Saddam ordered WMD strike on Israel

  • Thread starter Thread starter gilliam
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
G

gilliam

Guest
The former deputy of the Iraqi air force, General Georges Sada, revealed on Saturday that that former dictator of Iraq, Saddam Hussein, ordered him during the first Gulf War to bomb Israeli population centers with chemical weapons.

The ousted dictator, said Sada in recently published book, Saddam’s secret’s, ordered 96 Russian fighter jets to be armed with chemical weapons and sent to bomb Israel. According to Sada, who recently served as a national security advisor to the temporary prime minister and was in the midst of a book tour in the US, said he succeeded in convincing Hussein to reconsider his order.

jpost.com/servlet/Satellite?cid=1137605933738&pagename=JPost%2FJPArticle%2FShowFull
 
Shame on the mean ole USA for ousting a brutal murderer. He should be able to kill freely as long as there is a shred of doubt that he would threaten us. :tsktsk:
 
1.) Saddam ordered WMD strike.

2.) Saddam canceled his order.

Why did he cancel the order?

Answer: Isreali Deterrence (Deterrence is an act of preventing or controlling actions or behavior through fear of punishment or retribution).

There’s a long list of brutal murderers out there in the world. If brave warriors on the Catholic forum want to join a volunteer brigade and go attack brutal murderers all over the world, I’ll stay on the sidelines and laugh at your folly.

If brave warriors on the Catholic forum want to send our military personnel to attack brutal murders all over the world and do the fighting and dying, then I’ll question your bravado and oppose your political philosophy.

Did someone mention Iraq, for example: Here’s a factoid from last weeks McLaughlin Group:

MR. MCLAUGHLIN: Okay, the human toll: U.S. military dead in Iraq, including suicides, 2,214; U.S. military amputeed, wounded, injured, mentally ill, all now out of Iraq, 51,600; Iraqi civilians dead, 120,690.
 
And just WHAT will you do when confronted by a brutal murderer? Laugh on the sidelines? Hmmmmm. Oppose defending against an enemy? Hmmmmm.
 
40.png
grotto:
And just WHAT will you do when confronted by a brutal murderer? Laugh on the sidelines? Hmmmmm. Oppose defending against an enemy? Hmmmmm.
Hey G… he may be one of the 51k… included in the mentally ill along with Teddy, Nancy, John K, et al.
 
40.png
mdzialo1:
There’s a long list of brutal murderers out there in the world. If brave warriors on the Catholic forum want to join a volunteer brigade and go attack brutal murderers all over the world, I’ll stay on the sidelines and laugh at your folly.

If brave warriors on the Catholic forum want to send our military personnel to attack brutal murders all over the world and do the fighting and dying, then I’ll question your bravado and oppose your political philosophy.

.
I’ll pass your thoughts on to my son in Iraq.
 
40.png
gilliam:
I’ll pass your thoughts on to my son in Iraq.
And please pass on my prayers. Please tell your son that he serves a grateful nation.
 
40.png
grotto:
And just WHAT will you do when confronted by a brutal murderer? Laugh on the sidelines? Hmmmmm. Oppose defending against an enemy? Hmmmmm.
Perhaps dial 911, then laugh on the sidelines. At the police of course.
 
40.png
gilliam:
I’ll pass your thoughts on to my son in Iraq.
My wife and I pray for your son, along with many other brave soldiers. He deserves respect and appreciation, not the ridicule that another poster so absurdly prescribed.

Blessings to your family.
 
40.png
mdzialo1:
1.) Saddam ordered WMD strike.

2.) Saddam canceled his order.

Why did he cancel the order?

Answer: Isreali Deterrence (Deterrence is an act of preventing or controlling actions or behavior through fear of punishment or retribution).
You contradict yourself. On one had you say deterence and responding to evil works, and on the other you say you’ll laugh on the sidelines when one tries.

Saddam didn’t think we had the resolve to back up our demands. There comes a point where you must back up your demands with action…if not, you can’t deter anyone.
40.png
mdzialo1:
There’s a long list of brutal murderers out there in the world. If brave warriors on the Catholic forum want to join a volunteer brigade and go attack brutal murderers all over the world, I’ll stay on the sidelines and laugh at your folly.
Not only is this absurd, it is very isulting to the people who actually fight evil. If everyone took your attitude, no one would fight evil, and there would be more evil.
40.png
mdzialo1:
MR. MCLAUGHLIN: Okay, the human toll: U.S. military dead in Iraq, including suicides, 2,214; U.S. military amputeed, wounded, injured, mentally ill, all now out of Iraq, 51,600; Iraqi civilians dead, 120,690.
Your figures are wrong. Civilians dead number in the 30,000s. I’ll look up a source later.

Are you aware of this figure: 800,000? That’s the smallest estimate of people murdered by Saddam in his 25 year reign. That’s at least 32,000 people per year, with his murderous sons to follow. Now, I’m not saying that as long as we stay below that number, it’s fine. Not at all, its tragic.

But I don’t understand the logic that says that its better for civilians to be tortured, maimed and murdered under the tyrrany Husseins indefinitely than to be at risk temporarily in a struggle for freedom. Not only are they dying at slower rates, they are freer and have a chance at ending the bloodshed.

Also, the civilians aren’t being killed by the government or our military–they are being killed by terrorists. The goverment is now their allie, not their oppressor.

P.S. I think you owe gilliam and his son, as well as our military, an apology. They are literally risking their lives to protect the very freedom of speech that you just abused you prescribed sitting on the sidelines laughing at their folly.
 
40.png
Jay74:
My wife and I pray for your son, along with many other brave soldiers. He deserves respect and appreciation, not the ridicule that another poster so absurdly prescribed.

Blessings to your family.
Thank you. I heard this morning that his patrol was hit with an IED yesterday but, thankfully, no one was hurt.

Appreciate the prayers.
 
40.png
gilliam:
Thank you. I heard this morning that his patrol was hit with an IED yesterday but, thankfully, no one was hurt.
I had no idea, gilliam. What a shock to the heart. I am overjoyed that he was not hurt and that no one in his patrol was hurt. God bless to you and yours.
 
40.png
mdzialo1:
There’s a long list of brutal murderers out there in the world. If brave warriors on the Catholic forum want to join a volunteer brigade and go attack brutal murderers all over the world, I’ll stay on the sidelines and laugh at your folly.
You’ll stay on the sidelines. And laugh. So? I don’t get it. Is that supposed to deter us in some way?
40.png
mdzialo1:
If brave warriors on the Catholic forum want to send our military personnel to attack brutal murders all over the world and do the fighting and dying, then I’ll question your bravado and oppose your political philosophy.
Your post doesn’t make sense, mdzialo. But then hatred never does.
40.png
mdzialo1:
Did someone mention Iraq, for example: Here’s a factoid from last weeks McLaughlin Group:

MR. MCLAUGHLIN: Okay, the human toll: U.S. military dead in Iraq, including suicides, 2,214; U.S. military amputeed, wounded, injured, mentally ill, all now out of Iraq, 51,600; Iraqi civilians dead, 120,690.
Now that you have made your position clear, let me make mine clear: any claims that you have to make in future about so-called ‘facts’ please have the kindness to make in the context of links to credible sources. If the links aren’t there, then your claims aren’t there in my humble opinion.

Have a good Sunday.
 
If you don’t like what Mr. McLaughlin said, go argue with him. I merely copied the transcript verbatim from the January 13, 2006 TV show, available online at www.mclaughlingroup.com. Is that site so difficult to find? Do you think I lied? Well, then go search by date; the quote is about five paragraphs from the end of the transcript. Glad to help.

My major point was that Israel didn’t need to attack the brutal dictator, Saddam, and invade Iraq. The article explains that Saddam was deterred by Israeli military strength, when its potency was explained to him. We know deterrence worked, because we know Saddam canceled the WMD attack that he had ordered, right?

There are brutal dictators in the world. But did America invade the Soviet Union, whose brutal dictators happen to have killed no less than 63 million people. No. We did not do it. Instead we employed a strategy called deterrence and it worked, too, right?

There are good reasons why the notion of making the world safe for democracy is not only silly but that it is folly. There are good reasons why Bill Buckley said this yesterday: “democracy simply cannot be trusted always to do the right thing, in Palestine, in Bolivia, in Venezuela, in Weimar Germany, or in Iraq.” I won’t bother to enumerate the reasons why.

Also, I did not say what Gilliam thinks he heard.

Our military personnel fight for us and some of them die for us. That’s why I am mindful of their lives. We need a strong military, important strategic alliances, and protected borders (is Bush protecting our borders?). I don’t care a wit about nation building. We don’t need to have our military sent out on folly: never-ending wars, Muslims taking votes, doing sweeps of Fallujha for the 15th, 16th, 17th time when one half of IEDs are discovered only when they blow us up, while the locals are tipped off about the bombs but say nothing, while the Iraqis haven’t gotten around to instituting a military draft yet. I’m pro-winning wars (not just fighting wars). Tell your son that.

The Iraqis did not vote for the secularist candidate that Bush thought would win. That fellow got 8%. The Iraqis voted for their roots and their religion - a religion that has been at war with itself for 1400 years.

You all want democracy. Then why don’t you take the advice of a newly elected Iraqi governor who today said this: “The answer is to confine American forces to large bases outside of major cities, forbidding contact between anyone other than U.S. military officers and appointed Iraqi officials.” The governor, Hamed Hamud al-Shukti, and several other powerful provincial figures repeated the suggestion this week in council meetings, talks with U.S. military representatives, and interviews with journalists.

“If the Americans left next week, the security situation would improve, for sure,” said Sheik Rashid Ahmed Osman al-Jabuli, head of the Salah ad Din provincial council. “What they call the resistance would go away. I am resisting also, but believe in peaceful resistance.”
 
mdzialo1 said:
“If the Americans left next week, the security situation would improve, for sure,” said Sheik Rashid Ahmed Osman al-Jabuli, head of the Salah ad Din provincial council. “What they call the resistance would go away. I am resisting also, but believe in peaceful resistance.”

Now why would we listen to this guy? Any one who supports sadam should not have a say in americas tactics.
 
mdzialo1 said:
1.) Saddam ordered WMD strike.

2.) Saddam canceled his order.

Why did he cancel the order?

Answer: Isreali Deterrence (Deterrence is an act of preventing or controlling actions or behavior through fear of punishment or retribution).

There’s a long list of brutal murderers out there in the world. If brave warriors on the Catholic forum want to join a volunteer brigade and go attack brutal murderers all over the world, I’ll stay on the sidelines and laugh at your folly.

If brave warriors on the Catholic forum want to send our military personnel to attack brutal murders all over the world and do the fighting and dying, then I’ll question your bravado and oppose your political philosophy.

Did someone mention Iraq, for example: Here’s a factoid from last weeks McLaughlin Group:

MR. MCLAUGHLIN: Okay, the human toll: U.S. military dead in Iraq, including suicides, 2,214; U.S. military amputeed, wounded, injured, mentally ill, all now out of Iraq, 51,600; Iraqi civilians dead, 120,690.

Question: Why did Saddam cancel the order?

Answer: Because he realized that you can only push the Americans just so far and then they snap back and bite you. It has happened time after time.

Question: Why don’t all you brave warriors on the Catholic Answers forum join a volunteer brigade and go attack brutal murderers all over the world?

Answer: A lot of us did, when we were the appropriate age, and some of us were active participants at more advanced ages… For World War 2, Korea, Vietnam, the Gulf War, and countless other military encounters in between and since. Consider that EVERY soldier, sailor, airman, marine, CIA operative and security contractor in Iraq and Afghanistan today and everywhere else for more than 20 years is a volunteer; the draft was eliminated decades ago. The recruitment of new enlistees was about 98% to 99% of goal (according to a radio interview with the Secretary of the Army on the Monica Crowley radio program) and re-enlistments are way up over early estimates.

Question: I’ll stay on the sidelines and laugh at your folly.

Answer: You might want to re-read history and reconsider your statement. You might want to invest in a used copy of Kohn’s “Dictionary of Wars” or Dupuy & Dupuy’s “Harper Encyclopedia of Military History”. Wars are things we always seem to have with us. If you want to let other people do the fighting and be your protectors, that’s fine. We don’t appreciate your laughing at us. Keep in mind that those who chose not to “stay on the sidelines” rescued Europe in the world war of 1914 and rescued Europe and Asia in the world war of 1940.

Question: I’ll question your bravado and oppose your political philosophy.

Answer: The U.S. has been drawn into foreign wars for a very long time… since 1805 at least… the shores of Tripoli and all that. "Bravado?.. readers might want to look that up in their dictionaries. The book I have here says:“false bravery… swaggering or defiant show of courage.” Is that what the record shows? An awful lot of men went out and died in wars so tht others could remain free. Freedom isn’t free.

What exactly is YOUR political philosophy? … since you oppose ours…
 
40.png
mdzialo1:
If you don’t like what Mr. McLaughlin said, go argue with him.
I think I was addressing what you said, was I not? Why should McLaughlin should take the heat for you?
40.png
mdzialo1:
I merely copied the transcript verbatim
And how are we supposed to know which part is yours and which part is McLaughlin’s? There are conventions for referencing authorities. Quotation marks being the simplest way. Using the http://forums.catholic-questions.org/images/editor/quote.gifikon at the top of your reply window being visually clearer than quotation marks.
40.png
mdzialo1:
Is that site so difficult to find?
No. But that isn’t the point. The point is that there are courtesies in discussion. We are not here to do your work for you, go on rabbit chases for you, look up links which are your responsibility to provide.
40.png
mdzialo1:
Do you think I lied?
Did I say that? There is no need for strawmen, mdzialo.
40.png
mdzialo1:
Well, then go search by date; the quote is about five paragraphs from the end of the transcript.
That’s your responsibility, not ours.
40.png
mdzialo1:
Glad to help.
‘Glad’ does not come to mind.
40.png
mdzialo1:
There are good reasons why the notion of making the world safe for democracy is not only silly but that it is folly. There are good reasons why Bill Buckley said this yesterday: “democracy simply cannot be trusted always to do the right thing, in Palestine, in Bolivia, in Venezuela, in Weimar Germany, or in Iraq.” I won’t bother to enumerate the reasons why.
If you are not going to bother to enumerate the reasons, then I am not going to bother registering that you think there are good reasons for these various things.

Also ‘silly’ is not the most courteous terminology to deal with the opposing point of view.
40.png
mdzialo1:
Also, I did not say what Gilliam thinks he heard.
Which is?
40.png
mdzialo1:
Our military personnel fight for us and some of them die for us. That’s why I am mindful of their lives.
But not mindful of their freedom to choose their vocation? And not mindful of their freedom to choose what they do with those lives?
40.png
mdzialo1:
We need a strong military, important strategic alliances, and protected borders (is Bush protecting our borders?).
9/11?
40.png
mdzialo1:
I don’t care a wit about nation building.
Why?
40.png
mdzialo1:
We don’t need to have our military sent out on folly: never-ending wars, Muslims taking votes, doing sweeps of Fallujha for the 15th, 16th, 17th time when one half of IEDs are discovered only when they blow us up, while the locals are tipped off about the bombs but say nothing, while the Iraqis haven’t gotten around to instituting a military draft yet.
Once again, no reasons are given. Please give reasons.
40.png
mdzialo1:
I’m pro-winning wars (not just fighting wars).
Please set out your strategy for winning the War on Terror.
40.png
mdzialo1:
The Iraqis did not vote for the secularist candidate that Bush thought would win. That fellow got 8%. The Iraqis voted for their roots and their religion - a religion that has been at war with itself for 1400 years.
Your point is?

continued…
 
40.png
mdzialo1:
You all want democracy. Then why don’t you take the advice of a newly elected Iraqi governor who today said this: “The answer is to confine American forces to large bases outside of major cities, forbidding contact between anyone other than U.S. military officers and appointed Iraqi officials.”
The answer to what? What was the question? Link?

mdzialo1 said:
“If the Americans left next week, the security situation would improve, for sure,” said Sheik Rashid Ahmed Osman al-Jabuli, head of the Salah ad Din provincial council. “What they call the resistance would go away. I am resisting also, but believe in peaceful resistance.”

This is simply refuted by the facts. It is not true. The resistance is not there because Coalition troops are in Iraq. The resistance is there because the aims of the terrorists are to establish a Kaliphate and to exterminate any folks who are not Islamic.

We are not looking at a situation of defence against the Coalition. We are looking at a situation of aggressive expansionism on the part of the terrorists toward establishing a Kaliphate from which world-wide Islamic dominion will follow.
The recent attacks [in Afghanistan] fit bin Laden’s strategic goal of ensuring “the pious Caliphate will start from Afghanistan”… The ruling to kill the Americans and their allies–civilians and military–is an individual duty for every Muslim who can do it in any country in which it is possible to do it.
Some people do not want to be Islamic. Why should they be forced on pain of death to convert to Islam if they do not want to be Islamic?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top