- Can anyone out there recommend a good - and orthodox - RCIA program?*
As far as I know, there aren’t any, and I have looked hard for one that we could use in our parish. We have had to create our RCIA program from scratch, which seems very strange to me considering how long the RCIA program has been operating in the USA.
You can find many books and tapes
about the RCIA process, and they will all say that an important element of the RCIA process is a systematic catechesis of the faith. But none of the books that I have read have given a hint as to how this is to be accomplished. During the Rite of Initiation, the catechumens are going to be asked if they accept
everything that the Catholic Church teaches. Where does the catechist draw the line about what is going to be taught in RCIA? The bishops give no guidance. I have talked to many people online that have gone through an RCIA program. Superficial touchy-feely RCIA programs seem to be the norm for most parishes.
We have given all our catechumens and candidates the universal Catechism of the Catholic Church as a reference book, but that book is written for bishops, not catechumens. It is simply impossible to cover the CCC word for word. There must be a balance struck between being superficial and going overboard in catechesis. How to strike that balance is the biggest challenge of developing an RCIA program. Well … that and finding some Catholics in your parish that actually believe everything that the Catholic Church teaches, and that are willing to get involved in teaching an RCIA program. There are far too many cafeteria Catholics that want to take over the RCIA program, usually the same Catholics that are interested in bringing all sorts of liturgical innovations into the parish to make the Mass more exciting …
God help you if Father Groovy and Sister Issues are running your parish’s RCIA program.
Maybe Catholic Answers should develop an RCIA program!