Predestination/Calvinism

  • Thread starter Thread starter Cruxis117
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Appears so,

Must be wonderful to be that chosen one above all other Christians, what humility. Whats the criteria for that anyway?
 
And how does a Calvinist know that he is saved? He DOES NOT KNOW THAT. A Calvinist is as likely to be damned as others.

Yes. This is the most peculiar aspect of the entire doctrine of Calvinist predestination.

There* is* no assurance of salvation.

Salvation lies simply on the whims of a sovereign god who damns and saves whom he pleases.

This is a paradigm created in the depths of hell, IMHO.
 
Please re-read the bolded part.

I think you cannot really talk your way out this.

Clearly, Paul believes that we all participate in the afflictions of Christ.

Your pastor has never preached on this verse then?
Yes absolutely that was even part of today’s sermon. Being a Christian involves a cost. In our suffering and affliction we glorify Jesus. Psalm 34:19 Many are the afflictions of the just; but out of them all will the Lord deliver them. Christ said the world will revile us for His sake but the world is not worthy to receive.
 
That’s not what I asked. We ALL know what happened to them.
I asked you - did they go to hell?

Please answer the question.
I believe yes because of Abrahams conversation previously with God reveald. God was going to judge them for their sins. Then Abraham bargains with the Lord that the righteous would be destroyed along with the wicked. God delivered Lot and his daughters then destroying in judgement Sodom and Gomorrah. Gen 19
 
we may be arguing symantics here. show me in the CCC where the Catholicism does not guarantee eternal life for infants. the teaching of limbo, is not a belief we are bound to. it is not dogma. is this what you are refering to? if you are telling me that God would send an infant to hell, then what kind of God do the Calvinist worship? it goes against all reason, and also states God is not a Just God. Peace 😦
But the place is limbo and not heaven they do not receive the full love of God because it’s a lesser place. Scripture leaves only two places as a final destination. Scripture does not answer the question. I would like to see all conceived people go to heaven. Because God is just all people will be judged for sin.
 
with all due respect my friend. this is another problem i have with protestantism in general. they do not take the bible as a whole, they only pick and choose which verses support their claims at the expense of the rest. no protestant denomination has the whole picture. do you think that Calvinism is superior to Lutheranism? is it superior to Weslian theology? if so, why? all these reformers are looking at the same text, but can come to no agreement. why? can you see why someone would have a problem with this? Peace
My goal is to take the bible as a whole. I have not studied calvinism but know what I have read in scripture aligns with its tenents. I don’t like the label but it’s the one everyone is familiar with. I have not studied specific denominatins only the bible.
 
Yes absolutely that was even part of today’s sermon. Being a Christian involves a cost. In our suffering and affliction we glorify Jesus. Psalm 34:19 Many are the afflictions of the just; but out of them all will the Lord deliver them. Christ said the world will revile us for His sake but the world is not worthy to receive.
Right. So we make up what is lacking in Christ’s afflictions. Exactly what I said, and to which you objected.
 
We are all created sinners?

So if God created us sinners, then we are sinners not because of our own fault but because God made us sinners.** If that is so, then you are in effect saying that God is unjust because He is sending us to hell for being something which is not our own fault.

**Your statement says that murderers are not murderers by their own fault but because God made them murderers. And that applies to every single sin.
Original sin from Adam.
 
Original sin from Adam.
Original sin is the loss of sanctifying grace that was originally intended to be our natural right.

Original sin is not something we confess. It is not something we did. It is, analogously, a defect in our spiritual DNA.
 
Then why doesn’t He considering He created them all?
Maybe the same reason He created people He knows who will not accept Him and go to hell and be tormented for eternity.
So therefore you are saying that God is unjust. After all He knew that these children will be born through no will or their own, and that they will be born in a state of sin through no will of their own.

I mean if he is a really loving god, would it not be a more loving thing to do not to allow them to be conceived than to allow them to be conceive knowing that they, according to his will, will be damned forever?

Just as He knows there will be people He created who will reject Him and be in hell for eternity. By your thoughts God is unable to really save anyone. He must just sit back and hope someone will be worthy of the salvation He has provided.
benedictus2;7398597:
But Jericho, you always fall into this error. You keep citing passages that do not support your thesis.

All this says is that the baby was killed. Did the Bible also say that this baby was damned and is now in hell?
The point was someone else by their sin caused the death baby. The baby had no freewill in that matter. It was not about his eternal destination.
Yes it does, and so does Grace. Where sin abounds according to St Paul, grace abounds even more.
Exactly Amen!
 
Jericho:
Why did God pick you and not your non-elect neighbor? If God takes nothing about the man into account, what logically distinguishes you from your neighbor? Look at it this way - you have two idenical lumps of clay in front of you - you want to make a lovely pot and a common pot - how do you choose which lump for which purpose?
Romans 9:20-21 But who are you, O man, to talk back to God? “Shall what is formed say to him who formed it, ‘Why did you make me like this?’”h 21Does not the potter have the right to make out of the same lump of clay some pottery for noble purposes and some for common use?

You will have to ask God.
 
Nope. Does not sound like Calvinism at all.

Sounds like good Catholic Doctrine. We affirm God’s mercy. You don’t. You only pay it lip service and then proceed to show a blood thirsty god intent casting his creation to the furnace.

In good sound Catholic doctrine, salvation is indeed God’s choice but God chooses to save all. But the way he does it is by offering salvation not coercing them to be saved nor forcing them to be damned. Precisely because God is merciful, just and loving. 🙂
God’s grace and mercy is not related to who we are but to who He is.
 
Right. So we make up what is lacking in Christ’s afflictions. Exactly what I said, and to which you objected.
No! It’s what is lacking in us compared to Christ’s afflictions. So Christ’s finished work on the cross was not suffecient.
 
No! It’s what is lacking in us compared to Christ’s afflictions. So Christ’s finished work on the cross was not suffecient.
Not at all, jericho. Christ’s finished work on the cross paid our debt.

However, I was simply quoting St. Paul, that our sufferings make up what is lacking in Christ’s afflictions.

You objected to that which is clearly in Scripture.
 
Original sin is the loss of sanctifying grace that was originally intended to be our natural right.

Original sin is not something we confess. It is not something we did. It is, analogously, a defect in our spiritual DNA.
Wow we agree on something! 😃
 
Not at all, jericho. Christ’s finished work on the cross paid our debt.

However, I was simply quoting St. Paul, that our sufferings make up what is lacking in Christ’s afflictions.

You objected to that which is clearly in Scripture.
What is lacking in Christ’s afflictions?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top