Right-to-work law was constitutional

  • Thread starter Thread starter upant
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
This seems sort of like a no brainer, but then this was never an issue here. Sure there is a free-rider issue, but that exists in most of life. Charity groups like Red Cross and the Salvation Army provide emergency service, but people have no obligation to give to them. People can vote in a Primary and never send a dollar to that political party.
 
I see these court challenges of right to work laws as further proof that unions’ only concern is maintaining/increasing their own power.
 
Last edited:
The only issue I have with Act 1 (as I understand it) is that it forbids employers from entering closed shop agreements. Just as I dislike the state forcing employees to join unions or pay union dues, I equally dislike forbidding employers from negotiating their own agreements with unions.

It seems there’s no middle ground on this one. The unions want to require mandatory membership across the board or dues and the right-to-work folk want to forbid mandatory membership across the board. How about letting the parties negotiate and figure it out for themselves?
 
How about letting the parties negotiate and figure it out for themselves?
because neither party has the best interest of the worker in mind.

both sides benefit the worker in some way so there needs to be a balance.

i think the balance is to let the individual decide to belong or not.

the federal government unions aren’t closed and people can belong or choose not to. the union still has to represent them because they are not free to represent themselves after the lower step of the grievance procedures usually per contracts.
 
because neither party has the best interest of the worker in mind.
If unions do not have the best interest of the worker in mind, why do they exist? Isn’t that their entire reason for existence?

But regardless, I disagree. There are three parties, not two. I don’t think employees are the helpless pawns everyone paints them to be. They are not union stooges nor chattel for employers. I’m a firm believer–and every supervisor I know, including in union and non-union shops–believe that a happy employee is a productive employee.

All three parties can make demands on each other. If the union is not representing the employees, they should be free to jettison the union and remain separate, join a new union, or create a new one. If employers feel they are being unfairly dealt with by unions, they should be free to re-negotiate. If a union feels that an employer is treating members unfairly, they should be free to strike or take other action. All, of course, within the bounds of the union agreement.

Let the parties work it out. The less people involved, especially the government, the more likely a harmonious relationship will result.
i think the balance is to let the individual decide to belong or not.
Sure. But that’s an local decision between the parties involved. Subsidiarity and all that.
the federal government unions aren’t closed and people can belong or choose not to. the union still has to represent them because they are not free to represent themselves after the lower step of the grievance procedures usually per contracts.
Why aren’t they free to represent themselves? Perhaps because the government is involved?
 
Last edited:
I would agree with this if the unions would set themselves up as a contractor and hire them out. It seems they want the best of both worlds, which is probably why they have a history of corruption and are rife for abuse. The thing is, if you want to be the sole provider of labor through a contract, you should also take responsibility for your workers, including being the one to pay them when there is no work or taking out unemployment insurance for them.

I do see your point, but I wonder how you can have a right to work law and yet allow this law to be set aside through negotiation. It would be like grant the right to negotiate for below minimum wage, or no blacks allowed, or some other violation of labor law. That may be why middle ground is hard to legally find.
 
Last edited:
If unions do not have the best interest of the worker in mind, why do they exist? Isn’t that their entire reason for existence?
it was at one time. now they have just become fundraisers for the democratic party: at least at the national levels. at the local level YMMV.

when LA passed a $15 minimum wage why did the unions ask the city council to exempt union members from the $15 an hour minimum wage?
 
it was at one time. now they have just become fundraisers for the democratic party: at least at the national levels. at the local level YMMV.
I don’t think we disagree.

But I do think if that upsets the membership, they can vote to ditch the union. Employees are not helpless sots.
when LA passed a $15 minimum wage why did the unions ask the city council to exempt union members from the $15 an hour minimum wage?
I don’t know the details on this, but I wouldn’t be surprise. But then again, the members have chosen to let the union leadership act as they do. If they disagree, they should step up and take charge.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top