Nec5 - I didn’t want to join in but I see you are under attack. I am on your “side” buddy.
It’s pretty funny that in certain situations people will start throwing out the ‘free will’ argument to suit their view, and in other situations they’ll turn away and attack their upbringing.
Call it what it is and don’t by shy about it. There is a reason the home is central to the Catholic life (morally, socially, spiritually, intellectually). Yes, we have free will, but we are not some Kantian transcendental beings that are totally free from from our experiences - floating around liberally and making random choices amongst an infinite set of choices. That is just foolish if you ask me, and I think most of you recognise that. It is parenting itself that determines how a child behaves. If not, then please re-write history and philosophy. Our home is where we are rooted - it provides us with options. Thus, for some, drugs are not an option. Not in the metaphysical sense - but in the sense that somebody says “I would never do it, it just isn’t an option, I wasn’t brought up that way”. Sure, we are all capable of making mistakes, but mistake is a word that always refers to the past. Thus, upon looking back, upon learning some new information, we realise a mistake. Had the option not been there, had the thought that it was okay not been there, it wouldn’t have happened.
Sure, nobody is a perfect parent. And sure, children have free will. But if you claim that parenting is not absolutely and unbelievably causal in behaviour you need to check yourself because you are not being honest. Often times we play the role of psychologist when we see the bigger picture. We say “Hmmm, his Father never hugged him, it explains why he is afraid of commitment and intimacy”. Whether this is a true and proper assessment is questionable - but what is without question is the role that parents play in choices. Free will cannot be applied as if we are totally separate from our ends, experiences and upbringing. It is within the context of LIFE that we HAVE choice. And at the ages of 0-18 (mostly) our life is almost entirely our HOME.
For example, I made “mistakes” too. But I never made the sexual mistakes, just the alcohol ones. Why? Well, I am not sure but I know it has to do with my parents. Conversely, my best friend has no alcohol related mistakes, but has a variety of sexual ones. Why? Again, he knows its parent related. At one point or another, at one time, I agree that we cannot trace our behaviour entirely to our parents (though, I believe in actual fact, we can) because then we’d probably go into some infinite series regressing until Adam and Eve. But at the age of childhood (0-18) I think parents play a monumental role.
Sure, parents can be nice. Parents can be horrible. Parents can be this or that. But those attributes in some sense are the ones that are transcendental - what matters is the EFFECTIVENESS of the parenting in bringing up a child. For different people that might mean different things - for a Christian, a Jew, an Atheist it surely will mean different things. What is the same are the things that don’t matter - the niceness, the horribleness etc. What I am getting at is this - parents (i.e. some on this thread) justify their effectiveness by these contingent and unnecessary things. So for a man who is spoilt, his mother will say “But I was kind”. We then ask “But was that effective? How did you express that kindness?”.
It is hard to be a parent I am sure. But it is also hard to be a child. And unfortunately you bring a child into the world and you are expected (by society, yourself and God) to do an EFFECTIVE job.