I think their decision and values can be explained entirely by recourse to natural things (instinct, reason, tradition).
Whether their values are “really right” or not is a question for normative morality, and I’m personally of the opinion that there is no objective, normative morality.
You know what argument you are asking for with this statement?
There also was a society that decided to send all Jews to the gas chamber. Their decision can be explained entirely by recourse to natural things, e.g. traditions, political situation, need for scapegoats and so on. As you deny the existence of objective morality, you cannot judge this decision in any way and cannot say whether its in any way evil or good.
Furthermore lacking the ability to condem this decision, you would lack any reason to do something about that decision.
society has, at its root, the broad agreement that human beings will exit the state of nature and forge a social contract in which they’ll agree not to restrict, in some ways, killing and theft.
This is not self-evident. I do not know any society, where all members agreed to a social contract. At best a majority agreed to one.
And in many societies there were large groups who given the chance would have exited the contract immidieately, e.g. captured slaves in roman empire.
Since then, we’ve been refining those restrictions. But as you point out, there’s a lot of confusion and disagreement about these restrictions, even today.
This is one of the many problems with normative morality: it is often circular and arbitrary.
Whats arbitrary about trying to use violence only versus the initiator of violence?
Sometimes it might be trick to decide who started sometimes it might be tricky to only hit the initiator. But i do not understand why such a rule would be circular.
Arbitrary of course, thats true.
And how do you know we have been refining those rules?
We might have them even simplified, because in some other societies the “right” or “wrong” of killing a human being not only depended upon the actions of the participants but also on the social status, the weather, the words of the local seer or the position of the stars. Thats sounds more sophisticated than a “all humans are equal before the law”.
I would argue that its first political milestone was the American Revolution and the foundation of the American government, based on the principles of individual life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness.
Its a bit bad to argue for relativism and then put the american revolution in positive light:
“When in the Course of human events, it becomes necessary for one people to dissolve the political bands which have connected them with another, and to assume among the powers of the earth, the separate and equal station to which the Laws of Nature and of Nature’s God entitle them, a decent respect to the opinions of mankind requires that they should declare the causes which impel them to the separation.”
This guys assumed the existence of universal law and saw the moral need to justify their actions in regard to that law.
“We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights,[75] that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness.”
They declare that there are self-evidently (=they have no idea how to argue for them) unalienable rights for all human beings endowed by the creator.
Thats the very opposite of relativism.
" That to secure these rights, Governments are instituted among Men, deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed, That whenever any Form of Government becomes destructive of these ends, it is the Right of the People to alter or to abolish it, and to institute new Government, laying its foundation on such principles and organizing its powers in such form, as to them shall seem most likely to effect their Safety and Happiness."
Note that they do not limit here their position to the US 1776, but declare universally that any people is allowed to alter or abolish their current government, if the governement fails in respect to these universal rights.
So they claim the existence(though they do not define it in detail) of a universal moral standard for governments and if governments fail according to these standards the subjects are free to hang them from the next tree or whatever the situation calls for.
The French tried to replicate that achievement, but it got a little tricky, didn’t it?
They made the mistake not to declare the right of pursuit of happiness but a right to happiness. Very bad mistake. Unfortunately many are regularly willing to repeat it.
you’re going to find an awful lot of agreement.
Unfortunately no. The most basic decision about human rights or society is what is actually human or a member of society. As there is a fundamental divide between those, who consider unborn to be human and those who do not consider them to be, the agreement is limited.
A lot of disagreement exists also in respect to human dignity, what it actually means for practical politics.
Further future disagreement might arise from what a religion actually is, which is pretty important if a government want to promise religious freedom, and how religions or religious movements, which are in serious disagreement with a societies core values, should be treated.
Another serious disgreement is about the rights of people who want to immigrate into a society.
And some people have no compunctions about depicting all rich as being some sort of criminal thugs who suppress the poor and willingly cause their deaths - thats a lot worse than spitting in strangers faces.