Right to life: Canadian Style, eh?

  • Thread starter Thread starter markomalley
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Now how many are uninsured by choice.

There was a time in my life I went without health care insurance so I could buy a Mustang GT.

That was my choice ( abiet, a very stupid one). Is it your premise that someone else should have paid for my insurance for me, or should I have I done the responsible thing and purchased a more sensible car?

I agree we should provide a base level of care for those who cannot legimately cover their own insurance. But what about those who could purchase insurance without sacrificing the necessities of life, but would rather spend the money on a fancier car or cable tv?

What obligation does society owe to them?
I dunno Brenan, so how’d the Mustang work out for ya? LOL. That is a pretty nice ride.

Man if I see some joker ridin down the road in a new car, after they garnish my pension for mandatory socialized health care I’m gonna be UPSET.
 
Let me point out the way it works in Massachusetts, if you don’t have health insurance – your taxes go up!

Tell me how this helps those who cannot afford health insurance.
 
Let me point out the way it works in Massachusetts, if you don’t have health insurance – your taxes go up!

Tell me how this helps those who cannot afford health insurance.
What about the folks that DO have insurance? What happens to their taxes?
 
Well I was kinda of proud of the fact, this poor old old, retired, working class firefighter, was able to get his hernia fixed in little old Alabama, the likes of which the richest Canadian could NEVER do, unless he comes south.

You’re NOT gonna get your hernia fixed in 2 weeks in socialized system. End of story.
I won’t be getting mine fixed at all, since I do not share in my husband’s veterans care. We live on his disability from Vietnam. I cannot afford to pay for health care. I have not been to a doctor in nearly 20 years. I for one, am not finding your story so funny at all. Glad your minor problem is fixed. Sorry you don’t suffer mentally at all the folks who get zero while you relax in your private suite. Ain’t you lucky!
 
And you want these SAME people to run the entire county’s healthcare??? :rotfl:

BEST example I can give on why ya DON’T want the govt in yoiur healthcare. Now you can hand YOURS over to the govt, but leave ME outta of it scheme.
That was fairly isolated. that it happened in the Nation’s capital was the reason it go such play. Actually the Veterans admin. runs the best socialized medicine anywhere. My husband gets excellent treatment at the VA in Iowa city. We get our appts within a couple of weeks, never wait more than about 15 to be seen, he always has the same doctor, the meds are mailed to us. It’s about as good as it gets. I’d be thrilled if I could get it.

Yes I know you don’t want it. You don’t care that others have nothing. you have yours. You’ve made that clear. And you are a Catholic? and a Christian? go figure that one out!
 
That was fairly isolated. that it happened in the Nation’s capital was the reason it go such play. Actually the Veterans admin. runs the best socialized medicine anywhere. My husband gets excellent treatment at the VA in Iowa city. We get our appts within a couple of weeks, never wait more than about 15 to be seen, he always has the same doctor, the meds are mailed to us. It’s about as good as it gets. I’d be thrilled if I could get it.
I think you have stumbled onto a clever solution! More people should join the military…in fact, encourage everyone to. We will end up with a de facto national healthcare plan. 👍 😛
 
Gee… 47 million uninsured is a “few.” No wonk would describe that as “few.” If there is a finite supply of something, and that suppy is not sufficient to meet demand, there will be rationing regardless of the existence of government price controls.

Evidence or this is simply hyperbole?
Haven’t you heard? most of the 47 million are "people who can pay but won’t (they prefer to die apparently), young people who won’t pay because they think they will live forever, and immigrants who apparently are entitled to nothing. Of course everytime a health care worker, doctor, surgeon is interviewed, they say that the vast vast majority of their poverty patients are working class people who cannot afford any insurance or more likely are pitifully underinsured.

No this is a simple case of them that has it don’t want to do with less so that others may have some, just anything.

We are now told that drug companies are not gouging America. Funny, but they don’t get the same price for their drugs anywhere but here. No other country allows them to charge that much, and funny, they continue to do business with them.

Report after report comes out about the drug companies and their criminal hiding of bad results in testing. They sell this **** as long as they can get away with it. The FDA is nothing but a mouthpiece for them now. Legitimate medical science is stiffled when they protest.

Medicare I believe negociates with drug companies like Canada does. Bush refused to allow that in the new medicaid legislation supposed to help the poorer people. It’s a joke of the rich and the hysterical thing is it’s supported by these working class stiffs here who are rich wannabe’s and are used by the rich to further their agenda, which is keep them rich, keep everyone else poor.
 
=BamaRider;3468137]Neil sez-
This is where we mostly part ways. The U.S. is not perfect, but I believe cutting the govt out of it, would improve the system. The insurance and drug companies have been so villified by the press and liberals, that people actually believe (example Latin Rite in post # 65) that hospitals and doctors actually put kids on the street to die. No one goes in this country without essential healthcare, it is a myth perpuated by a liberal press pushing a socialist agenda. If you go without healthcare it is not the hospital and doctors fault, because for whatever reason you didn’t show up at the ER.
Not true,there have been many reports and one not long ago of a woman turned away from a hospital because she had no insurance and she died before she got to another. Further, even though hospitals are ‘required’ to treat, they hardly absorb the loss voluntarily. They will and do sue any person who cannot pay if they have any assets. Most people do pay those bills off, even though it may take them years and destroy any hope they have of buying a home, a newer car, or putting money aside for college. Such illness literally devestates their lives. Please take the time to learn the facts.
Socialism has never worked anywhere it has been tried, yet there are many that insist it will. The Soviet Union should have been a socialist dream state, but it collasped on itself. The place imploded, and those that go down that road will see the same thing.
The veterans admin runs its health care in a socialized system and over all its a great running one. Secondly the USSR was not a socialist regime. It was a communist one, albeit not even a pure form of that. Please, again, learn a bit of what you try to speak about. Please address the socialized systems in most of Europe. Are you claiming they are all horrid as well? Why are thousands of americans going to the East for operations? and at 1/10th the cost? By board certified doctors? Most of which were educated in the US?
Neil, you actually like a system where misery is applied equally, and take comfort in all in the same boat, but that boat is sinking, and you’re just going down with the group. But I’m a individual as are most Americans. It is in the fabric of our DNA. Sadly, some have lost that, and think we should turn to the govt to save us. But I’m telling ya, I don’t wanna be stuck in a sinking "boat, " with no way to save MYSELF. I might wanna jump out, and swim to the Island, or be pro active and go LOOK for the Coast Guard, and I’d resent being told I CAN’T do that, by a bunch of folks that surrendered their freedom a long time ago.
What is so hysterical about your post is that you are spouting the most clear social darwinism of the 18th and 19th century. Spencer would be proud. Do you believe in evolution too? Survival of the fittest! You are a great proponent. I think the church thinks otherwise.
It was taught to me early in life, when you sign up for a govt scheme, you fork over a piece of your freedom. You trade it for what you perceive is security. But what you get is just as you point out in the boat scenario-misery applied equally. I’m sorry that runs counter to everything I value, and if they make such a thing law, and I lose my BCBS insurance, I’m gonna be kicking and screaming.
Some might suggest that as we age, we do best when we grow in knowledge and wisdom, not simply remain stuck in one place. I contend of course that such a position is simply not Christian but a secularist reliance on the social darwinism of the 18th century. The term rugged individualism was very big then, a term you undoubtedly favor.
 
The veterans admin runs its health care in a socialized system and over all its a great running one. Secondly the USSR was not a socialist regime. It was a communist one, albeit not even a pure form of that. Please, again, learn a bit of what you try to speak about. Please address the socialized systems in most of Europe. Are you claiming they are all horrid as well? Why are thousands of americans going to the East for operations? and at 1/10th the cost? By board certified doctors? Most of which were educated in the US?
You’re telling us the USSR (Union of Soviet Socialist Republics) did not operate a socialists economy? I’m telling ya Europe is mired in economic doldrums. They have no armies to speak of to even protect themselves ( outside of the Brits) WE protect their freedoms, with the finest military ever assembled. Just think what we could do if we didn’t have to have field a army to protect the free people of the world? Cause NO one else is gonna do it, heck I’ll take it one step further, NOT even one group of someones is gonna do it. No m’am they’re gonna let the USA do it. If not for our umbrella where would they be? They neither have the money or the inclination to field a army.

How is it that a country with only 250 million people have built a society in just 200 years the likes the world has ever seen? If this is such a bad place, explain how that happened?

Liberals are such a pessimistic, gloomy lot. I dunno how they get outta bed each morning. Always thinkin the USA is a bad place, etc.

My 26 years of fire dept service (many of those years on the ambulance trasnport side) I took hundreds of patients to the local VA. It was not the best place to be, from my observations and those of the patients that had a opinion. I’m sure active duty hospitals are vastly superior. But there are hundreds of VA hospitals acorss the USA, and for sure some better than others.

I guess some go east, for healthcare because its a better a deal? I don’t have a problem with that. But like you mentioned, guess where many of their doctors are educated?
Not true,there have been many reports and one not long ago of a woman turned away from a hospital because she had no insurance and she died before she got to another. Further, even though hospitals are ‘required’ to treat, they hardly absorb the loss voluntarily. They will and do sue any person who cannot pay if they have any assets. Most people do pay those bills off, even though it may take them years and destroy any hope they have of buying a home, a newer car, or putting money aside for college. Such illness literally devestates their lives. Please take the time to learn the facts.
Like I say, all you get is “reports” never THE name of a patient or hospital.
What is so hysterical about your post is that you are spouting the most clear social darwinism of the 18th and 19th century. Spencer would be proud. Do you believe in evolution too? Survival of the fittest! You are a great proponent. I think the church thinks otherwise.
Not exactly m’am, I’m gonna try to talk as many as I can to come with me, but I’m sure some with the same outlook you adhere to, are gonna be bound and determine to drown themselves, for those with THAT mentality, I’m gonan leave it with them, but they are NOT taking me down with them without a fight. Now if that hurts people’s feelings I dunno what else to say.
Some might suggest that as we age, we do best when we grow in knowledge and wisdom, not simply remain stuck in one place. I contend of course that such a position is simply not Christian but a secularist reliance on the social darwinism of the 18th century. The term rugged individualism was very big then, a term you undoubtedly favor.
We are now told that drug companies are not gouging America. Funny, but they don’t get the same price for their drugs anywhere but here. No other country allows them to charge that much, and funny, they continue to do business with them.
Do you have ANY idea how much it costs to develop a miracle drug? You think that just happens over night? I don’t have the numbers but I’m guessing in the millions. After spending all that money, a segment of people are beating down their walls demanding that they give it away, for no other reason then they feel entitled to it. I’m not gonna tell ya drug companines are not culpable for the bad stuff they do, but there are things in place to deal with that.

I’m not for the govt telling ANY private business what it can charge for anything, because it won’t stop there. You have people wanting congress to pass laws, capping how much a bank can charge for ATM fees outside network. When threatened with such a law the bank lobby just said “ok, we’ll confine our customers to the network only.” So when I’m out of town, and need cash, I have NO place to go. I’ll pay the 2 dollars. The samething is gonna happen with drugs if the govt steps in. Why would they pour millions into R and D, and lose money on the product? They’ll just forget developing anything new, and we ALL suffer.
Yes I know you don’t want it. You don’t care that others have nothing. you have yours. You’ve made that clear. And you are a Catholic? and a Christian? go figure that one out!
Is it wrong for a Catholic not to want the govt to mess with his healthcare???

I do care about those less fortunate then I. I know I’m blessed, I don’t take it for granted. But c’mon there are millions and millions out there who just make dumb decesions, and now y’all wanna hold my feet to the fire for it. Now befroe a bunch of folks, start beating down my door asking me to pay for his healthcare (which is bascially what ya do in such a system) I wanna make sure you cut off his digital cable tv, internet, big screens, riding lawn mowers, etc. Cause we ALL know there’s a bunch of them out there, and are prolly crying the loudest for govt healthcare.

Weed them out, and then come talk to us about what we can do for those that are truly needy.

I know I speak for many folks. I worked 26 years in the fire dept, I earned a good pension for that service and labor, my wife has a good job, we do ok, but according to one political party we’re “rich?” And if given a chance they’re gonna jack up my taxes for some pie in the sky healthcare?? Frankly, I’m tired of them telling me I ain’t doin enough. They raked me over when I was working, and are still at it now. I’m one of the “rich” that benefited from the Bush tax cuts, that the dems don’t want to renew. I’m looking a 2,500 dollar a year increase in taxes. I’m sure that will make some in this country feel good and I don’t understand why.

Tell me Spirit, how much longer can the regular folks like me, and the millions of others (many on this forum) carry this load before our backs break? We just keep on working while the govt, and a segment of the population, literally demands more and more from us. For crying out loud I already pay the feds almost 30% of my income, Its crazy.
Medicare I believe negociates with drug companies like Canada does. Bush refused to allow that in the new medicaid legislation supposed to help the poorer people. It’s a joke of the rich and the hysterical thing is it’s supported by these working class stiffs here who are rich wannabe’s and are used by the rich to further their agenda, which is keep them rich, keep everyone else poor.

M’am you really think rich folks are keeping poor people down? I wouldn’t know about being rich, but that is simply not true. NO rich guy ever kept me from being what I wanted to be. I was a firefighter because I loved the job, it was what I wanted to do, I could have chose ANY career path. NO rich guy was ever gonna keep me from my dream, heck they had NO power to prevent it… And what is the agenda of the rich? To keep the poor down for what reason?

I can’t pretend to know your life circumstance that causes you to feel this way, but I’ll listen if you want to explain.

Now that my blood pressure is up, I better go LOL…
 
You’re telling us the USSR (Union of Soviet Socialist Republics) did not operate a socialists economy? I’m telling ya Europe is mired in economic doldrums. They have no armies to speak of to even protect themselves ( outside of the Brits) WE protect their freedoms, with the finest military ever assembled.
Um… they have a reasonable army to protect themselves. I think what you mean is that their army isn’t big enough to attack other countries around the world who have not attacked them.
How is it that a country with only 250 million people have built a society in just 200 years the likes the world has ever seen? If this is such a bad place, explain how that happened?
Um… a small growing population with a huge territory full of resources. Enough arable land that it can be called the breadbasket of the world. Millions of slaves kidnapped from africa brought over to work the land. Using political corruption to virtually enslave the entire latin american world.

And combine that with an arrogance and ignorance of the outside world potent enough to make the people believe that they are the best country in the world with the right to wage war on their neighbours.
 
Um… a small growing population with a huge territory full of resources. Enough arable land that it can be called the breadbasket of the world. Millions of slaves kidnapped from africa brought over to work the land. Using political corruption to virtually enslave the entire latin american world.
Oh man Neil, now ya got us enslaving the Latin American World. I’m not even gonna respond to that accusation. But there hasn’t been a slave in American for 150 years. I guess your just gonna dimiss all the hard work of immigrants who came here in the early part of the century. THEY were major contributors to get us here, and subsequent generations built upon it.

And the hard work and innovation of the American people had nothing to do with it? There are fertile regions all over the world but they don’t produce like American farmers. On motorcycle trips I’ll spend days riding across the Great Plains. It is amazing how so few, produce so much, for so many. The fertile valleys of Caliornia, fruit basket of the world, were mostly arid, dry places, before American know how and ingenuity brought water in. Been through there a time or two also. For sure lots of natural resources, but you gotta do something with them.

As far as European armies? They are virtually helpless if anyone of any significance attacked them. If somebody flew a plane into the Eiffel Tower, not one thing France could do to respond. A small band of terroists blew a bomb up in Madrid, the WHOLE country rolled over and changed an election. I hate to know I lived in a place where elections are determined by a bunch of thugs with some explosives. Why? Because those thugs know the Spainish can’t do anything about it, just like the rest of the continient. It’s sad.

I’ve been around a place or 2. All documented on my web site. I can’t live, and do what I do anywhere else. I couldn’t afford it. I retired to a good life at age 49. My biggest worry today, is what time I’m going out to run, or I might ride my bicycle down to the historical district and meet my wife for lunch, for no other than I can, but I dunno she has a meeting at 1pm. I get up each morning expecting a good day, I do feel guilty sometimes at having so much fun, and I do give back. But liberals are so mired in woe, and looking for govt to save someone, that can’t get anything done.

So this all goes back to the system you’re in. I happen to think the reason the USA is exceptional is because of the system, but doggone now some want to change it so we can be more like that of Europe?? I’ve seen and experienced middle class in Europe, and here. If a guy doesn’t own 2 cars, all brick home on a 1 acre lot, big screen tv, we call him poor in Alabama. The bar is so high here most Europeans don’t understand.

I hosted 2 of my Brit friends for a 10 day ride of the Southeast in 2006. I could NOT get them out of the 6.99 all you can eat buffets. They never saw anything like it. Kid you not. LOL. I was returning the favor from 2005 when I spent a week riding the UK. I can tell ya a modest mean in restaraunt there goes for about 100 dollars. Eating out is not something the average guy does alot of there.

Look, I’ve had my say, so I’m gonna ease out and go eat lunch. It is 70 degrees and nice here, and I don’t wanna miss anymore of it. Y’all try to have a good day.
 
It’s amazing how much bandwidth some people need to say, “I hate America.”😛
 
I’ve seen and experienced middle class in Europe, and here. If a guy doesn’t own 2 cars, all brick home on a 1 acre lot, big screen tv, we call him poor in Alabama. The bar is so high here most Europeans don’t understand.

I hosted 2 of my Brit friends for a 10 day ride of the Southeast in 2006. I could NOT get them out of the 6.99 all you can eat buffets.
Europe has a higher population density. The math simply doesn’t allow everyone to own as much land as in the USA.

Also, tell me about the people who made the food and served you at the all you can eat restaurant. Will they get to retire at age 50? Do they have the all brick house and the two cars?

The difference between the systems is you can’t sit on your behind after age 50 and own an obscene amount of wealth unless someone else is suffering so that you can do it. For every guy like you with two gas guzzlers and a McMansion, there are a dozen poor people sweating away in a kitchen in a dead-end job or baking in the hot son picking veggies so that you don’t have to even cook your own food. You can’t have that situation in a fair egalitarian society.
 
Europe has a higher population density. The math simply doesn’t allow everyone to own as much land as in the USA.

Also, tell me about the people who made the food and served you at the all you can eat restaurant. Will they get to retire at age 50? Do they have the all brick house and the two cars?

The difference between the systems is you can’t sit on your behind after age 50 and own an obscene amount of wealth unless someone else is suffering so that you can do it. For every guy like you with two gas guzzlers and a McMansion, there are a dozen poor people sweating away in a kitchen in a dead-end job or baking in the hot son picking veggies so that you don’t have to even cook your own food. You can’t have that situation in a fair egalitarian society.
So for every family in the US with a house and two cars, there are “a dozen poor people sweating away in a kitchen in a dead-end job or baking in the hot son picking veggies.”

You’ve said it, now prove it.
 
No kidding, like my wife for one. She’s a Canadian and won’t go back to that system.

Canadian Health Care works reasonably well if you are in a big city like Toronto or Montreal. She was from across the river in Windsor.

In Windsor, if your dog needed an MRI, no problem, 3 vet hospitals have one. But not a single one for human use. You had to go to Toronto.

Also, OHIP ( the Ontario Health org) limits how much doctors can bill in any given year. So if they reach the max number of patients, they cannot see any more that year.

So several of the Windsor doctors have offices in the States as well. That way, they can keep a full schedule of patients (some Stateside and some in Canada) and still actually get paid for seeing patients.

And finally, about a 1/4 of the nurses in Detroit area hospitals are Canadian. OHIP closed down 2 hospitals in Windsor (too expensive you see), so the most senior ones came to work in the States, where jobs are plentiful and the pay is much higher than what the government will pay.
That there are no MRI’s in Windsor is just plain false.
February 20, 2004
MCGUINTY ANNOUNCES NEW MRI FOR WINDSOR
Working Together To Shorten Wait Times
WINDSOR — Ontario Premier Dalton McGuinty today announced a second MRI for the Windsor area to shorten waiting times and improve access to health care for local residents.
premier.gov.on.ca/news/Product.asp?ProductID=447
 
There are two MRIs in Windsor?

Wow! We only have one here in Mountain View, Arkansas (population, 2,800.)😛
 
While it is not perfect I have had no real problem with the health care system in Canada. I lived in a small isolated community in Northern Ontario (where I could always see a doctor the same day). I had a retinal detachment. I had to go to see a specialist in Winnipeg Manitoba. The appointment was quickly arranged. I saw the specialist in the afternoon and had surgery scheduled and performed the next morning. OHIP covered the travel and stay in Winnipeg as well as the medical costs.

I had a hernia. Saw my doctor the same day. Saw a specialist in less than a week, had surgery less than a week later.

Doctors are not government employees. They are generally self employed businessmen. The only thing is that there is just one insurer to bill. Rates are set by negotiation between the Ontario Medical Association and the government. Doctor’s practices are run by themselves. My doctor is part of a group that guarantees availability 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. I have been able to see one of the doctors in the group even on Sunday, when it was necessary.
 
Rates are set by negotiation between the Ontario Medical Association and the government.
Now how would YOU like it if the govt set rates on how much money you could make? Then you’d know how your doc feels. I can tell ya, I’d be HACKED. But if the purpose is not to have any millionare docs in Canada, I’m sure it serves that goal well. I don’t have the numbers, but I don’t reckon there are many top of the line docs beating the walls down to practice in Canada. When thye can come south and be a millioniare. I wonder how many MDs flee the USA to go make their fortune in Canada? LOL. A doc up there, no matter how good he IS, can only charge what has been already negotiated for him. Sumptin about that just ain’t right. Next thing ya know the bricklayer is gonna get regulated, or the plumber.
Also, tell me about the people who made the food and served you at the all you can eat restaurant. Will they get to retire at age 50? Do they have the all brick house and the two cars?
Who serverd me? I dunno know Neil, but I’m not the reason they’re flipping burgers or sliggin hash. Heck, maybe they LIKE it, and its what they want to do? My McMansion? LOL, yes I have a good life, and sit on my butt everyday, but not because I robbed and cheated, can ya give me just little credit? LOL.

Vern, how many folks in the Ozarks have ya got washing ya car at the local car wash? Did you know their being there is YOUR fault? Shoot, with cards Vern is holdin, ain’t no telling how many people he’s holdin back. :rotfl:

Look y’all, I don’t mean to be flippant, cos the Lord has blessed me, and continues to do so. . I don’t take it for granted. But I’m NOT the reason anyone is flippin burgers LOL. But this is gettin downright funny
You can’t have that situation in a fair egalitarian society.
Why you WON’T ever find me in one brother!
 
Who serverd me? I dunno know Neil, but I’m not the reason they’re flipping burgers or sliggin hash. Heck, maybe they LIKE it, and its what they want to do? My McMansion? LOL, yes I have a good life, and sit on my butt everyday, but not because I robbed and cheated, can ya give me just little credit? LOL.
Bein’ a good ol’ boy getting handed a cushy job with a ridiculous pension on the backs of the tax-paying people because you’re white and have friends in the mayor’s office, while the blacks flip burgers for you to eat and the mexicans work the land for, is pretty close to robbing and cheating in my opinion.

Whether that applies to you or not, I have no idea.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top