Responding during Mass

  • Thread starter Thread starter Diana_Catherine
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
D

Diana_Catherine

Guest
This question is for those who attend both an EF and occasionally an OF. Since during an EF it is pretty quiet and you don’t usually respond the same as in the OF, when you attend an OF do you pray quietly or out loud with the rest.
 
This question is for those who attend both an EF and occasionally an OF. Since during an EF it is pretty quiet and you don’t usually respond the same as in the OF, when you attend an OF do you pray quietly or out loud with the rest.
I respond in the EF where I can respond, like the “et cum spiritu tuo” , at the preface, the “domine non sum dignus”, the deo gratias etc.

I would say that there are less opportunities to respond in the EF, but I don’t see anything wrong with responding.

At least at a missa cantata.
 
At an OF Mass, I am usually fairly quiet because I have only been to four of them now, since November 27th. And the last two were Thursday and Friday for funeral Masses so I’m not that familiar with them since the new translation. Looking forward to Easter Triduum in the EF again this year.
 
This question is for those who attend both an EF and occasionally an OF. Since during an EF it is pretty quiet and you don’t usually respond the same as in the OF, when you attend an OF do you pray quietly or out loud with the rest.
For approximately four years, I have assisted the EF Mass on Sunday. The Augustinian Canons Regular who pastor our community and administer the Sacraments taught us that ALL the responses [traditionally made by the altar servers] are to be made by the entire congregation. We were taught the correct Latin pronunciations of ALL the prayers and responses of the EF Mass and are expected to respond unison with the servers. Between our assigned prayers however, there is dead silence.

For the past two years I have attended the daily OF Mass with a [different] community of religious priests and brothers. Before Mass, we pray the morning office aloud, monastery-style. During the Mass, I prefer to listen [rather than speak] for things beneficial to my salvation. I am seldom disappointed.

.
 
This question is for those who attend both an EF and occasionally an OF. Since during an EF it is pretty quiet and you don’t usually respond the same as in the OF, when you attend an OF do you pray quietly or out loud with the rest.
I do whatever the rubrics call for, or, if they do not specify, whatever is the custom. The only things I do differently than most are to receive Communion on the tongue and kneeling and I avoid shaking hands for the Kiss of Peace. I even sing the songs unless they are theologically objectionable.
 
In the OF I respond and sing out loud as others do. In the EF I respond very quietly but still audible, songs that I know I will sing out loud with the choir.
 
I’m the same at both the TLM and NO (or EF/OF as some prefer). I don’t say a word. The exception is when all the Mass parts are being sung and I’m with the choir to sing the responses.
 
I avoid shaking hands for the Kiss of Peace.
So, I am curious, what do you do when the priest or deacon instructs us to “Show each other a sign of that Peace.” Do you simply ignore those around you, and stay consumed within yourself and you prayer, or do you go around kissing everyone in sight, as a literal interpretation of the instruction
 
When I attend a daily Mass in the OF I try to follow the missal and make all the responses because I think I’m supposed to, but it does feel jarring and distracting to me, so I often say them in a low voice.

Of course as often as not I forget things like saying “Amen” before receiving Holy Communion, but I don’t mean to.
 
So, I am curious, what do you do when the priest or deacon instructs us to “Show each other a sign of that Peace.” Do you simply ignore those around you, and stay consumed within yourself and you prayer, or do you go around kissing everyone in sight, as a literal interpretation of the instruction
Haha, do you kiss people at Mass? If some guy tried that I’m afraid I’d punch first and think later, haha.

I try to set a good example at Mass so I’m always torn at the kiss of peace. I don’t want to hurt people’s feelings who might be new or poorly catechized, but I also hate turning my back on Our Lord on the altar just then. Usually I shake hands with those nearest and stop to kneel as soon as father says “Angus Dei…” even if people are still trying to get my attention. It never feels like I get it just right, another reason the EF is more comfortable for me.
 
So, I am curious, what do you do when the priest or deacon instructs us to “Show each other a sign of that Peace.” Do you simply ignore those around you, and stay consumed within yourself and you prayer, or do you go around kissing everyone in sight, as a literal interpretation of the instruction
I smile and nod at people. If I am with my family, I hug or kiss family members. No theological significance - I just don’t like shaking hands. I do participate in a sign of peace, but I pick one that I am comfortable with.
 
Haha, do you kiss people at Mass? If some guy tried that I’m afraid I’d punch first and think later, haha.

I try to set a good example at Mass so I’m always torn at the kiss of peace. I don’t want to hurt people’s feelings who might be new or poorly catechized, but I also hate turning my back on Our Lord on the altar just then. Usually I shake hands with those nearest and stop to kneel as soon as father says “Angus Dei…” even if people are still trying to get my attention. It never feels like I get it just right, another reason the EF is more comfortable for me.
I kind of do the same thing. I think some times people get a little carried away with the sign of peace and feel they can’t miss anyone. I shake hands with those nearest me, maybe one or two behind me and then return to our Lord.
 
It depends on the congregation and the church I am at when I go to TLM. Some people do not reply at all even to the simple responses. Some people will reply along when its the servers turn. Some reply to some of them. Myself, I do know the simpler responses & say them. For the longer ones, I have my missal (or missalette) and do my best to respond to them.

When I go to Ordinary Form, I know most of the responses by heart now even with the changes implemented Advent 2011. With the exception of the Creed, Gloria and The Confiteor (which I must use an aid until I memorize them), the rest of the responses I know without use of various worship aids.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top