Scientists discover what makes us 'kind'

  • Thread starter Thread starter Franciscan
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Are you suggesting that we grow that part of our brain at Baptism?
 
I’d say God put it there in the first place, just like that spot the scientists claim is most active in religiously faithful people.
 
Are you suggesting that we grow that part of our brain at Baptism?
Are you suggesting that the unBaptised cannot be charitable?

I’m suggesting that we are how God evolved us.
Surely we all have the capacity for charity…we just don’t always use it.
 
Good point. i thought of that after I posted.

Of course evryone has the capacity for (natural) charity it just seems to contradict with the teaching of infused (supernatural) virtues received at Baptism and other sacraments.

The danger is that we see charity as more biological than an act of the will or supernatural.
 
Good point. i thought of that after I posted.

Of course evryone has the capacity for (natural) charity it just seems to contradict with the teaching of infused (supernatural) virtues received at Baptism and other sacraments.

The danger is that we see charity as more biological than an act of the will or supernatural.
The CCC itself states that all persons are capable of acting within the natural law.
 
just some thoughts

This leads into the argument that we are body then spirit. This kind of evolutionary thinking is perfect fodder for atheist doctrine. The atheist hangs his hat on this and says if we all evolved and we are just bits of matter, what need of God.

The problem there is that we are more than matter. Whatever brain effect is measured when charity occurs (assuming the experiment is correct) does not cause the charity. The charity itself is caused by the heart, by an act of will.

I just can’t get out of my head this program I saw that interviewed evolution and almost every single atheist used evolution as the “scientific” basis for making a belief in God superfluous.

It is so sad and so destructive on so many leveles for them and the people around them. The brain and the “evolution” is not where to look, but the thing in itself, the “I” that must be nurtured, by our will and by God, that when seeing life with charity we can conform more perfectly to the image of God.

I fear that without some intellectual assent to the existence of a loving God we are left akin to animals and seeing each other driven by animal needs and wants. How can you lift yourself to agape then? Pity is not enough. Charity I think almost requires some fundamental acknowlegement that we are made to be Christ’s brothers and sisters. If not then would our fellow man even be worthy of charity as we are commanded?

Would charity itself be strangled by degrees without the fullness of the truth?
 
…I just can’t get out of my head this program I saw that interviewed evolution and almost every single atheist used evolution as the “scientific” basis for making a belief in God superfluous.
Don’t blame the science.
It is not supposed to be normative, just descriptive.
There are plenty of folks who understand evolution AND believe in God.
…Would charity itself be strangled by degrees without the fullness of the truth?
Possibly
 
Are you suggesting that the unBaptised cannot be charitable?

I’m suggesting that we are how God evolved us.
Surely we all have the capacity for charity…we just don’t always use it.
When God created us supernaturally this was written into our heart.
 
I wouldn’t write off enviromental factors and religion just yet (nuture vs. nature). The organic biological aspect only indicates the capacity for kindness in an individual, just as an I.Q. test may give some indication of the capacity of an individual’s intelligence. We always knew we had the ability to be kind. It still remains up to us to utilize that ability to its fullest.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top