I have seen many, many first class relics of St. Pius X that
do have the paperwork (and have been to his tomb in St. Peter’s Basilica, also!). Anyway, a very large number of them were distributed around the 1950s, when he was canonized. Yes, it’s true that:
-relics have to have the paperwork to be used for
public veneration
-there is a recent increase in manufacture of fake relics lately, and the simony and sacrilege of selling them (esp. online)
But, if the seal and strings are intact, and you can compare it to other relics that you know are authentic and it looks very similar in terms of the writing inside the theca (the brass container), apparent age of the theca, and its presentation (yes, that white flower-shaped background was used in many of them), then go ahead and assume it’s authentic, I say. I can’t say whether this particular one is authentic, but it has the same appearance as those I was just describing that I know are:
images.paulus21op.multiply.com/image/1/photos/upload/300x300/SDll8woKCqUAABUlfKM1/StPioX2.jpg?et=a%2CCDyOcOEHI%2C1D5eiHlyUw&nmid=0
Anyway, if you have reason to think it’s really legit, you are very fortunate to have it, and should privately venerate it! I envy you (in a holy way, lol), since he is one of my favorite saints!
If you are really paying attention you can detect many fake relics easily. Proving that one is authentic is another matter, though. For example, bone relics of St. Philip Neri - if you do your reading, you will know that no bone relics were ever removed from his incorrupt body, so anybody who claims to have one obviously has a fake. Brand new-looking relics of very famous saints (Francis of Assisi, Aquinas, etc) in sparkling thecas are often fake these days. Also, there are fake papers floating around online that simoniacs have adapted. For example, the relic of a Jesuit saint with the seal of the Benedictine order on its paperwork is highly fishy.
Look up “Ferrante” and “relics” online, and you will see what I mean.
Everybody here is well aware, I’m sure, that buying and selling first/second class relics is a serious sin. Any spiritual benefit one can derive from venerating relics is canceled out a thousand times over by the sin of simony, so don’t do it.
Wow, what a long post.
