Scouts consider oath for atheists

  • Thread starter Thread starter Digitonomy
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
D

Digitonomy

Guest
The existing Scout Promise reads: “On my honour, I promise that I will do my best, to do my duty to God and to the Queen, to help other people and to keep the Scout Law.”
The alternative versions introduced more than 40 years ago allow Hindus and Buddhists to use the word “my Dharma” and Muslims “Allah” instead of God. Non UK citizens are able to replace the phrase “duty to the Queen” with “duty to the country in which I am now living”.
In March, the National Secular Society, which aims to restrict the role of religion in public life, wrote to Chief Scout Bear Grylls, complaining that atheist children were being excluded or having to lie to join the movement.
Source
 
What will these humanists come up with next? A Bible for atheists with references to God removed? :rolleyes:

Political Correctness will be the death of our civilization.
 
I am proud to say that the Boy Scouts of America has staunchly defended “Duty to God”. Of course, it helps that the majority of troops are sponsored by churches of various sorts.

I don’t know if scouting in England is similarly organized by by local community groups as done in the United States.
 
I am proud to say that the Boy Scouts of America has staunchly defended “Duty to God”. Of course, it helps that the majority of troops are sponsored by churches of various sorts.
But they aren’t real scouts because they changed to oath to leave out the bit about the Monarch. How dare they change the Oath! All Scouts swear an oath to the Queen.

Or is it that you only accept the changes to the oath that suit you, and not the changes that suit other people. Do American scouts have oaths for Hindus, Muslims and Buddhists?

rossum
 
I don’t want the boy scouts going the way of Girl Scouts. If they consider an “oath” for atheists…what next…letting girls who THINK they are BOYS join? After all, one GS group in Colorado I think it was…allowed a BOY to join!
 
Why are we catering to 3% of society?

ArguingWithAtheists.com/Index.htm
We “cater” because we were taught to be inclusive, even of the despicable, by Jesus (tax collectors, soldiers, lepers, the poor).

Let them have their oath. Especially with young people, it opens the door for catechesis when an one child asks why another says “and to God”.

Pray for peace through imitation of the Lord Jesus Christ!
 
We “cater” because we were taught to be inclusive, even of the despicable, by Jesus (tax collectors, soldiers, lepers, the poor).

Let them have their oath. Especially with young people, it opens the door for catechesis when an one child asks why another says “and to God”.

Pray for peace through imitation of the Lord Jesus Christ!
I think it opens the door to more lawsuits by the atheists.
 
they should allow this.

That given, it is a private organization.

I just don’t see everything as an “us versus them”.

That’s for comic books.
 
Just to be clear. The article is about the UK Scout Association. Which are the Boy Scouts in the UK only. There is no such plan that I know of being considered in the BSA. In fact the BSA just voted to have the same Oath and Law be used throughout all thier traditional programs (Cubs, Boy Scouts and Venturing)
 
This is actually something that seems reasonable. I could understand Atheists or their parents feelings uncomfortable taking an oath to God. Theres little reason to oppose this.
 
There really isn’t a reason necessary. The Oath has been unchanged for 100 years. The burden for giving reasons for any change to the Oath should fall on those who wish to change it.
 
This is actually something that seems reasonable. I could understand Atheists or their parents feelings uncomfortable taking an oath to God. Theres little reason to oppose this.
Since a Scout is supposed to be Reverent, why would an Atheist parent enroll their child in a monotheist organization. Or expect the monotheist, private org to change to accommodate them
 
There really isn’t a reason necessary. The Oath has been unchanged for 100 years. The burden for giving reasons for any change to the Oath should fall on those who wish to change it.
That is not true in the UK, the oath has been changed to allow Hindus, Moslems and Buddhists to join.

rossum
 
Since a Scout is supposed to be Reverent, why would an Atheist parent enroll their child in a monotheist organization. Or expect the monotheist, private org to change to accommodate them
There is a lot more to boy scouts than religion. That is like asking why anyone that isn’t Catholic would choose to go to Notre Dame.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top