"Pro-Choice" Americans at Record-Low 41%

  • Thread starter Thread starter Stylteralmaldo
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
S

Stylteralmaldo

Guest
…
Bottom Line
Since 2009, Americans have been closely divided in their identification with the labels most commonly used by each side of the abortion debate, although twice in that time period, including today, the percentage identifying as pro-life has been significantly higher than the pro-choice percentage. This represents a clear shift from 2001 to 2008, when Gallup most often found pro-choice adherents in the plurality.
Abortion has been the focal point of some prominent news stories in the past year, including congressional efforts to eliminate federal funding for Planned Parenthood because of its abortion services, as well as to investigate Planned Parenthood’s financial practices. There was also a widely reported controversy over the Susan G. Komen for the Cure cancer foundation’s temporary decision to suspend grants to Planned Parenthood pending the outcome of that congressional investigation. And the ongoing conflict between the U.S. Roman Catholic Church and the Obama administration over mandated health insurance for contraception is partially related to abortion, in that some contraception methods, such as the “morning-after pill,” can halt the development of a fertilized egg.
Whether any of these controversies is related to the shift in Americans’ identification as pro-choice or pro-life is not clear. However, it is notable that while Americans’ labeling of their position has changed, their fundamental views on the issue have not. If the advantage for the “pro-life” position persists in future Gallup updates on abortion, these would seem to be important factors to look at to help explain the shift in labeling.
Upcoming Gallup reports will explore Americans’ 2012 views on abortion in greater depth, including looking at trends by gender, age, and other demographic variables.

Read more:
gallup.com/poll/154838/Pro-Choice-Americans-Record-Low.aspx
 
I atrribute this to the internet and the ability of information and the truth to get out.
 
The problem with Gallup’s handling of this issue is that it doesn’t define the labels “pro-choice” or “pro-life.” Each respondent uses their own understanding of the terms, so the definition which one person considers “pro-life” (e.g. abortion should be allowed in the case of rape or to save the mother’s life) may not be what someone else considers “pro-life,” (e.g. no abortion, ever)

This is important to note, because as the Gallup Poll also shows is that Americans haven’t shifted in their attitudes towards abortion.
"Gallup poll cited in first post:
Gallup’s longest-running measure of abortion views, established in 1975, asks Americans if abortion should be legal in all circumstances, legal only under certain circumstances, or illegal in all circumstances. Since 2001, at least half of Americans have consistently chosen the middle position, saying abortion should be legal under certain circumstances, and the 52% saying this today is similar to the 50% in May 2011. The 25% currently wanting abortion to be legal in all cases and the 20% in favor of making it illegal in all cases are also similar to last year’s findings.
I atrribute this to the internet and the ability of information and the truth to get out.
Maybe, although given that attitudes haven’t changed, it just may be that the news coverage simply makes people more comfortable saying they are pro-life.

As the first post notes, whether the change in identification from pro-choice to pro-life will eventually lead to changes in attitudes towards abortion remains to be seen.
 
The problem with Gallup’s handling of this issue is that it doesn’t define the labels “pro-choice” or “pro-life.” Each respondent uses their own understanding of the terms, so the definition which one person considers “pro-life” (e.g. abortion should be allowed in the case of rape or to save the mother’s life) may not be what someone else considers “pro-life,” (e.g. no abortion, ever)

This is important to note, because as the Gallup Poll also shows is that Americans haven’t shifted in their attitudes towards abortion.

Maybe, although given that attitudes haven’t changed, it just may be that the news coverage simply makes people more comfortable saying they are pro-life.

As the first post notes, whether the change in identification from pro-choice to pro-life will eventually lead to changes in attitudes towards abortion remains to be seen.
Previous Gallup poll shows majority of pro choice Americans would support abortion in certain cases. But most pro choice people do not support unrestricted abortion access, they support abortion restrictions like many pro life people do as seen in a previous Gallup poll:

http://sas-origin.onstreammedia.com...roduction/Cms/POLL/jq5vy9_nyuwb5gsru9hm_w.gif

http://sas-origin.onstreammedia.com...roduction/Cms/POLL/paubysrml0c5dgntn_tdxg.gif

There is a big gap between the attitudes to abortion from millennials who are more pro life and those who are older.

Attitudes towards abortion have shifted. As Gallup has said from 2011:
“Americans are rather conservative in their stance on abortion, with 61% now preferring that abortion be legal in only a few circumstances or no circumstances. By contrast, 37% want abortion legal in all or most circumstances,” Gallup analyst Lydia Saad writes. “Over the past two decades, Americans have consistently leaned toward believing abortion should be legal in only a few or no circumstances, although less so in the mid-1990s than since about 1997, when combined support for these has averaged close to 60%.”
 
Attitudes towards abortion have shifted.
Hmm? What you quoted says that attitudes towards abortion have been stable for the past two decades.
“Over the past two decades, Americans have consistently leaned toward believing abortion should be legal in only a few or no circumstances, although less so in the mid-1990s than since about 1997, when combined support for these has averaged close to 60%.”
Here is the graph

(click to make bigger)
 
Hmm? What you quoted says that attitudes towards abortion have been stable for the past two decades.

Here is the graph

(click to make bigger)
Millenials are certainly more pro life now than in decades previous.

Gallup said in a poll from 2009 that more Americans are pro life than pro choice than when Gallup first started asking the question in 1995. Attitudes have changed:

gallup.com/poll/118399/more-americans-pro-life-than-pro-choice-first-time.aspx

Gallup are confused.
 
Millenials are certainly more pro life now than in decades previous.
I think that would be a noteworthy development, and I would be interested in reading about it. However, I don’t think any of your links have mentioned age differences.

And, again, I would caution that the Gallup polls which have been cited indicate that even though more people call themselves pro-life, their actual attitudes regarding abortion haven’t changed. This seems to indicate that in recent years the label “pro-life” has become more fashionable, and the label “pro-choice” less fashionable. Whether the people who are now calling themselves pro-fife will change their attitudes regarding the permissibility of abortion remains to be seen.
 
A new Gallup poll finds support for legal abortion at its lowest ebb in America since 2000. Only 41% of Americans call themselves “pro-choice,” Gallup reports. That figure represents a …

More…
 
I think that would be a noteworthy development, and I would be interested in reading about it. However, I don’t think any of your links have mentioned age differences.

And, again, I would caution that the Gallup polls which have been cited indicate that even though more people call themselves pro-life, their actual attitudes regarding abortion haven’t changed. This seems to indicate that in recent years the label “pro-life” has become more fashionable, and the label “pro-choice” less fashionable. Whether the people who are now calling themselves pro-fife will change their attitudes regarding the permissibility of abortion remains to be seen.
It might not be that it is fashionable or less fashionable, but that genuinely more Americans do feel unrestricted abortion access is wrong and believe it needs to be limited to certain circumstances.

Knights of Columbus - Marsist poll found 58% of millennials believe abortion is ‘morally wrong,’ 74% favor at least some legal restrictions on abortion. Millenials are most likely to believe abortion should be illegal in all circumstances of any age group.

Poll by NPR asked, ‘do you personally believe having an abortion is wrong?’ 59.3% said yes, 40.7% said no. Under 35s had the most pro life responses with 65.5% saying abortion is wrong:

npr.org/blogs/health/2011/06/07/136857132/questions-about-legality-and-morality-of-abortion-divide-americans

factsforhealthcare.com/pressroom/NPR_report_Abortion.pdf
 
The only question that should be asked is if you think it’s murder. The rest is rationalization. And on that point, at least half do not believe it is murder. Then there’s the nonsense thinking that says it is murder but must be allowed in rape or incest.
 
IMillenials are most likely to believe abortion should be illegal in all circumstances of any age group. ]
Okay, thank you for the link to the 2010 Gallup poll. Here is the graph which supports that statement. It shows a pronounced increase in the portion of Millenials who oppose abortion in all circumstances: from 15% to 23% during the past 20 years.

(click picture to make larger)
 
The only question that should be asked is if you think it’s murder. The rest is rationalization. And on that point, at least half do not believe it is murder. Then there’s the nonsense thinking that says it is murder but must be allowed in rape or incest.
Oh, its more than half who don’t think its murder. Or if they do, they are inconsistent in their beliefs. Only 20% of Americans think abortion should be illegal in all circumstances.

One of the interesting finds in these polls is that even though the majority of Americans think abortion is immoral, a much lower percentage actually want to ban it.
 
Okay, thank you for the link to the 2010 Gallup poll. Here is the graph which supports that statement. It shows a pronounced rise in the portion of Millenials who oppose abortion in all circumstances.

(click picture to make larger)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top