Protestants, when did the Catholic Church go bad?

  • Thread starter Thread starter smp501
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
yea, during the time of the the protestant reformation the church was selling indulgences, and doing many things it shouldnt have, but the catholic church responded to the reformation and renewed itself in the COUNCIL OF TRENT:)
 
do catholics believe in “invincible ignorance”? Is that a belief of yours?
That’s a doctrine of salvation of the Catholic Church that you had been telling us was wrong for 1,500 years. Now you say you believe in it.
 
well this a typical counter-claim by people that reject sola scriptura. scripture is the only infallible authority in regards to faith. and life IMO. being that you have moved away from the topic and have delved into a different subject i would invite to contact Wels through their website.
Scripture is the ONLY infallible authority in regards to faith? Where does Scripture teach it is the ONLY infallible authority?
 
You haven’t answered the question of what happened after the early apostles died:
basically christians worshipped and spread the gospel under persecution. Rome didn’t legalize it until the 3rd or 4th century. early christianity didnt have a supreme pontiff or pope. Paul wrote more than peter did, John wrote what considered the greatest gospel, as well as revelation. I see no reason to believe that Peter was a Pope or that there ever was suppose to be a supreme pontiff. Seem wildy unbiblical IMO. The Orthodox christians seem to have a more biblical structure. no supreme leader on earth.
 
Scripture is the ONLY infallible authority in regards to faith? Where does Scripture teach it is the ONLY infallible authority?
Looking at the corruption that has occured in every church in every era it seems, scripture is it to me. everything else answers to the word.
 
Wels is a traditional Lutheran Synod. biblical and christ centered. thats it. Thats all it is to me. If people want a liberalized lutheran church that can be found elsewhere. there is a lot of confusion in Protestant Christianty. Being that I was a non-wels when i walked in the door and worshipped , i guess i will have to disagree with your post.
Why don’t the WELS and LCMS form a single denomination? Just wondering.
 
when exactly? i dont know when exactly.seems to me that FAITH is what saved the early apostles. Jesus found Peter and said follow me and he followed. We’re all called the same way IMO. he didnt give Peter a list of works to be done or else. Faith is what saves in my view. Saved to obey is what i TRY to live by. TRY.
No one is arguing that faith saves. But just not faith alone. Faith must be accompanied by hope and charity infused into the soul by the grace of the Holy Spirit through Baptism. 🙂
 
That’s a doctrine of salvation of the Catholic Church that you had been telling us was wrong for 1,500 years. Now you say you believe in it.
if a man doesn’t KNOW he doesn’t know. If a man has FAITH he is saved, even if hes been decieved by a church in other aspects. My view. would god condemm a man who has been misinformed by no fault of his own? if I’m illiterate and you teach me the word thats all i have to go by. But once people could see for themselves, the rest is history. The CC has disfunction too, but is able to keep in line better via tradition… just as many liberal catholics as protestants.
 
No one is arguing that faith saves. But just not faith alone. Faith must be accompanied by hope and charity infused into the soul by the grace of the Holy Spirit through Baptism. 🙂
God is perfect, a saved man WILL obey the word of god. But the obedience isn’t what saved him, it was faith. Saved To Obey.
 
if a man doesn’t KNOW he doesn’t know. If a man has FAITH he is saved, even if hes been decieved by a church in other aspects. My view. would god condemm a man who has been misinformed by no fault of his own? if I’m illiterate and you teach me the word thats all i have to go by. But once people could see for themselves, the rest is history. The CC has disfunction too, but is able to keep in line better via tradition… just as many liberal catholics as protestants.
Aren’t all of us is saved by GRACE Alone? whatever we have including Faith we received from GOD. 1Cor 4:11?**
 
Looking at the corruption that has occured in every church in every era it seems, scripture is it to me. everything else answers to the word.
Well that is your opinion and your entitled to it,but you still did not answer. If scripture is the only infallible authority,thus you believe it,where is the infallible source declaring it?
 
if a man doesn’t KNOW he doesn’t know. If a man has FAITH he is saved, even if hes been decieved by a church in other aspects. My view. would god condemm a man who has been misinformed by no fault of his own? if I’m illiterate and you teach me the word thats all i have to go by. But once people could see for themselves, the rest is history. The CC has disfunction too, but is able to keep in line better via tradition… just as many liberal catholics as protestants.
How is he supposed to get faith if no one is telling him what faith is or giving him a Bible?
 
God is perfect, a saved man WILL obey the word of god. But the obedience isn’t what saved him, it was faith. Saved To Obey.
True, but at the same time we are working out our salvation (Philippians 2:12) by keeping in step with the Spirit (Galatians 5:25) by performing acts of charity under the influence of grace.
 
Well that is your opinion and your entitled to it,but you still did not answer. If scripture is the only infallible authority,thus you believe it,where is the infallible source declaring it?
well i believe GOD is infallible and i believe the bible to be the word of god. passed on, protected for centuries,cannonized and made into the book of our civilization. 40 authors, 3 languages,1600 years to write by bronze age sheepherders. No other source can equal that for me. studying bible history shows how amazing it really is.
 
well i believe GOD is infallible and i believe the bible to be the word of god. passed on, protected for centuries,cannonized and made into the book of our civilization. 40 authors, 3 languages,1600 years to write by bronze age sheepherders. No other source can equal that for me. studying bible history shows how amazing it really is.
But you told us that no one but priests and monks had a Bible for almost 1500 years and that those priests and monks did not have the correct knowledge of salvation.
 
True, but at the same time we are working out our salvation (Philippians 2:12) by keeping in step with the Spirit (Galatians 5:25) by performing acts of charity under the influence of grace.
we can quote scripture all day. I can give you Luke 17:21. I just dont believe salvation is something we can “work” for. I believe its an act of grace by god and we recieve it. Faith alone.
 
we can quote scripture all day. I can give you Luke 17:21. I just dont believe salvation is something we can “work” for. I believe its an act of grace by god and we recieve it. Faith alone.
I never said it is something we can work for. We receive salvation by grace. By God’s grace alone. But that grace enables us to have faith hope and charity. If we refuse to do what the Holy Spirit wants us to do (i.e refusing to be charitable, rejecting faith, or losing hope) then we lose that salvation.
 
But you told us that no one but priests and monks had a Bible for almost 1500 years and that those priests and monks did not have the correct knowledge of salvation.
those priests and monks upheld a monopoly. the CC has been as much a political force as religious. i just dont think the CC has the keys to the kingdom. Salvation is by faith in ones heart, not by a church with a supreme pontiff. thats my view
 
“For by grace you have been saved through faith, and that not of yourselves; it is the gift of God, not of works, lest anyone should boast.” - Ephesians 2:8-9

We are not saved by faith, nor are we saved by works. We are saved by God’s grace, through our faith, and that faith is expressed/matured/maintained by the works we do. Works without faith mean nothing, and faith without works is dead.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top