Pushing a Right to Bear Arms, the Sharp Kind

  • Thread starter Thread starter Digitonomy
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
D

Digitonomy

Guest
PHOENIX — Arizona used to be a knife carrier’s nightmare, with a patchwork of local laws that forced those inclined to strap Buck knives or other sharp objects to their belts to tread carefully as they moved from Phoenix (no knives except pocketknives) to Tempe (no knives at all) to Tucson (no knives on library grounds).
But that changed earlier this year when Arizona made its Legislature the sole arbiter of knife regulations. And because of loose restrictions on weapons here, Arizona is now considered a knife carrier’s dream, a place where everything from a samurai sword to a switchblade can be carried without a quibble.
Arizona’s transformation, and the recent lifting of a ban on switchblades, stilettos, dirks and daggers in New Hampshire, has given new life to the knife rights lobby, the little-known cousin of the more politically potent gun rights movement. Its vision is a knife-friendly America, where blades are viewed not as ominous but as tools — the equivalent of sharp-edged screw drivers or hammers — that serve useful purposes and can save lives as well as take them.
Source
 
I’m disappointed. 😦

I had hoped this story was about the right to have bear arms surgically grafted onto your body, so that you could use its claws for self-defense.

However, I suppose knives are a minor danger considering how awash the US is with guns.
 
I’m disappointed. 😦

I had hoped this story was about the right to have bear arms surgically grafted onto your body, so that you could use its claws for self-defense.

However, I suppose knives are a minor danger considering how awash the US is with guns.
We could solve a big part of the death toll from idiots this way. Make possession of a firearm for felons or in the act of a crime carry life without parole for a first violation. At the same time, give the gangbangers a way to settles “matters of honor” in the old Samurai tradition. Those who answered a challenge issued in a proper manner and engaged in a duel would be immune from prosecution for dismemberment or death. No innocent bystanders cut down, and a whole generation of thugs would have a wonderful incentive to learn some self-discipline and conflict resolution skills.
 
We could solve a big part of the death toll from idiots this way. Make possession of a firearm for felons or in the act of a crime carry life without parole for a first violation.
And may I ask, who is going to foot the bill to pay for the incareration of these people who are convicted of this crime?
 
And may I ask, who is going to foot the bill to pay for the incareration of these people who are convicted of this crime?
The costs will be offset by savings from making drugs legal, thereby cutting off the primary revenue source for the idiots.
 
I’m disappointed. 😦

I had hoped this story was about the right to have bear arms surgically grafted onto your body, so that you could use its claws for self-defense.

However, I suppose knives are a minor danger considering how awash the US is with guns.
😃

I’m a knife collector, so any good knews on knifes is kool.
 
We could solve a big part of the death toll from idiots this way. Make possession of a firearm for felons or in the act of a crime carry life without parole for a first violation. At the same time, give the gangbangers a way to settles “matters of honor” in the old Samurai tradition. Those who answered a challenge issued in a proper manner and engaged in a duel would be immune from prosecution for dismemberment or death. No innocent bystanders cut down, and a whole generation of thugs would have a wonderful incentive to learn some self-discipline and conflict resolution skills.
Not a bad set of ideas. It might help bring back the European ideal of knighthood as well. Seriously.
 
Not a bad set of ideas. It might help bring back the European ideal of knighthood as well. Seriously.
I can’t promise anyone would like all of my edicts as emperor, but I can promise that you would have some “out of the box” thinking and solutions!😃
 
I doubt that knives were what was intended by the protection of the 2nd Amendment - not because bayonets and the like were never used by militias, but because nobody considered the possibility that knives would ever be prohibited in any meaningful way that would put liberty at risk. I’m open to learning information to the contrary.

But whether that’s the case or not, I don’t think it’s wise of the state to prevent local regulations that municipalities may feel are necessary. Particular cities may occasionally have problems with samurai-type or similar swords at libraries, or stadiums, or public pools. These may be safety issues in those few towns, but are not the sort of thing the state assembly will be very interested in addressing.
 
I doubt that knives were what was intended by the protection of the 2nd Amendment - not because bayonets and the like were never used by militias, but because nobody considered the possibility that knives would ever be prohibited in any meaningful way that would put liberty at risk. I’m open to learning information to the contrary.

But whether that’s the case or not, I don’t think it’s wise of the state to prevent local regulations that municipalities may feel are necessary. Particular cities may occasionally have problems with samurai-type or similar swords at libraries, or stadiums, or public pools. These may be safety issues in those few towns, but are not the sort of thing the state assembly will be very interested in addressing.
That is because when the 2nd amendment was written, it was commonplace for men to carry with them a small sword or fighting knife and a pistol or rifle every where they went. The ability to defend one’s self against higwaymen or other ruffians was never questioned. It was considered integral to the Right to Life, i.e., the government has no right or place to infringe on my right to defend my life from anyone who would take it from me (including the government itself). The Constitution uses the language of the Declaration of Independence as its foundation.
 
It’s not so much the guns and knives as it is the breakdown of civility in our society.
People don’t care what they say, how they say it or to whom they say it.
 
Guns are tools too. I carry one around with me.
Mine: opens cans, useful for sowing, opening bottles, opening packages/letters, the annoying ~10% of pencils that sharpeners hate etc. How often do you use your tool? I use my 2-3 times a day.
 
Mine: opens cans, useful for sowing, opening bottles, opening packages/letters, the annoying ~10% of pencils that sharpeners hate etc. How often do you use your tool? I use my 2-3 times a day.
Shooting coyotes and beavers as often as we can.

Deer, turkey, ducks, hogs…the possibilities are limitless.

The rare occasion you have a suffering animal that needs to be put down. I’ve only had to do that once, wasn’t easy but she was about to go through some difficult times if I didn’t do something for her.
 
Shooting coyotes and beavers as often as we can.

Deer, turkey, ducks, hogs…the possibilities are limitless.

The rare occasion you have a suffering animal that needs to be put down. I’ve only had to do that once, wasn’t easy but she was about to go through some difficult times if I didn’t do something for her.
So it’s good at killing stuff, anything else?
 
So it’s good at killing stuff, anything else?
I look at it as saving and creating food.

To each his own.

As a knife collector and fan of shooting guns, both are tools. Your tool has the capability to perform various functions. Go camping in Alaska with your tool, I’ll take my tools and we’ll see whose tool comes in handy the most.

I’ll do my best to drop the bear before it get’s to you.

I’m sure people have found other applications for guns. I believe special .22 rounds are used in construction tools and I believe they use them in the oil field as well.
 
…in the old Samurai tradition. Those who answered a challenge issued in a proper manner and engaged in a duel would be immune from prosecution for dismemberment or death. No innocent bystanders cut down, and a whole generation of thugs would have a wonderful incentive to learn some self-discipline and conflict resolution skills.
Are you serious? More to the point, Maji de gozaru, onushi?

Samurai had the kiri sute gomen, or “cutting and walking right”. What that was, was, a samurai could simply cut down any person of lower status, for any reason. So, actually, lots of innocent bystanders cut down.

Samurai were always immune to prosecution for dismemberment or death, unless the victim was of higher status.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top