protestant but want confession

  • Thread starter Thread starter Loobyloo0209
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
L

Loobyloo0209

Guest
I have been raised protestant but have a Catholic Partner. I don’t feel like I know enough about Catholicism to convert but when I listen to my partner, I understand and know that he has been sent to me to guide me in my life. I have made several mistakes when I was younger that I have undergone counselling for and I have had many years of spiritual searching, none of which has helped in any way…I’ve only really felt that I’ve been offered acceptance about my actions which for some reason I cannot accept. My question is that I want to be able to go to confession but know that I can’t be accepted by the church as I am not Catholic. Can I at least speak to a Priest?
 
I have been raised protestant but have a Catholic Partner. I don’t feel like I know enough about Catholicism to convert but when I listen to my partner, I understand and know that he has been sent to me to guide me in my life. I have made several mistakes when I was younger that I have undergone counselling for and I have had many years of spiritual searching, none of which has helped in any way…I’ve only really felt that I’ve been offered acceptance about my actions which for some reason I cannot accept. My question is that I want to be able to go to confession but know that I can’t be accepted by the church as I am not Catholic. Can I at least speak to a Priest?
You can always speak to a priest, and most likely he might even be interested in your struggles. He might even act as a ‘confessor’ in the sense that you could confide in him. But just know that, because you are not a Roman Catholic, he could not offer you any kind of absolution.

Have you consider attempting also to contact someone in your own faith community, since you might understand that better? Perhaps a pastor from your own faith might help you too.

God protect you on your faith journey.
 
Thank you, No I haven’t spoken with my own vicar. Mainly as since I have learned that Catholicism is the one true Faith, I don’t understand how this can help. I feel in limbo really. I need to add that whilst I am protestant and do pray…I am not what you would call a devout protestant.
 
Thank you, No I haven’t spoken with my own vicar. Mainly as since I have learned that Catholicism is the one true Faith, I don’t understand how this can help. I feel in limbo really. I need to add that whilst I am protestant and do pray…I am not what you would call a devout protestant.
Why not become Catholic?
 
Thank you, No I haven’t spoken with my own vicar. Mainly as since I have learned that Catholicism is the one true Faith, I don’t understand how this can help. I feel in limbo really. I need to add that whilst I am protestant and do pray…I am not what you would call a devout protestant.
Well, it sounds like a good idea for you to speak to a priest, especially that you have learned that Catholicism contains the fullness of what Our Lord Jesus Christ taught. If you believe that, he can answer any questions you have and perhaps give you some good reading material about the faith.

May Our Lord lead you on your faith journey!
 
If you’re protestant and happen to be Lutheran or Anglican, you can also ask your pastor for a private confession. The practice hasn’t quite disappeared and at least in my church, it’s making a comeback, thanks be to God.
 
Well if you have accepted Catholicism as the one true church, then it sounds like your next step should be to talk to a priest. Find a good, faithful, orthodox one and start talking about being received. Then you can ask him about when is the soonest he will take your confession.
 
I will speak with my Priest…I’ve planned to many times over the last few months but then I start feeling really apprehensive…I don’t know why?? It is from researching RCIA that I stumbled across this site. I suppose the needing for me to confess is down to some of the threads I’ve followed here…for example, those who sin but are ignorant to the fact will be saved but those who become aware of the truth and are no longer ignorant, won’t be! I can’t repent as Protestant, not in the true sense, so what do I do?
 
I have been raised protestant but have a Catholic Partner. I don’t feel like I know enough about Catholicism to convert but when I listen to my partner, I understand and know that he has been sent to me to guide me in my life. I have made several mistakes when I was younger that I have undergone counselling for and I have had many years of spiritual searching, none of which has helped in any way…I’ve only really felt that I’ve been offered acceptance about my actions which for some reason I cannot accept. My question is that I want to be able to go to confession but know that I can’t be accepted by the church as I am not Catholic. Can I at least speak to a Priest?
Hello there, and welcome to CAF! 👋

Yes, you can go and speak to a priest! You cannot partake of the sacrament of confession and reconciliation unless you are a Catholic, but Catholic priests are known for their good counsel in general. So go! And while you are speaking with Father, ask him about the next RCIA classes since you seem to be on your way toward entering the Church! God bless you, you will be in my prayers.

:love:

Don’t worry, it’s the Holy Spirit who is leading you! 🙂
 
If you’re protestant and happen to be Lutheran or Anglican, you can also ask your pastor for a private confession. The practice hasn’t quite disappeared and at least in my church, it’s making a comeback, thanks be to God.
You Wrote exactly what I was going to say… Good work !
 
I have been raised protestant but have a Catholic Partner. I don’t feel like I know enough about Catholicism to convert but when I listen to my partner, I understand and know that he has been sent to me to guide me in my life. I have made several mistakes when I was younger that I have undergone counselling for and I have had many years of spiritual searching, none of which has helped in any way…I’ve only really felt that I’ve been offered acceptance about my actions which for some reason I cannot accept. My question is that I want to be able to go to confession but know that I can’t be accepted by the church as I am not Catholic. Can I at least speak to a Priest?
Since you are asking, and in a Catholic Forum for non-Catholic religions, you predicament will be solved if you are Catholic. 🙂 No, don’t get me wrong and as a Catholic it is natural for me to say that.

The Sacrament of Reconciliation, as a Sacrament is, an outward sign of an inner grace. So the Sacrament exudes grace. Specifically it is a grace of forgiveness. However, what many people do not realize is that this Sacrament is also a healing grace. In the Gospels, when Jesus pronounced forgiveness, healing also came about. So you are on the right track if you view Confession to have a healing effect; not just forgiveness of your sin but actually a restoration, a healing of your guilt.

Yes, certainly you can speak to a priest. If he is not busy enough, he would be glad to speak to you. You can ask for an appointment or through your Catholic partner or short of that, you can strike an informal conversation with him and if necessary with a view of a more personal follow-up. You see, there is no strict rule about this.

As I see it, and you said it, it is the counseling that you probably need at the moment. This, your pastor can do for you. I have seen Protestants doing this and they are good though comparing them with a priest is two different things altogether. Catholics find it more convenient to go to a priest because they can have two things done at one time – counseling and forgiveness through the Sacrament which the Priest can grant them right away. But this of course does not render lay people counselors obsolete; they have useful purpose too, sometimes in areas where they have life experience that priests do not have.

So do go ahead and speak to that priest. And may you be blessed and the hand of the Lord be upon you.🙂
 
One publication that might very well help you at this stage is Catholicism for Dummies. It is an excellent introduction to the faith and explains Catholic beliefs as well as the reasons behind them. It is an excellent, easily read resource that you can peruse at your leisure and rely on for years to come. Highly recommended. Prayers ascending.
 
I have been raised protestant but have a Catholic Partner. I don’t feel like I know enough about Catholicism to convert but when I listen to my partner, I understand and know that he has been sent to me to guide me in my life. I have made several mistakes when I was younger that I have undergone counselling for and I have had many years of spiritual searching, none of which has helped in any way…I’ve only really felt that I’ve been offered acceptance about my actions which for some reason I cannot accept. My question is that I want to be able to go to confession but know that I can’t be accepted by the church as I am not Catholic. Can I at least speak to a Priest?
You can schedule an appointment with a priest and he can talk to you yes. Just know that you are correct in thinking the priest cannot absolve you of your sins so long as you are not a Catholic. Yet, the priest can answer any questions for you.

Why do you not enroll in RCIA just out of curiousity? What holds you back. It sounds like your spirit is yearning for the sacraments, one being the sacrament of penance.
 
Thank you again everybody for your supportive posts. What do I say to the priest though. Am I asking for confession or just to talk? Do I have to address him in a certain way?
 
Thank you again everybody for your supportive posts. What do I say to the priest though. Am I asking for confession or just to talk? Do I have to address him in a certain way?
Well, you can’t ask for confession since you aren’t a Catholic, thought we’d made that clear. “Father, I’d like to talk to you about some things I’m having problems with. Can I make an appointment to speak with you in private?”

And then just talk to him as you would any other person whom you feel you trust. We do address our priests as “Father Joe,” or whatever, but in general conversation you might not even use the term.
 
Thank you again everybody for your supportive posts. What do I say to the priest though. Am I asking for confession or just to talk? Do I have to address him in a certain way?
Priests are spiritual fathers, so we address them as “Father” If you are not comfortable with that, you may also call them reverend, or pastor, if that suits you better. Mention that you feel guilt for sin that you do not think has been dealt with and let him advise you. We can make our confession to God, and an act of contrition can help. One need not be Catholic to participate in that. It is only the actual Sacrament of Penance that one must be fully in the Church to receive. Yet, God forgives whom He will. It is just that Jesus told those whom He forgave that their sins were forgiven, and it is such a comfort to hear those same words, knowing that our sins are gone. Yet, be as patient with God as He has been with you and you will be rewarded both in time and in eternity.
 
Thank you again everybody for your supportive posts. What do I say to the priest though. Am I asking for confession or just to talk? Do I have to address him in a certain way?
No problem at all. You can tell him what you said here and proceed from that. You can ask questions - he will know what to do and advise you accordingly. It will be something along this line, "I am not Catholic but I am keen to have Confesion. I would like your advice … " And start saying what you want to say, be it a disclosure of your sins because he can advise on that. Absolution may not be given since you are not Catholic, but that is a good start.

You can adress him Father. Some Protestants do have obstacle is using this kind of term but let just consider it as mere courtesy. It is like saying mister but a priest is a clergy and in Catholicism, Father is a common term to address him.

My prayer is with you. God bless.
 
It is for the healing that I want to confess…I don’t expect forgiveness just the opportunity to say that I am truly sorry. My guilt will stay with me forever. Incidently, “Catholicism for Dummies” has been my bed time read for the last month. Didn’t ever want to admit that to my partner but as a Protestant, I feared that he might feel that my questions were designed to make him stray.
 
It is for the healing that I want to confess…I don’t expect forgiveness just the opportunity to say that I am truly sorry. My guilt will stay with me forever. Incidently, “Catholicism for Dummies” has been my bed time read for the last month. Didn’t ever want to admit that to my partner but as a Protestant, I feared that he might feel that my questions were designed to make him stray.
Trust in God. Everything is possible with him. He will wipe every tear in our eyes.🙂
 
Thank you all…tonight has been my first conversation since joining. So much direction has been given me already from this brief post. I must say Goodnight now as it is very late in England. 🙂
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top