Question on daughter's lost virginity

  • Thread starter Thread starter Irish_Girl_68
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I find it very interesting how you completely ignore the option of “good parents, good kid, kid makes mistake”.
Which seems like is exactly what happened. Parents cannot spy on their kids every moment of every day. If some kid got her into a corner at school or on the way home from school, and she didn’t know how to react, or didn’t react quickly enough, what were the parents supposed to do? It’s not like they were there, watching her - and at fourteen, they probably thought they could wait at least a while before getting into the intimate details of sex, and how to prevent a boy from taking advantage of her.
 
I think kids can make mistakes, be influenced by peer pressure, be subject to assault, and all kinds of things. However I do think there can be abuse or something outside the home that the parents never find out about, which is hard on kids. This is a complicated society we live in and many people find it hard to keep up.

I have heard that communication between parents and kids can help. To give an example, I was subjected to a really bad group assault when I was 12, at a “friend’s” house, from Catholic school. My mother had had a stillbirth one month before and was really sick. They took advantage. I had a funny feeling about my friend, I never met my abusers before it happened, but I didn’t suspect violence. I thought she was mad at me but wanting to be friends anyway which was confusing. the thing is this whole thing was planned and I tried to leave but couldn’t. In better circumstances my parents might have been more aware and I’d never have gone to her house in the first place. She lived in a remote rural area where there was too much distance between houses to get away from, and this was before cell phones.

I’m not saying something like that is always a problem but I’ve found that sometimes either the parents or the child have an odd feeling about a person or situation that later turns out badly, such as assault or peer pressure or some dangerous behavior. Sometimes people can be too suspicious though. But when you talk it through, it’s easier to tell. These people deliberately took advantage knowing my mother was sick, that was a large part of why they “picked” me.

Around that time, someone else took on a “father” role so I’ll call him my father though we were not biologically related. He heard about this and tried to teach me to stay out of danger. In addition to not going out at night, being careful about who my friends were, and etc. - he said, do not go into bars under any circumstances. This was almost 30 years ago. Don’t go to bars and if you have to go to bars, like for a work reason or your friends go, do not drink. He got somewhat of a rep for being “sexist” for saying this b/c some people’s reaction was, shouldn’t a girl be able to go to a bar and get a drink or two, with friends, and be OK? that is what some of the other people in my life said. But he said, OK maybe that works for some people IF they have really good friends but I’d already been hurt partly for being naive although at 12 you can’t blame a child for that and the best thing was - sorry this is the way he said it - to STAY OUT OF BARS UNDER ANY CIRCUMSTANCES. That advice also applied to any party at college or anywhere else where alcohol was served. I said that would damage my social life. He said, tough.

That advice worked for me. Bars and drinking may be OK for some people but not for me, not at that point. He did not mean that to include pubs where people get together and eat lunch or dinner, but the places where you go dancing and/or drinking.

That does not make an assault anyone’s fault if there has been drinking involved, it is always the abuser’s fault, but I’d already been burned once by not realizing how to trust my instincts and he didn’t want me hurt again. My college years were a lot safer than they might have been b/c of that, partly b/c I made friends who weren’t into that stuff and we rarely went to bars.
 
I hate to break it to all of you, but parenting determines most of the big deal stuff that kids do. Traumatic external events also enter into it(kidnapping, rape, etc).
The generational curse is indeed real and was acknowledged long before Freud (though he did apply some scientific elements to strengthen it).

The people who accuse me of arrogance are the same ones who refuse to embrace their own responsibility as parents.

I don’t buy the “good parents often have bad kids” argument. That’s a cop out. The “good” parents were not “good” at all. They may have been nice, but not effective parents.

This is the problem with parenting today. Most parents I know, of all ilks, really have no clue what their kids are doing. If someone like me suggests that they not let their kid do social things without knowledge beforehand, I’m called abusive,oppressive, or controlling. Then their kids end up pregnant or in trouble.

I hate to break it to the relativists here but if you are a parent and your motto is “punishment=time out” or “be home by curfew”, then you’re not raising your kid. The world is raising your kid.
 
I hate to break it to all of you, but parenting determines most of the big deal stuff that kids do. Traumatic external events also enter into it(kidnapping, rape, etc).
The generational curse is indeed real and was acknowledged long before Freud (though he did apply some scientific elements to strengthen it).

The people who accuse me of arrogance are the same ones who refuse to embrace their own responsibility as parents.

I don’t buy the “good parents often have bad kids” argument. That’s a cop out. The “good” parents were not “good” at all. They may have been nice, but not effective parents.

This is the problem with parenting today. Most parents I know, of all ilks, really have no clue what their kids are doing. If someone like me suggests that they not let their kid do social things without knowledge beforehand, I’m called abusive,oppressive, or controlling. Then their kids end up pregnant or in trouble.

I hate to break it to the relativists here but if you are a parent and your motto is “punishment=time out” or “be home by curfew”, then you’re not raising your kid. The world is raising your kid.
Even the best children do bad things. Heck even the best adults do bad things.
 
I hate to break it to all of you, but parenting determines most of the big deal stuff that kids do. Traumatic external events also enter into it(kidnapping, rape, etc).
The generational curse is indeed real and was acknowledged long before Freud (though he did apply some scientific elements to strengthen it).

The people who accuse me of arrogance are the same ones who refuse to embrace their own responsibility as parents.

I don’t buy the “good parents often have bad kids” argument. That’s a cop out. The “good” parents were not “good” at all. They may have been nice, but not effective parents.

This is the problem with parenting today. Most parents I know, of all ilks, really have no clue what their kids are doing. If someone like me suggests that they not let their kid do social things without knowledge beforehand, I’m called abusive,oppressive, or controlling. Then their kids end up pregnant or in trouble.

I hate to break it to the relativists here but if you are a parent and your motto is “punishment=time out” or “be home by curfew”, then you’re not raising your kid. The world is raising your kid.
Well I hate to break it to YOU but you can be the best parent in the world, set all the right examples, give the child the best education in faith and other moral issues and you can still find your child could end up in a troubling situation. There are NO guarantees that your child will not find themselves in trouble, NONE. All you can do as a parent is give them all the knowledge and lessons in forming firm moral values and beliefs, but at some point the child has to decide for themselves.
 
I hate to break it to all of you, but parenting determines most of the big deal stuff that kids do. Traumatic external events also enter into it(kidnapping, rape, etc).
The generational curse is indeed real and was acknowledged long before Freud (though he did apply some scientific elements to strengthen it).

The people who accuse me of arrogance are the same ones who refuse to embrace their own responsibility as parents.

I don’t buy the “good parents often have bad kids” argument. That’s a cop out. The “good” parents were not “good” at all. They may have been nice, but not effective parents.

This is the problem with parenting today. Most parents I know, of all ilks, really have no clue what their kids are doing. If someone like me suggests that they not let their kid do social things without knowledge beforehand, I’m called abusive,oppressive, or controlling. Then their kids end up pregnant or in trouble.

I hate to break it to the relativists here but if you are a parent and your motto is “punishment=time out” or “be home by curfew”, then you’re not raising your kid. The world is raising your kid.
Nec5, please answer the question I posed to you earlier: What is your expertise in child psychology or adolescent development?
 
Well I hate to break it to YOU but you can be the best parent in the world, set all the right examples, give the child the best education in faith and other moral issues and you can still find your child could end up in a troubling situation. There are NO guarantees that your child will not find themselves in trouble, NONE. All you can do as a parent is give them all the knowledge and lessons in forming firm moral values and beliefs, but at some point the child has to decide for themselves.
Gosh, what about Mrs. Corapi? The way Father Corapi describes her she was a truly good and virtuous mother. It didn’t stop him from living life in the fast lane.

She prayed for him constantly.
 
ETA: I see MaryGail posted while I worked on my post. I would submit another candidate for the Bad Mother of the Year Award…Saint Monica. She must have been a bad mother, for Saint Augustine to turn out the way he did. Of course Saint Monica had to pray for him, it was her duty, since his sexual sins were obviously all because of bad parenting, too.

Anyway…I don’t have much to contribute from the parenting angle, but as the topic has expanded a little from that, I just thought I should share an anecdote that may be relevant.

I know of a girl who lost her virginity as a fairly young teenager (I think she was 15 or 16). The boy was around the same age, but it was a classic case of a good girl thinking she could “fix” a bad boy with the power of love. They weren’t even officially dating. After they had sex, the boy unceremoniously dumped her, and I suspect he might have been plotting all along to boost his ego by seducing her and taking her virginity. A few months after that, the girl tried to kill herself. Luckily, she lived.

That was some years ago, and I don’t know what happened to the girl. I hope she healed from her pain, and is doing ok. I would really hope that she’s found, or does find, a good man, who doesn’t think what happened when she was a teenager defines who she is.

I guess that’s the problem I have. Even among people who say they don’t have a double standard, it seems that often, virginity is seen as a part of a woman’s identity in a way that it’s not for a man. If a man sins sexually, everyone will accept that just because he committed a mortal sin doesn’t make him a horrible person worthy of damnation. But a woman is seen as damaged goods, as if she’s lost a part of herself permanently…and I am not talking about her hymen, here. Some people seem to think this is the case, and act like losing one’s virginity, to a woman, is like having radiation that has transformed the woman into some mutant subhuman…even if she’s gone to Confession and been absolved.

I do remember the case of the poster who found out that his wife had lied to him, before marriage, about her virginity status. He actually was not a hypocrite in that he hadn’t had premarital sex himself and his courtship with his wife before marriage was chaste. But interestingly, the man’s childhood friends did not share his beliefs, and were open about that, and he didn’t shun them. Indeed, one of the incidents the man discussed was that he was with a group of friends who were reminscing about past sexual conquests, and one of those friends told him about a past sexual partner his wife had. It really seemed that to this man, virginity, or lack thereof, defined a woman’s identity in a way it didn’t for a man.

However, that being said, I wouldn’t recommend directly lying, about anything really that could be a dealbreaker. For example, some people are very sensitive about the issue of drug use, especially if they’ve seen negative effects on friends or family. Such a person might consider it a dealbreaker if they find out a prospective marriage partner had ever used drugs, even if it was a “soft” drug such as marijuana. I’m sure many women would never want to marry a man who had ever engaged in same-sex sexual activity, even if it was just youthful experimentation. I can’t say such people are all “wrong” or uncharitable. Now, I personally would prefer to marry a man who doesn’t drink alcohol, due to my own experiences. I probably would not feel comfortable marrying anyone with a history of alcohol abuse. I don’t think that’s about being judgmental. I wouldn’t jump down the throat of a man (or woman) who expressed a preference for a virgin. I think, though, that there are charitable ways to express that preference, without making the person feel like they should go home and put on a scarlet letter.
 
Gosh, what about Mrs. Corapi? The way Father Corapi describes her she was a truly good and virtuous mother. It didn’t stop him from living life in the fast lane.

She prayed for him constantly.
Prayer, yes! That’s the other tool parents can use.
 
Well I hate to break it to YOU but you can be the best parent in the world, set all the right examples, give the child the best education in faith and other moral issues and you can still find your child could end up in a troubling situation. There are NO guarantees that your child will not find themselves in trouble, NONE. All you can do as a parent is give them all the knowledge and lessons in forming firm moral values and beliefs, but at some point the child has to decide for themselves.
Ditto this. We all have free will, and we are all sinners. No matter how great your parents are, Nec5, you are still a sinner, and you will still commit sins over the course of your lifetime – maybe even some big ones.

Someone else mentioned St. Monica, and I believe that’s an appropriate reference. She’s a perfect example of good parenting, and yet for years her son strayed so far away from virtue. She never gave up hope for him, though, even when he was in the depths of his sin, and she continued to pray ardently for him. Eventually, St. Augustine converted and became a doctor of the Church. Are we to believe that St. Monica was a bad mother because of her son exercising his free will and sinning? I doubt that.
 
CAF friends: I’ve had other threads on my daughter and her behavior. By the grace of God, she appears to be turning a corner. She has failed a couple of times where boys are concerned and regrets this. She asked me the other day how she will deal with this fact when she meets a “good guy who maybe wants to marry me.” She was 14 when she lost her virginity. Admittedly, a tough pill for many men to swallow. I’ve told her to give it to God, pray to Our Lady and it would take care of itself at the proper time.

I still feel like I failed her in terms of a correct answer. While I didn’t tell her this, my own thought is, a man of 30 might better understand, but I question how much any decent man in his late teens/early twenties might accept it (assuming she might meet marriage-appropriate men in college). Any thoughts or advice?
If the Lord can see his way to make St. Peter the first Pope, there will be a man after the Lord’s heart who will marry a woman who made mistakes while still in girlhood. The Lord only has to find her the one, and she’ll want no other than the man the Lord finds for you. If the Lord finds her none, then it is because the Lord has elected to keep her for service to him alone. That is a high calling. If she repents and lets God make her worthy to remain unmarried for the Lord, what sort of man would find her unworthy to marry? Tell her to concentrate on serving God, and let God take care of finding her a good man, if God desires to make her a wife and mother.

She needs to learn self-control and prudence from here on out, and not waste her time worrying over things that cannot be changed. That is all any of us can do. If she really becomes a woman of holiness, there will be many good men willing to marry her, even if her past is not perfect. She does need to lean very heavily on prudence, though, and not depend on her self-control to get her past near occasions of sin. Sin is enough of a danger, without sticking our fingers in its cage.

She is going to have to accept that perhaps this man she marries will be a “re-tread virgin”, too. Men fall, too, and repent, and it doesn’t mean they aren’t decent men. Many of the saints started badly. Of the Prodigal Son and his brother, I’m not so sure the Prodigal wouldn’t make the better husband. Virtue is far more than lacking a history of vice. I would not rule out that a very good man would be willing to marry a woman with a past, but I think if she realizes that a man with a past is not automatically “damaged goods”, she’ll hold herself of value. This is vital, if she is to preserve herself from here on out.

As for the man of 30, there is no reason to believe her husband will be her own age. He might easily be 6-8 years older. I see that working out very well all of the time.

As for you, OP: You can’t be a different parent yesterday. Yesterday is gone. The only thing any of us can do is to try to be a better parent today than we were yesterday.

As for accusations against you or your daughter, remember this: “Then I heard a loud voice in heaven say: "Now have salvation and power come, and the kingdom of our God and the authority of his Anointed. For the accuser of our brothers is cast out, who accuses them before our God day and night. They conquered him by the blood of the Lamb and by the word of their testimony; love for life did not deter them from death.” Rev. 12:10-11

It is not the sinners against whom Michael and his angels will go into battle, but it will be the Accuser who is cast from heaven. Sinners who repent have a refuge in the Lord, who shed his blood that they may have eternal life. He did not die in order to cleanse accusers. Rather, we have to let go of our desire to accuse in order to be cleansed. Let no one tell you differently. Go, sin no more, and let the Lord handle the people with the stones.

Let us instruct and admonish one another, but let us have no part in the judgment that belongs to God alone. That is a road to ruin, and the Lord clearly warned us about this.
 
I hate to break it to all of you, but parenting determines most of the big deal stuff that kids do. Traumatic external events also enter into it(kidnapping, rape, etc).
The generational curse is indeed real and was acknowledged long before Freud (though he did apply some scientific elements to strengthen it).

The people who accuse me of arrogance are the same ones who refuse to embrace their own responsibility as parents.

I don’t buy the “good parents often have bad kids” argument. That’s a cop out. The “good” parents were not “good” at all. They may have been nice, but not effective parents.

This is the problem with parenting today. Most parents I know, of all ilks, really have no clue what their kids are doing. If someone like me suggests that they not let their kid do social things without knowledge beforehand, I’m called abusive,oppressive, or controlling. Then their kids end up pregnant or in trouble.

I hate to break it to the relativists here but if you are a parent and your motto is “punishment=time out” or “be home by curfew”, then you’re not raising your kid. The world is raising your kid.
Are you telling us that if the woman caught in adultery were to be brought before you, your first instinct would be to ask the crowd who her father was, so you could stone him? That’s a thought that didn’t occur to anyone at the scene, I’ll have to hand you that. Luckily, you are not in the modern school of education, the one that gives partial credit for utterly wrong answers that nevertheless demonstrate originality.

The OP asked how to give hope to a girl who is going to need it, if she is going to hold herself in high enough value to be a chaste woman from here on out. Are you going to tell her no good man will want her? Why not just tell her to settle for someone who is less than a good man, then, since that is all she can hope for? Rather, let us give her the counsel modelled by Our Lord. When he was done, there was none who wanted to condemn her was left in his presence. He said to her: “Woman, where are they? Has no one condemned you?” She replied, “No one, sir.” Then Jesus said, “Neither do I condemn you. Go. From now on do not sin any more.”

That’s the best advice to give that girl. Go, and sin no more. Let Jesus take care of the stone-throwers. The men in that group are not ones that a good father would want his daughter to marry. They might be OK, but they would be too likely to lack the compassion required in married life.
 
Are you telling us that if the woman caught in adultery were to be brought before you, your first instinct would be to ask the crowd who her father was, so you could stone him? That’s a thought that didn’t occur to anyone at the scene, I’ll have to hand you that. Luckily, you are not in the modern school of education, the one that gives partial credit for utterly wrong answers that nevertheless demonstrate originality.

The OP asked how to give hope to a girl who is going to need it, if she is going to hold herself in high enough value to be a chaste woman from here on out. Are you going to tell her no good man will want her? Why not just tell her to settle for someone who is less than a good man, then, since that is all she can hope for? Rather, let us give her the counsel modelled by Our Lord. When he was done, there was none who wanted to condemn her was left in his presence. He said to her: “Woman, where are they? Has no one condemned you?” She replied, “No one, sir.” Then Jesus said, “Neither do I condemn you. Go. From now on do not sin any more.”

That’s the best advice to give that girl. Go, and sin no more. Let Jesus take care of the stone-throwers. The men in that group are not ones that a good father would want his daughter to marry. They might be OK, but they would be too likely to lack the compassion required in married life.
AMEN for orthodox Catholic wisdom!!!👍👍
 
Nec5 - I didn’t want to join in but I see you are under attack. I am on your “side” buddy.
It’s pretty funny that in certain situations people will start throwing out the ‘free will’ argument to suit their view, and in other situations they’ll turn away and attack their upbringing.

Call it what it is and don’t by shy about it. There is a reason the home is central to the Catholic life (morally, socially, spiritually, intellectually). Yes, we have free will, but we are not some Kantian transcendental beings that are totally free from from our experiences - floating around liberally and making random choices amongst an infinite set of choices. That is just foolish if you ask me, and I think most of you recognise that. It is parenting itself that determines how a child behaves. If not, then please re-write history and philosophy. Our home is where we are rooted - it provides us with options. Thus, for some, drugs are not an option. Not in the metaphysical sense - but in the sense that somebody says “I would never do it, it just isn’t an option, I wasn’t brought up that way”. Sure, we are all capable of making mistakes, but mistake is a word that always refers to the past. Thus, upon looking back, upon learning some new information, we realise a mistake. Had the option not been there, had the thought that it was okay not been there, it wouldn’t have happened.

Sure, nobody is a perfect parent. And sure, children have free will. But if you claim that parenting is not absolutely and unbelievably causal in behaviour you need to check yourself because you are not being honest. Often times we play the role of psychologist when we see the bigger picture. We say “Hmmm, his Father never hugged him, it explains why he is afraid of commitment and intimacy”. Whether this is a true and proper assessment is questionable - but what is without question is the role that parents play in choices. Free will cannot be applied as if we are totally separate from our ends, experiences and upbringing. It is within the context of LIFE that we HAVE choice. And at the ages of 0-18 (mostly) our life is almost entirely our HOME.

For example, I made “mistakes” too. But I never made the sexual mistakes, just the alcohol ones. Why? Well, I am not sure but I know it has to do with my parents. Conversely, my best friend has no alcohol related mistakes, but has a variety of sexual ones. Why? Again, he knows its parent related. At one point or another, at one time, I agree that we cannot trace our behaviour entirely to our parents (though, I believe in actual fact, we can) because then we’d probably go into some infinite series regressing until Adam and Eve. But at the age of childhood (0-18) I think parents play a monumental role.

Sure, parents can be nice. Parents can be horrible. Parents can be this or that. But those attributes in some sense are the ones that are transcendental - what matters is the EFFECTIVENESS of the parenting in bringing up a child. For different people that might mean different things - for a Christian, a Jew, an Atheist it surely will mean different things. What is the same are the things that don’t matter - the niceness, the horribleness etc. What I am getting at is this - parents (i.e. some on this thread) justify their effectiveness by these contingent and unnecessary things. So for a man who is spoilt, his mother will say “But I was kind”. We then ask “But was that effective? How did you express that kindness?”.

It is hard to be a parent I am sure. But it is also hard to be a child. And unfortunately you bring a child into the world and you are expected (by society, yourself and God) to do an EFFECTIVE job.
 
Nec5 - I didn’t want to join in but I see you are under attack. I am on your “side” buddy.
It’s pretty funny that in certain situations people will start throwing out the ‘free will’ argument to suit their view, and in other situations they’ll turn away and attack their upbringing.

Call it what it is and don’t by shy about it. There is a reason the home is central to the Catholic life (morally, socially, spiritually, intellectually). Yes, we have free will, but we are not some Kantian transcendental beings that are totally free from from our experiences - floating around liberally and making random choices amongst an infinite set of choices. That is just foolish if you ask me, and I think most of you recognise that. It is parenting itself that determines how a child behaves. If not, then please re-write history and philosophy. Our home is where we are rooted - it provides us with options. Thus, for some, drugs are not an option. Not in the metaphysical sense - but in the sense that somebody says “I would never do it, it just isn’t an option, I wasn’t brought up that way”. Sure, we are all capable of making mistakes, but mistake is a word that always refers to the past. Thus, upon looking back, upon learning some new information, we realise a mistake. Had the option not been there, had the thought that it was okay not been there, it wouldn’t have happened.

Sure, nobody is a perfect parent. And sure, children have free will. But if you claim that parenting is not absolutely and unbelievably causal in behaviour you need to check yourself because you are not being honest. Often times we play the role of psychologist when we see the bigger picture. We say “Hmmm, his Father never hugged him, it explains why he is afraid of commitment and intimacy”. Whether this is a true and proper assessment is questionable - but what is without question is the role that parents play in choices. Free will cannot be applied as if we are totally separate from our ends, experiences and upbringing. It is within the context of LIFE that we HAVE choice. And at the ages of 0-18 (mostly) our life is almost entirely our HOME.

For example, I made “mistakes” too. But I never made the sexual mistakes, just the alcohol ones. Why? Well, I am not sure but I know it has to do with my parents. Conversely, my best friend has no alcohol related mistakes, but has a variety of sexual ones. Why? Again, he knows its parent related. At one point or another, at one time, I agree that we cannot trace our behaviour entirely to our parents (though, I believe in actual fact, we can) because then we’d probably go into some infinite series regressing until Adam and Eve. But at the age of childhood (0-18) I think parents play a monumental role.

Sure, parents can be nice. Parents can be horrible. Parents can be this or that. But those attributes in some sense are the ones that are transcendental - what matters is the EFFECTIVENESS of the parenting in bringing up a child. For different people that might mean different things - for a Christian, a Jew, an Atheist it surely will mean different things. What is the same are the things that don’t matter - the niceness, the horribleness etc. What I am getting at is this - parents (i.e. some on this thread) justify their effectiveness by these contingent and unnecessary things. So for a man who is spoilt, his mother will say “But I was kind”. We then ask “But was that effective? How did you express that kindness?”.

It is hard to be a parent I am sure. But it is also hard to be a child. And unfortunately you bring a child into the world and you are expected (by society, yourself and God) to do an EFFECTIVE job.
I quite frankly am very sorry I even started this thread.

I don’t know if anything I could have done differently would have prevented my daughter’s regrettable choices. You don’t think I haven’t already asked myself that a thousand times? Do you think I haven’t prayed and wept before God over this? Good Lord, why do you think I came looking for advice from a Catholic perspective? That’s right, because I’m the permissive pushover with lines of coke on the coffee table and condoms under the cabinet…give me a break.

Am I a perfect mother? Absolutely not. Could I improve? Certainly. But, I have, to the best of my ability, raised my children in a Catholic environment and taught them right from wrong. God is a part of our DAILY lives. Period. I will take exception with anyone suggesting anything I did or ever said to my daughter somehow gave her a green light or even the remotest impression it was OK to make stupid, dangerous, immoral decisions at such a young age. Further, I have not ONCE said I didn’t take my responsibility as a parent seriously.

News, you’ll note I’m still waiting for Nec5 to cite me his expertise in child psychology and/or adolescent development. Since he’s spouting off like such an expert in these matters, I think it only fair to ask him to prove this to us all. I’ll ask you to do the same, please.

Truly, this has given me absolute clarity on my daughter’s situation. By all means I will suggest she be entirely honest with any future suitor. Perhaps in doing so she will avoid the likes of a man like you or Nec5.

Now, if you’ll both excuse me, I need to go get some sackcloth and ashes for my daughter and me.
 
Nec5 - I didn’t want to join in but I see you are under attack. I am on your “side” buddy.
It’s pretty funny that in certain situations people will start throwing out the ‘free will’ argument to suit their view, and in other situations they’ll turn away and attack their upbringing.

Call it what it is and don’t by shy about it. There is a reason the home is central to the Catholic life (morally, socially, spiritually, intellectually). Yes, we have free will, but we are not some Kantian transcendental beings that are totally free from from our experiences - floating around liberally and making random choices amongst an infinite set of choices. That is just foolish if you ask me, and I think most of you recognise that. It is parenting itself that determines how a child behaves. If not, then please re-write history and philosophy. Our home is where we are rooted - it provides us with options. Thus, for some, drugs are not an option. Not in the metaphysical sense - but in the sense that somebody says “I would never do it, it just isn’t an option, I wasn’t brought up that way”. Sure, we are all capable of making mistakes, but mistake is a word that always refers to the past. Thus, upon looking back, upon learning some new information, we realise a mistake. Had the option not been there, had the thought that it was okay not been there, it wouldn’t have happened.

Sure, nobody is a perfect parent. And sure, children have free will. But if you claim that parenting is not absolutely and unbelievably causal in behaviour you need to check yourself because you are not being honest. Often times we play the role of psychologist when we see the bigger picture. We say “Hmmm, his Father never hugged him, it explains why he is afraid of commitment and intimacy”. Whether this is a true and proper assessment is questionable - but what is without question is the role that parents play in choices. Free will cannot be applied as if we are totally separate from our ends, experiences and upbringing. It is within the context of LIFE that we HAVE choice. And at the ages of 0-18 (mostly) our life is almost entirely our HOME.

For example, I made “mistakes” too. But I never made the sexual mistakes, just the alcohol ones. Why? Well, I am not sure but I know it has to do with my parents. Conversely, my best friend has no alcohol related mistakes, but has a variety of sexual ones. Why? Again, he knows its parent related. At one point or another, at one time, I agree that we cannot trace our behaviour entirely to our parents (though, I believe in actual fact, we can) because then we’d probably go into some infinite series regressing until Adam and Eve. But at the age of childhood (0-18) I think parents play a monumental role.

Sure, parents can be nice. Parents can be horrible. Parents can be this or that. But those attributes in some sense are the ones that are transcendental - what matters is the EFFECTIVENESS of the parenting in bringing up a child. For different people that might mean different things - for a Christian, a Jew, an Atheist it surely will mean different things. What is the same are the things that don’t matter - the niceness, the horribleness etc. What I am getting at is this - parents (i.e. some on this thread) justify their effectiveness by these contingent and unnecessary things. So for a man who is spoilt, his mother will say “But I was kind”. We then ask “But was that effective? How did you express that kindness?”.

It is hard to be a parent I am sure. But it is also hard to be a child. And unfortunately you bring a child into the world and you are expected (by society, yourself and God) to do an EFFECTIVE job.
What I find most interesting in your post is that nowhere do you offer any advice to the OP’s daughter. Aren’t you a young man, a college student and single? Do you have any opinion or thoughts about what you would think or say if the OP’s daughter was someone you were considering marrying and they needed to talk to you about their sexual past? But instead you offer a whole theory on parenting, you missed your opportunity to help the OP and their daughter, instead your post came off as a condemnation on the OP’s parenting skills.
 
I quite frankly am very sorry I even started this thread.
I don’t know if anything I could have done differently would have prevented my daughter’s regrettable choices. You don’t think I haven’t already asked myself that a thousand times? Do you think I haven’t prayed and wept before God over this? Good Lord, why do you think I came looking for advice from a Catholic perspective? That’s right, because I’m the permissive pushover with lines of coke on the coffee table and condoms under the cabinet…give me a break. You are being extremely over-dramatic here. I am sure you have gone through turmoil. But the point of my post stands not in opposition to you, or as a criticism.
Am I a perfect mother? Absolutely not. Could I improve? Certainly. But, I have, to the best of my ability, raised my children in a Catholic environment and taught them right from wrong. God is a part of our DAILY lives. Period. I will take exception with anyone suggesting anything I did or ever said to my daughter somehow gave her a green light or even the remotest impression it was OK to make stupid, dangerous, immoral decisions at such a young age. Further, I have not ONCE said I didn’t take my responsibility as a parent seriously. Didn’t say you took your responsibility lightly or that you haven’t done your best. But objectively speaking your best might be different from the best. That is not a criticism, thats a reality that should actually be of help to you. There are many different ways people think and react - and once again I didn’t discount that.
News, you’ll note I’m still waiting for Nec5 to cite me his expertise in child psychology and/or adolescent development. Since he’s spouting off like such an expert in these matters, I think it only fair to ask him to prove this to us all. I’ll ask you to do the same, please. But I thought you came here for advice? This is not an experts only area - similarly you should expect credentials from every other poster. I offer an objective outlook and you suddenly want credentials. My credentials are that I have been a child, I am a son and I know people (and if its really necessary, my sister holds a masters degree in psychology - but thats not me)
Truly, this has given me absolute clarity on my daughter’s situation. By all means I will suggest she be entirely honest with any future suitor. Perhaps in doing so she will avoid the likes of a man like you or Nec5. You are over reacting.
Now, if you’ll both excuse me, I need to go get some sackcloth and ashes for my daughter and me.Over reacting
I am really sorry, but in my opinion you are over reacting. This thread is filled with white knights telling you what you want to hear and being absolute moral heroes. Give me a break. Every situation is different, every person is different. Nobody has the right to say “any man who cant accept sexual past is X Y and Z”.

I do feel for you, really, I do. But I agree with Nec5, and on my own I have certain views that may not sit pretty with you but that is life - and sometimes being a knight in shining armour telling you you are a sunflower doesn’t do good. It’s great that you are here saying you’ve done this and that, suffering etc - but I am sure your daughter has a different story to tell, and my advice then, is instead of trying to get a bunch of strangers to agree with you you speak to your daughter and go deep into your relationship.
What I find most interesting in your post is that nowhere do you offer any advice to the OP’s daughter. Aren’t you a young man, a college student and single? Do you have any opinion or thoughts about what you would think or say if the OP’s daughter was someone you were considering marrying and they needed to talk to you about their sexual past? But instead you offer a whole theory on parenting, you missed your opportunity to help the OP and their daughter, instead your post came off as a condemnation on the OP’s parenting skills.
What I find most interesting in your post is that you were perfectly happy speaking off-topic until now. Six pages in I don’t see my advice as particularly necessary or helpful, especially considering how divergent the thread has become.
 
I quite frankly am very sorry I even started this thread.
I don’t know if anything I could have done differently would have prevented my daughter’s regrettable choices. You don’t think I haven’t already asked myself that a thousand times? Do you think I haven’t prayed and wept before God over this? Good Lord, why do you think I came looking for advice from a Catholic perspective? That’s right, because I’m the permissive pushover with lines of coke on the coffee table and condoms under the cabinet…give me a break. You are being extremely over-dramatic here. I am sure you have gone through turmoil. But the point of my post stands not in opposition to you, or as a criticism.
Am I a perfect mother? Absolutely not. Could I improve? Certainly. But, I have, to the best of my ability, raised my children in a Catholic environment and taught them right from wrong. God is a part of our DAILY lives. Period. I will take exception with anyone suggesting anything I did or ever said to my daughter somehow gave her a green light or even the remotest impression it was OK to make stupid, dangerous, immoral decisions at such a young age. Further, I have not ONCE said I didn’t take my responsibility as a parent seriously. Didn’t say you took your responsibility lightly or that you haven’t done your best. But objectively speaking your best might be different from the best. That is not a criticism, thats a reality that should actually be of help to you. There are many different ways people think and react - and once again I didn’t discount that.
News, you’ll note I’m still waiting for Nec5 to cite me his expertise in child psychology and/or adolescent development. Since he’s spouting off like such an expert in these matters, I think it only fair to ask him to prove this to us all. I’ll ask you to do the same, please. But I thought you came here for advice? This is not an experts only area - similarly you should expect credentials from every other poster. I offer an objective outlook and you suddenly want credentials. My credentials are that I have been a child, I am a son and I know people (and if its really necessary, my sister holds a masters degree in psychology - but thats not me)
Truly, this has given me absolute clarity on my daughter’s situation. By all means I will suggest she be entirely honest with any future suitor. Perhaps in doing so she will avoid the likes of a man like you or Nec5. You are over reacting.
Now, if you’ll both excuse me, I need to go get some sackcloth and ashes for my daughter and me.Over reacting
I am really sorry, but in my opinion you are over reacting. This thread is filled with white knights telling you what you want to hear and being absolute moral heroes. Give me a break. Every situation is different, every person is different. Nobody has the right to say “any man who cant accept sexual past is X Y and Z”.

I do feel for you, really, I do. But I agree with Nec5, and on my own I have certain views that may not sit pretty with you but that is life - and sometimes being a knight in shining armour telling you you are a sunflower doesn’t do good. It’s great that you are here saying you’ve done this and that, suffering etc - but I am sure your daughter has a different story to tell, and my advice then, is instead of trying to get a bunch of strangers to agree with you you speak to your daughter and go deep into your relationship.
What I find most interesting in your post is that nowhere do you offer any advice to the OP’s daughter. Aren’t you a young man, a college student and single? Do you have any opinion or thoughts about what you would think or say if the OP’s daughter was someone you were considering marrying and they needed to talk to you about their sexual past? But instead you offer a whole theory on parenting, you missed your opportunity to help the OP and their daughter, instead your post came off as a condemnation on the OP’s parenting skills.
What I find most interesting in your post is that you were perfectly happy speaking off-topic until now. Six pages in I don’t see my advice as particularly necessary or helpful, especially considering how divergent the thread has become. Especially since the majority are actually just speaking as if anybody with different opinions is a monster etc etc etc.
 
40.png
NewsTheMan:
For example, I made “mistakes” too. But I never made the sexual mistakes, just the alcohol ones. Why? Well, I am not sure but I know it has to do with my parents. Conversely, my best friend has no alcohol related mistakes, but has a variety of sexual ones. Why? Again, he knows its parent related. At one point or another, at one time, I agree that we cannot trace our behaviour entirely to our parents (though, I believe in actual fact, we can) because then we’d probably go into some infinite series regressing until Adam and Eve. But at the age of childhood (0-18) I think parents play a monumental role.
My brother and I are one year apart. both grew up with the same parents, same rules, our parents knew what we were doing, same work ethic (on a farm), lots of joy in the house, discipline was always present, went to mass/confession regularly, said the family rosaries together, etc. etc. I think our parents did a great job. I have been blessed, he has gotten into trouble again and again. So how do you trace our different behavior to our parents?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top