Pope have too much power? Your thoughts

  • Thread starter Thread starter dolphinlove
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.

IMHO, yes. I think Popes should be subject to the Church, instead of over it as though they were the Lord of it (a position which is Christ’s alone); they are called “Servants of the servants of God”. So their total immunity from judgement by the Church - even by an Ecumenical Council - makes no sense. There has to be some way of trying & deposing a bad Pope - otherwise the Church (& its mission) is at the mercy of such a man. Other bishops or Catholics are not above the law of the Church, still less of God - why should they be exempt ? If (say) other bishops retire at 75, the Bishop of Rome should not be exempt, but should “set an example to the flock” by subjecting himself to the laws he requires others to obey.​

 
I hope bishops, retired or not, will realize that in order to fix the problem (or any problem) the Holy See must enforce standards with a strong and just conviction, not change any standard.
The problem is that the pope has the power he needs and it is proper to his position, but his authority is not, and has not been properly utilized.
Any priest or bishop found guilty should be punished. Celibacy has nothing to do with the problem even fathers of children are molesters just as doctors, lawyers, factory workers etc.
 
calling for a review of compulsory celibacy for priests and the church’s teachings on sex.
It’s already been shown that neither one of those things is the source of the problem. I think this particular Bishop is talking through his Mitre.
 
A few comments:

#1 - the newspaper’s eagerness to call these remarks by the Bishop some “explosive” story…explosive like what? Trick Whipper Snaps?

#2 - anyone who thinks celibacy is the root of the problem doesn’t realize that celibacy is hardly the common denominator of sex offenders, especially pedophiliacs. In fact such a vow is common in the vast minority of cases.

#3 - isn’t this a little like saying that Moses had too much power over the Israelites??? One could easily argue the Pope has even less power than him…

#4 - I agree with Pax.

#5 - why is he mentioned as “once touted” as a candidate for Archbishop of Sydney? Touted by whom? Whoever it was…perhaps it was the Holy Spirit that kept him from the office…??? :rolleyes:
 
Why change thw way the pop’es were elected. As long as the papacy remains in the Vatican then there is no need to change it. The papacy has grown tremendously in power and presteige. If it ain’t broke don’t fix it.

God speed

Vigis
 
I think the Pope has too LITTLE power. In my perfect world, B16 would be more closely monitoring what is going on here in America and removing some of the priests, Bishops, and even Cardinals who are doing everything in their power to dilute the Catholic faith.

And how interesting that Robinson is concerned that Bishop’s should have more say in really relevent issues like the headwear and collars of the clergy!:rolleyes:
 
calling for a review of compulsory celibacy for priests…
There is no such thing. Every man who is a priest has freely chosen celibacy and freely chooses to remain in that state. If a man should choose not to remain either in the active ministry of the priesthood or the celibate state, there are no enforcers preventing him from leaving.

This is not to say that some choices a man may make will not have the effect of precluding other choices. If a man chooses to be an ordained priest in the Latin Church, that choice will also prclude him from also being a married man. Such preclusion is not limited to priests. I am a maried man. My choice to marry my wife not only precludes me from being an ordained priest but also from being married to anyone else for as long as my wife is alive (for both preclusions). But we do not speak of these limitations of the married state as being compulsory, I have freely chosen them.
 
And the attire of bishops and priests needed to be modernised - the bishop’s mitre abandoned because of its “bad body language” and the priestly collar replaced in some circumstances with a distinctive tie.
But especially…
There was a need for the church to review…its “extreme” teachings on sexual ethics, in which the church treats as a sin sex before marriage between committed couples.
:confused:

He really needs our prayers! 😦
 
It’s already been shown that neither one of those things is the source of the problem. I think this particular Bishop is talking through his Mitre.
Exactly! The incidence of child abuse among the clergy is roughly the same (slightly lower) than the general population; and because the general population is half female this means that the offence rate of priests is more than half of that of the male population.
 
I agree with some of the ideas expressed here and disagree with others.
Pope’s power–
On infallibility–I think this is one of the most misunderstood symbols of his power that we have. I think the issue needs to be revisited–not to deny, but to set a very strict definition of what is meant. This is one doctrine that has to be interpreted in its most limited form to be effective. Secondly, this ‘power’ is really a power of the church, embodied in the pope. The pope cannot issue an infallible decree on his on–but only in union with the whole church and as the head of the whole church. There is reason why most scholars say that this doctrine has only been applied twice (2x) in history. A few would try to add a third–but there is enough debate about that one that it can be best asserted that there is true doubt about that one being an infallible statement made by the pope.
The pope has less power than what people realize. Unless, it does involve something that is a dogma of faith (there are more than what has been proclaimed thru infallibility), a bishop has the real power in his own diocese. An example of this is the Lincoln diocese in Nebr. refusing to go along with the US Bishops now established policy on sex abuse. (I assume, he has his own criteria set up for his diocese.)
As to celebacy and priesthood–they are not mutually exclusive. In the Latin, we have few married priests–but we do have some that were ordained after they were married. True, as it is presently set up–for most it is a mutually exclusive decision–marriage or priest–but it does not have to be so. Our church tradition also shows that a married clergy is both acceptable and can function well.
As to limiting the term of the pope and to having a means to depose the pope–I agree–both are needed. JPII’s end of life pointed to some real problems, but these problems did not materialize. He died quick enough after he became sick unto death.
I also agree that the pope should also be the first to retire at 75, if he is going to insist on the bishops submitting a letter of retirement at that age. Could it be set up that he submit his letter to the Cardinals–and if they so choose, they could delay accepting it. A certain percentage of them could be required to not accept. But even then, the delay should itself have a term limit.
To stop some of the inbreeding in the Vatican, I also think Cardinals should be elected by the bishops of the country they are to serve. The pope could be given the right to veto ‘for good reason.’
And for Bishops, I think it would be very good to have the priests at least propose priests to be bishops. And it could be set up that the Bishops would choose from a pool of these priests, or would accept a direct recommendation from the priests–again with veto for good cause.
 
The Pope needs more power.

He needs the power to dissolve inequity and war with the reconciliation of all peoples.

I think Jesus would really dig on that.
 
Exactly! The incidence of child abuse among the clergy is roughly the same (slightly lower) than the general population; and because the general population is half female this means that the offence rate of priests is more than half of that of the male population.
This does not necessarily follow; in the general population if the ratio of child abusers is significantly higher in males than females, the offense rate for clergy may be closer to equal that of the general male population. I do not know what the ratio of male:female child offenders is in the general population.
 
The pope has less power than what people realize. Unless, it does involve something that is a dogma of faith (there are more than what has been proclaimed thru infallibility), a bishop has the real power in his own diocese.
This is quite true. In many ways, a pope has less in the way of actual effective power over the worldwide church than a bishop has over his own diocese, since the bishop in effect “owns” his diocese.

In reality, centralized power is exercised more routinely and effectively within the U.S. government, in school districts, and in corporations, than it is in the Catholic Church, where most things are left to the pastor or the bishop.
 
The Pope needs more power.

He needs the power to dissolve inequity and war with the reconciliation of all peoples.

I think Jesus would really dig on that.
I wouldn’t say he “needs more power”…
He only needs to fully and properly excercise the authority he already has and has had since the time of Saint Peter.
He also needs good orthodox bishops to “get his back” espcecially in moves in regaining the tradition and dignity of the Holy Catholic Church.
The Pope is indeed the head of the church yet…
It takes more than just the Pope to lead and guide the church (in cooperation with the Holy Ghost the True authority), it takes the entire magesterium with the Pope and the authority of the papacy.
 
In no way should a pope be deposed. This has its advantages no doubt, but it invites severely grave consequences. It invites the secular world into hijacking the papacy. We don’t need another Great Schism of the Western Church. Popes either die or they resign. Why should the issue of Pope John Paul II give rise to the issue of deposing a pope? He did a great job as pope up to the very end. To form a system that has the power to depose a pope will only lead to the power of the pope being severely weakened. If such a system is set up then the pope will winde up just like the Holy Roman Emperor or the Monarch of England. They had or have their titles, but no power at all. Do we really want to do this to the papacy?

God speed.

Vigis
 
Very confused ideas. The proposal is to abolish celibacy, and allow elections for the role of priest. Doesn’t he see that this would be an open invitation for ambitious men to get the prestige of the priesthood, at little personal sacrifice? The results might be better or they might be worse, but they would be radically different to what we have now.

Modern media means that most non-Catholics, or non-practising Catholics, see the Pope rather than the local bishop as the voice of the Catholic church. Almost everyone could tell you who the Pope is, most British people could probably tell you something about the Cardinal Archbishop of Westminster, but very few non-Catholics in Leeds or Bradford could tell you the name of Arthur Roche, Bishop of Leeds. That’s not an ideal situation by any means, but it is the world we live in. You can’t uninvent the TV set.
 
I hope bishops, retired or not, will realize that in order to fix the problem (or any problem) the Holy See must enforce standards with a strong and just conviction, not change any standard.
The problem is that the pope has the power he needs and it is proper to his position, but his authority is not, and has not been properly utilized.
Any priest or bishop found guilty should be punished. Celibacy has nothing to do with the problem even fathers of children are molesters just as doctors, lawyers, factory workers etc.

👍 To bring celibacy into all this is a massive distraction - it’s not celibacy that causes sexual misdeeds, but incontinence: & that can cause trouble whether one is​

  • celibate
  • betrothed
  • married
  • or living in a state of continence whether as a:
    • *religious *
    • or a *cleric *
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top