Rubio warns: Christianity could be labeled 'hate speech'

  • Thread starter Thread starter Al_Moritz
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
politico story said:
“Because today we’ve reached the point in our society where if you do not support same-sex marriage you are labeled a homophobe and a hater.”

As he said, that is already the case. Why is there any question that speaking up for one’s Christian belief that marriage is for one man and one woman will also be called hate speech?

The them “hate speech” is a hammer to shut up anyone who disagrees with the politically correct position. It will obviously be used to force Christians to shut up.

Peace

Tim
 
Well, I agree. There was this discussion on Christian radio show I was listening to last year.
 
What exactly is “hate speech”???

Whatever happened to “free speech”???
 
Well, I agree. There was this discussion on Christian radio show I was listening to last year.
I agree, but I also view it as him pandering to those he thinks are the GOP base. So, while we are anxious, and agree with him, we are still left with what he proposes to do about it, if there is anything he can do about it.
 
How and where do we draw the line? Is Westbrro Baptiist Church guilty of hate speech? They sure don’t think so…
 
How and where do we draw the line? Is Westbrro Baptiist Church guilty of hate speech? They sure don’t think so…
The crucial question is what is meant by “where do we draw the line”. One can form an individual opinion on what is “hate speech”; there is no need for agreement on this.

The problem arises when “hate speech” is elevated into civil law. Now there must be an agree, legal definition of it. And those on the receiving end are not going to take kindly to being told not only that they are wrong but that they must pay fines and/or go to jail.

That’s why we have freedom of speech.
 
I agree, but I also view it as him pandering to those he thinks are the GOP base. So, while we are anxious, and agree with him, we are still left with what he proposes to do about it, if there is anything he can do about it.
I don’t think this is pandering to the GOP base, since 70% of the nation is Christian and even more people believe Jesus rose from the dead.

There are many Christians who are Democrats and other 3rd parties.
 
How and where do we draw the line? Is Westbrro Baptiist Church guilty of hate speech? They sure don’t think so…
You draw the line when it interferes with the rights of others. For instance, WBC should not be able to spew their garbage at the funerals of American soldiers, because funerals are a form of speech as well.

However, no one has a right to be offended. The proper response is charity.
 
You draw the line when it interferes with the rights of others. For instance, WBC should not be able to spew their garbage at the funerals of American soldiers, because funerals are a form of speech as well.

However, no one has a right to be offended. The proper response is charity.
In fact, though, WBC is well within their rights to “spew their garbage at the funerals of American soldiers” because that does not interfere with the funeral though it obviously upsets and offends many.

I don’t know how charitable funeral attendees should be to WBC but I don’t see a case for prohibiting their hate speech that would not ultimately lead to banning Catholic teaching.
 
You draw the line when it interferes with the rights of others. For instance, WBC should not be able to spew their garbage at the funerals of American soldiers, because funerals are a form of speech as well.

However, no one has a right to be offended. The proper response is charity.
And gays say we interfere with their rght to get married.
 
What happened to the “Religious Right”? I always thought they had a great deal of influence on candidates and primaries.
 
In fact, though, WBC is well within their rights to “spew their garbage at the funerals of American soldiers” because that does not interfere with the funeral though it obviously upsets and offends many.

I don’t know how charitable funeral attendees should be to WBC but I don’t see a case for prohibiting their hate speech that would not ultimately lead to banning Catholic teaching.
Well, the limits are on the behavior, not the content. One could say that child rape and mass murder is “free speech” or “just expressing oneself”, but that is why lines are drawn, and why we have contract and tort law.

That’s also why a private company in a free society would be able to prohibit employees from dressing like vagabands.
 
But there are civil rights or gay marriage would not be an issue.
It still could be regardless, it’s just easy for progressives to call what they want “rights” in order to demonize those who oppose them and make people afraid to take those “rights” away.

Besides, civil rights were based on appearance and to some degree economic benefits to the state.

Marriage is a behavior.
 
Well, the limits are on the behavior, not the content. One could say that child rape and mass murder is “free speech” or “just expressing oneself”, but that is why lines are drawn, and why we have contract and tort law.
Yes, speech is just that, speech, and nothing more. (Though some imagine “performance art” as free speech including burning flags).
 
But there are civil rights or gay marriage would not be an issue.
Civil marriage includes many benefits, privileges, and responsibilities that unmarried people don’t have, but it includes no additional rights that unmarried people don’t also have. All the rights you need to associate with someone are already enshrined in the First Amendment. Spending time with someone, living with them, sharing assets, sharing intimacy, etc. All these rights already fall under freedom of association. Except getting married to someone in a church, which is protected by the First Amendment under the free exercise clause.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top