Question on sacramentals

[SighGuy]

Specifically those kinds which are objects. Holy water, scapular, blessed medal, etc…
[Edit: as I continue to read, it appears the better word for these things are devotional objects, and sacramentals refers more to the rites of blessing that go into them]

As far as I understand, these sacramentals do not give us grace on their own power-- that would be magic. They help us to be more receptive to grace, I suppose, and maybe even warrant greater graces for us by the devotion with which we use them. Such that, one who used them carelessly would most likely receive no benefit (lest it be God’s intent to surprise them and thus convert them). Correct me here if I am wrong.

My question is, do they protect us from evil regardless of the disposition of the one in possession of them? Such that, one who does not necessarily have faith but treats them as magic charms will still receive some protection against demonic influence, regardless of their lack of faith?

Thanks. All the better if you can provide any kind of reference, but any (name removed by moderator)ut is appreciated.

 

[eggsbenedictine]

“As far as I understand, these sacramentals do not give us grace on their own power-- that would be magic.” I think you answered your own question.

 

[SighGuy]

I certainly see your meaning. I just wondered if this was different.

By way of loose analogy, a fire can help us read by virtue of the light it sheds, although the actual reading is up to us-- it does not cause us to read. Yet despite the disposition of one sitting next to the fire, to read or not to read, it still keeps wild animals at bay.

Poor analogy. But I’m sure it gets across what I’m wondering.

 

[pianistclare]

I certainly see your meaning. I just wondered if this was different.

By way of loose analogy, a fire can help us read by virtue of the light it sheds, although the actual reading is up to us-- it does not cause us to read. Yet despite the disposition of one sitting next to the fire, to read or not to read, it still keeps wild animals at bay.

Poor analogy. But I’m sure it gets across what I’m wondering.

Exorcists use the Crucifix in their battle with the devil. But yeah, you answered your own question.