L
littleflower77
Guest
I surprised my boyfriend a few months ago by visiting him for his birthday. When I was telling a friend about it, my friend asked whether or not I had lied. Startled, I said I guess I had. First of all, I lied about what I was doing that weekend when he had asked, saying I had projects I was working on and that I had meetings for my projects that I was expected to be at. (I was this elaborate because he knew I was on break and had wanted me to come visit him.) Second of all, I lied to him and said my phone was dying so that while I was on the plane he wouldn’t suspect anything if he was calling. Third of all, all of his friends were lying to him because they knew I was coming!
My friend I was talking to disapproved that I had lied.
I looked it up in the catechism, and based on what it said, I actually felt guilty about lying. Is this scrupulosity or is it bad to lie in order to surprise someone? Of course when I actually got there I told him what I had made up.
This is silly, but if over the phone someone jokes they are cleaning the toilet but then after a moment says, just kidding, I’m watching TV…they “lied” but obviously no one would truly consider that a lie.
So what is really a “lie”? Was it bad that I “lied” in order to surprise someone?
My friend I was talking to disapproved that I had lied.
I looked it up in the catechism, and based on what it said, I actually felt guilty about lying. Is this scrupulosity or is it bad to lie in order to surprise someone? Of course when I actually got there I told him what I had made up.
This is silly, but if over the phone someone jokes they are cleaning the toilet but then after a moment says, just kidding, I’m watching TV…they “lied” but obviously no one would truly consider that a lie.
So what is really a “lie”? Was it bad that I “lied” in order to surprise someone?