Relativism actually don't contradict morality?

  • Thread starter Thread starter hihiip201
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
but couldn’t they argue that the ultimate source of a standard exist independently and eternal? just like some people argue that the universe is eternal itself?
Ultimate sources (plural). Remember we’re talkin’ relativism here. 😉

They could, but would they? If there are multiple sources, what is the criteria to value one above the other?

Seems to me another source is needed. Or there is only one to begin with.

peace
steve
 
Ultimate sources (plural). Remember we’re talkin’ relativism here. 😉

They could, but would they? If there are multiple sources, what is the criteria to value one above the other?

Seems to me another source is needed. Or there is only one to begin with.

peace
steve
Right, so let’s say there is only one to begin with, can that be the ultimate source(that’s why I used source) which exist independently? that “always has been” and does not require a beginning?
 
]morality as we understand it is in direct contradiction to evolution. Compassion for strangers is completely unexplainable in terms of survival of our genetic material.
You and I have been through this on another thread, but the long and short of it is this: what we call “moral decisions” are a product of a combination of evolved instinct (for example, a cooperative tendency similar to those seen in other social animals), an application of reason to the situation in conjunction with our goals, and our social conditioning.

The behavior we call “moral” isn’t entirely explainable by evolved instinct, but it is explainable by those three natural factors that I listed above.
Morality, though, has NOT changed from the beginning of time.
This is just an empty blanket assertion that claims that there is some kind of eternal normative framework for deciding whether an action is moral. There’s no reason to think that this claim is true.

Indeed, if you look at actual moral judgments that have been made (descriptive morality), we’ll see that morality absolutely has changed over time. Slavery is a good example of this. Despite the apologist rhetoric to the contrary, Biblical slavery was the owning of one human being by another: the BIble lists rules – supposedly given by God – for owning other human beings, passing them on to descendents like property, rules for tricking your indentured servants to want to be your slave forever by giving them a wife, and rules for beating your slaves. These are all things that we, today, would be horrified by today, but the writers of the Bible found them to be perfectly moral and good.

To the OP:

It’s very, very easy to get confused with philosophy and to get tripped up in word games so that you miss what’s right in front of your nose, so let’s drop the “relativism” terminology, which can mean different things in different contexts and can increase confusion rather than bring clarity.

We observe that there is – among human beings in this time period raised in the same culture – very broad agreement about what constitutes “good” and “bad” behavior. Most of these judgments are the self-evident result of civilization (don’t kill, don’t steal) and form the basis of having a community to begin with: they were rules established at the dawn of society and have been passed down to us. Other values that we hold – such as, for example, the value that all of us in our culture place on freedom, reason, and individualism – are the product of an intellectual development, mainly stemming from the Enlightenment. They are part of our social conditioning that we’ve inherited.

As I see it, our judgments are driven by values, and values are shaped by completely natural things: our instinctual drives, our ability to reason the optimal course of action in connection with goals, and our social conditioning. These natural things, working together in a complicated fashion in relation to situations, produce values and judgments that we label “moral.”

It is both unknowable and irrelevant whether there’s some “real” or “objective” morality to which our judgments correspond. What we have are moral judgments that are broadly very much similar compatible and explainable entirely by natural means.

Places where values come into contact are opportunities for discourse or dialogue on the subject, operating under the shared value we have – developed over centuries – for people pursuing their own goals so long as they are not overtly harming their neighbor’s chance at pursuing his goals.
 
NonServiam ,#23
what we call “moral decisions” are a product of a combination of evolved instinct (for example, a cooperative tendency similar to those seen in other social animals), an application of reason to the situation in conjunction with our goals, and our social conditioning.
Such assumptions suit those who do not know history. In fact, what is present is the natural moral law with which God created us and to which even pagans subscribed as in the Roman philosopher Cicero (died 43 B.C.) who wrote in De Republica, 3.22: “True law is right reason in agreement with nature. It is of universal application, unchanging, everlasting. We cannot be freed from it by Senate or people. This law is not one thing at Rome and another at Athens, but is eternal and immutable, valid for all nations and for all times. God is the Author of it, its promulgator, and its enforcing judge. Whoever is disobedient to it is abandoning his true self and denying his own nature.”

Morality is not new or limited to Christians. It has been an issue since ancient times.
For instance the Code of Hammarubi and The 42 negative confessions of the Ancient Egyptians.
(templeankh.com/negativeconfessions.htm)

As against this phobia, see:
tothesource.org/3_17_2010/3_17_2010_printer.htm
“The natural law is the law of human being alone—not other animals, not birds, not rocks, not trees, not planets. The natural law arises from our particular nature. It is natural insofar as it is rooted in our nature, and moral insofar as our nature defines what is good and evil for us.
“Well, just what are we? We are rational, moral animals—the only rational, moral animals. We are the one animal that must think even to survive, and the one animal whose actions are not governed by instincts but are judged by standards of good and evil. We don’t consider it cruel not to teach your dog to read, but we think that keeping children from getting an education deprives them of something they should have. We don’t jail rambunctious roosters for forcing themselves on beleaguered hens, but we send men to the slammer for rape.
“Our status as the only rational, moral animal is the source of our natural belief that human beings are distinct from other animals. That is the origin of all laws against murder, for the notion of “murder” assumes that killing a human being is fundamentally distinct from killing a chicken, and that the murderer actually had the moral freedom not to kill (otherwise, jailing the man would make as much sense as jailing the knife). Let go of this fundamental assumption, and soon killing anything will be considered murder (as some animal rights activists maintain) and a murderer’s DNA will be the only culprit (as genetic determinists maintain).
“This status as rational animal is exactly what is meant by the assumption that human beings are made in the image of God. The Ten Commandments are, in moral substance, not unique to the ancient Jews. As C. S. Lewis noted in his Abolition of Man, the moral commands to honor parents, not murder, not lie, not steal, and so on, are found everywhere. They are found everywhere because they arise from human nature. To ignore them, or manipulate them, can only result in the destruction of human nature, the Abolition of Man.”
Dr. Benjamin Wiker

Even Alfred North Whitehead, F.R.S., explained: “The greatest contribution of medievalism to the scientific movement [was] the inexpugnable belief that …there is a secret, a secret which can be unveiled. How has this conviction been so vividly implanted in the European mind?..It must come from the medieval insistence on the rationality of God, conceived with the personal energy of Jehovah and with the rationality of a Greek philosopher. Every detail was supervised and ordered: the search into nature could only result in the vindication of the faith in rationality.” [E.L. Jones, 1987; in *The Victory of Reason, Rodney Stark, Random House, 2005, p 15].
 
You and I have been through this on another thread, but the long and short of it is this: what we call “moral decisions” are a product of a combination of evolved instinct (for example, a cooperative tendency similar to those seen in other social animals), an application of reason to the situation in conjunction with our goals, and our social conditioning.

The behavior we call “moral” isn’t entirely explainable by evolved instinct, but it is explainable by those three natural factors that I listed above.

This is just an empty blanket assertion that claims that there is some kind of eternal normative framework for deciding whether an action is moral. There’s no reason to think that this claim is true.
Ok.
Is there then anyway to argue, that a society deciding to kill anyone changing his religion is wrong?

After all, our compunctions about such rules are just due to social conditioning.
We observe that there is – among human beings in this time period raised in the same culture – very broad agreement about what constitutes “good” and “bad” behavior. Most of these judgments are the self-evident result of civilization (don’t kill, don’t steal) and form the basis of having a community to begin with: they were rules established at the dawn of society and have been passed down to us.
Evidence for this outlandish claim?

There were numerous societies where the ruler or the ruling class had absolute power over life and property over a part or all their subjects. Examples:

-in Rome for several centuries the life of a slave and of a new born child could be taken at the household leaders whim

-in south america in many cities ritual human sacrifices were practiced

In both cases “don’t kill” was not a basis, at best “don’t kill members of group/class X or without orders from Y”.

Even today there are vast differences, north korea is a country with a functioning government, but its rather questionable whether don’t kill or don’t steal are the basis for their current society. Iran has punished homosexuals by stoning and currently a now christian islam apostate maybe executed in coming months, so they at least understand something completely different with “don’t kill”.
Other values that we hold – such as, for example, the value that all of us in our culture place on freedom, reason, and individualism – are the product of an intellectual development, mainly stemming from the Enlightenment. They are part of our social conditioning that we’ve inherited.
You mean that Enlightenment whose supposed first political milestone was the french Revolution, which degenerated first into a reign of terror and then a reign of war?
What we have are moral judgments that are broadly very much similar compatible and explainable entirely by natural means.
Evidence please. If the moral judgements are broadly compatible, why did it take mankind 10000 years of history to politically define the common morale basis in form of the human rights declaration?
And why do quite a number of countries still disagree with that consensus, e.g. the islamic declaration of human right from cairo 1991 differs in several important aspects from the UN 1948.

And our current standards would leave a ancient roman or egyptian probably laughing or crying about our stupid moral laws.

Even since the UN 1948 declaration there has been in many countries a huge change regarding “don’t kill”. Um until 1965-80 it was in many countries illegal to kill an unborn human being. Today it would be probably considered illegal by many supreme courts to punish in such cases the mothers or doctors acting in that way. That is a dramatic shift and it happened just 30-50 years ago.

So there is no human consensus on moral.
Places where values come into contact are opportunities for discourse or dialogue on the subject, operating under the shared value we have – developed over centuries – for people pursuing their own goals so long as they are not overtly harming their neighbor’s chance at pursuing his goals.
The consensus you claim exists without offering evidence is meaningless as there are dozens of opinions what “harming” might mean.
And places where vastly differing values come into contact are only in fantasy a opportunity for discourse, they are nearly always an opportunity for weapon traders.

Even in civilized europe, when a bunch of people gather to demonstrate for the right of unborn to live, their opponents with differing values - my womb is mine - do not use the opportunity for discourse but steal and attack if police does not interfere.
 
Ok.
Is there then anyway to argue, that a society deciding to kill anyone changing his religion is wrong?

After all, our compunctions about such rules are just due to social conditioning.
I’m not talking about normative morality here (deciding what is “really” right or wrong). I’m talking about descriptive morality here (explaining the “moral” choices that people really do make).

There indeed are societies that kill people for changing religions, and these societies argue that such actions are “good.” I think their decision and values can be explained entirely by recourse to natural things (instinct, reason, tradition).

Whether their values are “really right” or not is a question for normative morality, and I’m personally of the opinion that there is no objective, normative morality.
There were numerous societies where the ruler or the ruling class had absolute power over life and property over a part or all their subjects.
Yes, of course. I was oversimplifying to make my point easy to grasp, but the basic idea of what I was saying is more or less self-evident: society has, at its root, the broad agreement that human beings will exit the state of nature and forge a social contract in which they’ll agree not to restrict, in some ways, killing and theft. Obviously, societies developed sophisticated hierarchies and social “levels” in which such behavior was permissible, but I don’t think there’s ever been a society that had no restrictions at all on killing and theft.

Since then, we’ve been refining those restrictions. But as you point out, there’s a lot of confusion and disagreement about these restrictions, even today. Today, we have no problem with some killings: executing criminals, killing in self-defense, killing animals for food, and in times past they had no problem with gladiator killings, human sacrifice, beating slaves to death, public torture and execution, etc.

People today like to say, “Oh, it’s not killing itself that’s bad…it’s murder.” That begs the question of what murder is. “Oh, ‘unjustified killing’.” Deeper and deeper we go – what is “unjustified”? “Well,” the answer comes, “any kind of killing not on the list of approved killings.”

This is one of the many problems with normative morality: it is often circular and arbitrary.
You mean that Enlightenment whose supposed first political milestone was the french Revolution, which degenerated first into a reign of terror and then a reign of war?
I would argue that its first political milestone was the American Revolution and the foundation of the American government, based on the principles of individual life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness.

The French tried to replicate that achievement, but it got a little tricky, didn’t it?
If the moral judgements are broadly compatible, why did it take mankind 10000 years of history to politically define the common morale basis in form of the human rights declaration?
I didn’t say that moral judgments were always broadly compatible - I said that they are today, when we look at judgments made by individuals raised in the same society.

Obviously, there are some serious moral disagreements even in our own society, but if you break down a society’s values to their extreme basics – values regarding killing people, taking the stuff of other people, swindling people out of money, randomly spitting on strangers on the street – you’re going to find an awful lot of agreement.
 
according to richard dawkins morality is evolved, so maybe “right” and “Wrong” in our conscience is just a sense that was also evolved based on the morality that human develop? which is in fact consistent with relativism is that there is no absolute truth. And “right” and “wrong” has always been a definition we given to the morality evolved within humanity?

is this case there will be no point in talking about morally right and wrong as it has been defined and it always is. and it doesn’t collide with relativism. (as morally right and wrong apart from “truth”)

just as an the EM wave with wavelength between 620–750 nm is defined as red. its is meaningless to define well how do you know if that is “red” or asking questions such as what is true “Red” or are there REAL “red”.
I think you were onto the answer with this last paragraph.

Ask Dawkins, or one of his many acolytes, if he believes that reason is evolved. They will almost certainly answer in the affirmative. Then ask what that implies about the reliability of science and even elementary logic. Is there no point in talking about scientific or logical truth? (There are some who will answer in the affirmative but they are not Dawkins’ acolytes.)
 
I think their decision and values can be explained entirely by recourse to natural things (instinct, reason, tradition).

Whether their values are “really right” or not is a question for normative morality, and I’m personally of the opinion that there is no objective, normative morality.
You know what argument you are asking for with this statement?

There also was a society that decided to send all Jews to the gas chamber. Their decision can be explained entirely by recourse to natural things, e.g. traditions, political situation, need for scapegoats and so on. As you deny the existence of objective morality, you cannot judge this decision in any way and cannot say whether its in any way evil or good.
Furthermore lacking the ability to condem this decision, you would lack any reason to do something about that decision.
society has, at its root, the broad agreement that human beings will exit the state of nature and forge a social contract in which they’ll agree not to restrict, in some ways, killing and theft.
This is not self-evident. I do not know any society, where all members agreed to a social contract. At best a majority agreed to one.
And in many societies there were large groups who given the chance would have exited the contract immidieately, e.g. captured slaves in roman empire.
Since then, we’ve been refining those restrictions. But as you point out, there’s a lot of confusion and disagreement about these restrictions, even today.

This is one of the many problems with normative morality: it is often circular and arbitrary.
Whats arbitrary about trying to use violence only versus the initiator of violence?
Sometimes it might be trick to decide who started sometimes it might be tricky to only hit the initiator. But i do not understand why such a rule would be circular.
Arbitrary of course, thats true.

And how do you know we have been refining those rules?

We might have them even simplified, because in some other societies the “right” or “wrong” of killing a human being not only depended upon the actions of the participants but also on the social status, the weather, the words of the local seer or the position of the stars. Thats sounds more sophisticated than a “all humans are equal before the law”.
I would argue that its first political milestone was the American Revolution and the foundation of the American government, based on the principles of individual life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness.
Its a bit bad to argue for relativism and then put the american revolution in positive light:
“When in the Course of human events, it becomes necessary for one people to dissolve the political bands which have connected them with another, and to assume among the powers of the earth, the separate and equal station to which the Laws of Nature and of Nature’s God entitle them, a decent respect to the opinions of mankind requires that they should declare the causes which impel them to the separation.”
This guys assumed the existence of universal law and saw the moral need to justify their actions in regard to that law.
“We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights,[75] that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness.”
They declare that there are self-evidently (=they have no idea how to argue for them) unalienable rights for all human beings endowed by the creator.
Thats the very opposite of relativism.
" That to secure these rights, Governments are instituted among Men, deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed, That whenever any Form of Government becomes destructive of these ends, it is the Right of the People to alter or to abolish it, and to institute new Government, laying its foundation on such principles and organizing its powers in such form, as to them shall seem most likely to effect their Safety and Happiness."

Note that they do not limit here their position to the US 1776, but declare universally that any people is allowed to alter or abolish their current government, if the governement fails in respect to these universal rights.

So they claim the existence(though they do not define it in detail) of a universal moral standard for governments and if governments fail according to these standards the subjects are free to hang them from the next tree or whatever the situation calls for.
The French tried to replicate that achievement, but it got a little tricky, didn’t it?
They made the mistake not to declare the right of pursuit of happiness but a right to happiness. Very bad mistake. Unfortunately many are regularly willing to repeat it.
you’re going to find an awful lot of agreement.
Unfortunately no. The most basic decision about human rights or society is what is actually human or a member of society. As there is a fundamental divide between those, who consider unborn to be human and those who do not consider them to be, the agreement is limited.
A lot of disagreement exists also in respect to human dignity, what it actually means for practical politics.
Further future disagreement might arise from what a religion actually is, which is pretty important if a government want to promise religious freedom, and how religions or religious movements, which are in serious disagreement with a societies core values, should be treated.
Another serious disgreement is about the rights of people who want to immigrate into a society.
And some people have no compunctions about depicting all rich as being some sort of criminal thugs who suppress the poor and willingly cause their deaths - thats a lot worse than spitting in strangers faces.
 
You and I have been through this on another thread, but the long and short of it is this: what we call “moral decisions” are a product of a combination of evolved instinct (for example, a cooperative tendency similar to those seen in other social animals), an application of reason to the situation in conjunction with our goals, and our social conditioning.

The behavior we call “moral” isn’t entirely explainable by evolved instinct, but it is explainable by those three natural factors that I listed above.
And yet you never did explain either:
  1. the rational explanation for a man diving into a burning building to save a stranger at great risk to his own life.
  2. where the social conditioning that risking one’s own life for a stranger actually originated (I’ll give you a hint: Christianity came up with the idea and now it’s built into our society)
You’ve made assertions about these sources of morality, but have never backed them with anything of an official source OR an explanation about where these methods arise from… so basically you’ve told me nothing other than your personal opinion.
This is just an empty blanket assertion that claims that there is some kind of eternal normative framework for deciding whether an action is moral. There’s no reason to think that this claim is true.

Indeed, if you look at actual moral judgments that have been made (descriptive morality), we’ll see that morality absolutely has changed over time. Slavery is a good example of this. Despite the apologist rhetoric to the contrary, Biblical slavery was the owning of one human being by another: the BIble lists rules – supposedly given by God – for owning other human beings, passing them on to descendents like property, rules for tricking your indentured servants to want to be your slave forever by giving them a wife, and rules for beating your slaves. These are all things that we, today, would be horrified by today, but the writers of the Bible found them to be perfectly moral and good.
I thought you just said morality is fluid with time? If that is the case, then slavery WAS moral and good in the time of ancient israel.

Perhaps what you meant is that understanding of morality is fluid. That, I would agree with. But unless you purport to tell me that the slavery used to be morally right and now it’s morally wrong (not that it was REGARDED as right, but was actually wrong) then I have to call hogwash.

Let’s look at other things that are “sometimes” right if morality is fluid based on culture and time:
cannibalism
prostitution
murder
first night priveledges
torture (most of the third world nations today)
women as property
sex slavery (thailand)
genocide (africa)
homophobic hate crimes (africa, south america)

And if morality is fluid based on time and culture, we can’t argue that these things are ACTUALLY wrong. In fact, we have to accept that they are sometimes and places MORALLY RIGHT. That’s grossly unhuman, if you ask me.
 
Ask Dawkins, or one of his many acolytes, if he believes that reason is evolved. They will almost certainly answer in the affirmative.
Of course it did, just like eyes and sight evolved.
Then ask what that implies about the reliability of science and even elementary logic.
Well, what does it imply about the reliability of eyes and sight?

Our eyes aren’t perfect, just as our reason isn’t perfect, but reason is the only tool we have available to us to distinguish fact from fiction, and it seems to be doing a decent enough job, given the fact that it’s enabled us to control our environment so well.

What you’re suggesting here – that reason is unreliable merely because it evolved – also suggests that all of our senses must equally be unreliable, and the ultimate conclusion of such an argument, taken to its logical end, is that man knows nothing.

If you are arguing that man knows nothing, then you contradict your own premise because your argument – which uses reason – has reached a conclusion. In other words, in order to assert that man can’t know anything, you have to know at least one thing, which defeats your own argument.

In short, you don’t have an argument.
 
You know what argument you are asking for with this statement?

There also was a society that decided to send all Jews to the gas chamber. Their decision can be explained entirely by recourse to natural things, e.g. traditions, political situation, need for scapegoats and so on. As you deny the existence of objective morality, you cannot judge this decision in any way and cannot say whether its in any way evil or good.
Furthermore lacking the ability to condem this decision, you would lack any reason to do something about that decision.
Just because I’m a moral nihilist – not a moral relativist, a moral nihilist: I don’t accept that there is an objective moral standard at all – doesn’t mean I can’t judge things. It just means that I’m upfront about my judgments being expressions of my individual values.

And, on the basis of my values, I’m more than capable of reacting with horror to atrocity and opposing it in all of its forms.
Whats arbitrary about trying to use violence only versus the initiator of violence?
Sometimes it might be trick to decide who started sometimes it might be tricky to only hit the initiator. But i do not understand why such a rule would be circular.
Arbitrary of course, thats true.
Emphasis added.
Its a bit bad to argue for relativism and then put the american revolution in positive light
Again, I’m not a relativist. I’m a moral nihilist, and I’m not arguing that the American Revolution was a manifestation of some objective moral good – even if some of its proponents adopted that rhetorical strategy.

I’m merely saying that it was something of which my values approve.
 
Of course it did, just like eyes and sight evolved. Well, what does it imply about the reliability of eyes and sight?

Our eyes aren’t perfect, just as our reason isn’t perfect, but reason is the only tool we have available to us to distinguish fact from fiction, and it seems to be doing a decent enough job, given the fact that it’s enabled us to control our environment so well.
Whether or not reason is the only tool, the reliability of reason as a tool is crucially important. It is well known that eyes are not infallible tools for seeing, that they have many inbuilt limitations and weaknesses. The fact that we can only see with our eyes does not negate that fact.
What you’re suggesting here – that reason is unreliable merely because it evolved – also suggests that all of our senses must equally be unreliable, and the ultimate conclusion of such an argument, taken to its logical end, is that man knows nothing.
Note that I did not introduce the claim that evolution negates reliability, I am only applying the claim more broadly than morality to include reason. There are certainly those who claim that man knows nothing, or at least nothing with certainty. In fact it is a nontrivial problem to be certain of anything, especially when your own reasoning is suspect.
If you are arguing that man knows nothing, then you contradict your own premise because your argument – which uses reason – has reached a conclusion. In other words, in order to assert that man can’t know anything, you have to know at least one thing, which defeats your own argument. In short, you don’t have an argument.
The same argument can be (has been) applied to the claim that there are no moral certainties. If there are no moral certainties then there is nothing wrong with believing or even advocating things which are false.
 
Whether or not reason is the only tool, the reliability of reason as a tool is crucially important. It is well known that eyes are not infallible tools for seeing, that they have many inbuilt limitations and weaknesses. The fact that we can only see with our eyes does not negate that fact.
Obviously our eyes are not infallible, and in a similar way, our reason is not infallible either.

But so what? Neither our eyesight nor our reason needs to be infallible for us to obtain a very good picture of what the world is like and a very good idea of which claims are very likely to be true.
In fact it is a nontrivial problem to be certain of anything, especially when your own reasoning is suspect.
No one lives his life based on “certainty” in the absolute sense you seem to mean it here. We live our lives based on our evaluation of whether claims are likely to be true, to the best possible evidence available to us. And the only way to determine whether claims are likely to be true or not is to use reason. Obviously, that process isn’t “infallible” and it doesn’t produce absolute “certainty,” but since no one lives his life based on this kind of absolute “certainty,” that’s not any kind of problem.
If there are no moral certainties then there is nothing wrong with believing or even advocating things which are false.
It should be obvious that I’m not presenting a moral argument against being incorrect: I’m not saying that it’s “morally wrong” to have incorrect ideas or to advocate false ideas. I’m saying that it’s “factually wrong,” and since the subject of discussion is morality, that subject includes the topic of whether objective morality is factually true or not.

The only way we’re going to decide the issue is through reason and rational discourse enabling us to come to a conclusion as to what is most likely true.
 
Obviously our eyes are not infallible, and in a similar way, our reason is not infallible either.

But so what? Neither our eyesight nor our reason needs to be infallible for us to obtain a very good picture of what the world is like and a very good idea of which claims are very likely to be true.
Ok, so why does this same reasoning not also apply to morality?
No one lives his life based on “certainty” in the absolute sense you seem to mean it here. We live our lives based on our evaluation of whether claims are likely to be true, to the best possible evidence available to us. And the only way to determine whether claims are likely to be true or not is to use reason. Obviously, that process isn’t “infallible” and it doesn’t produce absolute “certainty,” but since no one lives his life based on this kind of absolute “certainty,” that’s not any kind of problem.
It should be obvious that I’m not presenting a moral argument against being incorrect: I’m not saying that it’s “morally wrong” to have incorrect ideas or to advocate false ideas. I’m saying that it’s “factually wrong,” and since the subject of discussion is morality, that subject includes the topic of whether objective morality is factually true or not
But why should it matter to be factually wrong? Or to advocate wrong facts? (And please don’t pretend that Dawkinsians are morally neutral on this point. Nothing animates that type more than advocacy of Biblical creationism.)
The only way we’re going to decide the issue is through reason and rational discourse enabling us to come to a conclusion as to what is most likely true.
This does not follow whatsoever. To give but one additional aspect, we rely on experience with the real world, i.e. empiricism. Reason, which is flawed, is also inadequate to the task. And rational discourse is valued, in part, because it provides multiple points of view, i.e. more eyes on the question which, it is hoped, might reduce the potential for error.
 
Ok, so why does this same reasoning not also apply to morality?
Because the statement “Objective, normative morality exists outside of human minds” is a claim about the world. We evaluate claims about the world through reason, which is the purpose of having a rational discussion about it, which is what we’re doing here.

I’ve presented a case for so-called moral decisions being products of completely natural forces. You can have a go at trying to present a different case or at trying to dispute what I say, but you can’t just declare objective morality to exist because you say so.
But why should it matter to be factually wrong?
Because something doesn’t have to be “objectively morally right or wrong” to matter to people. The whole phenomenon of “mattering” depends on values, which aren’t objective and eternal, but individual and subjective and transitory.

Look, it’s not “objectively morally wrong” for me to miss watching a television program that I want to see, but it still matters to me. It’s not “objectively morally wrong” for me to ignore great literature, but reading great literature is still something that matters to me.

You seem to be under the impression that if there’s no “objective morality” then nothing would matter to anyone, but that’s clearly not the case. Things do matter to people, regardless of whether there’s some morality floating out there or not.
This * does not follow whatsoever.*Ok, I’ll tell you what. Name one method – other than via reason and rational discourse – by which we can come to a conclusion as to what is most likely true.
 
Just because I’m a moral nihilist – not a moral relativist, a moral nihilist: I don’t accept that there is an objective moral standard at all – doesn’t mean I can’t judge things. It just means that I’m upfront about my judgments being expressions of my individual values.

And, on the basis of my values, I’m more than capable of reacting with horror to atrocity and opposing it in all of its forms.

Again, I’m not a relativist. I’m a moral nihilist, and I’m not arguing that the American Revolution was a manifestation of some objective moral good – even if some of its proponents adopted that rhetorical strategy.

I’m merely saying that it was something of which my values approve.
But then you actually propose a universal moral standard, your own values. You think it is legitimate to judge people according to this standard even if they live under completely different circumstances, cultures or time.

The difference would be, that you do not claim it to be absolute in so far as you learn and evolve.
 
Let me first note that you are no longer, if you ever were, defending the original claim of the OP that moral reasoning is suspect because it is evolved. If I am mistaken, please let me know.
Because the statement “Objective, normative morality exists outside of human minds” is a claim about the world. We evaluate claims about the world through reason, which is the purpose of having a rational discussion about it, which is what we’re doing here. I’ve presented a case for so-called moral decisions being products of completely natural forces. You can have a go at trying to present a different case or at trying to dispute what I say, but you can’t just declare objective morality to exist because you say so.
Again, though, reason is but one tool and, as noted previously, not necessarily a reliable tool. The fact that we rely on reason doesn’t make it reliable any more than a creationist’s reliance on the biblical account of creation makes that account reliable.

I’m guessing that you would also present a case for scientific decisions being products of completely natural forces, right? Again, what’s the distinction?
Because something doesn’t have to be “objectively morally right or wrong” to matter to people. The whole phenomenon of “mattering” depends on values, which aren’t objective and eternal, but individual and subjective and transitory.
Here you are simply misrepresenting reality. Dawkinists are quite expressly declaring that, for example, the teaching of biblical creationism in school is wrong. That’s moral claim. Based on the more general moral claim that it is wrong to believe and teach that which is false. Further, values are not distinguished from morality; morality is steeped in values.
Ok, I’ll tell you what. Name one method – other than via reason and rational discourse – by which we can come to a conclusion as to what is most likely true.
I already did: empiricism. In fact, it is not reason which distinguishes moral reasoning from science but the difficulty of empirical analysis of the subject owing precisely to nature of values.

Relativism is, essentially, a resignation from reason in the domain of morality. It observes the difficulties, throws up its hands, and walks away from it.
 
Let me first note that you are no longer, if you ever were, defending the original claim of the OP that moral reasoning is suspect because it is evolved.
I was never defending that claim. I’m arguing that there’s no such thing as objective morality, in the sense of there being rules that exist outside of minds.

Obviously, within minds, people have constructed rules and judgments that they call “moral.” My stance, however, is that these rules and judgments don’t correspond to any rules that exist outside of minds If all minds vanished from the universe tomorrow, then all morality would vanish too because “morality” is just a word for judgments that exist in minds…not some external rules.
Again, though, reason is but one tool and, as noted previously, not necessarily a reliable tool.
Reason is consistently reliable when it’s properly applied. It’s not perfect, but it is consistently reliable. That’s why we use it.
The fact that we rely on reason doesn’t make it reliable
Obviously not. It’s the fact that it’s consistently reliable that makes it reliable.
I’m guessing that you would also present a case for scientific decisions being products of completely natural forces, right? Again, what’s the distinction?
You are confused. You think that I’m arguing that we can’t believe in morality because moral judgments are the product of natural forces; therefore, you’re trying to extend that argument into a reductio ad absurdum by saying, “Well, science is the product of natural forces, but you trust that!”

But that’s not at all what I’m arguing.

I’m arguing that there is no such thing as morality, in the sense of rules that exist outside of human beings. What we call “morality” is nothing more than subjective value judgments made in the minds of individuals. In other words, I’m arguing against the idea that morality is some set of eternal rules that existed before humans and exist “out there” in the world for us to discover. I argue against that by demonstrating that there is no good reason to accept that morality is something that exists outside of the minds of humans, for the simple reason that the moral judgments that humans make can be explained entirely by recourse to natural forces and do not at all rely on the existence of some morality external to minds.

No one argues that the scientific method is some eternal set of rules that existed before humans and exists “out there” outside of human minds. People made up the scientific method, just like people made up their moral codes. If someone came along and tried to argue that the scientific method was some eternally-existing set of rules that didn’t depend on human minds, I would argue against that position in the same way as I argue against the position that morality exists objectively outside of minds: by pointing out that our scientific investigations can be explained entirely by recourse to natural forces and do not at all rely on the existence of some scientific method external to minds.
Dawkinists are quite expressly declaring that, for example, the teaching of biblical creationism in school is wrong. That’s moral claim.
Yes, people who are sane generally do think that teaching unfounded superstition as science is bad. Some of them might call this judgment of theirs “moral.”

I’m saying that there’s not some eternally-existing standard outside of minds that makes it “wrong.” What makes it “wrong” to those people is their own subjective value judgments, just like some creationists have subjective value judgments that make them say that it’s “right” to do that very same thing.

Again, I’m arguing against the existence of an eternally-existing standard outside of human minds.
 
I was never defending that claim. I’m arguing that there’s no such thing as objective morality, in the sense of there being rules that exist outside of minds…Again, I’m arguing against the existence of an eternally-existing standard outside of human minds.
Context matters and influences meaning. I was working within the context of this thread and so was interpreting your comments accordingly. I think the argument of the OP is silly. I am more sympathetic to the argument you have put forward though I will happily argue with you on it because I have come to a slightly different conclusion.

I will return to respond to your last post accordingly. Before I do, however, I must note that you have twice excised my mention of empiricism in response to your own questions. That is an important element here and I will raise it again.
 
I think the argument of the OP is silly. I am more sympathetic to the argument you have put forward though I will happily argue with you on it because I have come to a slightly different conclusion.
I’d be happy to hear your different conclusion so that we can dialogue about it.
I must note that you have twice excised my mention of empiricism in response to your own questions. That is an important element here and I will raise it again.
Well, I “excised” it because there was so much else to talk about and because it seemed like a waste of time getting into it until you were sure of what I was arguing.

I’m confused by what you say about it. I asked you to name one method – other than via reason and rational discourse – by which we can determine whether claims are likely to be true or not.

Perhaps this is just a difference of language between us, but I understand “empiricism” to mean the reliance on empirical evidence, evidence derived from what we can sense, measure, detect, etc. For me, using evidence is a part of rational discourse (one of the most important parts) – you can’t rationally come to accurate conclusions if you don’t start from true, verifiable premises.

We all know that you can start from false premises and reason your way to a false – but thoroughly logical and consistent – position. For this reason, I advocate the use of what I call “evidence-based inquiry”…rational inquiry that starts from evidence and true, verifiable premises.

For me, reason applied to evidence is the only method of determining whether or not a claim is likely to be true.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top