Preaching for the Environment

  • Thread starter Thread starter fnr
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
“Roman Catholics, per capita, have the greatest potential to preserve biological diversity where they live.”

Not if they don’t see it.

Also linked there:

Air pollution causes about 200,000 early deaths each year in the United States, according to a new study from the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT).

m.voanews.com/a/1739804.html
 
“Roman Catholics, per capita, have the greatest potential to preserve biological diversity where they live.”

Not if they don’t see it.

Also linked there:

Air pollution causes about 200,000 early deaths each year in the United States, according to a new study from the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT).

m.voanews.com/a/1739804.html
For air pollution we aim for reasonable standards that enable a person routinely exposed to live a life of about 75 years on average.
 
Supposed to die? We never know that.

We do know that they died of ailments exacerbated by pollution.
Probably true that some of them were.

But our chances for survival overall at the current life expectancy and quality of life would be much less without access to affordable energy.

I think we can walk and chew here at the same and manage pollution. A lot of companies have shown at least some kind of interest in this.
 
“Roman Catholics, per capita, have the greatest potential to preserve biological diversity where they live.”

Not if they don’t see it.

Also linked there:

Air pollution causes about 200,000 early deaths each year in the United States, according to a new study from the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT).

m.voanews.com/a/1739804.html
Caring for the environment is something we are all called to do to fulfill our role as stewards of God’s creation. However, I think there are much more pressing, important matters for our priests to preach about than global warming and greenhouse gasses: such as the lack of respect for the sanctity of life, the prevalence of war, the growth of government and secular attitudes designed to replace the traditional roles of Church and family. In short, the “brave new world” we are living in is pretty scary - and radical environmentalism is another way for otherwise good Catholics/Christians to be distracted from what is most important.

Ishiii
 
There are always trade offs. People move away from the bad air of cities for example, especially old people who cannot handle bad air, and they do not die from air pollution at the same rates.
But they die at higher rates on the way to hospital from other causes associated with old age.

It is not so much a moral problem as one that can be assessed best with actuarial tables. Priests are likely not the best people to refer to for problems like that.
 
Caring for the environment is something we are all called to do to fulfill our role as stewards of God’s creation. However, I think there are much more pressing, important matters for our priests to preach about than global warming and greenhouse gasses: such as the lack of respect for the sanctity of life, the prevalence of war, the growth of government and secular attitudes designed to replace the traditional roles of Church and family. In short, the “brave new world” we are living in is pretty scary - and radical environmentalism is another way for otherwise good Catholics/Christians to be distracted from what is most important.

Ishiii
And yet it is all related to stewardship:
osv.com/tabid/7621/itemid/11291/Pope-Francis-guide-to-avoiding-a-throwaway-cultu.aspx

Dear brothers and sisters, Christ died and rose once for all, and for everyone, but the power of the Resurrection, this passover from slavery to evil to the freedom of goodness, must be accomplished in every age, in our concrete existence, in our everyday lives. How many deserts, even today, do human beings need to cross! Above all, the desert within, when we have no love for God or neighbour, when we fail to realize that we are guardians of all that the Creator has given us and continues to give us. God’s mercy can make even the driest land become a garden, can restore life to dry bones (cf. Ez 37:1-14).

So this is the invitation which I address to everyone: Let us accept the grace of Christ’s Resurrection! Let us be renewed by God’s mercy, let us be loved by Jesus, let us enable the power of his love to transform our lives too; and let us become agents of this mercy, channels through which God can water the earth, protect all creation and make justice and peace flourish.

Peace in the whole world, still divided by greed looking for easy gain, wounded by the selfishness which threatens human life and the family, selfishness that continues in human trafficking, the most extensive form of slavery in this twenty-first century; human trafficking is the most extensive form of slavery in this twenty-first century! Peace to the whole world, torn apart by violence linked to drug trafficking and by the iniquitous exploitation of natural resources! Peace to this our Earth! Made the risen Jesus bring comfort to the victims of natural disasters and make us responsible guardians of creation.

faithandenvironment.wordpress.com/2013/04/13/pope-francis-on-stewardship-and-world-youth-day/
 
Supposed to die? We never know that.

We do know that they died of ailments exacerbated by pollution.
Actually, from this article, we don’t know that. They simply assert it. There is no foundational information to support it in the article. They might simply be taking the number of “premature deaths” (which could be from all sorts of causes, like gangland violence, for instance) adding a higher pollution level in urban areas, then leaping to the conclusion that the latter causes the former. The article doesn’t support the conclusions all.

But even if it did, then what’s the answer? Perhaps to decentralize the cities? Perhaps to centralize them more so people don’t drive from suburbs to work? The article has no answer.
 
For air pollution we aim for reasonable standards that enable a person routinely exposed to live a life of about 75 years on average.
Statistically, the older a population is, the longer is its life expectancy expressed in years of life. That’s just an actuarial thing, because younger people have lots of hazards of life to go through that older people have already gone through and survived. A 75 year old has a much greater chance of living to age 80 than does a child of 10.

So, a lower life expectancy in big cities might simply reflect a lower average age than is the case in rural areas.
 
I think we will e hearing more about this interrelationship people/environement.

Cardinal Turkson links care for environment, human life

“Both of them are interrelated,” he explained. “We cannot show concern for the earth and not show concern for human life. Neither can we show concern for human life and not show concern for the environment or the earth. The two go hand-in-hand.”

The cardinal invited his audience to reconsider the way they see the created world. He stressed the importance of understanding our world as a cosmos, or ordered system, that derives its order from the Word of God, which puts everything in its place.

catholicnewsagency.com/news/cardinal-turkson-links-care-for-environment-human-life/

In the Pope’s assessment, the world is not only suffering from an economic management crisis, but also a lack of “concern for human resources.”

Not enough people think about “the needs of our brothers and sisters living in extreme poverty, and especially for the many children in our world lacking adequate education, health care and nutrition,” he said.

“Consumerism and a culture of waste have led some of us to tolerate the waste of precious resources, including food, while others are literally wasting away from hunger,” he warned.

“I ask all of you to reflect on this grave ethical problem in a spirit of solidarity grounded in our common responsibility for the earth and for all our brothers and sisters in the human family,” the Pope said.

catholicnewsagency.com/news/pope-stresses-threats-to-human-person-on-environment-day/
 
Pope Benedict preaching the environement Castel Gandolfo, Italy, Aug 26, 2009

“The different phenomena of environmental degradation and natural catastrophes,” Pope Benedict explained, “which unfortunately occur all too often, remind us of the urgency of dutiful respect toward nature, recovering and valuing a correct relationship with the environment each day.”

catholicnewsagency.com/news/human_progress_depends_on_care_for_the_environment_pope_says/

“This obedience to the voice of the Earth is more important for our future happiness … than the desires of the moment. Our Earth is talking to us and we must listen to it and decipher its message if we want to survive,” he stated.

catholicnewsagency.com/news/pope_calls_for_protection_of_environment_says_creationevolution_debate_is_absurdity/
 
Caring for the environment is something we are all called to do to fulfill our role as stewards of God’s creation. However, I think there are much more pressing, important matters for our priests to preach about than global warming and greenhouse gasses: such as the lack of respect for the sanctity of life, the prevalence of war, the growth of government and secular attitudes designed to replace the traditional roles of Church and family. In short, the “brave new world” we are living in is pretty scary - and radical environmentalism is another way for otherwise good Catholics/Christians to be distracted from what is most important.

Ishiii
It is precisely my respect for the sanctity of life that has led me to mitigate my GHGs and other pollution for the past few decades. I don’t like killing people, not at all, and that is what we are doing thru environmental harms.

I think once one has developed a prolife ethic (I’ve always had one), and one has worked on reducing their other sins, has remained faithful to their one and only spouse, has not sought or promoted abortion or other killings and harms to people, then that person would surely strive to reduce their killing of people thru environmental harms. That would flow naturally from their prolife ethic.

It is just those who pay lipservice to prolife issues, maybe even attend a pro-life rally or two, and focus on other people’s sins and not their own who would not be intersted in protecting creation (reducing their harms and killings thru environmental harms).

In other words, selfishness and ego problems tend to take center stage in our lives, and we are more easily able to see the harms others are doing without seeing our own harms. It feels so much better to point fingers at others’ sins, while ignoring our own. 🙂

Unfortunately I never hear any of my priests even include creation protection in their homilies (tho Pope Francis had been big on the issue), but a person sincerely intent on reducing the harm and killing would figure it out for themselves and do the needful.
 
Supposed to die? We never know that.

We do know that they died of ailments exacerbated by pollution.
You are very luck not to have anyone in your family with cancer, asthma, or other diseases that are often exacerbated by environmental assaults. It is, however, very sad for people to suffer from these and have family members and friends suffering.

I know people don’t make the link, but a lot of cancers and diseases are caused by or enhanced by environmental harms. The other day on the news they said that women are twice as likely as men to have serious asthmatic conditions, and were surprised why that might be…without considering that women use 3 times more personal care products and more frequently use household cleaning products than men – and a huge amount of these have toxins harmful to human health.

This is not to say men are not at risk – they tend to have riskier jobs than women, engage in more riskly lifestyle behavior, and get stressed out more from societal pressures.

It’s too bad that we look at long-living people (who may have avoided such toxins, etc, or may have better physical constitutions to withstand such assaults), and consider them lucky heroes, and those who die earlier from environmental factors as unlucky chumps. Anything to avoid facing up to our own responsibilities in contributing to other peoples harms and deaths.
 
You are very luck not to have anyone in your family with cancer, asthma, or other diseases that are often exacerbated by environmental assaults. It is, however, very sad for people to suffer from these and have family members and friends suffering.

I know people don’t make the link, but a lot of cancers and diseases are caused by or enhanced by environmental harms. The other day on the news they said that women are twice as likely as men to have serious asthmatic conditions, and were surprised why that might be…without considering that women use 3 times more personal care products and more frequently use household cleaning products than men – and a huge amount of these have toxins harmful to human health.

This is not to say men are not at risk – they tend to have riskier jobs than women, engage in more riskly lifestyle behavior, and get stressed out more from societal pressures.

It’s too bad that we look at long-living people (who may have avoided such toxins, etc, or may have better physical constitutions to withstand such assaults), and consider them lucky heroes, and those who die earlier from environmental factors as unlucky chumps. Anything to avoid facing up to our own responsibilities in contributing to other peoples harms and deaths.
In the bible, the expected lifespan allotted to man is “three score and ten” years. 70 years, and that was in an environment without any of the life-extending developments of today, or the industrially produced toxins, either one.

People then did, however, have greater exposure to toxins different from those of today. They used lead and copper a lot, and melted and smelted them over open hearths. They had significant exposure to aflatoxins, much more than we have today.

We can certainly do things to minimize exposures to toxic things, and we do attempt to do that. It isn’t as if people are dumping PCBs into every lake and stream without restraint.

But in truth, we don’t really know what “causes” most cancers or asthmas. We really don’t. Likely in biblical days they didn’t either, and perhaps no less than we do for most things. But for sure, we’re much more likely to be aware because of diagnostic methods and easy remediation of conditions that throw the ireemediable conditions into stark relief.

One reads old novels or historical accounts and one reads of people “wasting away”, “dying of a broken heart”, “dying of ‘the fever’” and so on, and one wonders what those things really were. Possibly many of them were early symptoms of things we now beat back only to find that the real cause is some incurable thing.

I agree that many parts of the world are horribly, horribly contaminated. I don’t know that they’ll ever clean up all the environmental horrors communism bestowed on Russia, China and eastern Europe. In the third world, some places are “dumping grounds” for waste.

But in the “first world” a great deal has been done and is ongoing.

I do have a problem, however, with attributing adverse effects speculatively and magnifying them. years ago, some speculated that virtually all cancers were caused by sodium nitrite in food or Red Dye #2. All of that speculation faded. I remember the dioxin scares of decades ago; how the government evacuated Times Beach, Missouri because of dioxin, only to realize years later that it wasn’t a threat at all and converted the place into a public park.
 
Smoking remains the largest cause of preventable death, killing nearly half-million people in the U.S. annually. Left untreated, an estimated 60% of smokers will die of tobacco-caused diseases such as lung cancer and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease.

In 2009 the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit upheld U.S. District Judge Gladys Kessler’s ruling in a Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations, or RICO, case, which found the tobacco industry guilty of engaging in a decades-long conspiracy to defraud the American public about the health risks of tobacco.

And yet Participants in the industry argue that commercial tobacco production is a vital part of the American and world economy. They state that thousands of farmers in the United States, alone, make their living from raising tobacco leaves for use by the industry. They cite the fact that the tobacco industry contributes billions of dollars in tax revenue to the state and federal government every year.

So what is more improtant, the economic contribution of the tobacco industry or health?

In June 2009, U.S. President Barack Obama signed into law the Family Smoking Prevention and Tobacco Control Act which has been called a “sweeping anti-smoking” bill. Amongst other restrictions, this Act banned the use of any constituent, additive, herb or spice that adds a “characterizing flavor” to the tobacco product or smoke. The aim of this ban is to prevent children and teenagers from becoming addicted to cigarettes at a young age with the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services citing that “studies have shown that 17 year old smokers are three times as likely to use flavored cigarettes as are smokers over the age of 2”. This ban however does not apply to menthol cigarettes, which are exempt from the bill.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tobacco_industry

Is this governmental action appropriate?
 
Smoking remains the largest cause of preventable death, killing nearly half-million people in the U.S. annually. Left untreated, an estimated 60% of smokers will die of tobacco-caused diseases such as lung cancer and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease.

In 2009 the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit upheld U.S. District Judge Gladys Kessler’s ruling in a Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations, or RICO, case, which found the tobacco industry guilty of engaging in a decades-long conspiracy to defraud the American public about the health risks of tobacco.

And yet Participants in the industry argue that commercial tobacco production is a vital part of the American and world economy. They state that thousands of farmers in the United States, alone, make their living from raising tobacco leaves for use by the industry. They cite the fact that the tobacco industry contributes billions of dollars in tax revenue to the state and federal government every year.

So what is more improtant, the economic contribution of the tobacco industry or health?

In June 2009, U.S. President Barack Obama signed into law the Family Smoking Prevention and Tobacco Control Act which has been called a “sweeping anti-smoking” bill. Amongst other restrictions, this Act banned the use of any constituent, additive, herb or spice that adds a “characterizing flavor” to the tobacco product or smoke. The aim of this ban is to prevent children and teenagers from becoming addicted to cigarettes at a young age with the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services citing that “studies have shown that 17 year old smokers are three times as likely to use flavored cigarettes as are smokers over the age of 2”. This ban however does not apply to menthol cigarettes, which are exempt from the bill.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tobacco_industry

Is this governmental action appropriate?
Not related to the topic at all, but here’s my response anyway:

I couldn’t say, because I don’t know:
a. How many children and teenagers started smoking because of additives.
b. How many children and teenagers did not start smoking because of this law.

Parenthetically, one would expect teenagers aged 17 or over to be three times more likely to smoke flavored cigarettes than most others “over the age of two”. Also, I would expect them to be much more likely to drive, to be juniors or seniors in high school, to have had sex, to have drunk alcohol, to have taken the SAT, to have looked at colleges, to have played high school sports, and a number of other things.
 
Substitute oil & coal for tobbaco industry.
Why not substitute cotton candy, or perhaps high-heeled shoes? It would make as much sense.

This is just silly. Everybody always knew the potential harms of tobacco, and everybody always knew you could live without it. Everybody knew U.S. Grant died of throat cancer, and everybody knew why.

Everybody knows there are hazards with oil and coal use, just as there are hazards with the heavy metals used in electric cars and the manufacturing processes for wind turbines and the toxic materials used in solar panels.

The difference is that we really can’t live without heat, refrigeration, transportation, the manufacture of goods, the production of food and all the things for which we use energy. We also know fossil fuels are presently the least expensive and most efficient ways to generate energy. We know from our own experience and that of Europe that solar, wind and so on, can’t presently do the job.

And MMGW, the big scare people like to associate with fossil fuels, is not proven. Who, after all, were the big-spenders in the tobacco debate? (which nobody really believed anyway) ? The tobacco industry. Who are the big spenders in the MMGW controversy? Those who are invested in “alternative energy” politically or financially.

The analogy utterly fails.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top