Scientists Clone Human Embryos To Make Stem Cells

  • Thread starter Thread starter Holly3278
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
The diagram is misleading.
  1. Take Bob’s skin cells
  2. Remove egg’s DNA
  3. Insert DNA into egg
  4. Get embryo to grow
    5)Use Bob’s stem cells to make new therapies for Bob.
  5. should read “Destroy Bob’s son, and use his stem cells to make new therapies for Bob.”
 
I don’t know how I feel about this, honestly. If they weren’t destroying them, then maybe such a thing [stem cells] could be helpful and one day, restore mobility to the paraplegic or cure muscular dystrophy or something like that.
 
I find this morally repugnant, but I am not too concerned at this point that successful human cloning will take place (mentioned in the article as a concern). I heard about this yesterday on the radio.

Even in Dolly’s case, it took 277 times before they even got it right! And Dolly was herself not very healthy- she was severely affected by arthritis and contracted jaaksiekte (a viral lung cancer disease of sheep), and had to be euthanized by age six. A Finn-Dorset cross, produced the old-fashioned way (or even by artificial insemination), should live to ten at least, or even into her teens, provided she is not slaughtered or killed by a predator before then. I have plenty of sheep that are around six and none of them are unhealthy or even remotely arthritic.

While I believe that they will try, and who knows how many embryos will die as a result, I can’t see it being successful, at least not for many years. I do believe-even as a scientist-in-training- that there are “biological brick walls” and therefore limits to what can be successfully done. Never mind ethical “brick walls”…
 
My question is: what does the Church teach on the morality of an unfertilized egg?
 
My question is: what does the Church teach on the morality of an unfertilized egg?
By giving the egg a complete set of dna, they are, in essence, fertilizing the egg. If the egg were not fertilized, it would not grow. So the same morality to this applies to a fertilized egg that is created naturally.

An actual unfertilized egg still holds the potential to be a human, but is not itself a human. However, removing the possibility of it becoming human by purposeful means, is against Natural Law. The human body has its own faculties to properly dispose of an unfertilized egg that it is no longer viable.
 
“Harvestable Beings!” – the time foretold in the movie “The Island” (2005)* is here (on a small scale).

(Please Note: This uploaded content is no longer available.)
  • People find out they are clones being bred for “real people’s” spare parts or replacement.
    Clones are not considered people and can be harvested, whole or in part, at any time by the state or the insurance company that “grows and keeps” clones for the time that the “real person” (citizens they are cloned “from”) might need, say, a new heart. At which point, well …
The clones think they are real people too … right up until the operation that ends their lives and benefits their “real person” who needs a body part. :bigyikes:
 
I saw this in the paper yesterday… In addition to being immediately disgusted and saddened that this is taking place at all, I did wonder about the spiritual status of a cloned embryo. Obviously, a being conceived by unnatural means (IVF, for example, or the means described above) is still endowed with a soul at the moment of conception. But what of the clone? Let’s say for argument’s sake that the doctors here took an embryo, already fertilized, already a person with an immortal soul, and then cloned that embryo, does this clone have a unique soul? Would they essentially be identical twins, genetically the same in every relevant aspect, but possessing distinct, immortal souls?

The ethical implications of this scenario are genuinely frightening. As much as I’m sure I will idle over this thought, rest assured the doctors are in my prayers that they be moved to understand the gravity of this situation and stop trying to play God.
 
Let’s wait and see what the official Church says about this matter. Cooler heads will prevail. Information is power.
 
Vampirism?

Perhaps folks here don’t understand the science and are just calling out “NO! NO! NO!!” without taking the time to learn about the issue.
What additional thing is there to understand? From the article, we read:

“The controversy arises from several factors. The experiments involve creating and then destroying human embryos for research purposes, which some find morally repugnant. The scientists also used cloning techniques, which raise concerns that the research could lead to the cloning of people.
Ever since human embryonic stem cells were discovered, scientists have had high hopes for them because the cells can morph into any kind of cell in the body. That ability means, in theory, that they could be used eventually to treat all sorts of illnesses, including diabetes, Alzheimer’s, Parkinson’s and spinal cord injuries.”

In other words, they will be creating human embryos in order to destroy them by taking out their stem cells to keep others alive or healthy. Not so very different from Dracula killing people and drinking their blood in order to stay alive and healthy, now, is it?

The Church has already opposed embryonic stem cell research because it kills living humans. All mankind should oppose it because it is no different from the vampirism against which all mankind has shrunk in horror from time immemorial.

Yes, yes, I understand the difference. Dracula wore a cape and these guys wear white smocks.
 
What additional thing is there to understand? From the article, we read:

“The controversy arises from several factors. The experiments involve creating and then destroying human embryos for research purposes, which some find morally repugnant. The scientists also used cloning techniques, which raise concerns that the research could lead to the cloning of people.
Ever since human embryonic stem cells were discovered, scientists have had high hopes for them because the cells can morph into any kind of cell in the body. That ability means, in theory, that they could be used eventually to treat all sorts of illnesses, including diabetes, Alzheimer’s, Parkinson’s and spinal cord injuries.”

In other words, they will be creating human embryos in order to destroy them by taking out their stem cells to keep others alive or healthy. Not so very different from Dracula killing people and drinking their blood in order to stay alive and healthy, now, is it?

The Church has already opposed embryonic stem cell research because it kills living humans. All mankind should oppose it because it is no different from the vampirism against which all mankind has shrunk in horror from time immemorial.

Yes, yes, I understand the difference. Dracula wore a cape and these guys wear white smocks.
Thanks, but like I said I’ll wait and see what the Church has to say- which she has not on this matter.
 
adult stem cells are where the cures and treatments will be. And it doesn’t involve killing HUMAN EMBRYOS for research!

Here’s a biology lesson for those who do not understand about human embryos and how research KILLS THEM: female egg + male sperm = BABY. HUMAN EMBRYO+9 months of growth = HUMAN BABY.

This means those embryos they are destroying to find “cures”? They are HUMAN BEINGS.

seems a little too much about what HITLER did with his experiments!
 
adult stem cells are where the cures and treatments will be. And it doesn’t involve killing HUMAN EMBRYOS for research!

Here’s a biology lesson for those who do not understand about human embryos and how research KILLS THEM: female egg + male sperm = BABY. HUMAN EMBRYO+9 months of growth = HUMAN BABY.

This means those embryos they are destroying to find “cures”? They are HUMAN BEINGS.

seems a little too much about what HITLER did with his experiments!
These scientists are creating babies?
 
These scientists are creating babies?
No - they are creating stem cells. From an (unfertilised) egg, sure, but I’m not sure where anyone gets the idea that this modified egg could ever grow into a baby.

Would taking cells from the patient and somehow growing them into replacement bone marrow (for example) also count as killing ‘a baby’? If we get the technological ability to grow any human cell into a baby, would allowing any human cells to die count as murder? 🤷
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top