Question from a Seeking Jew

  • Thread starter Thread starter Jew_Man_73
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
40.png
neophyte:
BTW,

The question of the geneologies has interested me for a while. The Fourth Century historian Eusebius explains the two geneologies as being the result of the Law of Levirite Marriage, which would result in a man being counted as having two fathers, one biological and one legal.

The two geneologies show that both lines have Joseph tracing his lineage to the House of David.

If you like I can e-mail you a copy of the text (it’s close to 1600 words so I hesitate to paste it here). Or you can probably Google it.

Here’s a taste:
Could you email it to me? I’d like to read it. Thanks.
 
40.png
CARose:
Are you suggesting we start a new thread there? I think it originally got started because a once upon a time newbie, now a veritable standard, started it where he was hanging at the water cooler.

I like what happened as a result! We got a good, non-confrontational conversation.

But moving it shouldn’t pose any problems if you want to do that (via admin.) or we could start a new thread if that’s what you want.

CARose

PS I wonder if we’ll attract a different crowd being in a different forum?
I was just reading your post again. I agree, look what has happened! One simple question from me, and this post has evolved into this! Isn’t it great? :dancing:
 
Done.

It wasn’t the liturgy that really struck me so much as it was the theological similarities. For example, the idea of tikkun olam is absolutely foreign to any Protestant theology that I ever heard, but it is virtually identical to the Catholic idea of working in union with God and thus participating in the redemptive work of Christ. And all of the Protestant ideas I ever heard about original sin are completely foreign to Jewish thought, but the Catholic teaching on it is identical to the yetzer hara.
 
40.png
neophyte:
Done.

It wasn’t the liturgy that really struck me so much as it was the theological similarities. For example, the idea of tikkun olam is absolutely foreign to any Protestant theology that I ever heard, but it is virtually identical to the Catholic idea of working in union with God and thus participating in the redemptive work of Christ. And all of the Protestant ideas I ever heard about original sin are completely foreign to Jewish thought, but the Catholic teaching on it is identical to the yetzer hara.
Where can we party-crashing (non-Jewish 🙂 ) Catholics read more about this stuff?
 
40.png
neophyte:
Done.

It wasn’t the liturgy that really struck me so much as it was the theological similarities. For example, the idea of tikkun olam is absolutely foreign to any Protestant theology that I ever heard, but it is virtually identical to the Catholic idea of working in union with God and thus participating in the redemptive work of Christ. And all of the Protestant ideas I ever heard about original sin are completely foreign to Jewish thought, but the Catholic teaching on it is identical to the yetzer hara.
I can’t believe I didn’t see that. The Catholic teaching of working in union with G-d and participating in the redemptive work of Jesus is virtually identical to tikkun olam. And the teaching of original sin and yetzer hara too. When viewed in the context of Catholicism being Judaism fulfilled, it’s almost eerie. More to pray about, I think. Thanks.
 
40.png
VociMike:
Where can we party-crashing (non-Jewish 🙂 ) Catholics read more about this stuff?
An excellent site is www.jewfaq.org. It has information on all aspects of Jewish faith, from the most basic to the most advanced. It also contains detailed information about all the branches of Judaism. And don’t worry, it’s Gentile friendly! 😃
 
Just to let you know that the most reverent Catholics in our Parish are those who converted from Judaism. :bounce:

Reason?

They can see the typology… because they know the Old Testament so very well.

(That’s where the Old Testament is fulfilled by the New Testament, and the New Testament was already predicted in the Old.)

They can also see that the Catholic Mass is very similar to the worship found in the synagogue. They can also see the similarities between Catholicism and the Levitical Law.

Remember, Christ himself said that he did not come to abolish the law but to fulfill it.

Shalom,
Joanie
 
40.png
GodBlessJoanie:
Just to let you know that the most reverent Catholics in our Parish are those who converted from Judaism. :bounce:

Reason?

They can see the typology… because they know the Old Testament so very well.

(That’s where the Old Testament is fulfilled by the New Testament, and the New Testament was already predicted in the Old.)

They can also see that the Catholic Mass is very similar to the worship found in the synagogue. They can also see the similarities between Catholicism and the Levitical Law.

Remember, Christ himself said that he did not come to abolish the law but to fulfill it.

Shalom,
Joanie
I’ve noticed some similarities as well. I would love to find some Jewish Catholics in my area, but I don’t know of any. There aren’t alot of Jews here, period.
 
Hi again,
Jewish Catholics? You may want to contact several of your local parishes and speak with the Pastors. Ask them if any of their parishioners are Jewish converts. Remember that the wave is moving south (you are in North Carolina I believe) so it may not be as hard as you think to find them.

Give Father your number and let them call you. Of course, put this all in prayer and let the Lord lead.

Also, I know that this may be new to you, but you can always ask the intercession of the Blessed Mother (who you know was a most holy Jewish girl… – or is it gurl…–)

Blessings,
Joanie
 
40.png
Jew_Man_73:
I can’t believe I didn’t see that. The Catholic teaching of working in union with G-d and participating in the redemptive work of Jesus is virtually identical to tikkun olam. And the teaching of original sin and yetzer hara too. When viewed in the context of Catholicism being Judaism fulfilled, it’s almost eerie. More to pray about, I think. Thanks.
Isn’t there also a teaching that, after the Messiah comes, all sacrifice will be done away with except bread and wine?
 
40.png
GodBlessJoanie:
Hi again,
Jewish Catholics? You may want to contact several of your local parishes and speak with the Pastors. Ask them if any of their parishioners are Jewish converts. Remember that the wave is moving south (you are in North Carolina I believe) so it may not be as hard as you think to find them.

Give Father your number and let them call you. Of course, put this all in prayer and let the Lord lead.

Also, I know that this may be new to you, but you can always ask the intercession of the Blessed Mother (who you know was a most holy Jewish girl… – or is it gurl…–)

Blessings,
Joanie
Thank you. I didn’t think of that, because there just aren’t many Jews here. It’s worth a try, though. It would be great to meet some Jewish Catholics. (I’ve been praying to Mary off and on, by the way. Gotten some interesting results 🙂 .)
 
40.png
Ignatius:
Isn’t there also a teaching that, after the Messiah comes, all sacrifice will be done away with except bread and wine?
I believe so, but I’m not sure. Let me look it up and get back to you.
 
40.png
VociMike:
It could only be fulfilled in one way – God’s way!
Thanks to Zooey for the very interesting explanation. I gather that it would have been (and will still be) impossible for any human to gain the throne of David. Is that right?
BTW, if a man came along today who claimed to be the Messiah, how would his bloodline be verified? Just wondering.
I think that is quite true; no ordinary human being would qualify for the throne of David, if you go by all that is written of the Messiah in the Jewish scriptures.

I had never even thought about someone trying to claim to be the Messiah today, how he would be able to prove his bloodlines…I think that this may be a question for Jew Man! Do Jews today know what tribe they are descended from, even?After the centuries of the Diaspora?? (I know that we Celts don’t! My family is still trying to figure out where in Ireland & Wales the family came from!)
 
40.png
Jew_Man_73:
An excellent site is www.jewfaq.org. It has information on all aspects of Jewish faith, from the most basic to the most advanced. It also contains detailed information about all the branches of Judaism. And don’t worry, it’s Gentile friendly! 😃
Great site!! Thank you, I will be very interested in this!!
God bless.
 
40.png
Jew_Man_73:
An excellent site is www.jewfaq.org. It has information on all aspects of Jewish faith, from the most basic to the most advanced. It also contains detailed information about all the branches of Judaism. And don’t worry, it’s Gentile friendly! 😃
This looks like a great site. I’ll definitely be coming here as part of my studies. 👍
 
40.png
Zooey:
I think that is quite true; no ordinary human being would qualify for the throne of David, if you go by all that is written of the Messiah in the Jewish scriptures.

I had never even thought about someone trying to claim to be the Messiah today, how he would be able to prove his bloodlines…I think that this may be a question for Jew Man! Do Jews today know what tribe they are descended from, even?After the centuries of the Diaspora?? (I know that we Celts don’t! My family is still trying to figure out where in Ireland & Wales the family came from!)
I’m not an expert at this, but I have read up on the subject a bit. Most Jews can’t trace their lineage back to the original 12 tribes, but some can. There is a small movement in Israel today to restore the line of David to the throne. It’s small, but vocal, from what I’ve read. They’ve actually found a man who is of the line of David, and they’re looking for more. That’s where they’re at right now. Personally, I’m skeptical. In order to restore the throne, the current government would have to cease to exist. At best, I think all that could happen would be a type of constitutional monarchy with a Prime Minister and a king with limited power. However, if anything ever does happen, it’s a long way off. This group is small, and would need alot more supporters, I would imagine. I’ll look up some more information about this and post it here.
As for no human ever fulfilling the qualifications for Messiah, that is exactly what Jews believe. Jews believe he will be a mere mortal man. No more, no less. Don’t forget that the Christian concept of the Messiah is drastically different from the Jewish concept. The Messianic prophecies in the TANAKH are interpreted differently by Jews. For more information, look up “Moshiach” on jewfaq.org. It has alot of information on Jewish beliefs regarding the Messiah. Shalom! 🙂
 
40.png
Zooey:
Great site!! Thank you, I will be very interested in this!!
God bless.
Yes. I stumbled on it by accident last year. I’m glad I did, it’s great.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top