I hope bishops, retired or not, will realize that in order to fix the problem (or any problem) the Holy See must enforce standards with a strong and just conviction, not change any standard.
It’s already been shown that neither one of those things is the source of the problem. I think this particular Bishop is talking through his Mitre.calling for a review of compulsory celibacy for priests and the church’s teachings on sex.
There is no such thing. Every man who is a priest has freely chosen celibacy and freely chooses to remain in that state. If a man should choose not to remain either in the active ministry of the priesthood or the celibate state, there are no enforcers preventing him from leaving.calling for a review of compulsory celibacy for priests…
But especially…And the attire of bishops and priests needed to be modernised - the bishop’s mitre abandoned because of its “bad body language” and the priestly collar replaced in some circumstances with a distinctive tie.
There was a need for the church to review…its “extreme” teachings on sexual ethics, in which the church treats as a sin sex before marriage between committed couples.
Exactly! The incidence of child abuse among the clergy is roughly the same (slightly lower) than the general population; and because the general population is half female this means that the offence rate of priests is more than half of that of the male population.It’s already been shown that neither one of those things is the source of the problem. I think this particular Bishop is talking through his Mitre.
I think there is a way of deposing a bad Pope - his Father calls him home.There has to be some way of trying & deposing a bad Pope - otherwise the Church (& its mission) is at the mercy of such a man.
This does not necessarily follow; in the general population if the ratio of child abusers is significantly higher in males than females, the offense rate for clergy may be closer to equal that of the general male population. I do not know what the ratio of male:female child offenders is in the general population.Exactly! The incidence of child abuse among the clergy is roughly the same (slightly lower) than the general population; and because the general population is half female this means that the offence rate of priests is more than half of that of the male population.
This is quite true. In many ways, a pope has less in the way of actual effective power over the worldwide church than a bishop has over his own diocese, since the bishop in effect “owns” his diocese.The pope has less power than what people realize. Unless, it does involve something that is a dogma of faith (there are more than what has been proclaimed thru infallibility), a bishop has the real power in his own diocese.
I wouldn’t say he “needs more power”…The Pope needs more power.
He needs the power to dissolve inequity and war with the reconciliation of all peoples.
I think Jesus would really dig on that.
Very confused ideas. The proposal is to abolish celibacy, and allow elections for the role of priest. Doesn’t he see that this would be an open invitation for ambitious men to get the prestige of the priesthood, at little personal sacrifice? The results might be better or they might be worse, but they would be radically different to what we have now.
I hope bishops, retired or not, will realize that in order to fix the problem (or any problem) the Holy See must enforce standards with a strong and just conviction, not change any standard.
The problem is that the pope has the power he needs and it is proper to his position, but his authority is not, and has not been properly utilized.
Any priest or bishop found guilty should be punished. Celibacy has nothing to do with the problem even fathers of children are molesters just as doctors, lawyers, factory workers etc.