Protestants: What is the oddest thing about Catholicism?

  • Thread starter Thread starter distracted
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Hi Carjack,

So when do you think that embryo “A Human” recieves his or her SOUL?

Carjack, you are forgeting about the Soul. The soul is given by God at the moment of conception.

So if you have practiced Contraception you have committed an abortion, therefore anyone who uses contraception is guitly of a grave sin.

Yes, many believe what you believe but are Totaly Wrong!

Ufamtobie
I think you are a little off here as most contraception with exception such as the morning after pill impedes conception so conception does not take place.

So no egg and sperm ever unite to form life.

This is not being open to life and possibly impeding God’s will but not abortion.
 
Peace be with you!
The failure of the Episcopal church to follow the will of God particularly in it’s failure to condemn contraception and abortion, has, I think, resulted in the present disarray and near schism that is now occurring in the (particularly American) EC. This coupled with the ordination of women and the acceptance and promotion of homosexuals and lesbians, has robbed the EC of whatever credibility it may have once had. It is, I think, a moribund body. God does not prosper those who flaunt His laws.
 
:blessyou: sedes domi I am sorry I did not mean I read all this wisdom of the fathers during Massl No that it exsisted and the parish I go to has an awesome library that I am free to read all the book all the way back to the very followers of Jesus till today. All the popes wrote is there and not only that be the awesome Catholic web sites that for free you can read the history the very documents of the councils. As a Baptist I knew the Bible was not sure just how it came to be, KIng James fell out of sky one day, there were a few books on Baptist history oh the little red book can’t remeber the name. Now the riches of the faith kept for us all those years,handed down. And anyone can read it. So much riches. A full world the TRUTH to explore, even were the Bible came from. Who knew it was from the Catholics. Sorry didn’t make that clear. It is great to be in THE CHURCH:gopray2:
 
Maybe condoms do not cause abortion and they are a form of birth control. So the fetus/embryo is a “person”, I get it. The condom doesn’t allow sperm and egg to connect, so therefore, it is not causing an abortion.
 
Maybe condoms do not cause abortion and they are a form of birth control. So the fetus/embryo is a “person”, I get it. The condom doesn’t allow sperm and egg to connect, so therefore, it is not causing an abortion.
It prevents a life from being created during what is supposed to be an act that ends in new life being formed.

contra=against

conception=fertilisation

New life is not formed without a fertilised egg, so this is a method of preventing the formation of new life.
 
It prevents a life from being created during what is supposed to be an act that ends in new life being formed.

contra=against

conception=fertilisation

New life is not formed without a fertilised egg, so this is a method of preventing the formation of new life.
It is still not a form of abortion. So everytime a married couple has sexual intercourse, it is only for the purpose of forming a life. That is all the sexual union is for. Not to have intimacy with one another.
 
It is still not a form of abortion. So everytime a married couple has sexual intercourse, it is only for the purpose of forming a life. That is all the sexual union is for. Not to have intimacy with one another.
Intimacy is a secondary use, although admittedly important. God said ‘‘Be fruitful and multiply’’.

He did not command us to ‘‘go forth, have a bit of fun, feel good and if you think you’re ready…really ready…then sure go ahead and spawn some children’’

People who are not ready for children should not be having sex.
 
Maybe condoms do not cause abortion and they are a form of birth control. So the fetus/embryo is a “person”, I get it. The condom doesn’t allow sperm and egg to connect, so therefore, it is not causing an abortion.
no it is not causing abortion of course but you are not open to life and trusting God …so here it has to do with how much you trust God’s Will and Help by being open to life. In other words, trust God and let Him guide your life…it does not mean you’ll end up having tons of children…it means you are open to whatever God wants and if He wants 10, you are open and if He want 2 you are open as well…my friend had been trying for more than a year and it still did not happen. His Will and time, not ours. In other words, complete trust and surrender to divine will and help.
 
Everything is about the embryos and not for the people who were born out of a uterus. Shall i get more specific?
No. I know what you mean. But the CC
s position is that the embryo is as much a person as those that have been born. That’s all I was trying to tell you.

It’s not true that the CC is for the unborn and not for the born, since the teachings are for the good of both.
 
It is a fertilized egg. Not a baby.
I agree that a zygote is not an infant. But those are only words that describe stages human development. The zygote is a living thing, seperate from its mother. It is not part of the mother’s body, and it is a living thing… It has to be a living something. It is a living human. Zygote is merely the word we use to describe a human at that stage of life.

Do you believe that any human being can rightfully, morally be denied personhood?

If you do, what conditions have to exist to legally declare that a human being will not be considered a person?
 
I don’t believe in abortion. So no. A person should not abort their pregnancy.
If it’s not a person in the womb, why do you care if it’s aborted? It’s not a human, according to your reasoning. So what is it you have against abortion?
 
I didn’t know a person sits in amniotic fluid all day and is attached to their mom by a cord. I thought that stopped once the embryo/fetus leaves the womb.
Look in the mirror. You are a person who spent 9 months sitting in amniotic fluid. Of course that was just at the earliest stages of your personhood. After that your wore diapers and had to be carried around. Food had to be brought to you and fed to you, because if it were just left in front of you, you would have starved to death.

If you live long enough, or are unlucky enough to become very ill, you will wear diapers again. Someone will have to feed you. You will need oxygen pumped into your lungs. You will need to be moved around in a wheelchair.

A person goes through many stages in life. Why do you believe that humans in the earliest stages aren’t people?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top