C
CDNowak
Guest
It isn’t like we’re going to turn into Buddhists or something, because we use the word “emptying.”
Some have stumbled into that very trap: including monks, nuns, theologians, and priests. There is false contemplation, false mysticism, just as there is false humility. From my reading on Cistercian and American religious history while in a monastery, I can tell you that there were monks and entire communities that failed through seeking contemplation without progressing through meditation, and by forsaking the advice of more experienced monks.Note this is entirely Catholic. Silent prayer is not dangerous; of course the prayer form that the CCC says is what prayer “should” lead to is a prime target for misconceptions. Think about it; it’s important to the enemy to prevent people from discovering contemplative prayer forms that invite contemplation, that bring us into true union with God.
Personally I have seen too many people discouraged or burn out from seeking an “instant mysticism”. They go on a retreat, hear something (perhaps completely orthodox) about contemplation, and seek to live the spiritual life of the mystics without training. I’d sooner let someone with no physical training run a marathon, then to let those completely ignorant of the Spiritual path walk it alone. (And I am not saying that I am a fit guide by any means.)
It is very important to note that the Eastern religions mean completely different things than the Church does, and for the most part the world uses the Eastern meaning. ‘Emptying’ means just that, not the filling with God that displaces self. This is why a novice in the ways of prayer **must **be guided. Even the Carmelites had Spiritual Directors, nor did they say they were unnecessary, only that if someone was given the grace of contemplation that they should have an Director who had experienced it themselves, or at least had a sense of discernment not to quash the legitimate movement of the Spirit.