Sacred Tradition, Dogma, and Ecclesia

  • Thread starter Thread starter R_C
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Yes, but by the broadness of your definition of doctrine, it is not possible to be a human being without some doctrine.
No, that is perhaps what threw you off before.

Because one can be human by simply doing all the wrong things in life. One can just murder others, and do every evil possible in the world. They will be “alive” and “human” but they might not have any doctrine that what they do is wrong or what is the right thing to do.

So it is certainly possible to exist without doctrine, even under what you suggest is a very broad definition of mine.
 
Oh Jaberwocky…now you are saying that we can be saved without knowing or having knowledge/doctrine because God will have mercy on our iniquities?
No, ignorance does not save my friend. In fact, willfully remaining in ignorance damns. What I was pointing out was that God knows the limits of a person. As long as they strive to learn the truth (doctrines) and practice it, they will find favor with God. So God may forgive what they have not done.

But that does not give us or anyone license to live in willful ignorance since it our moral responsibility to inform ourselves of the truth.
 
No, ignorance does not save my friend. In fact, willfully remaining in ignorance damns. What I was pointing out was that God knows the limits of a person. **As long as they strive to learn the truth (doctrines) and practice it, they will find favor with God. So God may forgive what they have not done. **

But that does not give us or anyone license to live in willful ignorance since it our moral responsibility to inform ourselves of the truth.
Jaberwocky- I believe that if you carefully reread what you just wrote and what I emphasized and really come to fully know and understand what you are saying here I have faith and hope that you might eventually come to see and understand what others on this thread and another thread of yours have been trying to get you to understand.

My prayers are with you and please keep me in yours
 
Jaberwocky- I believe that if you carefully reread what you just wrote and what I emphasized and really come to fully know and understand what you are saying here I have faith and hope that you might eventually come to see and understand what others on this thread and another thread of yours have been trying to get you to understand.

My prayers are with you and please keep me in yours
Well, considering I wrote the sentence, you must understand that it is very likely that I already did know what I was referring to 🙂

Note that what I have said does not change what else I have said here and the other thread. Because what I said in the latest post before this was on how God reacts to what you do. I was not addressing the question of whether you can do the will of God without doctrine.

Even my reply insists that one must put an effort to know the will of God. Otherwise one cannot expect God’s mercy.

So perhaps it will help me better if you put down in your own wording what you would like me to see.
 
Well, considering I wrote the sentence, you must understand that it is very likely that I already did know what I was referring to 🙂

Note that what I have said does not change what else I have said here and the other thread. Because what I said in the latest post before this was on how God reacts to what you do. I was not addressing the question of whether you can do the will of God without doctrine.

Even my reply insists that one must put an effort to know the will of God. Otherwise one cannot expect God’s mercy.

So perhaps it will help me better if you put down in your own wording what you would like me to see.
After reading your posts and the manner and way in which you respond to other’s it has lead me to conclude that no matter what I post I will not be able to get you to see because I understand that some times and in some cases for those who beleive no explanation is necessary and for those who do not believe no explanation is possible… for some reason I very strongly believe that this is something only God will be able to help you see and understand… so I will continue to pray for you and I would ask you to please continue to pray for me that He continues to help me see Him, know Him and understand Him and His wonderouse works more and more every day…
 
No, that is perhaps what threw you off before.

Because one can be human by simply doing all the wrong things in life. One can just murder others, and do every evil possible in the world. They will be “alive” and “human” but they might not have any doctrine that what they do is wrong or what is the right thing to do.

So it is certainly possible to exist without doctrine, even under what you suggest is a very broad definition of mine.
Then the term is used loosely, changing and undefined, making meaningful discussion difficult at best. Best to get back to EENS.
 
Then the term is used loosely, changing and undefined, making meaningful discussion difficult at best. Best to get back to EENS.
Well, I think the term is defined sufficiently enough. But you make incorrect conclusions. As we can see here, you made an incorrect conclusion that by my definition, the knowledge of the truth is essential for existence. But as I pointed out to you, it is not for man may simply choose to act contrary to the truth and hold knowledge contrary to the truth and keep himself ignorant.

I am game for EENS discussion but I just want to make it clear that this discussion has had sufficient understanding of terms for anyone who is particularly unbiased to grasp what has been said. But if you start with the premise that love must be possible without doctrine, then everything just seems to be insufficient for you. That is unfortunate.
 
After reading your posts and the manner and way in which you respond to other’s it has lead me to conclude that no matter what I post I will not be able to get you to see because I understand that some times and in some cases for those who beleive no explanation is necessary and for those who do not believe no explanation is possible… for some reason I very strongly believe that this is something only God will be able to help you see and understand… so I will continue to pray for you and I would ask you to please continue to pray for me that He continues to help me see Him, know Him and understand Him and His wonderouse works more and more every day…
Hmm, I take it you consider me a hopeless case then. Very well, please do keep me in your prayers my friend!
 
Hmm, I take it you consider me a hopeless case then. Very well, please do keep me in your prayers my friend!
If that’s how you want to see it then ok. That is your prerogative. But For the record I do not see, think or believe anyone is a hopeless case. I believe there is always hope as long as I keep trusting in God and His Divine and Merciful Providence.🙂
 
If that’s how you want to see it then ok. That is your prerogative. But For the record I do not see, think or believe anyone is a hopeless case. I believe there is always hope as long as I keep trusting in God and His Divine and Merciful Providence.🙂
Well, you believe that for man, I am a hopeless case. But for God, anything is possible so he might be able to still drag me out of my drowning. Would that be correct understanding? 🙂

In any case, I thank you for that sentiment and prayers on my behalf!
 
Well, you believe that for man, I am a hopeless case. But for God, anything is possible so he might be able to still drag me out of my drowning. Would that be correct understanding? 🙂
I don’t know is it? I certainly did not think you were drowning. But if this is what you believe you are doing right now I will most definitely say a few more prayers for you.
In any case, I thank you for that sentiment and prayers on my behalf!
Please say a few prayers for me too. God knows I have my own issues with feeling like I am a hopeless case and drowning too.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top