Really? filling sandbags?

  • Thread starter Thread starter otrrl
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
O

otrrl

Guest
Well, there’s another hurricane heading for Florida (Michael) and the nightly news shows people filling sandbags BY HAND.

If anything needed to be done in a hurry I think it would be to fill a lot of sandbags. I just checked, and the (empty) bags are available at amazon, $2.60 each in lots of 10. (“hurry, supplies running low”)

Could somebody explain sandbags to me? Why do people wait until the last minute? Isn’t there a machine that could spit out 100 bags per minute, as compared to this slow method of doing it by hand?
 
I’m sure part of it is that we still don’t know a hurricane’s path up until about the last 18-24 hours of its track. And even then, even though you may know where the eye is going to hit, you don’t know how the rain will flood.

For example, I know plenty of people who were affected by Harvey. Up until the night before it hit landfall, it was like, “Yeah, this is no big deal. The storm is weakening.”

When it hit landfall, it was in Rockport, which is northeast of Corpus Christi.

I don’t know if any of my Corpus Christi friends were flooded, but my Houston friends were swamped, because they got 51" of rain out of it in just one weather event. The water couldn’t shed fast enough— and so it flooded, and flooded badly. So it wasn’t the storm per se; it was the storm just sitting and sitting and sitting and dumping a bazillion gallons of water all on the same geography.

Rockport to Houston is practically 200 miles away from each other.

A sandbag, if it’s overfilled, weighs about 70 lbs. A sandbag that’s filled properly weighs about 35-40 lbs. And you need, what? 20 sandbags for a single driveway? So that’s 800-1400 lbs of sand, minimum, for just one person. Do you think they’re going to keep them stockpiled and prefilled, just in case? What happens if you go for 30 years without needing to use them? What condition will they be in? 😛

I have seen portable flood barriers, though. Those seem to be pretty interesting. They look something like this:

a784d790b50e35ab3cf565d0c8a40710cd310db7.jpeg


But again— that’s presumably a pretty significant investment, even though I can’t find a cost online. People have enough trouble keeping a week’s worth of food and water in their house at any point in time, let alone buying a flood-protection device after, say, Hurricane Hugo in 1989, and then not needing it again until 1999 with Hurricane Floyd, and then perhaps Hurricane Joaquin in 2015. And that’s Charleston, where you’d expect people to be a bit more prudent than usual… 🙂
 
OK, I have a history of asking d*** questions - seriously. My other d*** question is why do people wait to the last minute to buy plywood, stock up on water, flashlights, batteries, etc.? But, I won’t ask it
 
A good machine is expensive, and would sit idle for possibly years, taking space in the garage.
 
Last edited:
Same answer. Weather events like hurricanes do not strike the same location with such frequency that one could predict the need for emergency supplies. While it is probably a good idea to have a stock of basics, like flashlights, it isn’t necessarily prudent to have all materials on hand just in case a hurricane hits. You could get hit 2 years in a row. You could get hit in 10yrs. You could never get hit.

Water goes bad, sandbags rot, plywood rots. Not everyone has room to store everything needed for the apocalypse either. And then people also just forget. Maybe you had spare batteries for an emergency, but you needed some for the TV remote and you didn’t want to run to the store that second. Then an emergency happens and you realize you haven’t got any batteries anymore.

IMO it is a good idea to keep an emergency kit ready, like flashlights, batteries, bottled water, 1st aid kit, etc. I generally keep a case of water on hand, then drink it up and replace it over time so it doesn’t just sit forever. Came in handy for Hurricane Matthew a few years ago. But I am not going to keep 10 sheets of plywood on hand.
 
I have a bunch of plywood, because of my biz— it’s 4x8 sheets of obnoxious heavy stuff that most people don’t have space to store, and you need a certain strength threshold to be able to wrangle the stuff single-handedly. The stuff I bought yesterday was about $30/sheet— but that was for 3/4ths-inch decking plywood for a garage roof, not the thinner stuff. If you want quarter-inch plywood, you’re still looking at about $20-$25 each for a 4x8 sheet. How many windows does your house have? Suppose you have a small house with ten windows. That’s still $200-$250 worth of plywood plus tax… so a lot of times, people don’t board up their houses until they know they’ll need to, because (a) that’s an expense they’d prefer to avoid until it’s critical, and (b) what do you do with all the plywood when the storm has passed?

Flashlights are good-- but often times, they’re used so infrequently, the batteries go bad before you need it again. And then the battery acid gets all over the innards. 🙂

Batteries are good-- but they use up energy so fast. I use rechargeable batteries for my kids’ video games-- I don’t know if they don’t hold energy as well as regular batteries, but it seems like I’m always charging those things, especially if they’ve just been sitting for a few days or weeks since their last use. I also have a baggie of assorted batteries. I bet some of them have been in that baggie for 10 years… I have no clue which ones work and which ones don’t, because I don’t normally rely on battery-operated anything.

Bottled water is good— but if you normally avoid it because plastic bottles are wasteful, it’s often not even on your radar until something happens to the city water supply.

First aid kits are awesome— but they need to be maintained. How many people keep sterile gauze dressings in their bathrooms as a matter of course, let alone know how to use them? How about eye dressings? 🙂 Versus the number of people who still have aspirin in their medicine chest from 1995? 😛

So, yeah. All those things are awesome and prudent things to be prepared about— but one size doesn’t fit all, either in terms of capacity (do you have a saw and an electric screwdriver and some 3" screws and a 12’ ladder to fasten plywood to your windows? where do you keep them? how often do you use them? how about your lumber?) or physical ability or financial ability or lifestyle or whatever.
 
Isn’t there a machine that could spit out 100 bags per minute, as compared to this slow method of doing it by hand?
When i was a young Airman I got “volunteered” to go fill sand bags. There was a machine that was supposed to make it easier but with any amount of moisture in the sand it would not flow into the bags. It was essentially a big hopper that let you hold a bag under it, open the bottom and a bag would fill easily. We ended up doing it by hand after it became obvious the machine was not working as it should.
 
A good machine is expensive, and would sit idle for possibly years, taking space in the garage.
Reminds me of a problem we have in Atlanta. There was a snowstorm in which some people got stuck in traffic and it took over 24 hours for many people to be able to drive home. Some people criticized the city for not having sufficient equipment to deal with snow; the city actually got help from some states further north. But Atlanta only sees snow once every few years, and only sees significant snow about 1.5 times per decade. It has been more cost effective to just shut things down when ever significant snow is coming.
 
One of my friends has an amazing snow-blower … and when he needed it … it wouldn’t start.
 
Sort of like a Southerner buying a snow plow. Sure, we get the freak snowstorm every decade or two, but unless you have plenty of spare money…
 
(Please Note: This uploaded content is no longer available.)
Hurricane Proof houses make more sense…
 
Also, it looks as if all the living is done on the second level, well above most flood damage.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top