Recently Got Engaged

  • Thread starter Thread starter Agatha813
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
What the heck is wrong with you people! You are totally proving what the OP said about you and this website is true. This is terrible. Who are you to call someone immature?

This is how you show the love of God? I am ashamed of this website at this moment.

I think almost everyone here is making this about money EXCEPT the OP. I notice people on this website jump to conclusions and judge people by what they read into their posts. It is really strange, as if you think you actually have met this person or are mind readers. Get a life and stop pretending like you are living someone else’s.

Okay - so now you can talk about what I said as if you really know me, which you don’t. So I don’t care. As long as you leave her alone, because it just really ticks me off that she is being judged.
Carol, I think you’re being a little over the top.

The OP said she doesn’t want to pay for a reception. She does want to pay for a honeymoon trip to Disneyworld. It’s fine to want a honeymoon to Disneyworld. That would be great, and a lot of fun. But a couple who invites people to their wedding, to celebrate with them, then doesn’t thank their guests, and then goes on an expensive wedding trip, is going to insult people. That’s the truth of it.

I can appreciate that it takes a long time to save up for a trip like that. But it is expected, when you invite people to celebrate with you, that you thank them for coming. The OP insinuated that that expectation is somehow a lack of proper understanding of our faith - rude in and of itself - and also false. If you invite people to a birthday party, you don’t have them come in the door, drop off their gift, sing you “Happy Birthday,” and then hustle them out the door. If you can’t afford to host them, you don’t invite them to your birthday party.

The bride and groom are free to have a wedding with no guests, even if they had the means for a reception for 500 with all the works. But if they want to invite people, they should show some way of thanking them, and there have been several excellent suggestions on this thread of how to do that without putting too much of a hit on the Disney fund.

I may have missed this, but has the OP actually asked anyone to help pitch in with the reception cost? Even if it’s just coffee and donuts in the church hall afterwards?
 
pensmama87 said:

“I may have missed this, but has the OP actually asked anyone to help pitch in with the reception cost? Even if it’s just coffee and donuts in the church hall afterwards?”

As I recall:
  1. She was just about to speak to the priest.
  2. The parish hall is a minimum of $1,000.
 
What the heck is wrong with you people! You are totally proving what the OP said about you and this website is true. This is terrible. Who are you to call someone immature?

This is how you show the love of God? I am ashamed of this website at this moment.

I think almost everyone here is making this about money EXCEPT the OP. I notice people on this website jump to conclusions and judge people by what they read into their posts. It is really strange, as if you think you actually have met this person or are mind readers. Get a life and stop pretending like you are living someone else’s.

Okay - so now you can talk about what I said as if you really know me, which you don’t. So I don’t care. As long as you leave her alone, because it just really ticks me off that she is being judged.
Speaking of being harsh and mindreading:
Re-read the OP. She clearly states that they would be happy to have a reception **if somebody else paid for it. **Sounds like a money issue to me.
And FWIW, myself and many others have gone out of the way to not call names, call the OP cheap, or anything like you are suggesting.
I wish her well. In her enthusiasm and youth, she is not open to the notion that she may end up embarrassed. Neither are you. THAT is the tone of most of the posts. This is a life lesson on being gracious, hospitality, and what it means to share milestones in your life.
Far more important than the size of the plate or the cost of the honeymoon.

You don’t have to be ashamed of me. I said nothing unkind. People ask for advice. You get what you ask for. She asked if there was a way to not have a reception without appearing rude. The answer is nearly unanimous, NO. 🤷

I’ll say it again: Matthew 14:16
Yeah, everyone here loves God. I’m pretty sure.
Peace.
 
Here’s a quote from the OP:

“We really wouldn’t mind a reception if someone paid for it, we but don’t want to put money into something we feel forced to do for the sake of other people.”
  1. They don’t want to spend their money on a reception, but would accept other people’s money
  2. They don’t want to do something “for the sake of other people” :eek:
 
What the heck is wrong with you people! You are totally proving what the OP said about you and this website is true. This is terrible. Who are you to call someone immature?

This is how you show the love of God? I am ashamed of this website at this moment.

I think almost everyone here is making this about money EXCEPT the OP. I notice people on this website jump to conclusions and judge people by what they read into their posts. It is really strange, as if you think you actually have met this person or are mind readers. Get a life and stop pretending like you are living someone else’s.

Okay - so now you can talk about what I said as if you really know me, which you don’t. So I don’t care. As long as you leave her alone, because it just really ticks me off that she is being judged.
First of all, as several others have mentioned, the OP herself mentioned money. Whether that is her true motivation or whether she just really doesn’t want to spend any more time with guests than she has to after the wedding, who knows.

Most of the contributors to this thread politely explained that no, there is no way to do this without sounding rude, because it is in fact rude. Many tried to give helpful advice about cost-saving measures, and the OP responded by telling everyone they were being judgmental and “bashing” her. If someone comes on here and asks a question and doesn’t like the answers (especially when nearly everyone says the same thing), some self-examination is probably in order.

Many of the posters on this thread are married and were able to throw economical receptions. Some didn’t particularly want a reception either, but had one anyway and are glad they did. No one said she was wrong for not wanting a reception, but nearly everyone pointed out (in charity) that it was not a good way to start off their marriage, no matter how eager they are to get to be alone on their honeymoon. This has the potential to affect family relationships beyond just one day. The OP is obviously free to take or leave all this advice, but telling people to “get a life” because they took the time to respond to a question is a little uncalled for.
 
First of all, I’d like to apologize to everyone. I really am sorry for lashing out. The dark cloud that I had over my head has finally left. Listening to different opinions is good and I’m really happy a lot of you wanted to help me out, even if it sounded rude to me at the time. I’m here to offer peace to all.

Secondly, my fiance and I were able to work out something with the priest and had a nice long chat with his uncle that had incredible advice for us. They both really helped out, because they listened to us without judgement.

Third, we are going to have a reception, but something small and will still get to enjoy our honeymoon because Disney World for us isn’t really expensive. We live in Florida and pretty close to it. Disney Land is in California for those that are confused.

Fourth, I’d like to explain our issues with a reception and the family members that really made us snap. The thing is, my fiance and I have been to quite a few weddings, all had these big receptions, but we noticed the bride and groom were completely unhappy in all of them. Some have even been told us that they have regretted doing a reception, period. Hearing those things really broke our hearts, so we thought that the root of all evil were the BIG receptions, so we decided against that since the beginning and we decided a small reception would be a great idea.

When we talked about our plans with his Protestant side of the family, they told us to stop ‘stressing’ out about a wedding that will take place in the future.Then, the next thing they told us is to not do a nice honeymoon in Disney, because it’s just a trip and we would be ‘missing out’ if we didn’t have a big reception. Mind you guys, they never mentioned the happiness of our families, or even our own happiness.

We thought that a small reception and the wedding itself would be enough originally, but then started doubting our small reception idea to the point of not wanting one at all, because we started to assume it would overpower the fact that we were getting married, or that our small reception would not be ‘good’ enough, so it’s better to not have one at all.

We really want to put emphasis and love into the wedding itself and have the reception as a nice gesture to accompany it, but we really don’t wish to have a big reception. And it all stemmed from the hurtful things they said. They even said that the church would not look nice enough without decorations. I mean, really? I know they meant well, but they really broke our hearts. So I really would like to apologize, taking it out on you guys didn’t make my words any less hurtful or right to do.

I’m still open to great ideas for a small reception and good Catholic reads for an engaged couple. Again, I’m sorry everyone.
 
:hug3:

Welcome back.
You only need one floral arrangement at church. We got married during the Christmas season. Voila! All the flowers were there already. All I had to do was pick colors that didn’t clash, LOL

We made the centerpieces ourselves at the reception. Maybe a crafty friend would do something you design as a gift?
My photos were a gift from someone who had a snazzy camera.

The biggest ticket item was food. Maybe those “helpful” in-laws could kick in for the light refreshments??? Don’t be afraid to ask for help! People truly want to help you. I’m sure your families will come together…

Ask for help. Be gracious, be grateful. Enjoy this exciting chapter in your life!!!
CONGRATULATIONS!!!

Thanks for comin back. So many folks were praying for you, still are. :grouphug:
 
We really want to put emphasis and love into the wedding itself and have the reception as a nice gesture to accompany it, but we really don’t wish to have a big reception. And it all stemmed from the hurtful things they said. They even said that the church would not look nice enough without decorations. I mean, really? I know they meant well, but they really broke our hearts. So I really would like to apologize, taking it out on you guys didn’t make my words any less hurtful or right to do.
I’m really glad that you both have decided to have something for your guests- I think it’s the right thing to do. Also, getting engaged and planning a wedding are both very stressful, even though they are good things, so go easy on yourself 🙂

As for the opinions about what the church will look like, first, your relatives will live if it’s not overflowing with flowers, and secondly, I’d recommend getting married during the Christmas season if you really care. I did, and the Church was gorgeous and we didn’t pay a dime for the decorations. There were Christmas trees, poinsettias, and of course the nativity.

Overall though, it sounds like you have a lot of people sticking their noses where they don’t belong. Some people who do this mean well, some are just nosy, and some really like to stir things up. The best thing you can do is limit what details you give these people, and learn to repeat “that is what we are doing” over and over. You will get people commenting about the guest list, your choice of a wedding date, you name it, you will hear about it. And then when you get married these same people will ask you a week later when you’re going to have kids. And when you have kids they’ll have an opinion about everything you do then as well. I don’t say all this to scare you away from having a reception, but rather because the busybodies will always be around, and it will save you a lot of grief and bring you peace if you can learn to deal with them now by setting boundaries.

Also- I understand not wanting to have a big reception. I didn’t want one either, and we kept ours rather small and informal. We had a morning wedding, followed by a nice afternoon meal. My husband and I both dislike a lot of attention, so we didn’t have dancing or a bouquet toss and it was still a really nice time. Of course we got comments, but we decided that although we wanted show our gratitude to them for coming, we did not need to make our reception into something we didn’t want. Overall, we enjoyed ourselves and I think most people had a nice time eating and socializing. It wasn’t the most exciting wedding of the century, but it was still nice and it was comfortable for us. And- since we had our wedding in the morning and our reception in the afternoon, everyone was gone by about 4-5pm and we had the whole rest of the night to ourselves.

Don’t worry about your reception not being “good enough”. As long as you provide a space for people to gather and some kind of refreshments, you only need to concern yourselves with what’s good enough for you.

I’m glad you seem to be working it out, and hope you’re able to plan something nice while ignoring unsolicited comments and advice.
 
Agatha, if you are not on Pinterest, you should be. They have so many do it yourself wedding ideas, article links for inexpensive weddings, dresses, everything you could want, and more!! But be careful, it is addictive!😃
 
The book Your Catholic Wedding might be helpful to you. I found it useful 👍
 
I agree with comments upthread about flowers–Catholic churches often come “pre-decorated,” so that would be an obvious budget-cutting option. I remember during my engagement having a big disagreement with my fiance over flowers. We had to have flowers!!! But then we got married on a three-figure budget (probably something on the order of $600 for literally everything–rings, dress, bouquet, check for parish, store cake and homemade lunch) and I discovered that indeed, we didn’t need to do more than just buy a small bouquet for me to hand over to the only single girl who came.

Agatha813:

“First of all, I’d like to apologize to everyone. I really am sorry for lashing out. The dark cloud that I had over my head has finally left. Listening to different opinions is good and I’m really happy a lot of you wanted to help me out, even if it sounded rude to me at the time. I’m here to offer peace to all.”

Awww.

Weddings and wedding planning are tremendously stressful.

“We really want to put emphasis and love into the wedding itself and have the reception as a nice gesture to accompany it, but we really don’t wish to have a big reception. And it all stemmed from the hurtful things they said. They even said that the church would not look nice enough without decorations. I mean, really? I know they meant well, but they really broke our hearts. So I really would like to apologize, taking it out on you guys didn’t make my words any less hurtful or right to do.”

I’m going to say something really catty (so cover your ears, sensitive ecumenical people).

Their church would look plain and sad undecorated. Your Catholic church will probably look amazing, especially if you do a Christmas season wedding (the Christmas season is nice and long–this year it just ended this past Sunday).

“I’m still open to great ideas for a small reception and good Catholic reads for an engaged couple. Again, I’m sorry everyone.”

True story–through the grapevine, I heard about some friends of friends who had pizza (nice pizza) and maple bars for their backyard wedding reception.

You can really do anything you like for your reception, just so long as there is something to eat, something to drink, and someplace to sit. Also, if you time it carefully, nobody will expect a full meal.

Also, you don’t have to stay for the whole reception. It’s actually pretty traditional for the bride and groom to run off as soon as they can.
 
True story–through the grapevine, I heard about some friends of friends who had pizza (nice pizza) and maple bars for their backyard wedding reception.

You can really do anything you like for your reception, just so long as there is something to eat, something to drink, and someplace to sit. Also, if you time it carefully, nobody will expect a full meal.

Also, you don’t have to stay for the whole reception. It’s actually pretty traditional for the bride and groom to run off as soon as they can.
We actually thought about pizza! Again, thanks guys. I really am not a nasty person, so I’m sorry for my actions earlier in the thread. I don’t think I ever realized how stressful wedding planning could be, especially when people throw in their negative attitudes.

.
 
Agatha813 said:

“I don’t think I ever realized how stressful wedding planning could be, especially when people throw in their negative attitudes.”

It’s pretty much the most stressful interpersonal situation I have ever experienced. We had relatives threatening not to come at all and citing “old country” traditions that allegedly there should be a two-year long engagement. We had other relatives getting offended by the first set of relatives’ demands, etc. (His family: In the old country, we do blah blah blah. My family: Well, we’re not in the old country, are we?) I also made the mistake of telling my dad about my fiance’s wishes not to do flowers.

It was a real education. We ultimately did a “Catholic elopement” rather than the home town extravaganza that I had envisioned, felt myself obligated to put on, but (in my heart of hearts) did not actually want.
 
Most Catholic Churches are beautifully decorated during the Easter season as well, which is even longer than Christmas season.

The main trouble with planning something small comes when other family members think something bigger would be nicer and push you along. My niece’s wedding plans went from a courthouse wedding, to a wedding at a lovely city landmark and reception at their favorite bar to a very expensive wedding at a country club! It is important to know what you want and maintain control. (By the way, she was very happy and we all had a great time. So, no matter what I believe things turn out for the best whatever happens.)
 
Welcome back all the wedding receptions in my family have been nothing more than cake punch and a few finger foods and every one was fine with it.
 
I’m still open to great ideas for a small reception and good Catholic reads for an engaged couple. /QUOTE]

I was matron of honor at a wedding where the reception was small and lovely. It was at the groom’s house, which had been cleaned up and simply decorated with the help of their friends. The food was prepared ahead of time (it was a tea party theme with mostly fingertip sandwiches, fruit, and other snack type foods) again, with the help of friends. The bride and groom spent their wedding night at a local B&B, and we all made sure the house was cleaned up after they left the reception.

As for the wedding itself, the bride was dressed at my home, I did her hair, she did her own makeup, her sister did the photography, and her mother did the flowers for the church. Musically talented friends formed the choir that sang for the mass, and the bridal party was small, just the Best Man and me.

The couple was (and remains) down to earth and preferring the simple and homemade to the showy and extravagant. Because of the comparatively small guest list (maybe 40-50 people at most) both the wedding and the reception were intimate and completely free of pretention, and reflective of the tastes and personality of the couple in question. I never heard anyone sneer at any of it. If anyone had felt it wasn’t good enough, they would have been free not to attend.

I think the pizza idea is great too!

Just remember, this is about the two of you. If simple and fun is your thing, do something simple and fun. Don’t even talk about your wedding plans with people who will only respond with pressure and pessimism, and don’t let anybody pay for anything if they are going to hold it over your head and use it to exert control.
 
It sounds like you guys are on the right track by getting some advice from the priest / uncle and planning a small reception.

You have complete control in a wedding on the size of the wedding and the guest list. The size can be as small as an elopement.

Also, you are learning to be gracious while simultaneously setting boundaries. It is important when you are starting out to do this otherwise “well meaning” family members can intrude into your personal life – if you let them (so don’t let them). So you learn to be gracious but firm.

Finally, it sounds like you are trusting God to help guide you through this. Don’t be surprised if one of the people you seek counsel from shows you a way to do this very inexpensively. I will briefly relate how we were able to save $ on our reception.

Our wedding was immediate family and a couple friends (~25 people). We did want a reception and miraculously, a restaurant across the street from our high rise apartment building offered to host the reception for much less than similar venue’s at other places. The owners did a wonderful job and personally hosted the reception as if we were in their home. They even supplied flowers we didn’t ask for. They acted unconcerned about the timetable for the final payment. Of course we paid on time.

A week or so after our reception the restaurant was raided and all the owners were arrested for dealing cocaine. Apparently, serving food was just part of the “cover”. Thus, income from receptions etc. was really irrelevant to them.

Shortly after the raid, I dinged a car in our building’s parking lot and left a note on the car. The owner of the car was an FBI special agent. The FBI had an apartment in our building that had a prime view of the restaurant.

So we assumed that we had been under surveillance going to and from the restaurant when planning the reception. We were grateful that the police waited until after the reception to raid the restaurant.

The Lord works in mysterious ways.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top