Question on different forms of prayer

  • Thread starter Thread starter Oumashta
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
It isn’t like we’re going to turn into Buddhists or something, because we use the word “emptying.”
Note this is entirely Catholic. Silent prayer is not dangerous; of course the prayer form that the CCC says is what prayer “should” lead to is a prime target for misconceptions. Think about it; it’s important to the enemy to prevent people from discovering contemplative prayer forms that invite contemplation, that bring us into true union with God.
Some have stumbled into that very trap: including monks, nuns, theologians, and priests. There is false contemplation, false mysticism, just as there is false humility. From my reading on Cistercian and American religious history while in a monastery, I can tell you that there were monks and entire communities that failed through seeking contemplation without progressing through meditation, and by forsaking the advice of more experienced monks.

Personally I have seen too many people discouraged or burn out from seeking an “instant mysticism”. They go on a retreat, hear something (perhaps completely orthodox) about contemplation, and seek to live the spiritual life of the mystics without training. I’d sooner let someone with no physical training run a marathon, then to let those completely ignorant of the Spiritual path walk it alone. (And I am not saying that I am a fit guide by any means.)

It is very important to note that the Eastern religions mean completely different things than the Church does, and for the most part the world uses the Eastern meaning. ‘Emptying’ means just that, not the filling with God that displaces self. This is why a novice in the ways of prayer **must **be guided. Even the Carmelites had Spiritual Directors, nor did they say they were unnecessary, only that if someone was given the grace of contemplation that they should have an Director who had experienced it themselves, or at least had a sense of discernment not to quash the legitimate movement of the Spirit.
 
  1. The CCC says prayer SHOULD go further than meditation into prayer that is union with God. (CCC 2708)
  2. The CCC says that contemplative prayer IS accessible to all. (CCC 2710)
  3. It’s always a good idea to have a spiritual director.
  4. Let’s not make sitting in silence, inviting the Lord into our hearts, into a scary thing. If that’s what we’re going to do we should tell the OP to pack it in. Stick with the Rosary and don’t go any further. Also we should warn those who go to Eucharistic adoration to remain mentally active and not sit silently in front of the Eucharist lest we catch something “Eastern” from the experience.
Alan
 
From my reading . . .
Do you have experience with infused prayer? Mystical graces? The passive nights? Not asking you to answer . . . just think about it yourself.
(And I am not saying that I am a fit guide by any means.)
Then why are you interjecting yourself?
It is very important to note that the Eastern religions mean completely different things than the Church does . . . .
Straw man . . . who is saying otherwise? 🙂 Careful reading would show all comments thusfar are grounded in the teaching of the Carmelite masters as well as other works like “The Cloud of Unknowing.”
Even the Carmelites had Spiritual Directors, nor did they say they were unnecessary, only that if someone was given the grace of contemplation that they should have an Director who had experienced it themselves, or at least had a sense of discernment not to quash the legitimate movement of the Spirit.
I am a Carmelite . . . and I am responsible for guiding souls in these matters 🙂 And, yes, what I do see in your comments is a quashing of the Spirit. 🙂

CD - I don’t know you from apple butter. But, as providence would have it, in this last week I’ve stumbled on two . . . and only two . . . of your posts. In both you seem to trash the entire Carmelite order (forgive me if I read you wrong). Worse you use weasle words like “resemble” heretics and “hard to distinquish them from” heretics.

CD, I’m trying my best to give you the benefit of the doubt and trust you are an honest seeker with good intentions . . . but we’re off to a rocky start 🙂 I’m willing to meet you half way to address any concerns you might have. Perhaps a PM would be best if you feel so inclined.

My best to you,
Dave 🙂
 
I posted this a few weeks ago, and the imagery is worth repeating. Oddly enough, Fr. Dubay just repeated this segment on Monday morning this week.

I saw a program last week that had a really good analogy (Fr. Dubay, perhaps?) He gave us a word picture of a pitcher in a baseball game winding up and getting ready to throw the ball. All the while, the catcher is in a mode of “active” receptance, silent, waiting, attentive, thinking nothing, but being alert to what the pitcher is doing, and quietly watching for his pitch. His receptiveness is very “active” – although quietly doing nothing, he is strongly focused.
 
Do you have experience with infused prayer? Mystical graces? The passive nights? Not asking you to answer . . . just think about it yourself.
No, I have not been given the grace, but I do have more knowledge of the subject and am trying to present to the OP the more cautious stance taken by St Ignatius, St Francis DeSales, and others.
40.png
CDNowak:
(And I am not saying that I am a fit guide by any means.)
Then why are you interjecting yourself?
Because this is not is not gnosticism. I do not need to be fully initiated to recognize that many who attempt to achieve contemplation without an experienced guide have been led astray. I don’t know how I can make that central point in each of my posts any clearer.
I am a Carmelite . . . and I am responsible for guiding souls in these matters 🙂 And, yes, what I do see in your comments is a quashing of the Spirit. 🙂
CD - I don’t know you from apple butter. But, as providence would have it, in this last week I’ve stumbled on two . . . and only two . . . of your posts. In both you seem to trash the entire Carmelite order (forgive me if I read you wrong). Worse you use weasle words like “resemble” heretics and “hard to distinquish them from” heretics.
I am sorry if I gave the impression of being critical of the entire order in this thread. It is the mystical theology of its great saints that I have concerns about, and despite my personal reaction, I acknowledge that the Church has found the writings sufficiently far from Quietism.

The OP, possibly a catechumen, perhaps not even that, has been googling ‘contemplation’ and ‘mental prayer’. The vast majority of the sites on these topics are not Christian, let alone orthodox in their handling of the subject. The difference in language is a serious one that should not be downplayed any such case.

The warnings of Sts John and Therese regarding “learned men” and spiritual directors who quash the Spirit by “insist[ing] individuals *return *to meditation” are not regarding the guidance of novices to this way of prayer, but those who already have been given the grace of contemplation. I do not feel I am going too far by encouraging a novice to test all spirits. I certainly don’t think I am helping “the enemy to prevent people from discovering contemplative prayer forms that invite contemplation, that bring us into true union with God,” as another poster put it. (The final clause in that quote has some serious issues, but that is another post).

For some reason I find smilies interspersed among barbs rather off-putting. They give the impression that the poster is taking a rather condescending attitude.
 
Hello CDNowak -

Sorry for the offense . . . no condecension at all. Smiling is just my personality. I suppose, though, that doesn’t come through over the internet.

Caution is fine and no one is counseling “going without a guide” so I’m not sure where that’s coming from. In fact, I’ve been around these forums many years and have spoken ad nauseum myself with regard to the “readiness” for such things . . . specifically St. John’s three signs for forgoing meditation.

But what I don’t understand is the quick linkage of what is being said to things like gnosticism, quietism etc. Of course all are concerned about the OP . . . but don’t you see everyone directing her to sources like the Carmelite Doctors, CCC or other works like “The Cloud of Unknowing” as opposed to more questionable sources?

Again, nothing wrong with caution . . . but it makes me a bit sad coming so forcefully from someone who admits no personal experience. It appears more like fear and mistrust . . . and that is unfortunate because it can scare off those truly called to infused prayer.

That having been said, though, you do make some good points the OP and other readers should weigh in their own discernment.

Again my best to you,
Dave.
 
What if a person has been utilizing the Divine Office for years because of a burning desire to Praise God at all times and to help sanctify the ordinary moments of each day, BUT now, through pentrating more deeply into the teachings on Contemplative Prayer, and realizing that such praise may be even better offered to God by praying at All times, but through an interior silence of the heart brought about by Infused Prayer, instead of through the LOH. Does one then forsake formal prayer times such as those of the LOH to move into the Unceasing Prayer of the Heart, and let go of scheduled prayer times? :confused:
 
Does one then forsake formal prayer times such as those of the LOH to move into the Unceasing Prayer of the Heart, and let go of scheduled prayer times?
No. In the Dialogue of St. Catherine of Siena, Our Lord directed her with regard to the LOTH, that it should never be willingly omitted. It is liturgical prayer, the prayer of the whole church. Many lay persons such as DBT who are professed in Secular Third Orders, commit themselves to praying this daily through formal promises.

The exception might be, as explained in the Dialogue, those times when Our Lord visits the soul in a manifest presence when one is praying the rosary or other “informal” prayer that is not obligatory. It would be an affront to Him to continue saying the rosary and refuse admittance to His Sacred Presence, thinking we have to finish it first. The rosary can always be concluded later.
 
But what I don’t understand is the quick linkage of what is being said to things like gnosticism, quietism etc.
Gnoticism only came up because a lack of direct experience is given as an obstacle to “injecting” oneself into the discussion. The implied reliance on esoteric teaching, apart from being foreign to Catholicism, only serves to make my point about the necessity of direction.
Again, nothing wrong with caution . . . but it makes me a bit sad coming so forcefully from someone who admits no personal experience. It appears more like fear and mistrust . . . and that is unfortunate because it can scare off those truly called to infused prayer.
I can’t understand the reaction to my initial post at all, particulary from people who “don’t know [me] from apple butter”. I devoted a handful of words to cautions that we all agree on (having a Catholic understanding of the terms used), gave the reason why there is a negative reaction to a particular term (one that I admit to sharing). And, because the only mention of a director was warnings *against *them, I stressed the importance of Spiritual Direction.

As thanks, one poster implies that I am an agent of Satan, and another conflates the objective statement regarding the popular understanding of emptying and quietism in one thread with a subjective issue in another thread. (Admittedly the only two posts out of ~1300 of mine said poster ever read). I admit that is going to make me much more forceful because, even had I previously agreed with these posters, their rash judgment would make me reconsider how responsible their postings on the subject matter were.
That having been said, though, you do make some good points the OP and other readers should weigh in their own discernment.
Thank you.

It is a good thing to remember that this is an anonymous internet forum, we should no more be giving spiritual direction than dispensing medical, legal, or psychological advice.
 
40.png
CDNowak:
Despite the warnings of St John of the Cross and St Therese, a spiritual director is essential as one is drawn into regular practice of meditation, particularly when one appears to be deliberately seeking the grace of contemplation.
Using meditation in prayer does not require a spiritual director. Good heavens, then everyone who reads scripture or does spiritual reading would need one. Your use of the term contemplation may be understood either as “acquired” or “infused.” If you are speaking about the former, the need of a director is not that urgent. It is clear that you are lacking understanding. Simply reading about contemplation does not qualify you to give advice when you have no experience of either form. If you did, you would not be asking the next question below.
A semi-rhetorical question: I do wonder if the contemplation described by the Carmelites is not the ecstasies and/or raptures described by the biographers of many saints?
Just a word to the wise about Dave (DBT) … there are none so qualified to speak about this experience. If I were you, I’d spend some time reading his past posts over the last six years, for he has been a wonderful asset to this forum and is one whom I would trust explicitly with any questions concerning the works of our Carmelite saints and their mystical experience. IOW, he walks the walk.
 
I can’t understand the reaction to my initial post at all, particulary from people who “don’t know [me] from apple butter”
CDNowak -

Maybe it would help to put yourself in readers shoes when you paint with such broad strokes (ie, Carmelites and quietism). And actually read what people are saying when they attempt to explain a controversial term like “emptying” from a Catholic perspective.

I suspect you have much good to say . . . and I hope to hear it! But for now at least what you have to say is getting lost in all the lashing out. For my part, I’ve apolgized once for hurting your feelings . . . and I do so again.

Can we move on now?

The Peace of Christ be with you,
Dave.
 
Another one? sigh
Using meditation in prayer does not require a spiritual director. Good heavens, then everyone who reads scripture or does spiritual reading would need one. Your use of the term contemplation may be understood either as “acquired” or “infused.” If you are speaking about the former, the need of a director is not that urgent. It is clear that you are lacking understanding.
You are correct, I have not an overabundance of the Gift of Understanding; Knowledge, perhaps, maybe even Counsel, Fear of the Lord, and Fortitude. Pray for me that I may grow in those that I lack.

Perhaps I need to be more direct with the extent of what I know and how I know it? I spent time in a Cistercian monastery, and left overmuch to my own devices, I delved into acetic and mystical theory. As a result I am versed in the more ancient approach to the acetic science, the long history of conflict between the mystical art and acetic and theological sciences, and the general approaches of some of the major orders.

The Desert Fathers emphasized quiet strongly that the way of perfection (acetic and mystical life) was not a solitary path, but one that required submitting oneself to a Father for training and guidance. This was not limited to their advice for the monks, but to the laity as well. This tradition was continued by the monastic orders (East and West), and was practiced among the laity. St Francis de Sales “Introduction to the Devout Life” was originally a series of conferences for a lay woman.

Historically, Mystics and Acetics walked a fine line in reconciling fidelity to the Church with their experiences. The ubiquitous practice of spiritual direction helped temper this tension. (St Faustina records her struggles with this rather well). In Spain, at the time of Sts John of the Cross and Theresa, there was more tension as the Inquisition was extremely cautious regarding anything that deviated from the normal extent of the Spiritual life. The comments regarding Spiritual directors posted by DBT, then came about in the most unfortunate of climates. Today the desire for mystical experience is great, much greater than the availability of good directors.

With the structured methods of meditation, (such as: Lectio, Ignatian) there need for less intense direction, as the choice of text itself provides a good deal of control. The acetic and mystical practices, however, along with the affective meditation of certain Franciscans, requires a more experienced, studied guide, capable of discerning hearts and spirits.

I know of none of the Orthodox or Catholic Fathers who did not hold that a spiritual director was necessary, particularly for those who wished to advance beyond meditation. “By no vice does the devil draw a monk headlong and bring him to death sooner than by persuading him to neglect the counsel of the Elders and trust to his own judgment and determination” ~Cassian. In fact I would recommend the entire article on the subject of Spiritual Direction at New Advent.
 
The problem with spiritual directors is that there are hardly any who have the gift; if they have the gift, they haven’t the time. One big difference I note in reading the classics of the 15th century saints is that books were unavailable to those desiring to grow in prayer, perfection and virtue. That is probably why St. Francis de Sales wrote his Intro, and even then, books on spirituality were scarce. Not so today.

I know a person who was receiving mystical gifts of contemplative prayer and recalled the admonition of certain saints to seek spiritual direction. Because it was a lay person, the assumption was that the clergy would know of it experientially and be able to give counsel. Not so. To the utter astonishment of this person, even though the Bishop’s office recommended the priest, he knew not how to direct with respect to the gifts of grace being received.

Fortunately, little by little with the help of the Holy Spirit, and reading these treatises by the Carmelites et al, the matter became very clear. We ought not to think that Our Lord, Who graciously gives Himself to souls in intimate union, will fail to become a good teacher and help this soul advance. St. Therese, by the way, had NO spiritual director, and learned all her wisdom in prayer, scripture, and the works of St. John of the Cross.

Edit: I might add, St. Therese, without any S.D., became a Doctor of the Church, for her writings were so eminently gifted to teach others her little way to Jesus.
 
Maybe it would help to put yourself in readers shoes when you paint with such broad strokes (ie, Carmelites and quietism). And actually read what people are saying when they attempt to explain a controversial term like “emptying” from a Catholic perspective.
Can I make the same suggestion regarding reading? I did not put Carmelites and quietism together in this thread, because that has little to do with this thread. If you wish to discuss the other thread, it was on the bottom of the second page this morning.

I expressed why people are wary of the term ‘emptying’, with no comment on what others had said, and in essential agreement with what everyone has said regarding the different use of terminology.

I am not trying to lash out, defend my good name perhaps. I do tend to come on strong to people who are more emotionally invested, for that I apologize. Rest assured,you have not hurt my feelings in anyway (it takes a good deal more to do that). It would be nice however, if people responded, as sirach did, to what I wrote. (BTW, Sirach, I do owe you an apology, as to the extent that you replied to what I wrote you deserved less of the heavy handed response)
Can we move on now?
If we can leave things in the proper threads, we might.
 
First of all I have to apologize for the previous heavy-handed response.
The problem with spiritual directors is that there are hardly any who have the gift; if they have the gift, they haven’t the time. One big difference I note in reading the classics of the 15th century saints is that books were unavailable to those desiring to grow in prayer, perfection and virtue. That is probably why St. Francis de Sales wrote his Intro, and even then, books on spirituality were scarce. Not so today.
I myself am not a huge fan of spiritual direction (surprise!), in part because it is hard to find any priest who is capable of it particularly for cases such as natural acetics (like myself) or mystics (not me). From experience books are a poor substitute, you can learn the science but little of the art.

In many cases we have to make do, but that is no reason not to try to find solid direction. For those like the OP who may be starting down the way of perfection, a priest can at least guide through the beginning stages.
 
In many cases we have to make do, but that is no reason not to try to find solid direction. For those like the OP who may be starting down the way of perfection, a priest can at least guide through the beginning stages.
Agreed. 🙂

Sirach2 mentioned the role of the Holy Spirit as our ultimate director, particularily with regard to infused graces, and to this I also heartily agree. He who unites Himself with souls so closely will not leave them without resources. As demonstrated in the latter stanzas of “Spiritual Canticle” and the entirety of “Living Flame of Love,” the Holy Spirit comes to us and teaches in a very direct and personal way.

And until we reach that point, some of the most charming comments both Sts. John and Teresa make is how the Holy Spirit will often lead us to souls capable of helping out with just the right word of encouragement or pointing us to the proper teaching to clarify a troubling matter . . . even if only in an informal way.

And I have witnessed that first hand more times than I can count. 🙂

Dave 🙂
 
40.png
DBT:
And until we reach that point, some of the most charming comments both Sts. John and Teresa make is how the Holy Spirit will often lead us to souls capable of helping out with just the right word of encouragement or pointing us to the proper teaching to clarify a troubling matter . . . even if only in an informal way.
This brought back a pleasant reflection on St. Teresa’s meeting with St. Peter of Alcantara who dispelled a lot of her doubts, and even after his death, appeared to her with help in her foundations. Wasn’t he the one who influenced her so powerfully with regard to founding in poverty? He had lived his own advice. There is nothing so influential as “experience.” 😉

Interesting, too, that she knew both St. Francis Borgia and St. Francis de Sales. I wonder how many elbows we rub in our lifetime with real honest to goodness saints?
 
Incidently, CDNowak, it’s very interesting you mentioned the role of asceticism . . . for the times I’ve seen contemplative souls go most astry is when they try and divorce the ascetic from the mystic. For example, I’ve seen this several times with souls very attached to the imaginative visions, private revelations or locutions they’ve recieved . . . yet they are entirely resistent to proper teaching on how we are to respond to such things. They follow their own light . . . the false mystic.

And, on another front, it’s from the perspective of asceticism that I’ve made much of my earlier comments regarding “emptying.” What some readers might not be aware of is there is a very spiritual form of asceticism St. John of the Cross teaches in the context of the active night of the spirit. Specifically, the work we do (guided by grace) to conform our thoughts and feelings to His holy will.

For those interested, I share this key passage . . .
St. John of the Cross:
Ch 15. Which sets down the general method whereby the spiritual person must govern himself with respect to this sense (the purification of memory in hope).

In order to conclude this discussion on the memory, it will be well at this point to give the spiritual reader an account of the method which he must observe, and which is of universal application, in order that he may be united with God according to this sense. For, although what has been said makes the subject quite clear, it will nevertheless be more easily apprehended if we summarize it here.

To this end it must be remembered that, since our aim is the union of the soul with God in hope, according to the memory, and since that which is hoped for is that which is not possessed, and since, the less we possess of other things, the greater scope and the greater capacity have we for hoping, and consequently the greater hope, therefore, the more things we possess, the less scope and capacity is there for hoping, and consequently the less hope have we.

Hence, the more the soul dispossesses the memory of forms and things which may be recalled by it, which are not God, the more will it set its memory upon God, and the emptier will its memory become, so that it may hope for Him Who shall fill it. **What must be done, then, that the soul may live in the perfect and pure hope of God is that, whensoever these distinct images, forms and ideas come to it (our thoughts and feelings), it must not rest in them, but must turn immediately to God, voiding the memory of them entirely, with loving affection.

It must neither think of these things nor consider them beyond the degree which is necessary for the understanding and performing of its obligations, if they have any concern with these. And this it must do without setting any affection or inclination upon them, so that they may produce no effects in the soul.**

And thus a man must not fail to think and recall that which he ought to know and do, for, provided he preserves no affection or attachments, this will do him no harm. For this matter the lines of the Mount, which are in the thirteenth chapter of the first book, will be of profit.
This habitual redirecting of our thoughts and feelings . . . away from an interior monologue with self . . . to an interior dialogue with God is one meaning I give for how emptying and filling might be conceived in an orthodox Catholic context. This passage, in particular, summarizes very nicely the theological underpinnings behind all the great texts on recollection including “The Cloud of Unknowing,” “Third Spiritual Alphabet” and “The Practice of the Presence of God.”

The other meaning of emptying/filling I tried to convey is in the context of St. Teresa’s teaching on the suspension of the faculties as prayer progresses from meditation to the prayer of simplicity and, ultimately, to the infused states of quiet and union. This slowing down of mental activity . . . relying less and less on “images, forms and ideas” for the simple gaze and loving attentivness of silent love . . . seems to me, in an experiential way, that of an emptying of self (in the form of thoughts and feelings) and a filling with God (in simple presence).

And, in a much broader sense, I see the interplay of asceticism and mysticism in this very same light. Our efforts to deny ourselves through interior or exterior mortification (asceticism) is a kind of emptying . . . and the “loving inflow” of God in contemplation (mysticism) is a type of filling.

I spoke of these things only because the OP specificially mentioned that term in her opening post. My hope was that proper contexting of terminology would lead to understanding . . . and that fear of a controversial term need not hold one back once the proper meaning was conveyed. And, of course, as you say so well . . . the meaning of this type of emptying/filling is very different from eastern traditions.

And in all of this I don’t know if I failed or succeeded in what I set out to do. But I thought it good to speak one more time on the subject in the hope we are in essential agreement as I think you are saying.

Dave 🙂
 
Originally by DBT
And, in a much broader sense, I see the interplay of asceticism and mysticism in this very same light. Our efforts to deny ourselves through interior or exterior mortification (asceticism) is a kind of emptying . . . and the “loving inflow” of God in contemplation (mysticism) is a type of filling.
Dave, as you mentioned about denying ourselves, asceticism is necessary for our efforts toward holiness. Without true holiness, true union with God is not likely to come. We discussed in another thread a while ago - mysticism without asceticism is a shame.

You know I am not a Carmelite. But I am familiar with contemplation in Carmelite sense. By the leading of the Holy Spirit, I have received certain degree of infused contemplation and only to find out later my experience was explained by St. John’s and St. Teresa’s teaching. That proves God himself does lead souls into contemplation.

Mysticism itself is not a goal to seek, holiness is. Therefore, I believe spiritual direction is good for everyone. Spiritual direction is to make saints. And we are all called to be saints. When one becomes a saint, there is true union with God. Without seeking mysticism, mysticism arrives. During the past a few years, two spiritual directors of mine have helped me grow in holiness. None of my directors is a mystic; regardless, they helped me move forward in my journey with the Lord. It’s not that I’ve reached holiness, but spiritual direction keeps me on the right track. Without guide, my work in process may slow down.

(Contemplation in the Ignatian sense is more imaginative reflection. People practice Ignatius spirituality also call it contemplation.)
 
40.png
InLight247:
Mysticism itself is not a goal to seek, holiness is.
Very true. When a person’s life is examined for canonization, the Church does not look into their mysticism, but makes the pronouncement of sainthood based on the heroic degree with which they practiced the theological virtues of faith, hope and charity, and the four cardinal virtues.

OTOH, I trust the promise Jesus made in Jn. 14:21: “He who has My commandments and keeps them, it is he who loves Me. And he who loves Me will be loved by My Father, and I will love him and manifest myself to him." Whether the degree of manifestation is intensely mystical or simply gratuitous consolation, the lover and beloved will KNOW one another.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top