Priest can not stand me

  • Thread starter Thread starter pat_mc_1
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Maybe it is simply that he doesn’t want any volunteer to feel like they “own” their ministry - he needs them to realize that he is in charge; not them. If you were ever telling him what to do instead of waiting for him to tell you what to do, this could be the source of his reaction.
I never over stepped that boundary thats not my job.
 
He doesn’t have a problem with any of the women sacristans or female servers just me who is the only male server/ sacristan.
Well, could be he associates females as being more akin to the sisters (and there was the Altar Society too) of old who didn’t serve Mass but certainly were sacristans and did a whole lot more than just that, but thinks of a male in the same role as being just a bit close to usurping the role of a priest. “Back in the day”, grown men were the volunteer carpenters, mowers, electricians, donors and plasterers. Kind of sounds to me like you took him to task over some liturgical practice and some priests absolutely won’t put up with that. To tell the truth, I don’t think most would. But okay, you were used to a different way.

All I know is I have seen it before, and it was very clear to me what the deal was when I saw it. Saw it more than once, in fact. Priests come and go, and they vary a great deal in what they will have people do or not do.

For the time being, my friend, you have become “disinvolved” in that parish from your former role. You can learn to live with it or find a parish where the pastor is different. Or, indeed, you can find some Catholic charity or other institution where you can serve in some other capacity. I’m not trying to be unkind, but it’s just one of those things that happen. Yes, Vatican II did encourage lay involvement in the Church, but different people interpret that in different ways, and so do different priests.

I know of a parish in which, for instance, the priest puts up with cantors and readers, but won’t allow them to sit in the sanctuary, which many priests will. Not even for a second. They have to jump up and down in and out of the pews and go up at every hymn and reading and immediately leave when it’s done. It’s just that priest’s way. He won’t have laypeople remaining in the sanctuary beyond the exercise of their immediate function. I suppose if a music director or reader had grown accustomed to sitting up in the sanctuary, which is the case in a lot of parishes, and were told by a new priest that they had to go sit in the pews between functions, they would get offended. That priest will allow servers, even girl servers, but he won’t have an adult server, period. I know of one priest who won’t have Eucharistic Ministers at all, no matter what.

They’re just different in their ways, that’s all, and, at least for myself, I have to accept that.
 
Christmas was a Turing point he was very rude towards me and told me I needed to be straighten out because I questioned him on how he likes to process in and out of church.
I never over stepped that boundary thats not my job.
You have contradicted yourself here.

What exactly did the priest do that you questioned him, and how did you do it?
 
You have contradicted yourself here.

What exactly did the priest do that you questioned him, and how did you do it?
Yes, and did you actually question him in the first place?

I know priests can be jerks, even to their own demise. I served in several committees in the parish and knew a great deal of what was going on. Our last pastor (thank God not the current one) actually banned me from parish property except to pick up or drop off kids at school, or to come play music for Mass. He did this because I was slightly manic and tried to explain to him some problems we objectively had within the parish leadership, and I objectively knew about because the previous pastor paid for me to take training in it and come back and help him straighten it out – until he got very sick and had to retire suddenly.

A few years later we are now reaping the rewards of his refusal to listen, as the finances of the school have gotten so bad that the recovery is going to involve drastic measures I’m not even supposed to know about but I do. This pastor has inherited a mess; luckily he is very supportive of me and takes what I say very seriously because he knows I don’t go around spreading rumors or making things up, and that I am a very good observer of human behavior – especially parish leadership-related human behavior.

Alan
 
Yes, and did you actually question him in the first place?

I know priests can be jerks, even to their own demise. I served in several committees in the parish and knew a great deal of what was going on. Our last pastor (thank God not the current one) actually banned me from parish property except to pick up or drop off kids at school, or to come play music for Mass. He did this because I was slightly manic and tried to explain to him some problems we objectively had within the parish leadership, and I objectively knew about because the previous pastor paid for me to take training in it and come back and help him straighten it out – until he got very sick and had to retire suddenly.

A few years later we are now reaping the rewards of his refusal to listen, as the finances of the school have gotten so bad that the recovery is going to involve drastic measures I’m not even supposed to know about but I do. This pastor has inherited a mess; luckily he is very supportive of me and takes what I say very seriously because he knows I don’t go around spreading rumors or making things up, and that I am a very good observer of human behavior – especially parish leadership-related human behavior.

Alan
I asked him why does he need a server to walk next to him in procession in mass. He told me he doesn’t like to look like a bunch of ducks, I said I like order and he smirked and said I need to be straightened out. The whole thing was very rude and uncalled for. He ignored the rest of the time. So I left all the sacristy after mass with a mess for him to clean up since he doesn’t need my help any more.
 
I asked him why does he need a server to walk next to him in procession in mass. He told me he doesn’t like to look like a bunch of ducks.
This should have been the end of the conversation; the proper response would be to say, OH, I see.

He is the priest; do it his way.
I said I like order
You’re not in charge; what you like is irrelevant. Sorry to be so blunt; this is a fact of life. “I must decrease; he must increase.” He is the priest; you are not - you don’t get to have an opinion.
The whole thing was very rude and uncalled for. He ignored the rest of the time. So I left all the sacristy after mass with a mess for him to clean up since he doesn’t need my help any more.
Could be why he doesn’t like you any more.
 
Our new parish priest can not stand me. He has even gone as far as taking me off the parish schedule for serving.

He leaves the sacristy when I enter ignores me at the sign of peace and gives rude statements to me.

I haven’t done anything to this man and this is how Im treated.

What should I do? Change parishes? Confront him? Tell him off? What?
Im really annoyed with his behavior. :mad:
You sound like you might be a traditionalist. If so get used to it. That’s how most priests treat us. 😃
 
I asked him why does he need a server to walk next to him in procession in mass. He told me he doesn’t like to look like a bunch of ducks, I said I like order and he smirked and said I need to be straightened out. The whole thing was very rude and uncalled for. He ignored the rest of the time. So I left all the sacristy after mass with a mess for him to clean up since he doesn’t need my help any more.
In just a quick reading, the only thing I found in the GIRM in regards to the procession is this.
The Entrance
  1. When the people are gathered, and as the Priest enters with the Deacon and ministers, the Entrance Chant begins. Its purpose is to open the celebration, foster the unity of those who have been gathered, introduce their thoughts to the mystery of the liturgical time or festivity, and accompany the procession of the Priest and ministers.
  1. This chant is sung alternately by the choir and the people or similarly by a cantor and the people, or entirely by the people, or by the choir alone. In the Dioceses of the United States of America, there are four options for the Entrance Chant: (1) the antiphon from the Missal or the antiphon with its Psalm from the Graduale Romanum, as set to music there or in another setting; (2) the antiphon and Psalm of the Graduale Simplex for the liturgical time; (3) a chant from another collection of Psalms and antiphons, approved by the Conference of Bishops or the Diocesan Bishop, including Psalms arranged in responsorial or metrical forms; (4) another liturgical chant that is suited to the sacred action, the day, or the time of year, similarly approved by the Conference of Bishops or the Diocesan Bishop.
If there is no singing at the Entrance, the antiphon given in the Missal is recited either by the faithful, or by some of them, or by a reader; otherwise, it is recited by the Priest himself, who may even adapt it as an introductory explanation (cf. no. 31).
As jmcrae stated so eloquently, it is the priest’s call, not yours.

And @ Tradycja- for me, “traditional” has nothing to do with it, it sounds like
arrogance , pure & simple. 😦
 
I have asked around the parish and they are all noticing how he treats me. Its really weird.
You can be quite sure someone (there’s always one) will have reported this back to him, and he may well think you are gossiping about him. If you had kept this all to yourself you might have had a chance of meeting with him and resolving your differences. If he thinks you are talking about him behind his back (which I am sure you did not intend) this will make it all the more difficult.

Hold off on the letter for now, sleep on it and look at your letter again in the morning.
 
This should have been the end of the conversation; the proper response would be to say, OH, I see.

He is the priest; do it his way.

You’re not in charge; what you like is irrelevant. Sorry to be so blunt; this is a fact of life. “I must decrease; he must increase.” He is the priest; you are not - you don’t get to have an opinion.

Could be why he doesn’t like you any more.
First off these were my last words to the men. His attitude came before I questioned him. He has no respect for the sanctuary he was lucky I didn’t say something about that. I’ll give him a reason to not like me tomorrow. 😃
 
You can be quite sure someone (there’s always one) will have reported this back to him, and he may well think you are gossiping about him. If you had kept this all to yourself you might have had a chance of meeting with him and resolving your differences. If he thinks you are talking about him behind his back (which I am sure you did not intend) this will make it all the more difficult.

Hold off on the letter for now, sleep on it and look at your letter again in the morning.
Nope I just started asking after Christmas I haven’t seen him since Christmas Mass.
 
You sound like you might be a traditionalist. If so get used to it. That’s how most priests treat us. 😃
I consider myself a traditionalist when it comes to the liturgy. I demand respect for the blessed sacrament when it comes to the servers. It was my job, he could careless. He doesn’t even genuflect to the tabernacle.
 
This whole thing just doesn’t sound right to me at all. I simply cannot imagine two grown men conversing the way the OP has spelled it out here. Sorry, but I am pretty sure we’re not getting the whole story here.
 
WOW, just WOW!! :eek:
And you wonder why the man doesn’t like you?! 🤷

How do you know he “could care less”?
How do you know he doesn’t have bad knees, so he can’t genuflect?

Your lack of respect for the clergy is just shameful! :mad:
I consider myself a traditionalist when it comes to the liturgy. I demand respect for the blessed sacrament when it comes to the servers. It was my job, he could careless. He doesn’t even genuflect to the tabernacle.
 
👍 Exactly my thought also!
This whole thing just doesn’t sound right to me at all. I simply cannot imagine two grown men conversing the way the OP has spelled it out here. Sorry, but I am pretty sure we’re not getting the whole story here.
 
First off these were my last words to the men. His attitude came before I questioned him. He has no respect for the sanctuary he was lucky I didn’t say something about that. I’ll give him a reason to not like me tomorrow. 😃
You could all of a sudden “shape up” and be absolutely perfect when in his presence, to the best of your ability to guess what perfect might be in his eyes – or least imperfect, anyway. Do not give him any tangible reason to suspect you haven’t “gotten the message.” This will buy you some time until you can analyze this guy further.

I’ve always heard we should pray for priests, because they will have to answer to a higher standard than the rest of us. IMO priests displaying anger and resentment in such a way that a good number of people notice it, is a problem in and of itself, without regard to you at all.

A very angry priest (many people in the diocese considered him very mean but the bishop liked his writing so after this he got promoted to monsignor) was actually the trigger of my 10 year psychotic episode starting June 8, 2001, which caused me to be involuntarily hospitalized after he scared the life out of me by screaming at me in the cathedral, right in front of the Blessed Sacrament, and I lost a 20 year engineering career and raised my six kids I already had, in poverty. That’s what one angry outburst from a priest can do to someone’s life.

What does our Lord say about anger?

Matt 5:21-22
“You have heard that it was said to your ancestors, ‘You shall not kill; and whoever kills will be liable to judgment.’ But I say to you, whoever is angry with his brother will be liable to judgment, and whoever says to his brother, ‘Raqa,’ will be answerable to the Sanhedrin, and whoever says, ‘You fool,’ will be liable to fiery Gehenna.

So IMO any priest who knowingly and intentionally displays anger and/or belittles people, needs our prayers, Big Time.

Alan
 
This whole thing just doesn’t sound right to me at all. I simply cannot imagine two grown men conversing the way the OP has spelled it out here. Sorry, but I am pretty sure we’re not getting the whole story here.
If you have ever met a mean priest, you wouldn’t have any problem believing the OP. I’ve met several varieties.

Alan
 
This whole thing just doesn’t sound right to me at all. I simply cannot imagine two grown men conversing the way the OP has spelled it out here. Sorry, but I am pretty sure we’re not getting the whole story here.
There is something missing and I would love to know it. There is a family that cant stand me. It might be them whispering in the priest ear.
 
I have met my fair share of “mean” priests also.
However, we do not have both sides of this story.

I lived in an invalid marriage for over 20 years because of the actions of a “mean” priest. When I returned to the Church, and started looking into having my marriage validated, I was very concerned about “bad mouthing” said priest because he had since died, and could not defend himself. I felt that it would be unkind to accuse a man of things if he could not defend himself, “mean” or not.
Fortunately, this particular priest’s actions were well known in the Bishop’s office, as he had done similar things to many other people in his time, and in the end, that history helped in getting my marriage validated through “radical sanation”.

IMHO, the is no excuse for the type of venom the OP is spewing against a priest who is not here to defend himself. :mad:
The priest is a servant of God, and deserves some respect.
If you have ever met a mean priest, you wouldn’t have any problem believing the OP. I’ve met several varieties.

Alan
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top