Pro choice catholics

  • Thread starter Thread starter blaskoman
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
B

blaskoman

Guest
I know many non-practicing catholics who believe in pro-choice with regard to the abortion issue. Do these catholics automatically excommunicate themselves from the catholic church by simply believing in a woman’s right to procure an abortion? Can someone of these beliefs be allowed to receive the Eucharist, even though they have never actually gotten an abortion (but only are pro-choice–anti-life, the real term)… thx.
 
:confused:

How can one excommunicate themself?

It seems to me that all one can do is leave the Church.Only the priest can excommunicate a member. So if they leave on their own accord then they can return at any time.
 
I heard or read somewhere that a catholic who procures an abortion automatically excommunicates themselves. So, I thought that by virtue of sharing in such a belief system (pro-choice), a pro-choice catholic would be 180 degrees away from catholic teaching. Abortion in plain and simple terms is murder. How could a catholic believe in murder and continue to be a faithful believer in Christ?
 
Note that the excommunication is automatic for successfully procuring an abortion. Just how much participation in procuring the abortion results in excommunication is subject to some debate, however it would be considerably more than just advocating abortion, which nevertheless is a mortal sin.
Can. 1398 A person who procures a completed abortion incurs a latae sententiae excommunication.
latae sententiae means automatic without further action by Church authorities.
 
Note that the excommunication is automatic for successfully procuring an abortion. Just how much participation in procuring the abortion results in excommunication is subject to some debate, however it would be considerably more than just advocating abortion, which nevertheless is a mortal sin.

latae sententiae means automatic without further action by Church authorities.
Is there anything that states how one can then get “un-excommunicated” i.e. what is the process for getting back into the church?
 
Is there anything that states how one can then get “un-excommunicated” i.e. what is the process for getting back into the church?
If a woman has an abortion she is automatically excommunicated. If she repents all she needs to do is to go to Confession and get absolution.
 
I am glad that these individuals you know are non-practicing in light of their beliefs. I am sad that they are still being identified as Catholic. I am not sure what a “non-practicing Catholic” is, since ours is a religion, not an ethnicity. Acceptance of a religion involves conforming to the teachings of the faith. The Catholic Church condemns abortion.
 
If a woman has an abortion she is automatically excommunicated. If she repents all she needs to do is to go to Confession and get absolution.
Do you have a reference for this?

It doesn’t seem like it would/should be that “easy”. Let’s say someone murders another. They’re not excommunicated, or are they? I’ve never heard not. Yet, “all” they have to do is seek and receive confession and absolution; they are never excommunicated. The woman who has an aboriton gets excommunicated, but has the same route of restoration back into the church?

Seems like there should be more to it. 🤷
 
Do you have a reference for this?

It doesn’t seem like it would/should be that “easy”. Let’s say someone murders another. They’re not excommunicated, or are they? I’ve never heard not. Yet, “all” they have to do is seek and receive confession and absolution; they are never excommunicated. The woman who has an aboriton gets excommunicated, but has the same route of restoration back into the church?

Seems like there should be more to it. 🤷
Well, Christ died for all of our sins. The debt has already been paid.

We have seven sacraments. The Sacrament of Reconciliation applies here.

Now, if one has an abortion, with the intent that later they will “just confess it”, then that is a whole together different issue.

The priest must judge, as he always does, the seriousness of the sin and the regret/attitude of the penitent.
 
Well, Christ died for all of our sins. The debt has already been paid.

We have seven sacraments. The Sacrament of Reconciliation applies here.

Now, if one has an abortion, with the intent that later they will “just confess it”, then that is a whole together different issue.

The priest must judge, as he always does, the seriousness of the sin and the regret/attitude of the penitent.
Yes, of course, as far as the sacrament is concerned. What I was addressing is the excommunication issue. If a woman is automatically excommunicated for procuring an abortion, is she automatically re-communicated after reconciliation and where is this documented?
 
If a woman has an abortion she is automatically excommunicated. If she repents all she needs to do is to go to Confession and get absolution.
Do you have a reference for this?

It doesn’t seem like it would/should be that “easy”. Let’s say someone murders another. They’re not excommunicated, or are they? I’ve never heard not. Yet, “all” they have to do is seek and receive confession and absolution; they are never excommunicated. The woman who has an aboriton gets excommunicated, but has the same route of restoration back into the church?

Seems like there should be more to it. 🤷
It was but is not now

*1463
Certain particularly grave sins incur excommunication, the most severe ecclesiastical penalty, which impedes the reception of the sacraments and the exercise of certain ecclesiastical acts, and for which absolution consequently cannot be granted, according to canon law, except by the Pope, the bishop of the place or priests authorized by them.68 In danger of death any priest, even if deprived of faculties for hearing confessions, can absolve from every sin and excommunication.69

68 Cf. CIC, cann. 1331; 1354-1357; CCEO, can. 1431; 1434; 1420.

69 Cf. CIC, can. 976; CCEO, can. 725
.*usccb.org/catechism/text/pt2sect2chpt2.shtml#vi
 
Yes, of course, as far as the sacrament is concerned. What I was addressing is the excommunication issue. If a woman is automatically excommunicated for procuring an abortion, is she automatically re-communicated after reconciliation and where is this documented?
The excommunication must be lifted by her bishop. However, in most/all dioceses the bishop has delegated that power to the priests. Therefore the priest will lift the excommunication at the same time he grants absolution.
 
“Pro-choice Catholic” is an oxymoron as far as I’m concerned.
 
“Pro-choice Catholic” is an oxymoron as far as I’m concerned.
The pro-choice Catholic may believe that abortion is morally wrong but that it is wrong to use the law to limit their ability to kill their unwanted off-spring. Even many bishops, I fear, hase bought into this notion. IAC, many, many Catholics have been taught that it is wrong for Catholics to lobby for stricter abortion law because they feel they don’t have the right to compel others not to have abortions. Except that law is compulsion. Pro-abortion groups do not hesitate to try to obtains laws that compel Catholic hospitals and physicians to do abortions. They define an abortion as simply another medical procedure, like cutting out a tumor.
 
Under canon law, regarding abortion, you can only be excommunicated if you obtain a completed abortion or if you aid someone in procuring a completed abortion (such as by encouraging a person to abort or you perform one) and also meet the other requirements for the imputation of guilt (having reached a certain age and being old enough to understand your actions, having use of reason, not doing an act out of grave fear for one’s safety or life, etc). A woman who had an abortion for example, because her life was threatened if she were not to have one, would not be held responsible.

Someone who is pro-choice may be excommunicated or interdicted by their bishop if they vocally support abortion or abortion rights in a very public manner and in a way that is contrary to the teaching of the church, or they may be refused communion if they support a pro-choice political candidate by their priest, or if they are a pro-choice politician themself. These things have all happened in the U.S., where Catholics belonging to groups like Call to Action were excommunicated or interdicted, and one law professor was refused communion because of his endorsement of Barack Obama (who is pro-choice).

As for Catholics who have left the church, technically speaking they are excommunicated for schism or apostasy rather than the beliefs they adopt on abortion or other matters.

Those who remain and are excommunicated, are probably excommunicated on the ground of heresy. Canon 1371 also provides an unspecified ‘just penalty’ for those who disagree openly with a magesterial teaching.
 
I know many non-practicing catholics who believe in pro-choice with regard to the abortion issue. Do these catholics automatically excommunicate themselves from the catholic church by simply believing in a woman’s right to procure an abortion? Can someone of these beliefs be allowed to receive the Eucharist, even though they have never actually gotten an abortion (but only are pro-choice–anti-life, the real term)… thx.
From the Catechism of the Catholic Church:

2272 Formal cooperation in an abortion constitutes a grave offense. The Church attaches the canonical penalty of excommunication to this crime against human life. "A person who procures a completed abortion incurs excommunication latae sententiae,"76 "by the very commission of the offense,"77 and subject to the conditions provided by Canon Law.78 The Church does not thereby intend to restrict the scope of mercy. Rather, she makes clear the gravity of the crime committed, the irreparable harm done to the innocent who is put to death, as well as to the parents and the whole of society.

2322 From its conception, the child has the right to life. Direct abortion, that is, abortion willed as an end or as a means, is a “criminal” practice (GS 27 # 3), gravely contrary to the moral law. the Church imposes the canonical penalty of excommunication for this crime against human life.
 
…, or they may be refused communion if they support a pro-choice political candidate by their priest, … and one law professor was refused communion because of his endorsement of Barack Obama (who is pro-choice)…
Please document both conditions; it would seem neither would meet the church standards of moral sin.
 
I know many non-practicing catholics who believe in pro-choice with regard to the abortion issue. Do these catholics automatically excommunicate themselves from the catholic church by simply believing in a woman’s right to procure an abortion? Can someone of these beliefs be allowed to receive the Eucharist, even though they have never actually gotten an abortion (but only are pro-choice–anti-life, the real term)… thx.
No, they do not. This is because of what “pro-choice” means between different groups. There are two camps out there with two definitions. If you talk to many who identify as “pro-choice”, they want as few abortions as possible, but have a different approach in how to minimize it. That is consistent with Church teachings. Both sides want the same goal but have two different ways to go about it.
 
No, they do not. This is because of what “pro-choice” means between different groups. There are two camps out there with two definitions. If you talk to many who identify as “pro-choice”, they want as few abortions as possible, but have a different approach in how to minimize it. That is consistent with Church teachings. Both sides want the same goal but have two different ways to go about it.
It is not consistent with Catholic teachings to allow abortions in any circumstance. The group you describe is the lesser evil, but they are certainly not in line with Church teaching.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top