Religion and Politics

  • Thread starter Thread starter JamesN
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Many of the comments were to the effect that religion and politics shouldn’t mix, which made me ask the question, as a practicing Christian how do you keep them separate?:hmmm:
That’s an old liberal trick. “Don’t get your religion mixed up with your politics.” If morality doesn’t apply to the governing of a nation like ours, what does?
 
Here’s the ORIGINAL version of the rule.

“Politics must not interfere with religion.”

Somehow, that has gotten upended into ‘religion must not meddle in politics.’ Weird, topsy turvy world.
 
My local paper printed a letter proposing genetic screening for “loners” and genetic counseling (presumably to kill the child) as a response to the Virginia Tech. tragedy. This is getting scary. How to respond to this?

see below, full text at the URL

From the Daily Progress letter section: dailyprogress.com/servlet/Satellite?pagename=CDP%2FMGArticle%2FCDP_BasicArticle&c=MGArticle&cid=1173351017051&path=!news

May 1, 2007

In view of the recent tragic events, it seems appropriate that, as a lasting memorial, funding be established to initiate or further research projects for DNA-biochemistry in order give a handle to the “loner syndrome.”
 
It is probably the reason the left is turning many moral issues into political issues. They want to shut us up. It ain’t gonna work. :mad:
 
By “original,” how far back are you talking?
The first Constitutional Convention: Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof…

Problem is, it has to work both ways or it doesn’t work at all. If a religion successfully lobbies for legislation reflecting its moral beliefs, it can infringe on the beliefs of others and on rights in general.

Imagine if a Jewish or Muslim lobby got pork outlawed – after all, it’s unclean. Since there is currently no law restricting our diets, we have an implicit right to eat whatever we want (unless it’s drugs, must acknowledge that nasty little inconsistency) so such a ban would infringe on everyone else’s rights. In the end, the American government would be unrecognizable, having effectively transformed into a theocracy. Religious noninterference in government is therefore implied but not written out.
 
It is probably the reason the left is turning many moral issues into political issues. They want to shut us up. It ain’t gonna work. :mad:
They twist things to suit themselves.I remember MP’s in the British Parliament,when we were chasing them up over abortion,
taunting us with the"one issue politics charge".Implying that we were too dim to debate other political matters.
The same people are having kittens because there is an Election
tomorrow,May,3rd.,and a lot of them could be voted out because
people could vote on one issue,“The Iraq War”.
 
"Digitonomy:
By “original,” how far back are you talking?
The first Constitutional Convention: Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof…
With respect, I’m not sure whether that’s what manualman meant or not. Being that the OP is British, the Constitutional Convention doesn’t apply to him. I was hoping there would be something earlier.
 
With respect, I’m not sure whether that’s what manualman meant or not. Being that the OP is British, the Constitutional Convention doesn’t apply to him. I was hoping there would be something earlier.
Britain has no such thing as separation of church and state. The head of the state is the head of the Anglican Church. I have not heard of any earlier separation than the late 18th century.
 
The first Constitutional Convention: Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof…
Yes! 🙂
Problem is, it has to work both ways or it doesn’t work at all. If a religion successfully lobbies for legislation reflecting its moral beliefs, it can infringe on the beliefs of others and on rights in general.
Yes, such is the nature of a democracy. Laws sometime get passed which contravene the values of some of the public e.g. laws tightly restricting immigration - Some support such laws, others oppose them.
In the end, the American government would be unrecognizable, having effectively transformed into a theocracy. Religious noninterference in government is therefore implied but not written out.
Sorry Mirdath, but I have to disagree with you on both points. While a theocracy might have been a threat 200 years ago, our nation has become too diverse and too secular for that to be a threat today.

The influence of religion is notimplicitly excluded from government - it is explicitly included in the First Amendment. The free exercise of religion includes seeking to influence government so that the values of the citizens are reflected in its laws and actions.
 
Sorry Mirdath, but I have to disagree with you on both points. While a theocracy might have been a threat 200 years ago, our nation has become too diverse and too secular for that to be a threat today.
You have no idea how much I want that to be true. Sadly, fundamentalist Christianity seems to hold a controlling interest in our government at present. True, it’s not really turning into a theocracy right now – but one has to ask, is a fascist state any better – or worse?
The influence of religion is notimplicitly excluded from government - it is explicitly included in the First Amendment. The free exercise of religion includes seeking to influence government so that the values of the citizens are reflected in its laws and actions.
Free exercise of religion should seek to influence citizens, and then the citizens can, perhaps, influence government. If a religion attempts to bypass that, it can infringe on the rights of others. Additionally, keep in mind that while the majority may make the decisions, the government also exists to represent the minority – religious interference in government should be curtailed simply to keep those minorities protected.
 
Free exercise of religion should seek to influence citizens, and then the citizens can, perhaps, influence government. If a religion attempts to bypass that, it can infringe on the rights of others.
Good point. But I am not sure I agree with the latter part. How do religious leaders acting as lobbyists differ from any other public interest group with representatives acting as lobbyists?
Additionally, keep in mind that while the majority may make the decisions, the government also exists to represent the minority – religious interference in government should be curtailed simply to keep those minorities protected.
Tyranny of the majority can exist in a democracy. Yes, minorities do need a voice in government, they need a hand in the governing. Abuses need to be watched for and corrected. But I am not sure what this has to do with religion. Do you have any examples of abuses which have occurred?
 
Good point. But I am not sure I agree with the latter part. How do religious leaders acting as lobbyists differ from any other public interest group with representatives acting as lobbyists?
I dislike the fact that lobbyists exist in general, religious or not. And all too often, religious leaders do not have religion in mind but secular power. Look at the Moral Majority – how focused on the salvation of souls was that? Not at all! It instead existed to further an agenda of secular control.
Tyranny of the majority can exist in a democracy. Yes, minorities do need a voice in government, they need a hand in the governing. Abuses need to be watched for and corrected. But I am not sure what this has to do with religion. Do you have any examples of abuses which have occurred?
We are reaping the whirlwind of fundamentalism right now. The crashing dollar, the soaring oil prices, the debased image of America worldwide, the mess of the inner cities of our once-proud nation, the collapse of American manufacturing can all be laid at the doorsteps of Jerry Falwell, Ronald Reagan, and those who have followed or thought like them. We have a president who thinks he’s on a God-given mission to interfere with other countries; we have an economy based on massive debt and the ridiculous idea that money trickles down from the wealthy; we have a culture that stymies dissent and free thought in the name of patriotism; and we are told to be afraid of those who are different. All this from fundamentalism, Zionism, militarism, run-amok capitalism, and a variety of other -isms, none of which exist for the good of the nation or the world but rather for the good of their founders. And those in control of our runaway nation claim a mandate from God. What more evidence of abuse does one need?
 
That’s an old liberal trick. “Don’t get your religion mixed up with your politics.” If morality doesn’t apply to the governing of a nation like ours, what does?
You dont need religion to have morals.
 
You dont need religion to have morals.
I have had friends who were not religious but had their standards.However,i feel they were just adopting some of my own
principles(the 10 Commandments) and ignoring the others.
You can have a dodgy motive.If you steal from or kill another man,his brother could do the same thing to you.
 
hola

i do not like politics or commen on it often but i am troubled by how much people put politics before the Church…

it seems like in talking to republicans that many Catholic republicans think the terms are synonyms and that democrats like me are less Catholic… i think this comes from the misperception that Catholic democrats vote for pro choice candidates…

i am also troubled by the way Catholics bring politics into Church… after Mass while we were still in our parish i overheard a boy about my age talking about what he would “like to do to the mexicans,” and all of this nonsense about the border… i did not feel any Catholic fraternal connection from this…

why do Catholics put politics before the Church? it does not matter what political adjective we label ourselves with as long as we just do what the Church says, and these national issues are not as important as the Church…

Dominus Vobiscum
 
why do Catholics put politics before the Church?
You ask a very good question. Personally, I have spent the past few years uprooting my beliefs and motivations which are based on what I want and what I think. The goal is to re-root my motivations in what God wants and what God thinks. I still have a long ways to go, and may never be free of personal motivations which detract from God.

Thanks for reminding me of the task.
 
I have had friends who were not religious but had their standards.However,i feel they were just adopting some of my own
principles(the 10 Commandments) and ignoring the others.
You can have a dodgy motive.If you steal from or kill another man,his brother could do the same thing to you.
Or you are adopting theirs? 😮
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top