at p. 700: “***the common opinion in the Church judges that we are here confronted with an irrevocable condemnation of conjugal onanism ***.”

According to John Ford, S.J. and Gerard Kelly, S.J., in their text Contemporary Moral Theology, Vol II - Marriage Questions, published in 1964, “in condemning contraception as intrinsically and gravely immoral, Pius XI was clearly and solemnly declaring a truth already infallibly taught by the universal Church… the main point is to insist on the substantial immutability of the Catholic doctrine on contraception**.” (p.271)

Consequently, according to Catholic moral theology texts of the 30s, 40s, 50s and early 60s, Casti Connubii’s teaching against contraception was unanimously considered irrevocable teaching of the Church. Why Fr. Charles Curran and many other dissidents claimed otherwise tells us more about their own bias and denial of the faith than about authentic Catholic moral theology.

Furthermore, in Humanae Vitae e Infallibilità (Vatican City, Libreria Editrice Vaticana, 1986), Fr. Ermenegildo Lio, O.F.M., affirms the teaching against contraception in Pope Paul VI’s encyclical letter Humanae Vitae is infallible, not merely by virtue of being an instance of the constant, ordinary and universal magisterium of the Popes and Catholic Bishops against this practice, but because the encyclical itself contains (in article 14) **an ex cathedra definition. **Fr. Lio is a professor in Rome’s Pontifical Lateran University, was a peritus at Vatican Council II, and was an adviser to Pope Paul VI over the birth control issue. John Paul II wrote him a letter thanking him for the presentation of his book, which was published by the Vatican Press.

I think the thesis that Humanae Vitae is merely a “personal opinion” of the pope which can be licitly dissented with has lost all credibility among the Catholic faithful, clung to only by notoriously dissident theologians.
 
…The official teachings on contraception are, to say the least, a stumbling block for married people and a really unfair and impossible teaching.
The same could be said about the Divinity of Christ. It was also (and still is today) a stumbling block for most people, many thought it was an unscriptural “invention” and not true dogma, and the entire world at one point seemed Arian because of it. However, Liberius, Athanasius, and the others who understood that this teaching was not “impossible” prevailed, even if in the minority.

According to St. Paul, “For there must be also heresies: that they also, who are approved may be made manifest among you.” (1 Cor 11:19)

This I say as one who wrote against Humanae Vitae in college, citing such “authorities” as Fr. Charles Curran. I had been a dissenting Catholic for decades, only to later realize I was selfishly preferring the “clever” writings of dissidents who believed themselves more intelligent that 2000 years of doctors and saint.
Most people ignore the rule.
Yes. Throughout history people have been ignoring God’s will on many number of things. However, they do so to their own detriment. May God have mercy on their soul.
Rather then be hypocrites, lets just be intellectually honest and admit the Pope is not infallible.
It’s not hypocritical to hold fast to the deposit of faith taught in every century since the advent of Christ. On the contrary, it is consistent with calling oneself Christian.

I prefer truth to what the unholy masses conclude. I must follow the Lord, no matter how “common” it is not to. No matter how many commit the sin of Korah’s rebellion, I refuse to join. The more I study Catholic theology, the more ridiculous and pridefull the dissident like Kung and Curran appear. They commit Korah’s sin again and again…

“Woe to them! For they walk in the way of Cain, and abandon themselves for the sake of gain to Balaam’s error, and perish in Korah’s rebellion.” (Jude 11).
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top