Putin Criticizes Europe's Secularization

  • Thread starter Thread starter mdgspencer
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
If wanting to see the terrorists in Syria crushed is un-Christian, then perhaps wanting to see them defeated in Nairobi, Nigeria, Mindanao, etc is likewise un-Christian.
 
Which good option? These things are usually run through the UN’s processes which go something like this: first warn, then penalize/sanction, then give the green light for military intervention. Even the Iraq war was preceded by going through those motions. In the case of Syria, Putin and his Chinese counterparts prevented this process by using their veto power. That was the reason the US finally contemplated going alone. You don’t START taking action against a tyrant by dropping bombs - it is usually the last resort.
When the civil war broke out in 2011 we should have had political leader we trusted waiting in the wings especially since we were never guaranteed that Assad would live and then we needed to go through the UN to remove Assad and put another moderate in power like Clinton did with Milosevic . We obviously don’t have anyone or know what to do in Syria. The US foreign policy for the longest time was to put our allies in power.
 
It is not our business when grown men are having children tortured with cigarette butts? That’s how they progress to brazenly gassing them. You know how it goes: “first they came for the Jews and I said nothing…”
North Korea tortures and kills as well…their gulags and treatment of their own people are the stuff of infamy. Why are we not in a hurry to invade and liberate the people? Do we play whack a mole with every bad guy in the world? Is that what we should do?
 
The way Israel was established wasn’t exactly nice and neat, either. The Israelis are not blameless…that doesn’t mean they should be all killed, but some of the anger at Israel is justified. The Palestinians are not all hateful terrorists, and the Israelis are not anti-Arab monsters. As you say…complicated.
Oh you don’t know how Russia’s oh so Christian Putins view of orthodoxy fits into the scheme of things with Israel?

You see Obama isn’t pretending to be promoting a Christian view in the middle east, that’s Putin and as claimed on this thread. Which is about Putin.
 
If wanting to see the terrorists in Syria crushed is un-Christian, then perhaps wanting to see them defeated in Nairobi, Nigeria, Mindanao, etc is likewise un-Christian.
Indeed, although I prefer the term defeated rather than crushed (even though the brutality of war is very real)
 
Oh you don’t know how Russia’s oh so Christian Putins view of orthodoxy fits into the scheme of things with Israel?

You see Obama isn’t pretending to be promoting a Christian view in the middle east, that’s Putin and as claimed on this thread. Which is about Putin.
I never said Putin was promoting Christianity in the Middle East. What I said was that Putin’s actions are supporting the Christians in Syria.
 
There was one saint, or apparition, that said to pray for the conversion of Russia. The reason was that Russia’s errors, abortion, etc., would spread throughout the world. That turned out to be true.

Plus, I understood the reason we needed to pray for their conversion was that, in the end, Russia would actually convert US!

Now, if I hadn’t seen this, I wouldn’t have believed it…to see Putin promoting Christianity! Wow! This is one for the record books, but what if the saints are right? What if Russia is the KEY?!

All I can tell you is that in the US, we’ve legalized abortion on demand, extended it to second, and even third trimesters and are now wondering what to do if the baby survives. Obama has tried to make international aid contingent on accepting abortion, or the aid isn’t given! Countries have responded by rewriting their constitutions to permit it!

I have never seen Obama come out in defense of life like Putin has. So, right now, Putin is starting to look VERY good! At least he not only approves of freedom of religion but has thrown political correctness to the wind and is encouraging religion!

I have never seen our modern American presidents take such a bold step. I will NOT criticize Putin for promoting Christianity!
 
I never said Putin was promoting Christianity in the Middle East. What I said was that Putin’s actions are supporting the Christians in Syria.
Oh I get you now, he’s only Christian in Syria, 😃 Not Iran or Israel? What do you think Russia should do with the Israel situation?
 
Oh I get you now, he’s only Christian in Syria, 😃 Not Iran or Israel? What do you think Russia should do with the Israel situation?
I am not President Putin’s Spiritual Father.

I don’t think Russian intervention would be particularly helpful in that case.
 
I am not President Putin’s Spiritual Father.

I don’t think Russian intervention would be particularly helpful in that case.
No but your defending his Christianity and Christians but only in Syria? No need to defend that with Iran and Israel. Your reduced to something about Israel and secular thinking.

However there’s no getting around Abraham and how intimately tied Christianity is with Israel?

That doesn’t resolve this vision of Putin and National Christianity in the name of orthodoxy.

I believe you see the problem? He’s still working out his salvation in that area? Perhaps he’ll continue to listen to the Pope.
 
Russia is an unhealthy country with a life expectancy of 69, lower than Tonga, Egypt, Honduras, Jamaica, etc. They have a powerful Russian mafia that practically runs the country. They have a huge, huge alcoholism problem, and corruption of every level of society that is unheard of in the rest of Europe, or North America.

So, he is standing on shaky ground in pointing fingers at us. :eek:
 
No but your defending his Christianity and Christians but only in Syria? No need to defend that with Iran and Israel. Your reduced to something about Israel and secular thinking.

However there’s no getting around Abraham and how intimately tied Christianity is with Israel?

That doesn’t resolve this vision of Putin and National Christianity in the name of orthodoxy.

I believe you see the problem? He’s still working out his salvation in that area? Perhaps he’ll continue to listen to the Pope.
The modern nation-state of Israel governed from Tel Aviv and the Biblical Israel are NOT the same.
 
Russia is an unhealthy country with a life expectancy of 69, lower than Tonga, Egypt, Honduras, Jamaica, etc. They have a powerful Russian mafia that practically runs the country. They have a huge, huge alcoholism problem, and corruption of every level of society that is unheard of in the rest of Europe, or North America.

So, he is standing on shaky ground in pointing fingers at us. :eek:
Russia has a very serious population crisis on it hands and it is scaring the heck out of Putin because Russia and a lot of Europe is dying right now and below a population level they can get back soon. A lot of what Putin is doing is to either trying to prevent something worse from happening or for Russia to exist in two generations. That is why Putin was extremely sensitive about the Boston Bombing and Chechnya not being named a terrorist hotbed by the US because Muslims and most especially Muslim radicals present a big problem to him and the future of Russia. When the US invaded Afghanistan the radicals relocated to places like Chechnya and neighboring countries of Russia and they each have five or six children.
 
Russian President Putin spoke of Western countries on both side of the Atlantic as he spoke of their renouncing Christian values and of some terrible results of this.
www.catholicculture.org/news/headlines/index.cfm?storyid=19145
Utter cheek, considering that while he condemns modern “secularism” - *and mind there are positive, church approved forms of secularism such as the American constitution model which exists to uphold religious liberty for all groups rather than oppress it *- his authoritarian tenure in power has seen a whole-sale glorification of and resurrection in the memory of history’s (probably along with Mao) most vile secularist, communist and aggressively anti-religious atheist: Joseph Stalin who turned the Soviet Union into one of the most terrifying secular, totalitarian nightmares.

Hypocrite. Plain and simple. He glories in the international media spotlight, pretending to be a force for good while his own people are locked up in prisons in Siberia for daring to criticize Russia’s “state-approved” history of the Stalin era; complain about corruption and crime at the highest echelons of society; campaign for an end to bribery and rigged elections and the rights of minorities.

The West has problems, like all societies, nonetheless we have a proud heritage of human liberty and constitutional government based upon the classical authors, the Bible, renaissance philosophers and later thinkers and parliamentary systems that make Russia’s current mafia state look like the bureaucratic, tyrannical - sorry excuse for a stable, representative government - regime that it is.

Russia does not hold a candle to the civilization of the West, stemming from its cradle in classical and renaissance Europe, no matter how much some Christians - disillusioned with gay marriage and abortion - wish to convince themselves otherwise.

Forgive me, brothers and sisters, for my strong language. However Putin is not the “Christian hero” he tries to make himself out to be so as to win a niche in the hearts of disillusioned Westerners. He has three letters emblazoned across his face in my opinion: *A K a G and * B. **Do not be fooled by his cunning criticisms of the West (some of which are true, like all astute thinkers, but utterly groundless coming from his mouth when he stands for a political system that is 1 BILLION times worse than anything our societies could produce).
 
I don’t know how anyone can doubt that Russia was consecrated to the Immaculate Heart of Mary.
This is exactly what I have been thinking. Ever since the consecration, Russia has gone from communist anti-religious Atheist country to the only state in the world that seems to stand up for Christianity and its values.

Truly remarkable.

Praise be to God! We should consecrate the whole world to our Blessed Mother 🙂
 
This is exactly what I have been thinking. Ever since the consecration, Russia has gone from communist anti-religious Atheist country to the only state in the world that seems to stand up for Christianity and its values.

Truly remarkable.

Praise be to God! We should consecrate the whole world to our Blessed Mother 🙂
I thought I read somewhere Pope Francis was going to do that.
 
This is exactly what I have been thinking. Ever since the consecration, Russia has gone from communist anti-religious country to the only state in the world that seems to stand up for Christianity and its values.

Truly remarkable.
There is nothing at all remarkable about Russia’s current condition. The only good thing about it right now is that Orthodox Christianity has steadily re-gained acceptability among the masses and a bigger following than ever since the 1917 revolution. That is good. What isn’t good is the fact that this has not come alongside a Christianisation and humanization of the morality in the national ethos and state. In fact the reverse has occurred. Putin is much worse, from a human rights perspective, than the final years of the Soviet Union under the liberalizing Gorbachev. There was a brief experiment in democracy in the 1990s which ended in financial ruin and chaos as the country tried to shift successfully from a Marxist to a capitalist, free-market economy. The transition was not a smooth one. Crime reached the highest levels of society and an authoritarian regime was installed under Putin with the promise of re-gaining stability but at what cost? A strong man and centralized regime in return for the loss of civil liberties and state-approved violence against dissidents. We have seen this exact same scenario before, with disastrous consequences. The situation in Russia has gradually, over the 2000s, become worse and worse as this massive country slips deeper into totalitarianism of a kind Russia hasn’t seen since Stalin died in 1953.
 
There is nothing at all remarkable about Russia’s current condition. The only good thing about it right now is that Orthodox Christianity has steadily re-gained acceptability among the masses and a bigger following than ever since the 1917 revolution. That is good. What isn’t good is the fact that this has not come alongside a Christianisation and humanization of the morality in the national ethos and state. In fact the reverse has occurred. Putin is much worse, from a human rights perspective, than the final years of the Soviet Union under the liberalizing Gorbachev. There was a brief experiment in democracy in the 1990s which ended in financial ruin and chaos as the country tried to shift successfully from a Marxist to a capitalist, free-market economy. The transition was not a smooth one. Crime reached the highest levels of society and an authoritarian regime was installed under Putin, which has gradually over the 2000s become worse and worse, slipping deeper into (possible) totalitarianism of a kind Russia hasn’t seen since Stalin died in 1952.
I understand what you are saying but it seems more of a Westernized political concept of freedom and state.

The way I see it, as long as Christian values are respected, they will become accepted more and more over time. Whether this means a transition to a democracy is not something we can answer. Democracy does not always work as we see in places like Egypt. In regard to the transition from Atheism to even have a government that condemns non-Christian values that other governments would dare speak about is truly remarkable, right? You have to admit, that is not something a person would have predicted in the 1960’s.

So who knows, maybe the Russians will end up with a Monarchy with King Putin 😃
 
I understand what you are saying but it seems more of a Westernized political concept of freedom and state.

The way I see it, as long as Christian values are respected, they will become accepted more and more over time. Whether this means a transition to a democracy is not something we can answer. Democracy does not always work as we see in places like Egypt. In regard to the transition from Christianity to even have a government that condemns non-Christian values that other governments would dare speak about is truly remarkable, right? You have to admit, that is not something a person would have predicted in the 1960’s.

So who knows, maybe the Russians will end up with a Monarchy with King Putin 😃
John Rawls once made a distinction between “decent hierarchical societies” and “liberal democracies”. A DHS (decent hierarchical society) doesn’t have a democratic system of government but what it does possess is a public protection of private life; as well as recognizing its citizens civil liberties, such as immunity from arbitrary arrest and the right to a fair and free trial. He identified the Roman Republic before its Imperial phase - a de facto oligarchy with some limited democratic representation - as one such historical example of this kind of state. Even into the early Empire era St. Paul could identify himself as “roman citizen” in the Book of Acts and therefore demand the right to appeal to the Emperor and expected to be defended from arbitrarily imprisonment.

Does Russia have such a system? The answer is NO. Earlier this year:
BBC - Russia’s freedoms crackdown ‘worst since USSR fall’
Russian President Vladimir Putin has unleashed the worst political crackdown in the country’s post-Soviet era, a human rights group has said.
In a report, Human Rights Watch said Mr Putin had signed a raft of laws quashing freedoms after his return to the Kremlin for a third term in 2012.
Mr Putin’s fear of mass street protests had been behind the moves, the report’s authors said.
Putin’s regime is one which lacks nearly any respect for the value of human life and is run by criminal gangs (it is literally called a “mafia state” by political analysts, a term coined to refer to modern Russia).

There are things, truly reprehensible things, wrong with Russian society that go deeper than merely democracy. Where it simply the lack of democracy, that would be lamentable, but nowhere near as dire as it actually is. Human rights, the dignity of mankind and the integrity of private life and liberties, is here at stake.

Romanticized notions of Putin as some white-Christian crusader (not saying you believe this by the way, I’m speaking generally in relation to other posters) and Russian society as “Christian” (something its people might be but which its government certainly isn’t) does not, I assure you, help to understand what it is truly going on in Russia.

1930s Romania was a deeply Christian society, with a majority population belonging to the Orthodox Church. Its wartime government, the Iron Guard, came to power after a coup and combined Christianity with Fascism to create a particularly vicious regime which mercilessly deported and slaughtered Jews at a rate and in a public manner which even disgruntled the Nazis (out of reasons of efficiency, not humanity). That regime called itself “the Legion of the Archangel Michael” and proclaimed its adherence to Romanian Orthodox Christianity. Romania was Hitler’s main Axis ally after Italy and Japan.

Why do I bring this up? Because we must object to any regime or ideology which places ideas before human lives or subordinates human life to ideas, regardless of whether that “idea” professes to be Christian or not, in fact even more so if it claims to commit its villainies in the name of Christ.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top