Question about lying

  • Thread starter Thread starter littleflower77
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
L

littleflower77

Guest
I surprised my boyfriend a few months ago by visiting him for his birthday. When I was telling a friend about it, my friend asked whether or not I had lied. Startled, I said I guess I had. First of all, I lied about what I was doing that weekend when he had asked, saying I had projects I was working on and that I had meetings for my projects that I was expected to be at. (I was this elaborate because he knew I was on break and had wanted me to come visit him.) Second of all, I lied to him and said my phone was dying so that while I was on the plane he wouldn’t suspect anything if he was calling. Third of all, all of his friends were lying to him because they knew I was coming!

My friend I was talking to disapproved that I had lied.

I looked it up in the catechism, and based on what it said, I actually felt guilty about lying. Is this scrupulosity or is it bad to lie in order to surprise someone? Of course when I actually got there I told him what I had made up.

This is silly, but if over the phone someone jokes they are cleaning the toilet but then after a moment says, just kidding, I’m watching TV…they “lied” but obviously no one would truly consider that a lie.

So what is really a “lie”? Was it bad that I “lied” in order to surprise someone?
 
I am a little unsure about this and would be happy to hear any official church teaching on the matter, but my feeling is this:

A real lie is one that you don’t want discovered. In this case it is deliberately temporary - that is, you fully expect your deception to be rectified, and it’s only for a short time that you must maintain the falsehood.

Therefore I don’t see it as sinful. I have another example - I had to tow a trailer home without hubby’s help the other day and back it into the carport, which I did without trouble. He rang and asked how I had gone, and in my most convincing voice, I told him it had rolled out the back end and down the hill and was sitting at the bottom of the garden. He didn’t believe me for an instant and we both laughed because I can never manage to “get him”, even when he gets me in a similar way. So did I sin by not telling him the truth instantly? I really hope not. I knew that within a few minutes I would set him straight, there was no intention of long-term deception.

Same goes with the Santa Claus debate. Nobody expects to continue their child’s belief in Santa until adulthood.
 
I believe that intentions are essential to classifing whether or not a lie is sinful. So when you ask if lying was bad in order to surprise someone, I would say no. Because your reason for lying was to create an eventual happiness (a good thing) for your bf and yourself.

Also with the trailer, I’m assuming you were trying to “get him”, kind of like a little joke that you have between the two of you. This little ‘joke’ or thing that you share in turn stregthens your marriage, as it affirms the special and unique relationship you have. So the real intention is good.
 
I think you carefully orchestrated a nice surprise, and I really don’t think you did anything wrong. Was your boyfriend happy? Was it a nice surprise for him? If so, just focus on that. It’s really none of your friend’s business.

It is, like another poster mentioned, like Santa Claus. It’s not deceitful, just fun.
 
You are getting bad advice here. A lie is a lie. You told a number of lies to deceive your boyfriend. It doesn’t matter that you were deceiving him to surprise him with a visit. They were venial sins. I’m sure, with some thought, you could have kept him unaware of what you were doing without lying. For instance, you could have told him that you were very busy working on a project without lying (the project was the surprise visit). It is when you embroidered it by making it plural and making up meetings that you ventured in the the arena of lying.

You could have just turned off your phone and been out of contact - we actually can survive without cell phones!!

When admonsta told her husband “it had rolled out the back end and down the hill and was sitting at the bottom of the garden. He didn’t believe me for an instant and we both laughed because I can never manage to “get him”, even when he gets me in a similar way.” this was not a lie, since no reasonable person would believe it to be the truth. This is the crux of determining if something is a lie.
 
You are getting bad advice here. A lie is a lie.
Two weeks ago, my fiance told me we were going to the movies. Instead, he brought me to my surprise bridal shower. You’re saying this was deceitful and wrong?

What about Santa Claus?
 
You are getting bad advice here. A lie is a lie. You told a number of lies to deceive your boyfriend. It doesn’t matter that you were deceiving him to surprise him with a visit. They were venial sins. I’m sure, with some thought, you could have kept him unaware of what you were doing without lying. For instance, you could have told him that you were very busy working on a project without lying (the project was the surprise visit). It is when you embroidered it by making it plural and making up meetings that you ventured in the the arena of lying.

You could have just turned off your phone and been out of contact - we actually can survive without cell phones!!

When admonsta told her husband “it had rolled out the back end and down the hill and was sitting at the bottom of the garden. He didn’t believe me for an instant and we both laughed because I can never manage to “get him”, even when he gets me in a similar way.” this was not a lie, since no reasonable person would believe it to be the truth. This is the crux of determining if something is a lie.
Well it seems her trip did involve plural projects. Arranging it, getting on the plane etc. etc. As for the meetings, it could easily be said, that the need to get to the plane, was a meeting place she needed to be, that the party was another meeting etc.

Also her phone would basically be dead for all intent and purposes, once she got on the plane and turned it off.

Honestly Joan it seems if one is going to be so scrupulous then they would realize that just carefully choosing your words to deceive another is still a deception, because anyway you try to look at it, the INTENT would be to deceive.

To the OP, there was nothing evil about what you did nor your intent. If you feel concerned, I would confess it to your priest and let him and his knowledge on the matter better guide you for future reference.

I hope your boyfriend had a lovely party:-)
 
Honestly Joan it seems if one is going to be so scrupulous then they would realize that just carefully choosing your words to deceive another is still a deception, because anyway you try to look at it, the INTENT would be to deceive.
I agree, and I’d be wary of anyone who is good at such “wordsmithing”. Being able to twist words so they represent just enough truth to get by isn’t exactly an honorable skill.
 
Don’t lie, period. But a pleasant surprise would be a lie only technically and it’s probably exceedingly scrupulous to consider it a real lie and a moral wrong. It’s like the joke where you say “just kidding”, except more protracted in time.
 
I think the intentions behind a lie are what make it acceptable or bad. If I meet my mother for lunch and she’s so happy about the shoes (that are hideous) she just bought, and she’s lovingly showing them off to me…I’m not going to tell her they look like cow pucky. In addition, a few years ago, my now husband lied on the phone to me and told me he was coming back from his 3 week military AT in australia in a few days. He was actually back in the states and TOTALLY surprised me at the end of my work shift that day with of course, himself, and flowers. I will never forget that. It was a wonderful surprise.

If I lie to get out of something, avoid punishment, etc----that’s a no brainer. That’s bad. But bending the truth for an ultimately positive outcome I believe is fine.
 
If I lie to get out of something, avoid punishment, etc----that’s a no brainer. That’s bad. But bending the truth for an ultimately positive outcome I believe is fine.
Depends if you lie to avoid evil or to achieve some kind of beneficial state of matters via illicit means. I remember watching a film in which a priest asked a mayor or some such for a building or funds or something else he needed for his ministry. The official didn’t want to hear about it but the priest went to the press and went on and on about what great a guy the mayor was for agreeing and helping. 😃 I’m not gonna criticise that priest (he was helping dying people) but I wouldn’t do something like that.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top