Reasons I've found to return to the Catholic Church

  • Thread starter Thread starter Koineman
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
K

Koineman

Guest
I’m not quite there yet, but I thought I’d share some things that have come into sharper focus for me in the time that I’ve been reading about the Catholic Church, strengths that have really stood out to me clearly:

In all the time the Church has been in existence, it has successfully and steadfastly resisted corrupting influences from within Christianity. While some Protestant churches have been infiltrated by false teachers, resulting in further splits, the Catholic Church has not succumbed to corrupting teachings. They have held their teachings intact for the past 2,000 years. For example, they have not abandoned the doctrine of the Trinity, the deity of Christ, and their stand on the inspiration of Scripture–all highly important teachings.

Along the same lines, they consistently resist corruption from the world. I’m thinking here of their continued, unwavering stand against society’s pressures to condone homosexuality, abortion, and contraception. Many today are giving in to those pressures, but the Catholic Church has stood firm.

Then, of course, there are the problems with Sola Scriptura, i.e., since the Bible is itself a tradition, and therefore had to have come into existence through the Church, how can the Bible be the only infallible rule for Christian faith and practice?

There are still things I’m working through, particularly the big issue between Protestants and Catholics: salvation, particularly justification. That to me is a huge sticking point. I’ve found some help, though, in the posts at this blog: calledtocommunion.com and this one as well: principiumunitatis.blogspot.com/, not to mention some books I’ve been reading and others I plan to still read.

God bless you,

Jeremy
 
I’m not quite there yet, but I thought I’d share some things that have come into sharper focus for me in the time that I’ve been reading about the Catholic Church, strengths that have really stood out to me clearly:

In all the time the Church has been in existence, it has successfully and steadfastly resisted corrupting influences from within Christianity. While some Protestant churches have been infiltrated by false teachers, resulting in further splits, the Catholic Church has not succumbed to corrupting teachings. They have held their teachings intact for the past 2,000 years. For example, they have not abandoned the doctrine of the Trinity, the deity of Christ, and their stand on the inspiration of Scripture–all highly important teachings.

Along the same lines, they consistently resist corruption from the world. I’m thinking here of their continued, unwavering stand against society’s pressures to condone homosexuality, abortion, and contraception. Many today are giving in to those pressures, but the Catholic Church has stood firm.

Then, of course, there are the problems with Sola Scriptura, i.e., since the Bible is itself a tradition, and therefore had to have come into existence through the Church, how can the Bible be the only infallible rule for Christian faith and practice?

There are still things I’m working through, particularly the big issue between Protestants and Catholics: salvation, particularly justification. That to me is a huge sticking point. I’ve found some help, though, in the posts at this blog: calledtocommunion.com and this one as well: principiumunitatis.blogspot.com/, not to mention some books I’ve been reading and others I plan to still read.

God bless you,

Jeremy
Thanks for the post Jeremy. Keep learning what the Church has to say and thank you for taking the time to give it a fair and honest look no matter which direction you ultimately find yourself going in. God Bless.
 
You are well on your way on your lifetime journey of faith! I hope you consider joining an RCIA program this fall. It will answer your questions and help you sort out your concerns about Catholicism. Welcome Home. 👋
 
We’ve posted to each other and so I know something of your situation. I just wanted to assure you that I am still praying for you and pulling for you. God bless you. :crossrc:
 
I’m not quite there yet, but I thought I’d share some things that have come into sharper focus for me in the time that I’ve been reading about the Catholic Church, strengths that have really stood out to me clearly:
There are still things I’m working through, particularly the big issue between Protestants and Catholics: salvation, particularly justification.
 
Have you read The Salvation Controversy by James (aka Jimmy) Akin? I though it was pretty good, though it addresses mainly a certain kind of Protestant theology of justification which was not my own personal background in a sort of moderate-liberal Methodism.
 
Jeremy,

One book which I’ve read along the way which seemed to go into a lot of detail on Justification was ‘Return to Rome - Confessions of an Evangelical Catholic’ by Francis Beckwith. I’m not sure if you have read it or not.
 
I’m not quite there yet, but I thought I’d share some things that have come into sharper focus for me in the time that I’ve been reading about the Catholic Church, strengths that have really stood out to me clearly:

In all the time the Church has been in existence, it has successfully and steadfastly resisted corrupting influences from within Christianity. While some Protestant churches have been infiltrated by false teachers, resulting in further splits, the Catholic Church has not succumbed to corrupting teachings. They have held their teachings intact for the past 2,000 years. For example, they have not abandoned the doctrine of the Trinity, the deity of Christ, and their stand on the inspiration of Scripture–all highly important teachings.

Along the same lines, they consistently resist corruption from the world. I’m thinking here of their continued, unwavering stand against society’s pressures to condone homosexuality, abortion, and contraception. Many today are giving in to those pressures, but the Catholic Church has stood firm.

Then, of course, there are the problems with Sola Scriptura, i.e., since the Bible is itself a tradition, and therefore had to have come into existence through the Church, how can the Bible be the only infallible rule for Christian faith and practice?

There are still things I’m working through, particularly the big issue between Protestants and Catholics: salvation, particularly justification. That to me is a huge sticking point. I’ve found some help, though, in the posts at this blog: calledtocommunion.com and this one as well: principiumunitatis.blogspot.com/, not to mention some books I’ve been reading and others I plan to still read.

God bless you,

Jeremy
This blog is helpful for explaining justification. Wish you the best.
philvaz.com/apologetics/apolog.htm#SALVATION
 
Have you read The Salvation Controversy by James (aka Jimmy) Akin? I though it was pretty good, though it addresses mainly a certain kind of Protestant theology of justification which was not my own personal background in a sort of moderate-liberal Methodism.
I haven’t read it yet, but I plan to (just ordered it yesterday).
 
I personally am seriously considering becoming Catholic.

One of the reasons is that I have this feeling that the Roman Catholic Church is going to allow its members to behave much like Dr. Moses Coady did here in Nova Scotia, Canada. He got poor people together in cooperatives that profoundly altered the local economy!

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moses_Coady

Of all Christians groups, with few exceptions Catholics seem to be the most open to the possibility that the being of light who meets people at their death may well be none other than the God of Abraham/The Creator. Obviously many Catholics have noticed the possible relevance of Baruch 6:6:
[6] For my angel is with you: And I myself will demand an account of your souls.
I admit that I may be wrong but I have studied this subject extensively and I do feel that this being of light is indeed the Logos/Word, the God of the Jewish Bible?!
 
Another reason is that the leadership of the Catholic Church seem to have gotten their heads around the idea that we Christians do not have to attempt to change Jews around to our ways of thinking. Yes, we should be able to give a good answer for specifics on our beliefs but I don’t think that we need to push and shove and try to make people think like we do…Again I do admit that my sense of time may be off but I do know that the age when we do not have to teach each other is coming and coming fast!

Jeremiah 31:34
And they shall teach no more every man his neighbour, and every man his brother, saying, Know the LORD: for they shall all know me, from the least of them unto the greatest of them, saith the LORD: for I will forgive their iniquity, and I will remember their sin no more.
I admire both Pastor Ray Comfort and Pastor Kirk Cameron for their courage but it seems to me as if they are almost like actors playing a role that I often thank God that I don’t have to approach my religion quite as aggressively as they do?!

On the other hand Pastor Ray Comfort was greatly rewarded for his phenomenal courage by God giving him that amazing film:
180movie.com/

His courage and aggressive approach can indeed result in specific cases of a lost soul being saved from hell…so I admire him…but I still am glad that I don’t think that I have to be exactly like him!!!
 
Another reason is that the leadership of the Catholic Church seem to have gotten their heads around the idea that we Christians do not have to attempt to change Jews around to our ways of thinking. Yes, we should be able to give a good answer for specifics on our beliefs but I don’t think that we need to push and shove and try to make people think like we do…Again I do admit that my sense of time may be off but I do know that the age when we do not have to teach each other is coming and coming fast!

Jeremiah 31:34

I admire both Pastor Ray Comfort and Pastor Kirk Cameron for their courage but it seems to me as if they are almost like actors playing a role that I often thank God that I don’t have to approach my religion quite as aggressively as they do?!

On the other hand Pastor Ray Comfort was greatly rewarded for his phenomenal courage by God giving him that amazing film:
180movie.com/

Dennis,
There is only one reason to belong to any religion, which is if you believe and agree with all of the particular religion’s doctrines. If one were to join a church or religion and profess to be of that faith without agreeing with its precepts it would be hypocrtical. You can find many religions that will teach some things that sound attractive and with which you agree. Look for one whose teaching you can support completely.
God bless you on your journey.

His courage and aggressive approach can indeed result in specific cases of a lost soul being saved from hell…so I admire him…but I still am glad that I don’t think that I have to be exactly like him!!!
 
There are still things I’m working through, particularly the big issue between Protestants and Catholics: salvation, particularly justification. That to me is a huge sticking point.
Hi, and God bless you on your search for truth. Might I ask what is the huge sticking point, exactly? By huge, I take it to mean, a major impediment to salvation?
 
There are still things I’m working through, particularly the big issue between Protestants and Catholics: salvation, particularly justification. That to me is a huge sticking point.
Whose view of salvation do you like?
 
Koineman. you may want the thread on “Authority” which Linc started and is extensive, However, this topic comes up… oh, about 850 on the posts. They are talking about this now.

May help, I have no idea. It will give you perspective. I’m assuming your speaking on Justification by Faith Alone?

Peace
 
Hi, and God bless you on your search for truth. Might I ask what is the huge sticking point, exactly? By huge, I take it to mean, a major impediment to salvation?
It’s the issue of justification by faith alone vs. the Catholic view of ongoing justification and the role of works. I can understand the Catholic view on a certain level, but it is somewhat complicated.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top