Possible polygamy challenge in Canada

  • Thread starter Thread starter Spirithound
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Happy or pretending to be happy? A 13 yr old girl is not ready for marital intimacy…and who is she marrying, a grown man? It’s perverse, and immoral. It is not of God. God would never instruct us to allow our children to be married off to grown men.

If it is two 13 yr olds getting married, again, neither is ‘ready.’ I have heard of arranged marriages ‘working,’ but I would want more than a ‘working’ marriage. A tolerable marriage. I think that for some, love can be found…I don’t imagine for most, a 13 yr old girl wouldn’t even know what true love is at that stage of life or what is required in a marriage to make it work.

I think that what we are missing about radical mormon sects, is that they typically link teen girls with OLD men…not even older men. Again, wrong and sick.
I’m telling you. I’ve met women who ended up very happy and not only happy, able to share love and help others. The kindest woman in the world that I know entered into just that sort of marriage. Besides, isn’t this the type of relationship that the Virgin Mary was supposed to have? 🤷 I thought she was around that age 14 or so. 🤷 I doubt this argument is universally agreed upon with many Muslim immigrants.

I’m just saying that if traditional marriage is not upheld, it opens the logical and legal door open to many other forms of marriage. It may not happen in 5 years, may not happen in 10 years, but it may one day happen. For example, incest is legal in the Netherlands as long as the child is over 18 so is prostitution. Many of the prostitutes and young heroin survors (approximately 65- 75%) are incest babies. Sex slavery is pretty much legal in the Netherlands. See here: weblogs.nrc.nl/weblog/discussion/2008/09/18/the-bankruptcy-of-legalised-prostitution/
Human nature has been corrupted by original sin and it seems likely that we can approve of almost anything. Changing the definition of marriage may open the legal door to the changes that have happened in other countries around the world.

I haven’t examined this document in detail but I should How the Netherlands protects Child Molesters stolenchildren.net/exhibits/NLpedprotect.html
 
Happy or pretending to be happy? A 13 yr old girl is not ready for marital intimacy…and who is she marrying, a grown man? It’s perverse, and immoral. It is not of God. God would never instruct us to allow our children to be married off to grown men.

If it is two 13 yr olds getting married, again, neither is ‘ready.’ I have heard of arranged marriages ‘working,’ but I would want more than a ‘working’ marriage. A tolerable marriage. I think that for some, love can be found…I don’t imagine for most, a 13 yr old girl wouldn’t even know what true love is at that stage of life or what is required in a marriage to make it work.

I think that what we are missing about radical mormon sects, is that they typically link teen girls with OLD men…not even older men. Again, wrong and sick.
I knew one 13 year old girl that was married due to being pregnant, so she was already familiar with "marital intimacy"so to speak & was soon to be a mother.Her husband was maybe 17. I’m not endorsing kids getting married today at 13 or even 16 but you have to admit it was pretty common back in the day.If you look at records going back thru’ the centuries even saints were married at 14 or younger.Life spans were shorter & I guess folks did what they needed to do.How old was Our Lady when she was betrothed to St. Joseph?
Things change.
I agree though re. the polygamist men they have charged.
 
I knew one 13 year old girl that was married due to being pregnant, so she was already familiar with "marital intimacy"so to speak & was soon to be a mother.Her husband was maybe 17. I’m not endorsing kids getting married today at 13 or even 16 but you have to admit it was pretty common back in the day.If you look at records going back thru’ the centuries even saints were married at 14 or younger.Life spans were shorter & I guess folks did what they needed to do.How old was Our Lady when she was betrothed to St. Joseph?
Things change.
I agree though re. the polygamist men they have charged.
Oh yes, I agree…most of my Italian side of the family all had arranged marriages, except my dad and a few younger cousins and siblings of his. I remember my aunts being very unhappy growing up…and perhaps, my view on arranged marriages is slanted from that…but, I don’t agree with them. Plus most of my aunts were barely teens themselves, when they were married off.

The abusive polygamist men should be put in jail…without a doubt, for a very long time. :mad: I can’t believe this even goes on in our country in this day and age. I suggest reading Escape for a real eye opening look at some of these radical mormon cults. (I have been watching Big Love, which is a show ironically almost glamourizing polygamy with the main characters, and I doubt it’s anything like that) 😦 God would never want women to degrade themselves in such a way, that they are competing with other ‘wives’ for their husband’s love.
 
A 13 yr old girl is not ready for marital intimacy…and who is she marrying, a grown man? It’s perverse, and immoral. It is not of God. God would never instruct us to allow our children to be married off to grown men.
I don’t think it is a good idea either. But, in Catholic tradition, as someone brought up, there’s different ideas about what happened with Mary and Joseph. One idea is that Mary was a young girl, about 12 years old, when she was betrothed to Joseph and that Joseph was an old widower and that his death later on explains why he isn’t mentioned in parts of the gospels and that Joseph’s children from his first marriage explains the brothers of Jesus. Whether this tradition is true or not, this kind of thing was not rare at the time among the Jewish people. Another idea is that Mary, still a very young girl (the age varies depending on the tradition or saint), was betrothed to a not so old Joseph who hadn’t married before and that on the spiritual and physical level, they were quite suited for each as a chaste virginal couple. The brothers of Jesus are explained as relatives of Jesus.

For better or worse, church canon law today allows girls as young as 14 to get married validly. And, for better or worse, there is no restriction making it invalid for them to marry someone significantly older. These provisions may make things look better though:

Can. 1071 §1 Except in a case of necessity, no one is to assist without the permission of the local Ordinary at:

2° a marriage which cannot be recognised by the civil law or celebrated in accordance with it;

6° a marriage of a minor whose parents are either unaware of it or are reasonably opposed to it;

Can. 1072 Pastors of souls are to see to it that they dissuade young people from entering marriage before the age customarily accepted in the region.

So it is required of priests that they obtain the permission of their bishop before marrying someone whose marriage wouldn’t be recognized by secular law or whose parents are unaware of the marriage or are “reasonably opposed to it.” So, yes, this means that if the church thinks the parents are unreasonably opposed, there’s nothing the parents can do about that specific aspect. Note also the note on regional custom in canon 1072,
 
We should not paint polygamists with a broad brush anymore than we would heterosexuals, homosexuals, races or religions.

There are polygamists of all kinds as people have mentioned. Christian (not just Mormon) polygamists. Islamic polygamists. Jewish polygamists. This piece was originally reported by John Stossel for ABC but I guess the conservative bastion, townhall.com has picked up Stossel as one of their columnists.

townhall.com/columnists/JohnStossel/2008/07/30/how_many_wives_is_too_many?page=full&comments=true

Henkel and his website, TruthBearer campaign against the media and others who lump criminals … with all polygamy … Henkel complains that American laws are hypocritical. “Someone like a Hugh Hefner will have a successful television show with three live-in girlfriends! And that’s all OK, and he’s making great money, and that’s all fine and great entertainment. But suddenly, if that man was to marry them, then suddenly he’s a criminal. That’s insane!” … there’s lots of polygamy in America that has nothing to do with [Mormon groups] For my “20/20” special, we interviewed Jewish and evangelical Christian polygamists. Henkel’s website is subtitled “Organization for Christian Polygamy.” He estimates that there are 100,000 polygamists in America.

Ten years ago, University of Georgia Professor Patricia Dixon thought polygamy exploited women. Then she embarked on a study of it. “I was transformed by the experience.” She spent years living with different polygamous communities. She was surprised to find that polygamy was not about men exploiting women. “It’s female-centered. The women are the ones who are benefiting… It’s not about another notch on your belt or anything like that. It really is the women who really promote this idea.” … Mark Henkel [says] “If they’re saying that’s immoral, they’re calling the greatest heroes in the Bible … immoral! … Saying that Abraham, with his three wives, was immoral. Jacob had four wives. David had seven known named wives before Bathsheba.”

Prince Ben-Israel, who has four wives, calls plural marriage a civil-rights issue. “Who is this government that’s in somebody’s bedroom? … It was illegal for me to marry a white woman at one time. … It was illegal for me to vote at one time. And if I had accepted somebody else’s definition of what was right and wrong, I would still be riding in the back of the bus. We’re not saying this is for everybody. …”

The organization Stossel refers to says on its website:

Christian Polygamy
Code:
* This is NOT about polyandry or polyamory.
* This is NOT about fornication or adultery.
* This is NOT about group marriage or wife swapping.
* This is NOT about dishonest bigamy or infidelity.
* This is NOT about underaged or arranged marriage.
* This is NOT about any form of mormonism.
* This is NOT about re-defining marriage.
So let’s separate criticism of polygamy from all of the above. Maybe arranged marriages are bad but arranged marriages have nothing to do with polygamy; there are many more arranged monogamous marriages than polygamous ones.

Thanks for recommending the show Big Love. I’ll have to give it a second look. I was turned off by it the first time I saw it; it didn’t seem to have much of a premise or storyline. I only saw the pilot so I’m sure it’s good entertainment.
 
Hi vs–yeah, give it another try. I too thought it odd when I saw one or two episodes…like hard to get into. It has a very deep plot actually…a few going on at one time, so if you jump in the middle, it can seem confusing. But, it’s a great show.

Re: polygamy…I view it as an objectification and exploitation of women. When a man has more than one ‘wife,’ (technically these women are just live in girlfriends because one cannot be legally married in the U.S. to more than one person) there will be division. Even in the best of situations. Marriage is designed for monogamy, not for a woman to have to wonder if her husband loves this one mroe than her…etc. Those things definitely go on, because we are human. I think that polygamy is most definitely a manmade invention, and sadly…touted as coming from God. That is what is most damaging to the women involved…they really believe they are living out God’s will, by being a second or third wife. God’s love doesn’t bring pain, devisiveness and strife. It brings peace. If you ever watch some of the news footage where the ‘wives’ are being interviewed…oh my gosh. They literally all sound exactly alike. Their eyes paint a different picture. If polygamy was healthy for women, they wouldn’t age so dramatically…I couldn’t believe that some of the women were my age (40)…they looked 60.

It’s a distortion of Truth, to tell women that they are serving the Lord by sharing their husband with other women. I respect all people, but I don’t respect a ‘faith’ or ‘religion’ that exploits women in this way. Degradation and exploitation of women is not of God. Women are not to be property, and Mormons actually do not believe in polygamy anymore. The radical offshoots of Mormonism however, do and practice it. (FLDS members for example)

I also believe it to be wrong in Islam. I have muslim friends, one who’s mom was married to a polygamist. She said it was horrible. The fighting that went on…the husband always in the middle, almost gloating that two women were ‘fighting’ over him. This is not of God.

Just my two cents.
 
I don’t think it is a good idea either. But, in Catholic tradition, as someone brought up, there’s different ideas about what happened with Mary and Joseph. One idea is that Mary was a young girl, about 12 years old, when she was betrothed to Joseph and that Joseph was an old widower and that his death later on explains why he isn’t mentioned in parts of the gospels and that Joseph’s children from his first marriage explains the brothers of Jesus. Whether this tradition is true or not, this kind of thing was not rare at the time among the Jewish people. Another idea is that Mary, still a very young girl (the age varies depending on the tradition or saint), was betrothed to a not so old Joseph who hadn’t married before and that on the spiritual and physical level, they were quite suited for each as a chaste virginal couple. The brothers of Jesus are explained as relatives of Jesus.
As is often the case, you have made some factual errors in your assertions. Neither Catholic tradition nor any of the chuirch approved visionaries (St. Birgitta, Ven. Anne Katherine Emmerich to name just two) does not speculate that Mary was about 12. Instead, the ages cited are generally 15 or 16.
In your last paragraph, you really twist things around and try to assert that the a priest or bishop would casually disregard a the objections of a parent. Dude, reality check. What kind of a priest would marry a 15 year girl when her parents are screaming at him claiming she is too young? Answer, unless that priest is you, no one.
[/QUOTE]
 
The U.S. is led by one whose IQ when measured when entering high school was 166 and in kindergarten, 172. As long as we don’t support obstructionism, we should be in good hands. When the crisis is averted, we can concentrate on things of lesser importance in the ways we might think good to pursue.
🤷
 
According to Catholic doctrine, polygyny is not more sinful than homosexual couplings.
Where is the proof?

Homosexual acts are intrinsically evil. That is Catholic doctrine.

Polygamy is not intrinsically evil, is it?

In fact the old CE spells it out well:
The strict law of marriage was made known to our first parents in Paradise: “They shall be two in one flesh” (Genesis 2:24). When the sacred text says two it excludes polygamy, when it says one flesh it excludes divorce. Amid the general laxity with regard to marriage which existed among the Semitic tribes, it would have been difficult to preserve the strict law. The importance of a rapid increase among the chosen people of God so as to enable them to defend themselves from their neighbours, and to fulfil their appointed destiny, seemed to favour relaxation. The example of some of the chief of the ancient Patriarchs was taken by their descendants as being a sufficient indication of the dispensation granted by God. With special safeguards annexed to it Moses adopted the Divine dispensation on account of the hardness of heart of the Jewish people. Neither polygamy nor divorce can be said to be contrary to the primary precepts of nature. The primary end of marriage is compatible with both. But at least they are against the secondary precepts of the natural law: contrary, that is, to what is required for the well-ordering of human life. In these secondary precepts, however, God can dispense for good reason if He sees fit to do so. In so doing He uses His sovereign authority to diminish the right of absolute equality which naturally exists between man and woman with reference to marriage. In this way, without suffering any stain on His holiness, God could permit and sanction polygamy and divorce in the Old Law.
 
Neither Catholic tradition nor any of the chuirch approved visionaries (St. Birgitta, Ven. Anne Katherine Emmerich to name just two) does not speculate that Mary was about 12.
Read the Protoevangelium of James. This is not necessarily big T Tradition. This is one of as I mentioned different traditions.

In any event, it is historical fact per the Catholic Encyclopedia, that the church has permitted in the West marriages by girls as young as 12 and in the East as young as 10. I don’t think such practices were good ones, but that is the history. In present church law for the West, the mininum age is 14.
 
Where is the proof?

Homosexual acts are intrinsically evil. That is Catholic doctrine.

Polygamy is not intrinsically evil, is it?

In fact the old CE spells it out well:
Um, that’s what I was saying. As you point out according to Catholic doctrine homosexuality is intrinsically evil while polygyny is not intrinsically evil. So as I said, Catholic doctrine and Thomistic doctrine would both say that gay marriage is a bigger deal than homosexual marriage and that polygyny is not more sinful than homosexuality. You were totally agreeing with me.
 
Um, that’s what I was saying. As you point out according to Catholic doctrine homosexuality is intrinsically evil while polygyny is not intrinsically evil. So as I said, Catholic doctrine and Thomistic doctrine would both say that gay marriage is a bigger deal than homosexual marriage and that polygyny is not more sinful than homosexuality. You were totally agreeing with me.
What is the difference between gay marriage and homosexual marriage?
 
The problem of polygamy seems to fall under the area of forced marriages. Many women born into polygamist communities, are forced to marry their husbands. They have little choice. Also, abuse is common in these types of communities. Not all husbands abuse their wives, but many 50, 60 yr old men are marrying teenagers…and many of the teens have no say in the matter. It’s just forced upon them.

While it is not intrinsically evil, polygamy can lead to sinful activities, such as abuse, rape, and incest. It has been shown to lead to these things, in historical studies. Plus, these men are not really ‘married’ in the legal sense to the additional ‘wives’, so to me, they are in essence committing adultery. Not intrinsically evil on its own, but what it leads to can be sinful.

If polygamists lead healthy lifestyles, they wouldn’t need to live in secluded compounds, with guards…which to me, the whole thing mirrors a prison set up. If the leaders in these communities have nothing to hide, why do they seclude their families like this? Very few polygamists just live out in the open…they are usually in these compounds, here in the U.S. If the barricaded communities is to keep women from ‘escaping,’ then it can’t be good. If people are looking to escape these communities…it can’t be good. People don’t escape good situations. The fact that people who have left polygamist marriages, situations, etc…call it ‘escape’ is scary, in and of itself.

Polygamy and homosexuality are two different things, and not sure why homosexuality is being brought up in this thread. It really has nothing to do with the subject.🤷
 
What is the difference between gay marriage and homosexual marriage?
I was wondering the same thing. 😉 Just a typo I am sure. I make them all the time myself, especially when I go back and edit what I just wrote, sometimes I get the words in the wrong order or use the wrong word when I mean the exact opposite.

While I would not presume to put words in his mouth, I interpreted what he wrote as “gay marriage is a bigger deal than polygamist marriage.”
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top