Pope condemns "unregulated capitalism"

  • Thread starter Thread starter Schism_hater
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
S

Schism_hater

Guest
bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-20882894

Viva il Papa!

Pope’s new year address deplores rampant capitalism The Pope blessed the gospel during Mass in St Peter’s Basilica Continue reading the main story
Related Stories
Pope starts tweeting as @pontifex
Vatican country profile

Pope Benedict XVI has condemned “unregulated capitalism” for contributing to world tension, in a new year address to worshippers.

The Pope also thanked the world’s peacemakers and said humanity had “an innate vocation for peace”.

The Roman Catholic Church leader spoke at a Mass in the Vatican, then greeted a crowd outside St Peter’s Basilica.

He deplored “hotbeds of tension and conflict caused by growing instances of inequality between rich and poor”.

Those “hotbeds” also grew out of “the prevalence of a selfish and individualistic mindset which also finds expression in an unregulated financial capitalism”, as well as “various forms of terrorism and crime”, he said.
 
What countries have unregulated capitalism and what are their immigration policies?
 
Where are the humanitarian values in unregulated capitalism? I predict that the world will continue to grow and prosper with true humanitarianism in place.
 
I agree with Benedict on that, and I dissagree with some on CAF that are far right, like the members who have called any taxation theft.
 
Hasn’t the Church opposed unregulated Capitalism for a while? When Rerum Novarum issued by Pope Leo XIII on May 15, 1891 it opposed Communism, Socialism and unregulated Capitalism.
 
Hasn’t the Church opposed unregulated Capitalism for a while? When Rerum Novarum issued by Pope Leo XIII on May 15, 1891 it opposed Communism, Socialism and unregulated Capitalism.
Indeed. It is just that many on CAF seem to be blind and deaf to it.
 
Hasn’t the Church opposed unregulated Capitalism for a while? When Rerum Novarum issued by Pope Leo XIII on May 15, 1891 it opposed Communism, Socialism and unregulated Capitalism.
You are right, but some need to hear the message again.
 
Indeed. It is just that many on CAF seem to be blind and deaf to it.
Such as? I don’t think I’ve seen a single person here so far advocate completely unregulated capitalism but maybe I just haven’t looked hard enough.
Especially those who totally oppose and hate any government regulations.
edit: Hey, another volunteer! Between the both of you and the OP I’m sure we’ll have a result in no time.
 
What countries have unregulated capitalism and what are their immigration policies?
I don’t think the pope was necessarly saying that there are examples of unregulated capitalism in today’s society as much as he was comparing the individualistic mindset that he is seeing to what was probably present in the days when there was unregulated capitalism (ie. pre-WWII).

Don’t worry, there are plenty of people on both sides of the political spectrum who struggle with the sin of greed in today’s world! Self-admittedly, I’m one of them. 😦
 
Such as? I don’t think I’ve seen a single person here so far advocate completely unregulated capitalism but maybe I just haven’t looked hard enough
I would submit that some libertarians who view taxation as theft from the federal government as those people.
 
Unregulated capitalism doesn’t really exist in the world. Oligarchic mixed economies are the norm. I personally believe that the market itself should be laissez-faire, i. e. free from government control, but it should be regulated and managed by the activity of workers and unions. Maybe this model resembles something more like market socialism than it does capitalism but I consider myself a capitalist.
 
amen! christian leftism all the way! its good to see that the church is finally breaking with this injurious union to the right wing. the right wing has exploited poor people’s religions long enough. the catholic church really should form its own political party.
 
Unregulated capitalism doesn’t really exist in the world. Oligarchic mixed economies are the norm. I personally believe that the market itself should be laissez-faire, i. e. free from government control, but it should be regulated and managed by the activity of workers and unions. Maybe this model resembles something more like market socialism than it does capitalism but I consider myself a capitalist.
you really dont understand economics if you think that. lassez faire capitalism will eventually turmn into an oligarchy.
the markets need strict regulation. the probelm with the capitalist mentality is that its based solely on self interest. the answer is obvious. capital (the economy) must be put into the service of the people. this means anything which is injurious to the common good should be banned. (i.e. outsourcing, planned obsolescence, speculation, etc.)
 
Do you think the market doesn’t have strict regulations already? This is what leads to oligarchy. Large companies buy regulations to protect themselves from competitors and control the market and ultimately exert political power. Regulation to protect the market from this is necessary, not the regulations the market already has. I believe there are over 10,000 federal regulations of the economy, generally bought and paid for by oligarchic companies. Even regulations that are supposed to help people, like minimum wage, do much more harm than good. Do I think it should be legal to sell snake oil? No. But setting prices and wages and granting subsidies and bailouts is bad.

Capitalism is not a philosophy, it is not an ethical system, it is nothing more than private property and market economy. Selfishness may exist in this system and it may not. Government control of the economy is only a road to serfdom and the servile state.
 
Do you think the market doesn’t have strict regulations already? This is what leads to oligarchy. Large companies buy regulations to protect themselves from competitors and control the market and ultimately exert political power. Regulation to protect the market from this is necessary, not the regulations the market already has. I believe there are over 10,000 federal regulations of the economy, generally bought and paid for by oligarchic companies…
all the more reasons why measures should be taken to prevent monopolies from forming. a great way to prevent big bussiness from influencing the government is to simply outlaw lobbies. the state must also be autocratic. parlaimentary democracy is a system which easily allows oligarchies to form. (by rich people controlling politicians). the idea of an autocracy may be scary to some right wingers, but that is only because they are blinded by the lies of democracy.
Capitalism is not a philosophy, it is not an ethical system, it is nothing more than private property and market economy. Selfishness may exist in this system and it may not. Government control of the economy is only a road to serfdom and the servile state.
we live in a society, therefore we should have a clearly defined goal which the nation strives towards. that is partly the problem with a capitalist democratic society. the people are without direction, thus they degenrate into materialism. have you no idealism? i honestly dont get conservatives, do you view humanity as just individual atoms floating around with no duty to society and no purpose?
 
all the more reasons why measures should be taken to prevent monopolies from forming.
Monopolies cannot be sustained without government support, this has been recognized for centuries. The moment a competitor sells a product for a lower price, the monopoly is broken.
a great way to prevent big bussiness from influencing the government is to simply outlaw lobbies. the state must also be autocratic. parlaimentary democracy is a system which easily allows oligarchies to form. (by rich people controlling politicians). the idea of an autocracy may be scary to some right wingers, but that is only because they are blinded by the lies of democracy.
I’m sympathetic to this but blanket legislation like that always backfires. There’s nothing wrong with democracy per se, the ideal government should have a democratic element, something recognized by philosophers for milennia, but they can easily become the worst form of government.
we live in a society, therefore we should have a clearly defined goal which the nation strives towards. that is partly the problem with a capitalist democratic society. the people are without direction, thus they degenrate into materialism. have you no idealism?
You’ve recognized a cultural problem, but not one that can be solved by the government, and if you’re arguing for central planning you need to brush up on your Hayek. Capitalism is not a synonym for materialism and consumerism. Capitalism should be rightly understood as private property and market economy, which the Church has always endorsed. History shows that idealism leads to bloodshed. Societies are not planned, they spontaneously order themselves.
i honestly dont get conservatives, do you view humanity as just individual atoms floating around with no duty to society and no purpose?
No, everyone has a duty to society because we are social animals and images of God. This does not translate into government controlling everyone’s life.
 
Capitalism is not a philosophy, it is not an ethical system, it is nothing more than private property and market economy. Selfishness may exist in this system and it may not. Government control of the economy is only a road to serfdom and the servile state.
By this description, isn’t “regulated capitalism” an oxymoron?
 
By this description, isn’t “regulated capitalism” an oxymoron?
No, you can regulate private property and market economy, but it should be done only for what can certainly be shown to be for the common good and not have disastrous unintended consequences. I think it would be better done by self-governing workers myself instead of the government.
 
No, you can regulate private property and market economy, but it should be done only for what can certainly be shown to be for the common good and not have disastrous unintended consequences. I think it would be better done by self-governing workers myself instead of the government.
The government has its own property and other assets. Do you think all of it should be in private hands? Just asking.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top