Regulators launch major crackdown on payday lenders

  • Thread starter Thread starter didymus
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I don’t think I’m specials at all. Millions of people somehow managed without pay day loan sharks or the leg breaking loan sharks. It’s an unnecessary industry.
 
I don’t think I’m specials at all. Millions of people somehow managed without pay day loan sharks or the leg breaking loan sharks. It’s an unnecessary industry.
That’s like saying because millions of people manage to stay in housing, anyone who wants to can avoid being homeless.
 
No, it’s not.
Why not?

Sure, millions of people have managed. That doesn’t mean there aren’t situations where people need more money right now than they have, and where there can be pretty serious consequences for not coughing up the extra right away. Or that people always can recover from them.
 
Why not?

Sure, millions of people have managed. That doesn’t mean there aren’t situations where people need more money right now than they have, and where there can be pretty serious consequences for not coughing up the extra right away. Or that people always can recover from them.
If that’s your example of logic, our conversation is done. Have fun.
 
No, it’s not.
So are you arguing that there is never a situation where a person would need a payday loan? Take the example of my friend, she is 16 and living in an apartment that she just moved into because her father kicked her out of the house, she has no family, and her car breaks down. She needs her car to get to work, her only alternative to get the car fixed is a payday loan. You are going to argue that it is better to be homeless than to take out a payday loan?
 
So are you arguing that there is never a situation where a person would need a payday loan? Take the example of my friend, she is 16 and living in an apartment that she just moved into because her father kicked her out of the house, she has no family, and her car breaks down. She needs her car to get to work, her only alternative to get the car fixed is a payday loan. You are going to argue that it is better to be homeless than to take out a payday loan?
Maybe not better, but unless the loan is paid back in full within the following two weeks, an enormous interest rate accrues, and the cycle repeats itself a few more times. What often happens is that people take out a second payday loan to pay for the first, and a third to pay for the other two, and so on. This situation may very well eventually lead to homelessness.
 
Maybe not better, but unless the loan is paid back in full within the following two weeks, an enormous interest rate accrues, and the cycle repeats itself a few more times. What often happens is that people take out a second payday loan to pay for the first, and a third to pay for the other two, and so on. This situation may very well eventually lead to homelessness.
I would say that if a payday loan were used, it would have to be used very carefully. One can easily get into trouble with payday loans. My point, is that there are times when a loan at an outrageous rate might be better than no loan at all.

In New York City they have the Provident Loan Society, which is a nonprofit alternative to payday lenders if you have an asset to pledge as collateral. Even they charge high interest rates which suggest there are high defaults and managing the loans is costly. I would like to see more organizations like that. Perhaps they can also provide some financial education to decrease the need for payday loans as well.
 
I think payday loan places are often an example of where the system of charity has failed.

Ideally, we would provide support to people who are in bad situations. This was actually what the original St. Vincent societies were supposed to do - act as pawnshops that provided loans for people who needed a bit of extra money to get back on their feet.

I’m in favor of regulating payday loan places to try to keep them less punitive, but I don’t think we’ll really be successful until people in desperate circumstances have alternatives.
 
If the capped rate is truly 36%, then someone needs to step in and stop this, whoever decided on the 36% number is likely in on this scam as well…My car loan is 5%, my credit is OK, not great, but for anyone to charge 36%…that is nothing more than legal loan sharking, in fact, I dont think the mafia charges that much interest!

They could easily cap the rate at 10 or 12 % and still make great profits. this is nothing more than taking advantage of people, I think a judge needs to step in and shut these places down or set their cap alot lower.
 
Here’s an interesting study of the payday loan industries.

ir.lawnet.fordham.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1227&context=jcfl

From the conclusion (emphasis mine):
This study finds that the industry’s proffered justifications for high service fees, and by extension high APRs, may be justified by both high store expenses and high loan losses. In addition, this study finds that payday lender profit margins are less than half that of their mainstream lending counterparts. The study also indicates that pawn operations significantly enhance the profitability of payday lending companies.
If payday loan companies are predatory, what does that say of mainstream banks?
 
Here’s an interesting study of the payday loan industries.

ir.lawnet.fordham.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1227&context=jcfl

From the conclusion (emphasis mine):
This study finds that the industry’s proffered justifications for high service fees, and by extension high APRs, may be justified by both high store expenses and high loan losses. In addition, this study finds that payday lender profit margins are less than half that of their mainstream lending counterparts. The study also indicates that pawn operations significantly enhance the profitability of payday lending companies.
If payday loan companies are predatory, what does that say of mainstream banks?
I’m not too surprised at this. Typically, payday borrowers have no credit and no collateral. If they walk away from the debt to the payday lender, there’s not much the latter can do to enforce payment effectively. I’m sure the loan losses are staggering in that industry.
 
I’m not too surprised at this. Typically, payday borrowers have no credit and no collateral. If they walk away from the debt to the payday lender, there’s not much the latter can do to enforce payment effectively. I’m sure the loan losses are staggering in that industry.
Well, if they are not profitable, why are new ones going up all over the place? Something fishy about those numbers I think…
 
Well, if they are not profitable, why are new ones going up all over the place? Something fishy about those numbers I think…
Maybe. But there are lots of things for which there is a demand but in which profitability isn’t spectacular.
 
Here’s an interesting study of the payday loan industries.

ir.lawnet.fordham.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1227&context=jcfl

From the conclusion (emphasis mine):
This study finds that the industry’s proffered justifications for high service fees, and by extension high APRs, may be justified by both high store expenses and high loan losses. In addition, this study finds that payday lender profit margins are less than half that of their mainstream lending counterparts. The study also indicates that pawn operations significantly enhance the profitability of payday lending companies.
If payday loan companies are predatory, what does that say of mainstream banks?
Nothing. Whether or not a business is predatory does not depend on how profitable they are.
 
There are other places you can get checks cashed, without falling into the hands of these people. A lot of grocery stores, for example.

I know people who’ve fallen for this. Payday loans are anything BUT an “oasis.”
You are right per the first part.

Grocery stores won’t give people an advance though.

I have some poor relatives (not nearby me) who told me how they have borrowed money for a day or two at the end of the month … to keep the motel room they’ve been living in for years (as their “landlord” would not give them such credit).

It WAS probably an expensive oasis I’ll grant. But it kept them afloat without having to bother relatives and having THEM pay big fees to wire them cash … plus the factor that relatives would know about their negative business.

There are certainly problems with such businesses … and pitfalls that can befall the poor who do not pay back promptly. Yet sometimes it’s worth it to them. 🤷

It WOULD be great for the poor to get that kind of help somewhere else … but sometimes neither the government nor the Church solves the immediate problem.

Anyway, I figured there’d be plenty of (justified) criticisms of the payday lenders posted. So my personal perspective on a case I knew about … I shared to give a bit of perspective.

As you duly give cautions about the payday lenders … let me add my cautions about government regulators (who can ALSO go too far … and with even less to reign them back in when they do). Will their office send my relative a quick loan (at a better rate) to avoid an immediate disaster? :nope: < is my guess. :imsorry:
 
So are you arguing that there is never a situation where a person would need a payday loan? Take the example of my friend, she is 16 and living in an apartment that she just moved into because her father kicked her out of the house, she has no family, and her car breaks down. She needs her car to get to work, her only alternative to get the car fixed is a payday loan. You are going to argue that it is better to be homeless than to take out a payday loan?
Your actual case study there is pretty compelling in favor of a possible legitimate need for this kind of business. With competition maybe the usury some fear would be less? Meanwhile :tiphat: to the 16 year old girl who is trying to handle her own business.

Not knowing all the other details, a 16 year old girl on her own could possibly just ask for help and possibly get free rent from some (couch surfing at friends’ houses) and other perqs that sometimes come to a young damsel in distress.

That said … I appreciate Meltzerboy’s observations and the other posters who caution against use of payday lenders. It does seem that the bigger problem with this kind of a business can be when the temporary solution gets dragged on and becomes part of an ongoing problem.

But hey, credit cards can be maxed out by people in similar circumstances - with far less of a stigma to Visa, Mastercard, or whomever the card issuer is. 🤷

Maybe the regulators will be doing the public a favor … but mayhaps they have just as likely picked a popular target to harrass, unto being applauded for some self-serving “do gooding”.

Have they considered that closing down these places still leaves the poor and desperate in their fix (in the short run) with their alternatives being even worse? Like begging and petty criminality (as for instances).
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top